The Neurologist as an Agent of Exercise Rehabilitation in Multiple Sclerosis

The Actionability of Physical Activity Guidelines for Multiple Sclerosis Care: A Systematic Review and AACTT Framework Analysis

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to conduct a systematic review of clinical guidelines, guidance documents and consensus statements regarding physical activity (PA) promotion by health care providers (HCPs) to people with multiple sclerosis (MS) and to assess the methodological quality, and actionability of the recommendations. The protocol was registered with Prospero (CRD42023495137).

DATA SOURCES

Clinical guidelines, guidance documents and consensus statements (hereafter guidelines) published in English between 2013 and 2023 were identified through extensive gray and scientific literature searches, and through contacting relevant HCP organizations in English speaking countries.

STUDY SELECTION

Two researchers independently screened titles and abstracts of the 939 identified records and included 19 guidelines, which were developed for PA promotion as part of MS clinical management and for which the target user was HCPs.

DATA EXTRACTION

Two researchers independently extracted data and appraised the methodological quality using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE-II). Behavioral actionability was analyzed using the Actor, Action, Context, Target and Time (AACTT) framework.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Seventy-eight recommendations from 19 guidelines were identified. Two guidelines had high methodological quality. Actor, Action, Context, Target and Time were clearly specified in 57 (73%), 45 (58%), 0 (0%), 51 (65%), and 24 (31%) of the 78 recommendations, respectively. Guidelines with the highest methodological quality did not always score well on actionability, and vice-versa.

CONCLUSIONS

Our comprehensive analysis of guidelines for PA promotion in MS reveals the need for more actionable recommendations and better reporting of guideline development, which has the potential to improve the translation of evidence into practice. .

Exercise as a Therapeutic Intervention in Multiple Sclerosis

The role of exercise as a therapeutic intervention in multiple sclerosis (MS) has shifted over time. Early views surrounding exercise in MS advocated for caution against participation. With increasing evidence, perspectives shifted to promote exercise as a therapeutic approach for symptom management. Recent efforts have focused on understanding the potential disease-modifying effects of exercise in MS, although this work is still in its infancy. While efforts continue to optimize exercise prescriptions and unravel underlying mechanisms of exercise effects, current knowledge and implementation gaps limit the accessibility of exercise as therapy for all people living with MS. This topical review is based on an invited presentation on 'Exercise as a Therapeutic Intervention in MS' delivered at the ACTRIMS Forum 2024. The review summarizes current evidence for the role of exercise as a therapeutic intervention in MS from symptomatic to disease-modifying potential. We highlight directions for future research efforts to advance our understanding of potential exercise benefits and translate findings into real-world contexts for people living with MS.

Exploring the relationship between neurologists and older persons with multiple sclerosis through the lens of social support theory

Background

Although healthcare practitioners (HCPs) are a valuable source of social support, research on support provided by neurologists to older persons with multiple sclerosis (pwMS) remains limited.

Objectives

To explore expectations of pwMS aged 55 years or older regarding MS care and to identify support types, met and unmet needs within their relationship with neurologists.

Methods

Utilizing a mixed-methods approach, we analyzed survey data from Swiss Multiple Sclerosis Registry participants. Quantitative data included Likert scales gauging the importance of various aspects of MS care for pwMS both in and out of neurological care. Qualitative data were derived from three open-ended questions, focusing on neurologist-provided support for pwMS in neurological care. Data underwent descriptive and deductive thematic analysis, using Cutrona and Suhr framework for coding social support.

Results

Among the 286 participants (median age 61.0 years, interquartile range (IQR) 57.0-66.0; median disease duration 23.5 years, IQR 15.0-31.0), 84.6% (N = 244) were under neurological care. Quantitative findings highlighted the significance of HCP expertise and consultation time. Qualitative analysis identified all social support domains in the neurologist-pwMS relationship, with informational support being most prevalent, followed by emotional support. Neurologists' expertise, availability, comprehensive advising, listening, and validation emerged as key themes. Unmet needs were relatively infrequent and concerned insufficient information on complementary medicine, empathy, and understanding of symptoms like fatigue.

Conclusions

Older pwMS see neurologists as adequate providers of comprehensive support and particularly value neurologists' sufficient availability, informational and emotional support. Areas for improvement include attention to complementary medicine and empathy.

Focusing on neural mechanisms of exercise training benefits in multiple sclerosis

Exercise training (ET) should be a mainstay of comprehensive care in multiple sclerosis (MS), yet there is reluctance regarding its implementation among healthcare providers. This reluctance has its roots in the lack of evidence from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that provide a neurobiological mechanism for beneficial outcomes. We argue that ET training is efficacious for improving mobility and cognitive dysfunction as hallmark consequences of MS, and propose an experimental medicine framework for guiding research focusing on CNS mechanisms-of-action for ET benefits. The framework establishes three hierarchical pathways as preconditions for applying a mediation framework in a fourth pathway for fully testing mechanistic research questions using a RCT. This paper describes the conceptual basis of the pathways, and then reviews the existing evidence within the pathways of the framework for ET effects on the CNS, mobility, and cognition in MS. Lastly, this paper discusses future directions and challenges for testing the pathways of the framework for advancing the evidence regarding CNS mechanisms of ET benefits in this population. Our objective is guiding the field toward evidence that facilitates the prescription and promotion of ET as a neurorestorative approach within MS clinical practice.

Updated Systematic Review and Quantitative Synthesis of Physical Activity Levels in Multiple Sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

This article provided an updated quantitative synthesis of physical activity levels in persons with multiple sclerosis compared with controls and other clinical populations.

DESIGN

A systematic search through PubMed, Scopus, and PsycINFO was conducted for articles published between August 2016 and July 2022. Articles that included a group comparison of at least one measurement of physical activity between adults with multiple sclerosis and controls or other clinical populations were included in the meta-analysis.

RESULTS

Twenty-four studies met the inclusion criteria and yielded a total of 119 comparisons. There was a moderate difference in physical activity levels between persons with multiple sclerosis and controls (effect size = -0.56, P < 0.01), but no significant difference between persons with multiple sclerosis and other clinical populations (effect size = 0.01, P = 0.90). The pooled effect sizes comparing multiple sclerosis with controls ( Q104 = 457.9, P < 0.01) as well as with clinical populations ( Q13 = 108.4, P < 0.01) were heterogeneous. Moderating variables included sex, disability status, measurement method, outcome, intensity, and application of a multiple sclerosis-specific cut-point.

CONCLUSIONS

Physical activity levels remain significantly lower in persons with multiple sclerosis compared with controls, but the magnitude of difference has become smaller over the past decade. There is a need for continued development of effective physical activity programs that can reach the greater community with multiple sclerosis.

The MoXFo initiative - adherence: Exercise adherence, compliance and sustainability among people with multiple sclerosis: An overview and roadmap for research

We know very little about exercise adherence, compliance and sustainability in multiple sclerosis (MS), yet adherence is seemingly important for yielding immediate and sustained health benefits. This paper is focused on exercise adherence, compliance and sustainability in the context of informing research and practice involving MS. This focus is critical for clarifying terminology for future research and providing a roadmap guiding clinical research and practice. Our objective was accomplished through a narrative summary of the literature by a panel of experts on exercise adherence from the Moving Exercise Research in Multiple Sclerosis Forward (MoXFo) initiative and a concluding summary of the state of the literature and future research directions. The panel of experts identified three overall themes (Background and Importance; Understanding and Promoting Exercise Adherence, Compliance and Sustainability and Challenges to Exercise Adherence, Compliance and Sustainability) that represented a categorization of nine subthemes. These overall themes and subthemes formed the basis of our recommendations regarding future research broadly involving exercise adherence in MS. Overall, there is limited evidence on rates and determinants of exercise adherence and compliance in MS, and little is known about techniques and interventions for immediate and long-term exercise behaviour change.

Neuroimaging Technology in Exercise Neurorehabilitation Research in Persons with MS: A Scoping Review

There is increasing interest in the application of neuroimaging technology in exercise neurorehabilitation research among persons with multiple sclerosis (MS). The inclusion and focus on neuroimaging outcomes in MS exercise training research is critical for establishing a biological basis for improvements in functioning and elevating exercise within the neurologist's clinical armamentarium alongside disease modifying therapies as an approach for treating the disease and its consequences. Indeed, the inclusion of selective neuroimaging approaches and sensor-based technology among physical activity, mobility, and balance outcomes in such MS research might further allow for detecting specific links between the brain and real-world behavior. This paper provided a scoping review on the application of neuroimaging in exercise training research among persons with MS based on searches conducted in PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus. We identified 60 studies on neuroimaging-technology-based (primarily MRI, which involved a variety of sequences and approaches) correlates of functions, based on multiple sensor-based measures, which are typically targets for exercise training trials in MS. We further identified 12 randomized controlled trials of exercise training effects on neuroimaging outcomes in MS. Overall, there was a large degree of heterogeneity whereby we could not identify definitive conclusions regarding a consistent neuroimaging biomarker of MS-related dysfunction or singular sensor-based measure, or consistent neural adaptation for exercise training in MS. Nevertheless, the present review provides a first step for better linking correlational and randomized controlled trial research for the development of high-quality exercise training studies on the brain in persons with MS, and this is timely given the substantial interest in exercise as a potential disease-modifying and/or neuroplasticity-inducing behavior in this population.

Lessons learned from clinical trials of exercise and physical activity in people with MS - guidance for improving the quality of future research

The body of research on exercise and physical activity among persons with multiple sclerosis(MS) has expanded rapidly in quantity, but not necessarily quality, over the past 20+ years. There is evidence for beneficial effects of exercise and physical activity on immune cells and neurotrophic factors, brain structure and function, walking and cognitive performance, fatigue, depression, and pain, and quality of life among persons with MS. Nevertheless, there is heterogeneity in the outcomes of exercise and physical activity, and a recognition of substantial challenges for improving the effectiveness of those behaviors in MS. To move the field forward, members of the National MS Society physical wellness research working-group pooled collective experiences for identifying challenges, logistic complexities, and opportunities for researchers in designing and conducting interventions of exercise and physical activity among persons with MS. We examined the scope of our experiences and identified collective "lessons learned" regarding the behaviors themselves; study design features and stage of research; study setting, safety, and sample selection; and implementation of randomized controlled trials(RCTs) and treatment fidelity. This paper provides a resource that can inform researchers, particularly new investigators or established investigators transitioning into MS, on conducting high-quality RCTs on exercise and physical activity in MS.

Do internet resources align with exercise training and physical activity guidelines for people with multiple sclerosis?

Background

Exercise training and lifestyle physical activity have been identified as evidence-based approaches for improving symptoms and quality of life among persons with multiple sclerosis (MS). Such evidence supported the development of physical activity guidelines (PAGs) for people with MS. The goal of such guidelines involved broad dissemination and uptake, as there is substantial evidence for low rates of participation in exercise training and physical activity in this population.

Objective

The current study evaluated the quality and consistency of information on webpages for physical activity against the established PAGs for people with MS.

Method

The search was conducted in September 2020 using the Google search engine for webpages containing physical activity information for people with MS. We evaluated the webpages with a list of 18 guidelines for adults with MS based on recommendations from three resources.

Results

The search yielded 157 webpages, of which 27 met the inclusion criteria. On average, webpages accurately addressed only 5 of the 18 guidelines. The most commonly addressed guidelines involved MS-specific symptom identification (n = 26), and example modalities for aerobic (n = 20) and strength (n = 16) training.

Conclusion

Many online recourses regarding physical activity and exercise training for MS were either inconsistent with the established PAGs or did not address the guidelines.