Molecular Identification of Three Aquilaria (Thymelaeaceae) Species through DNA Barcoding

Successful development of molecular diagnostic technology combining mini-barcoding and high-resolution melting for traditional Chinese medicine agarwood species based on single-nucleotide polymorphism in the chloroplast genome

Agarwood is a valuable traditional medicine and fragrance. The production process is a typical injury-induced defense response. Currently, there are approximately 22 known species in the genus Aquilaria Lam., all of which can produce agarwood, whereas there are only two legal species of traditional Chinese medicinal agarwood, Aquilaria sinensis (Lour.) Spreng. and Aquilaria agallocha (Lour.) Roxb. The Taiwan herbal Pharmacopoeia of China stipulates that the medicinal agarwood species are A. sinensis and its relatives in the same genus. Moreover, there are five species of agarwood available for clinical medicinal use in Japan, including A. agallocha and A. sinensis, which are often confused with each other or used in a mixed way in the trade process. Therefore, accurate identification of traditional Chinese medicinal agarwood species is important to ensure the authenticity of traditional medicines and to guide the safety of clinical medication. In this study, 59 specific single-nucleotide polymorphism loci were screened and obtained from the chloroplast genomes of 12 species of the genus Aquilaria Lam. We established an identification method for traditional Chinese medicinal agarwood using mini-barcoding combined with high-resolution melting (HRM) and designed and validated 10 pairs of primers from the psbM-trnD, psbA, rps16, petN, ndhE-psaC, rps4, atpE, ycf1, rps15-trnN, and matK regions. The amplification products were all less than 200 bp, with a high success rate of amplification. The method was applied to successfully identify traditional Chinese medicinal agarwood species from commercial agarwood samples. Overall, the sensitivity of this method was sufficient to detect 1% of adulterants in medicinal agarwood products, proving that mini-barcoding HRM is a powerful and flexible tool. This method can be used as a fast and effective high-throughput method for authenticity testing of traditional Chinese medicinal agarwood and its raw materials containing agarwood-containing proprietary Chinese medicines and is recommended for industrial applications.

Conservation Strategies for Aquilaria sinensis: Insights from DNA Barcoding and ISSR Markers

The evergreen tree species Aquilaria sinensis holds significant economic importance due to its specific medicinal values and increasing market demand. However, the unrestricted illegal exploitation of its wild population poses a threat to its survival. This study aims to contribute to the conservation efforts of A. sinensis by constructing a library database of DNA barcodes, including two chloroplast genes (psbA-trnH and matK) and two nuclear genes (ITS and ITS2). Additionally, the genetic diversity and structure were estimated using inter-simple sequence repeats (ISSR) markers. Four barcodes of 57 collections gained 194 sequences, and 1371 polymorphic bands (98.63%) were observed using DNA ISSR fingerprinting. The Nei's gene diversity (H) of A. sinensis at the species level is 0.2132, while the Shannon information index (I) is 0.3128. The analysis of molecular variance revealed a large significant proportion of total genetic variations and differentiation among populations (Gst = 0.4219), despite a relatively gene flow (Nm = 0.6853) among populations, which were divided into two groups by cluster analysis. There was a close genetic relationship among populations with distances of 0.0845 to 0.5555. This study provides evidence of the efficacy and dependability of establishing a DNA barcode database and using ISSR markers to assess the extent of genetic diversity A. sinensis. Preserving the genetic resources through the conservation of existing populations offers a valuable proposition. The effective utilization of these resources will be further deliberated in subsequent breeding endeavors, with the potential to breed agarwood commercial lines.

Highly divergent regions in the complete plastome sequences of Aquilaria are suitable for DNA barcoding applications including identifying species origin of agarwood products

Members of Aquilaria Lam. (Thymelaeaceae) are evergreen trees that are widely distributed in the Indomalesia region. Aquilaria is highly prized for its unique scented resin, agarwood, which is often the subject of unlawful trade activities. Survival of the tree is heavily threatened by destructive harvesting and agarwood poaching, leading to its protection under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES). Unfortunately, an efficient species identification method, which is crucial to aid in the conservation efforts of Aquilaria is lacking. Here, we described our search for a suitable specific DNA barcode for Aquilaria species using eight complete plastome sequences. We identified five highly variable regions (HVR) (matK-rps16, ndhF-rpl32, psbJ-petA, trnD, and trnT-trnL) in the plastomes. These regions were further analyzed using the neighbor-joining (NJ) method to assess their ability at discriminating the eight species. Coupled with in silico primer design, two potential barcoding regions, psbJ-petA and trnT-trnL, were identified. Their strengths in species delimitation were evaluated individually and in combination, via DNA barcoding analysis. Our findings showed that the combined dataset, psbJ-petA + trnT-trnL, effectively resolved members of the genus Aquilaria by clustering all species into their respective clades. In addition, we demonstrated that the newly proposed DNA barcode was capable at identifying the species of origin of six commercial agarwood samples that were included as unknown samples. Such achievement offers a new technical advancement, useful in the combat against illicit agarwood trades and in assisting the conservation of these valuable species in natural populations.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13205-023-03479-1.

Genetic relationship and source species identification of 58 Qi-Nan germplasms of Aquilaria species in China that easily form agarwood

Recently, Qi-Nan germplasm, the germplasm of Aquilaria species that easily forms agarwood, has been widely cultivated in Guangdong and Hainan Provinces in China. Since the morphological characteristics of Qi-Nan germplasm are similar to those of Aquilaria species and germplasm is bred by grafting, it is difficult to determine the source species of this germplasm by traditional taxonomic characteristics. In this study, we performed a DNA barcoding analysis of 58 major Qi-Nan germplasms as well as Aquilaria sinensis, A. yunnanensis, A. crassna, A. malaccensis and A. hirta with 5 primers (nuclear gene internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) and the chloroplast genes matK, trnH-psbA, rbcL and trnL-trnF). This field survey in the Qi-Nan germplasm plantations in Guangdong and Hainan Provinces aimed to accurately identify the source species of Qi-Nan germplasm. According to the results, ITS2 and matK showed the most variability and the highest divergence at all genetic distances. This ITS2+matK combination, screened for with TaxonDNA analysis, showed the highest success rate in species identification of the Qi-Nan germplasm. Clustering in the phylogenetic trees constructed with Bayesian inference and maximum likelihood indicated that the Qi-Nan germplasm was most closely related to A. sinensis and more distantly related to A. yunnanensis, A. crassna, A. malaccensis and A. hirta. Therefore, this study determined that the source species of the Qi-Nan germplasm is A. sinensis.

DNA databases of a CITES listed species Aquilaria malaccensis (Thymelaeaceae) as the tracking tools for forensic identification and chain of custody certification

Aquilaria malaccensis (Thymelaeaceae) is the main source of high-grade agarwood in Southeast Asia. Aggressive collections and trade activities over the past decades have put great pressure on the natural stands and raised concerns over the long-term survival potential of A. malaccensis. Tracking and authentication of agarwood require method with a high degree of accuracy. Therefore, this study aimed to develop DNA databases of A. malaccensis as the tracking tools at species, population and individual levels for forensic identification and chain of custody certification. Using two cpDNA (rbcL and matK) and an rDNA (ITS2) markers, species identification database of Aquilaria was developed to distinguish A. malaccensis from A. hirta, A. microcarpa, A. beccariana, A. crassna, A. sinensis and A. rostrata. In addition, based on 35 populations of A. malaccensis throughout Peninsular Malaysia, cpDNA haplotype and STR allele frequency databases were developed for population and individual identification. A haplotype distribution map based on 29 haplotypes derived from seven cpDNA showed that the A. malaccensis in Peninsular Malaysia can be associated to Kedah-Perak and Kelantan-Johor regions. Similarly, genetic relatedness and Bayesian clustering analyses based on 10 STR markers also divided the 35 populations into two main genetic clusters, corresponding to Kedah-Perak and Kelantan-Johor regions. The STR allele frequency databases were established and characterized according to these two regions. To determine the performance of the STR allele frequency databases for population identification, independent self-assignment tests showed that the percentage of individuals correctly assigned into the origin population was 93.88% in Kedah-Perak and 90.29% in Kelantan-Johor. For the STR allele frequency databases to be used for individual identification, conservativeness tests showed that the θ should be adjusted to 0.250 and 0.200 in the Kedah-Perak and Kelantan-Johor databases, respectively. To ensure consistency in allele calling for the dinucleotide repeat loci across different electrophoretic platforms or laboratories, allelic ladders have been developed for the 10 STR loci. Two case studies are presented of how these databases were used to track A. malaccensis to the origin population and stump. These databases are ready to be used to provide admissible forensic evidence for legal proceedings against the illegal harvesters of agarwood and for agarwood certification to meet the consumer country regulations.

Molecular identification of Aquilaria species with distribution records in China using DNA barcode technology

Aquilaria species is one of the main plant resources that produce agarwood, which containing black resin with important economic and medicinal values. There are about 15 species known to the genus around the world, but only two can be found in China, i.e. A. sinensis and A. yunnanensis. In this study, A. sinensis and A. yunnanensis that endemic respectively to Hainan and Yunnan were sampled, on the basis of the investigation and observation of their main morphological features in plantation. Five primers, i.e. ITS2, matK, trnL-trnF1, trnL-trnF2, and trnH-psbA, were eventually selected for DNA barcoding. The results showed that the seed surface of A. sinensis is smooth or sparsely pubescent, and the seed appendages were long. While the seed surface of A. yunnanensis is densely covered with yellow hairs and the seed appendages are short. The trnL-trnF1 sequence fragment has significant intraspecific and interspecific genetic distances. However, the species identification success rate of ITS2+matK combination was finally screened to be the highest, which was verified by the BBA method of TaxonDNA. The phylogenetic trees cluster analysis revealed that the classification of A. sinensis and A. yunnanensis is significant, and there is geographic isolation between the two species. Therefore, on the premise of accurate identification of plant morphological characters, ITS2+matK combination can be used to accurately identify the Aquilaria species in China.

DNA barcoding for identification of agarwood source species using trnL-trnF and matK DNA sequences

Agarwood is a type of resinous wood found in the trunks of Aquilaria, Gonystylus, and Gyrinops species [1]. High-quality agarwood is extraordinarily expensive and therefore its source plant species have become depleted due to exploitation. In 2005, these species were added to Appendix II of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora [1]. Because these wild agarwood resources have become depleted, commercial production of agarwood has long been a desirable goal. In addition, inauthentic agarwood is sometimes produced from non-agarwood species. Few reports have attempted to identify source species in order to distinguish genuine from false agarwood. In this study, DNA was extracted from putative agarwood samples collected from Japanese, Indonesian, Thai, and Vietnamese markets. The trnL-trnF region and matK gene were amplified from each sample by PCR to serve as DNA barcodes for identifying the plant species to which each sample belonged. One of the wood samples did not originate from a genuine agarwood species. Although some species were identified, sequence data for agarwood source species currently available in GenBank is insufficient to identify the species to which all of these putative agarwood samples belonged. Thus, positive identification of remaining samples will require further exploration.