The surface force balance: direct measurement of interactions in fluids and soft matter

Over the last half-century, direct measurements of surface forces have been instrumental in the exploration of a multitude of phenomena in liquid, soft, and biological matter. Measurements of van der Waals interactions, electrostatic interactions, hydrophobic interactions, structural forces, depletion forces, and many other effects have checked and challenged theoretical predictions and motivated new models and understanding. The gold-standard instrument for these measurements is thesurface force balance(SFB), orsurface forces apparatus, where interferometry is used to detect the interaction force and distance between two atomically smooth planes, with 0.1 nm resolution, over separations from about 1 µm down to contact. The measured interaction forcevs.distance gives access to the free energy of interaction across the fluid film; a fundamental quantity whose general form and subtle features reveal the underlying molecular and surface interactions and their variation. Motivated by new challenges in emerging fields of research, such as energy storage, biomaterials, non-equilibrium and driven systems, innovations to the apparatus are now clearing the way for new discoveries. It is now possible to measure interaction forces (and free energies) with control of electric field, surface potential, surface chemistry; to measure time-dependent effects; and to determine structurein situ. Here, we provide an overview the operating principles and capabilities of the SFB with particular focus on the recent developments and future possibilities of this remarkable technique.

Nano-confined electrochemical reaction studied by electrochemical surface forces apparatus

Electrochemical reactions in a nano-space are different from those in bulk solutions due to structuring of the liquid molecules and peculiar ion behavior at the electric double layer and are important for applications involving sensors and energy devices. The electrochemical surface forces apparatus (EC-SFA) we developed enabled us to study the electrochemical reactions in a solution nano-confined between the electrodes with varying distance (D) at nm resolution. We recorded measurements of the current-distance profiles due to the electrochemical reaction of the redox couples in the electrolyte nano-confined between Pt electrodes using our EC-SFA. We observed a long-range feedback current due to redox cycling and the sudden current increase at a short distance, the latter for the first time. This sudden current increase was two orders greater than the conventional feedback current and was observed at D < 5 nm when the electrodes were approaching and D < 200 nm on separation. We simultaneously measured the electric double layer force and the current between the electrodes in the solution to study the mechanisms of this sudden current increase in the short distance range. The results revealed a molecular insight as to how the redox species affect the current between two electrodes under nano-confinement. This study demonstrated that EC-SFA is a powerful tool for obtaining fundamental knowledge about the nano-confined electrochemical reactions for nanoelectrodes which can be applied to sensors and energy devices.

A Versatile and Simple Approach to Electrochemical Colloidal Probes for Direct Force Measurements

The colloidal probe technique, which is based on micrometer-sized colloidal particles that are attached to the end of a cantilever, revolutionized direct force measurements by atomic force microscopy (AFM). Its major advantages are a defined interaction geometry and a high force sensitivity. Here, we present a versatile and simple approach for preparing spherical electrodes in the micrometer range on an otherwise insulated AFM cantilever. Thereby, it becomes possible to combine direct force measurements and potentiostatic control of the probe for various types of electrode materials. Two examples for the use of such electrochemical colloidal probes (eCP) are presented: First, on soft, conductive films of poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) doped with poly(styrenesulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS) the adhesion behavior was studied. The current through the contact area between the probe and film remained constant until the jump-out of contact, indicating a constant geometrical contact area. Second, the long-range forces due to diffuse layer overlap between an eCP and a glass surface have been determined as a function of the externally applied potential. The resulting interaction force profiles are in good agreement with those calculated based on charge regulation and solutions of the full Poisson-Boltzmann equation.

Forces between solid surfaces in aqueous electrolyte solutions

This review addresses experimental findings obtained with direct force measurements between two similar or dissimilar solid surfaces in aqueous electrolyte solutions. Interpretation of these measurements is mainly put forward in terms of the classical theory of Derjaguin, Landau, Verwey, and Overbeek (DLVO). This theory invokes a superposition of attractive van der Waals forces and repulsive double layer forces. DLVO theory is shown to be extremely reliable, even in the case of multivalent ions. However, such a description is only successful, when appropriate surface charge densities, charge regulation characteristics, and ion pairing or complexation equilibria in solution are considered. Deviations from DLVO theory only manifest themselves at distances of typically below few nm. More long-ranged non-DLVO forces can be observed in some situations, particularly, in concentrated electrolyte solutions, in the presence of strongly adsorbed layers, or for hydrophobic surfaces. The latter forces probably originate from patch-charge surface heterogeneities, which can be induced by ion-ion correlation effects, charge fluctuations, or other types of surface heterogeneities.

Surface forces measurement for materials science

This article reviews the surface forces measurement as a novel tool for materials science. The history of the measurement is briefly described in the Introduction. The general overview covers specific features of the surface forces measurement as a tool for studying the solid-liquid interface, confined liquids and soft matter. This measurement is a powerful way for understanding interaction forces, and for characterizing (sometime unknown) phenomena at solid-liquid interfaces and soft complex matters. The surface force apparatus (SFA) we developed for opaque samples can study not only opaque samples in various media, but also electrochemical processes under various electrochemical conditions. Electrochemical SFA enables us to determine the distribution of counterions between strongly bound ones in the Stern layer and those diffused in the Gouy-Chapman layer. The shear measurement is another active area of the SFA research. We introduced a resonance method, i.e. the resonance shear measurement (RSM), that is used to study the effective viscosity and lubricity of confined liquids in their thickness from μm to contact. Advantages of these measurements are discussed by describing examples of each measurement. These studies demonstrate how the forces measurement is used for characterizing solid-liquid interfaces, confined liquids and reveal unknown phenomena. The readers will be introduced to the broad applications of the forces measurement in the materials science field.

Low-Temperature Surface Forces Apparatus to Determine the Interactions between Ice and Silica Surfaces

We have developed a low-temperature surface forces apparatus (SFA) using a thermoelectric Peltier module inserted below the bottom surface of the lower sample holder, giving easy access to the samples and allowing quick temperature changes. In air, the temperature can be decreased to ca. -20 °C. To demonstrate the performance of the apparatus, we measured the interactions between ice and a silica surface at -11.5 ± 0.5 °C. An exponentially decaying repulsion of the decay length, 11.2 ± 1.0 nm, was observed, and attributed to the electric double layer (EDL) repulsion. The surface potential of the ice was calculated to be -35 mV by fitting the data to the EDL model.

Preparation of stable silica surfaces for surface forces measurement

A surface forces apparatus (SFA) measures the forces between two surfaces as a function of the surface separation distance. It is regarded as an essential tool for studying the interactions between two surfaces. However, sample surfaces used for the conventional SFA measurements have been mostly limited to thin (ca. 2-3 μm) micas, which are coated with silver layers (ca. 50 nm) on their back, due to the requirement of the distance determination by transmission mode optical interferometry called FECO (fringes of equal chromatic order). The FECO method has the advantage of determining the absolute distance, so it should be important to increase the availability of samples other than mica, which is chemically nonreactive and also requires significant efforts for cleaving. Recently, silica sheets have been occasionally used in place of mica, which increases the possibility of surface modification. However, in this case, the silver layer side of the sheet is glued on a cylindrical quartz disc using epoxy resin, which is not stable in organic solvents and can be easily swollen or dissolved. The preparation of substrates more stable under severe conditions, such as in organic solvents, is necessary for extending application of the measurement. In this study, we report an easy method for preparing stable silica layers of ca. 2 μm in thickness deposited on gold layers (41 nm)/silica discs by sputtering, then annealed to enhance the stability. The obtained silica layers were stable and showed no swelling in organic solvents such as ethanol and toluene.

Nanotribological Characterization of Lubricants between Smooth Iron Surfaces

We performed the resonance shear measurement (RSM) for evaluating the nanorheological and tribological properties of model lubricants, hexadecane and poly(α-olefin) (PAO), confined between iron surfaces. The twin-path surface forces apparatus (SFA) was used for determining the distance between the surfaces. The obtained resonance curves for the confined lubricants showed that the viscosity of the confined hexadecane and PAO increased due to liquid structuring when the surface separation (D) decreased to a value less than 24 and 20 nm, respectively. It was also determined that the iron surfaces were lubricated by the hexadecane when normal load (L) was less than 1.1 mN, while the confined hexadecane behaved almost solid-like and showed poor lubricity when L was greater than 1.1 mN. In contrast, PAO between the iron surfaces showed high lubricity even under the high load (L > 2 mN). The surface separation of hexadecane and PAO at a hard wall contact between the iron surfaces was determined to be 4.6 ± 0.5 and 5.0 ± 0.4 nm by applying the fringes of equal chromatic order (FECO) for half-transparent iron films deposited on mica surfaces as substrates. We also characterized hexadecane and PAO confined between mica surfaces for studying the effect of substrates on the confined lubricants.

Molecular Architecture Studied by the Surface Forces Measurement

This feature article reviews the surface forces measurement as a tool for studying molecular architecture chemistry. The history of the measurement is briefly described in the Introduction. The general overview covers specific features of the surface forces measurement as a tool for studying and using molecular architecture. This measurement is powerful for understanding interaction forces and for characterizing and discovering the phenomena at solid-liquid interfaces and soft complex matter. An apparatus for opaque samples was developed, which can be used to study not only opaque samples in various media but also electrochemical processes under various electrochemical potentials. Our studies of molecular architecture are reviewed; they include biological molecular recognition especially involved in the enzyme-substrate interaction; polyelectrolyte brushes exhibiting steric repulsion, which can be reproduced by the osmotic pressure of the counterions, and a density-dependent transition; the hydrogen-bonded molecular macrocluster formation of alcohol and carboxylic acids adsorbed on silica in nonpolar solvents such as cyclohexane; and surface forces between ferrocene-modified electrodes under various applied potentials. These studies demonstrate how the forces measurement is used to identify interacting species such as in biological systems to reveal unknown phenomena and to characterize soft complex matter and the effective potential of the electrodes. Readers will be introduced to the broad applications of the force measurement.

Characterization of ferrocene-modified electrode using electrochemical surface forces apparatus

A electrochemical surface forces apparatus (EC-SFA) was employed to measure the interactions between gold electrodes modified with self-assembled monolayers of ferrocene alkyl thiol (Fc-SAM) and oxidized ferrocene (ferrocenium cation, Fc(+)-SAM) in a 1 mM aqueous electrolyte. The double-layer repulsion in both cases of the Fc-SAM and Fc(+)-SAM electrodes was observed. The surface charge density (σ) evaluated from the double-layer repulsions between the Fc(+)-SAM electrodes in 1 mM aqueous KClO4 was 0.0027 C/m(2), which was 2.5 times greater than that of the Fc-SAM, at 0.0011 C/m(2). The σ values of the Fc(+)-SAM were evaluated for various counteranions using the same method, which were 0.0048, 0.0040, and 0.0104 C/m(2) for NO3(-), SO4(2-), and CF3SO3(-), respectively. The degrees of dissociation (αd) between the ferrocenium cation and these counteranions were obtained from σ and the density of the ferrocenium on the electrode. The αd value of CF3SO3(-), 4.1%, was the highest, followed in the order, SO4(2-) > NO3(-) > ClO4(-), indicating that most of the positive charges of the ferrocenium cation were compensated by formation of an ion pair with counteranions.