Role of mastoid obliteration in patients with persistent cavity problems following modified radical mastoidectomy

Mastoid obliteration and reconstruction techniques: A review of the literature

Objective

To review the published literature related to the different obliteration and reconstruction techniques in the management of the canal wall down mastoidectomy.

Methods

A PubMed (Medline) and LILACS databases as well as crossed references search was performed with the following Mesh terms: "cholesteatoma", "cholesteatoma-middle ear", "otitis media", "otitis media, suppurative", "mastoiditis", "mastoidectomy", "canal wall down mastoidectomy", "radical mastoidectomy", "mastoid obliteration" and crossed references. Inclusion criteria were adult patients subject to mastoid cavity obliteration and posterior canal wall reconstruction. The technique and materials used, anatomic and functional results, complications, recurrence rates, and changes in quality of life, were analyzed. A total of 94 articles were screened, 38 were included for full-text detailed review.

Results

Twenty-one articles fulfilled the inclusion criteria. Techniques and materials used for canal wall reconstruction, tympanoplasty, and ossiculoplasty were varied and included autologous, biosynthetic, or both. Auditory results were reported in 16 studies and were inconsistent. Three studies reported improvement in the quality of life using the GBI scale. Follow-up time ranged from 1 to 83 months. Eleven articles used imaging studies to evaluate postoperative disease recurrence. The highest recurrence rate reported for cholesteatoma after obliteration was 19%. The most frequently reported complications were retraction pockets and transient otorrhea.

Conclusion

Plenty of techniques combining grafts and other materials have been used to overcome mastoidectomy cavity problems. So far, it is still not possible to standardize an ideal procedure. The available level of evidence for this topic is low and limited.

The Role of Obliteration in the Achievement of a Dry Mastoid Bowl

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the impact of mastoid obliteration on the achievement of a dry mastoid bowl and frequency of maintenance care.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

Academic medical center.

PATIENTS

There were 63 canal-wall-down mastoidectomies for chronic otitis media with or without cholesteatoma between 2007 and 2014 with follow-up of at least 6 months. Eighteen mastoids were nonobliterated and 45 were obliterated. Thirteen underwent secondary obliteration of existing mastoid bowls with chronic drainage, whereas 32 underwent primary obliteration at the original canal-wall-down procedure.

INTERVENTION

Mastoid obliteration.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Achievement of a dry healed mastoid cavity and frequency of outpatient visits.

RESULTS

In more than 80% of the cases, a dry ear was achieved, with no significant difference between the obliterated and nonobliterated cases (p = 0.786). Eleven of the 13 secondary cases experienced cessation of otorrhea, achieving dry ears at rates similar to that of the primary and nonobliterated cases. The secondary obliteration population was also significantly younger than the primary group (22.1 versus 43.5 years, p = 0.002). Multivariable-mixed effects analysis demonstrated a reduction in 0.1 visits per 6-month period following surgery overtime (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Mastoid obliteration may be valuable in the management of the well-developed and chronically wet mastoid cavity, particularly when the drainage emanates from mucosal disease or cell tracts in a deep sinodural angle. Younger patients may require secondary obliteration because of continued craniofacial maturation several years following canal-wall-down surgery.

Partial mastoid obliteration combined with soft-wall reconstruction for middle ear cholesteatoma

OBJECTIVES

The objective was to analyze the surgical outcomes of tympanoplasty with partial mastoid obliteration and soft-wall reconstruction for middle ear cholesteatoma.

METHODS

Sixty-nine patients (73 ears) with fresh middle ear cholesteatomas, 42 men and 27 women aged 6 to 89 years, were retrospectively analyzed. The cholesteatomas were the pars flaccida and tensa types in 59 and 12 ears, respectively. The patients underwent canal-wall-down tympanoplasty with partial mastoid obliteration and soft-wall reconstruction. Follow-up computed tomography was performed 6 to 12 months after surgery. Hearing outcomes were evaluated by the arithmetic mean of the hearing levels at 500, 1000, and 2000 Hz.

RESULTS

Residual cholesteatoma occurred in 7 ears (9.6%) and recurrent cholesteatoma in 1 ear (1.4%). No cavity problem was seen. Primary evaluation of postoperative hearing was performed 6 to 12 months after ossiculoplasy. Of the 50 ears with available audiogram in this period, the postoperative air-bone gaps were ≤ 15 dB and ≤ 20 dB in 27 (54.0%) and 37 (74.0%) ears, respectively. The postoperative hearing level was within 30 dB in 22 ears (44.0%). The hearing gain was ≥ 15 dB in 24 ears (48.0%).

CONCLUSIONS

The surgical outcomes of tympanoplasty with partial mastoid obliteration and soft-wall reconstruction for middle ear cholesteatoma were satisfactory with a low incidence of cholesteatoma recidivism and tolerable postoperative hearing without cavity problems.

Chronic suppurative otitis media: a review

OBJECTIVES

Chronic suppurative otitis media (CSOM) remains one of the most common childhood chronic infectious diseases worldwide. Although microbial, immunological, and genetically determined factors, as well as Eustachian tube characteristics, are supposed to be involved in the pathogenesis of CSOM, many aspects of the pathogenesis of CSOM still need to be clarified. Optimal treatment strategy has not been established yet. The objective of this review is to present and evaluate the current state of knowledge of CSOM.

DESIGN

Systematic narrative review.

METHODS

A PubMed search (1966-January 2005) was performed for studies on epidemiology, pathogenesis, clinical management, and complications of CSOM. All included articles were categorized according to level of evidence.

RESULTS

Five hundred and fifty papers were identified, of which 79 were found to be relevant for this review. The definition of CSOM was found to vary. CSOM is a multifactorial disease. Regarding management of CSOM, there is no consensus as to what the optimal management strategy should entail. No convincing evidence is available for most medical and surgical therapies. Topical quinolones have proven effective, but need further monitoring regarding adverse effects.

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Important goals in research of CSOM should be achieving consensus about the definition of CSOM and gaining more in-depth knowledge of the pathogenesis of CSOM, especially the role of innate and adaptive immunity. There is also a need for further well-designed studies on the effectiveness of various management strategies for CSOM.

Relative humidity of the external auditory canal in normal and abnormal ears, and its pathogenic effect

OBJECTIVE

To find the relative humidity of the normal external ear canal and to demonstrate that the relative humidity of the external auditory canal was higher in abnormal ears, i.e. ears commonly associated with chronic discharge.

SETTING

Secondary health care within the ENT departments of Addenbrooke's and Hinchingbrooke hospitals.

DESIGN

A clinical observational study.

PARTICIPANTS

Volunteers seen in ENT outpatients. Inclusion criteria for the normal ear group, was a normal ear with no history of infection or previous ear disease. Inclusion criteria for abnormal ear group commonly associated with chronic discharge. Exclusion criteria were the presence of pus or infection within the ear canal.

METHOD

The relative humidity of the external ear canal was measured in normal and abnormal ears. Abnormal ears were grouped as those commonly associated with chronic discharge, mastoid cavities, tympanic perforations, recurrent otitis externa and hearing-aided ears.

RESULTS

The range of relative humidity of normal ears is 40-70%. The humidity in abnormal ears was found to be significantly higher than the humidity in normal ears (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

The raised relative humidity in the external canal may explain the predisposition of certain abnormal ears to chronic discharge and infection. If the humidity of the canal could be brought down to a normal level, this could offer a new therapeutic treatment.