Identification of the Hfq-binding site on DsrA RNA: Hfq binds without altering DsrA secondary structure

Unveiling the orchestration: mycobacterial small RNAs as key mediators in host-pathogen interactions

Small RNA (sRNA) molecules, a class of non-coding RNAs, have emerged as pivotal players in the regulation of gene expression and cellular processes. Mycobacterium tuberculosis and other pathogenic mycobacteria produce diverse small RNA species that modulate bacterial physiology and pathogenesis. Recent advances in RNA sequencing have enabled identification of novel small RNAs and characterization of their regulatory functions. This review discusses the multifaceted roles of bacterial small RNAs, covering their biogenesis, classification, and functional diversity. Small RNAs (sRNAs) play pivotal roles in orchestrating diverse cellular processes, ranging from gene silencing to epigenetic modifications, across a broad spectrum of organisms. While traditionally associated with eukaryotic systems, recent research has unveiled their presence and significance within bacterial domains as well. Unlike their eukaryotic counterparts, which primarily function within the context of RNA interference (RNAi) pathways, bacterial sRNAs predominantly act through base-pairing interactions with target mRNAs, leading to post-transcriptional regulation. This fundamental distinction underscores the necessity of elucidating the unique roles and regulatory mechanisms of bacterial sRNAs in bacterial adaptation and survival. By doing these myriad functions, they regulate bacterial growth, metabolism, virulence, and drug resistance. In Mycobacterium tuberculosis, apart from having various roles in the bacillus itself, small RNA molecules have emerged as key regulators of gene expression and mediators of host-pathogen interactions. Understanding sRNA regulatory networks in mycobacteria can drive our understanding of significant role they play in regulating virulence and adaptation to the host environment. Detailed functional characterization of Mtb sRNAs at the host-pathogen interface is required to fully elucidate the complex sRNA-mediated gene regulatory networks deployed by Mtb, to manipulate the host. A deeper understanding of this aspect could pave the development of novel diagnostic and therapeutic strategies for tuberculosis.

Hfq-Antisense RNA I Binding Regulates RNase E-Dependent RNA Stability and ColE1 Plasmid Copy Number

The mechanisms and consequences of gene regulation by Hfq on trans-encoded small RNAs (sRNAs) have been well studied and documented. Recent employment of Genomic SELEX to search for Hfq-binding motifs has indicated that Hfq might frequently regulate gene expression controlled by cis-antisense RNAs. Here, we use the classic ColE1 plasmid antisense RNA-based regulation model (i.e., RNA I) to study the role of Hfq in controlling antisense regulatory functions. We show that Hfq exhibits a high binding affinity for RNA I and that binding limits RNase E cleavage, thereby stabilizing RNA I and reducing the plasmid copy number. Full-length RNA I displays a binding affinity for Hfq in the sub-micromolar range. In vivo overexpression of Hfq prolongs RNA I stability and reduces the ColE1 plasmid copy number, whereas deletion of hfq reduces RNA I stability and increases the plasmid copy number. RNA I predominantly binds to the proximal face of Hfq and exhibits competitive ability against a chromosome-borne proximal face-bound sRNA (DsrA) for Hfq binding. Through its strong promoter and high gene dosage features, plasmid-encoded antisense RNA I results in high RNA I expression, so it may antagonize the effects of trans-encoded RNAs in controlling target gene expression.

Contribution of Hfq to gene regulation and virulence in Histophilus somni

Histophilus somni is one of the predominant bacterial pathogens responsible for bovine respiratory and systemic diseases in cattle. Despite the identification of numerous H. somni virulence factors, little is known about the regulation of such factors. The post-transcriptional regulatory protein Hfq may play a crucial role in regulation of components that affect bacterial virulence. The contribution of Hfq to H. somni phenotype and virulence was investigated following creation of an hfq deletion mutant of H. somni strain 2336 (designated H. somni 2336Δhfq). A comparative analysis of the mutant to the wild-type strain was carried out by examining protein and carbohydrate phenotype, RNA sequence, intracellular survival in bovine monocytes, serum susceptibility, and virulence studies in mouse and calf models. H. somni 2336Δhfq exhibited a truncated lipooligosaccharide (LOS) structure, with loss of sialylation. The mutant demonstrated increased susceptibility to intracellular and serum-mediated killing compared to the wild-type strain. Transcriptomic analysis displayed significant differential expression of 832 upregulated genes and 809 downregulated genes in H. somni 2336Δhfq compared to H. somni strain 2336, including significant downregulation of lsgB and licA, which contribute to LOS oligosaccharide synthesis and sialylation. A substantial number of differentially expressed genes were associated with polysaccharide synthesis and other proteins that could influence virulence. The H. somni 2336Δhfq mutant strain was attenuated in a mouse septicemia model and somewhat attenuated in a calf intrabronchial challenge model. H. somni was recovered less frequently from nasopharyngeal swabs, endotracheal aspirates, and lung tissues of calves challenged with H. somni 2336Δhfq compared to the wild-type strain, and the percentage of abnormal lung tissue in calves challenged with H. somni 2336Δhfq was lower than in calves challenged with the wild-type strain. In conclusion, our results support that Hfq accounts for the regulation of H. somni virulence factors.

The bacterial protein Hfq: Stable modifications and growth phase-dependent changes in SPAM profiles

In bacteria transcription is coupled to translation, and while it is broadly accepted that transcription-translation complexes (TTCs) are formed in growing bacterial cells, the exact spatial organization of these macromolecular assemblies is not known with certainty. Recent studies indicated the formation of orderly cytosolic superstructures in growing E. coli cells. The bacterial nucleic acid (NA)-binding protein Hfq has been shown to function at the interface of RNA synthesis-degradation machinery; multiple, independent studies link Hfq to orderly cytosolic assemblies. In this work, using fast cell lysis/2D-PAGE and in vitro reconstitution analyses we studied the Hfq modifications and small protein-associated molecules (SPAM). We demonstrate that native Hfq carries stable modifications and simulate 2D patterns of native Hfq-SPAM complexes in reconstitution experiments with purified Hfq and synthetic NA probes. We also demonstrate that genetically engineered Hfq lacking the conserved arginine residues positioned near the rim of the disc formed by the subunits' N-terminal domains binds DNA with a reduced affinity in comparison with wild-type Hfq. These results are consistent with the proposed Hfq-mediated DNA remodeling and point to the involvement of this patch of conserved arginines in interactions with DNA.

RNA-based fluorescent biosensors for live cell detection of bacterial sRNA

Bacteria contain a diverse set of RNAs to provide tight regulation of gene expression in response to environmental stimuli. Bacterial small RNAs (sRNAs) work in conjunction with protein cofactors to bind complementary mRNA sequences in the cell, leading to up- or downregulation of protein synthesis. In vivo imaging of sRNAs can aid in understanding their spatiotemporal dynamics in real time, which inspires new ways to manipulate these systems for a variety of applications including synthetic biology and therapeutics. Current methods for sRNA imaging are quite limited in vivo and do not provide real-time information about fluctuations in sRNA levels. Herein, we describe our efforts toward the development of an RNA-based fluorescent biosensor for bacterial sRNA both in vitro and in vivo. We validated these sensors for three different bacterial sRNAs in Escherichia coli and demonstrated that the designs provide a bright, sequence-specific signal output in response to exogenous and endogenous RNA targets.

sRNA-mediated control in bacteria: An increasing diversity of regulatory mechanisms

Small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) act as post-transcriptional regulators controlling bacterial adaptation to environmental changes. Our current understanding of the mechanisms underlying sRNA-mediated control is mainly based on studies in Escherichia coli and Salmonella. Ever since the discovery of sRNAs decades ago, these Gram-negative species have served as excellent model organisms in the field of sRNA biology. More recently, the role of sRNAs in gene regulation has become the center of attention in a broader range of species, including Gram-positive model organisms. Here, we highlight some of the most apparent similarities and differences between Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria with respect to the mechanisms underlying sRNA-mediated control. Although key aspects of sRNA regulation appear to be highly conserved, novel themes are arising from studies in Gram-positive species, such as a clear abundance of sRNAs acting through multiple C-rich motifs, and an apparent lack of RNA-binding proteins with chaperone activity.

Quantitative Analysis of RNA Chaperone Activity by Native Gel Electrophoresis and Fluorescence Spectroscopy

Diverse types of RNA-binding proteins chaperone the interactions of noncoding RNAs by increasing the rate of RNA base pairing and by stabilizing the final RNA duplex. The E. coli protein Hfq facilitates interactions between small noncoding RNAs and their target mRNAs. The chaperone and RNA annealing activity of Hfq and other RNA chaperones can be evaluated by determining the kinetics of RNA base pairing in the presence and absence of the protein. This chapter presents protocols for measuring RNA annealing kinetics using electrophoretic gel mobility shift assays (EMSA), stopped-flow fluorescence, and fluorescence anisotropy. EMSA is low cost and can resolve reaction intermediates of natural small RNAs and mRNA fragments, as long as the complexes are sufficiently long-lived (≥10 s) to be trapped during electrophoresis. Stopped-flow fluorescence can detect annealing reactions between 1 ms and 30 s and is best suited for measuring the rapid annealing of oligoribonucleotides. Fluorescence anisotropy reports the physical size of the complex and is well-suited for monitoring the association and dissociation of RNA from Hfq during the chaperone cycle.

Broad-Spectrum Gene Repression Using Scaffold Engineering of Synthetic sRNAs

Gene expression regulation in broad-spectrum range is critical for constructing cell factories and genetic circuits to balance and control system-wide fluxes. Synthetic small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) effectively regulate gene expression at the translational level by modulating an mRNA-binding chance and sRNA abundance; however, it can control target gene expression only within the limit of the intrinsic repression ability of sRNAs. Here, we systematically mutated a SgrS scaffold as a model sRNA by dividing the Hfq-binding module of the sRNA into the three regions: the A/U-rich sequence, the stem, and the hairpin loop, and examined how efficiently the mutants suppressed DsRed2 expression. By doing this, we found that a scaffold with an altered A/U-rich sequence (CUUU) and stem length and that with altered A/U-rich sequence (GCAC) showed a 3-fold stronger and a 3-fold weaker repression than the original scaffold, respectively. For practical application of altered scaffolds, proof-of-concept experiments were performed by constructing a library of 67 synthetic sRNAs with the strongest scaffold, each one targeting a different rationally selected gene, and using this library to enhance cadaverine production in Escherichia coli, yielding in 27% increase (1.67 g/L in flask cultivation, 13.7 g/L in fed-batch cultivation). Synthetic sRNAs with engineered sRNA scaffolds could be useful in modulating gene expression for strain improvement.

Proteins That Chaperone RNA Regulation

RNA-binding proteins chaperone the biological functions of noncoding RNA by reducing RNA misfolding, improving matchmaking between regulatory RNA and targets, and exerting quality control over RNP biogenesis. Recent studies of Escherichia coli CspA, HIV NCp, and E. coli Hfq are beginning to show how RNA-binding proteins remodel RNA structures. These different protein families use common strategies for disrupting or annealing RNA double helices, which can be used to understand the mechanisms by which proteins chaperone RNA-dependent regulation in bacteria.

Excisionase in Pf filamentous prophage controls lysis-lysogeny decision-making in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Pf filamentous prophages are prevalent among clinical and environmental Pseudomonasaeruginosa isolates. Pf4 and Pf5 prophages are integrated into the host genomes of PAO1 and PA14, respectively, and play an important role in biofilm development. However, the genetic factors that directly control the lysis‐lysogeny switch in Pf prophages remain unclear. Here, we identified and characterized the excisionase genes in Pf4 and Pf5 (named xisF4 and xisF5, respectively). XisF4 and XisF5 represent two major subfamilies of functional excisionases and are commonly found in Pf prophages. While both of them can significantly promote prophage excision, only XisF5 is essential for Pf5 excision. XisF4 activates Pf4 phage replication by upregulating the phage initiator gene (PA0727). In addition, xisF4 and the neighboring phage repressor c gene pf4r are transcribed divergently and their 5′‐untranslated regions overlap. XisF4 and Pf4r not only auto‐activate their own expression but also repress each other. Furthermore, two H‐NS family proteins, MvaT and MvaU, coordinately repress Pf4 production by directly repressing xisF4. Collectively, we reveal that Pf prophage excisionases cooperate in controlling lysogeny and phage production.

A novel riboregulator switch system of gene expression for enhanced microbial production of succinic acid

In this paper, a novel riboregulator Switch System of Gene Expression including an OFF-TO-ON switch and an ON-TO-OFF switch was designed to regulate the expression state of target genes between "ON" and "OFF" by switching the identifiability of ribosome recognition site (RBS) based on the thermodynamic stability of different RNA-RNA hybridizations between RBS and small noncoding RNAs. The proposed riboregulator switch system was employed for the fermentative production of succinic acid using an engineered strain of E. coli JW1021, during which the expression of mgtC gene was controlled at "ON" state and that of pepc and ecaA genes were controlled at the "OFF" state in the lag phase and switched to the "OFF" and "ON" state once the strain enters the logarithmic phase. The results showed that using the strain of JW1021, the yield and productivity of succinic acid can reach 0.91 g g^-1 and 3.25 g L^-1 h^-1, respectively, much higher than those using the strains without harboring the riboregulator switch system.

The role of Hfq in regulation of lipA expression in Pseudomonas protegens Pf-5

Pseudomonas lipase is a well-studied lipase. However, few studies have been conducted to examine the mechanisms underlying the regulation of the lipase expression. Hfq is a global regulatory protein that, among others, controls the expression of multiple genes, regulate bacterial peristalsis, and participates in the regulation of quorum-sensing (QS) system. In this study, the effects of Hfq on lipase expression were investigated by knocking out the hfq and rsmY genes or overexpressing of hfq and rsmY genes. We found that Hfq regulates the expression of lipA at both transcriptional and translational levels. The translational level was the main regulatory level of lipA. Hfq also regulates the expression and stability of rsmY. Additionally, using hfq/rsmY double gene knock-out, we showed that Hfq can directly bind to the rsmY to regulate lipA activity. In conclusion, our results indicate that Hfq regulates the expression of rsmY mainly at the translational level to influence the expression of lipA in Pseudomonas protegens Pf-5.

Functional analyses of putative PalS (Palindromic Self-recognition) motifs in bacterial Hfq

The bacterial protein Hfq has been linked to nucleic acid metabolism and signaling, however its explicit role has been elusive. Recently it was proposed that the C-termini of Hfq subunits in Hfq₆ complexes could be involved in functional interactions with other Hfq hexamers and/or nucleic acids. To test the proposed model of the native Hfq complex experimentally, we genetically engineered chimeric Hfq₆ complexes, in which C-termini of bacterial Hfq subunits were substituted with a sequence derived from human histone H2B (hH2B) that includes multiple functionally significant amino acids whose modifications have been linked to carcinogenesis. We demonstrate that this substitution results in an enhanced formation of dodecameric assemblies by the Hfq-hH2B hybrid - a result pointing to the possibility of a (functional) homology between these motifs in proteins from distant kingdoms. We hypothesize that these putative Palindromic Self-recognition (PalS) motifs could act as proteins' 'cohesive ends' that could allow the protein complexes carrying such motifs to interact dynamically and dissociate-reassociate in response to stress and/or growth phase-specific changes. We provide experimental support to the latter hypothesis and demonstrate that in E. coli the dodecameric Hfq assemblies are formed in a growth stage-specific manner. We describe a refined system - consisting solely of purified Hfq, polynucleotide phosporylase (PNP) and ADP - that allows reconstitution in vitro of characteristic 'SDS-insensitive' Hfq₆-Hfq₆ assemblies observed in experiments with whole-cell extracts obtained from exponentially-growing cells. We also optimized conditions for the extraction of intact native dodecameric Hfq complexes.

C-terminal domain of the RNA chaperone Hfq drives sRNA competition and release of target RNA

The bacterial Sm protein and RNA chaperone Hfq stabilizes small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) and facilitates their annealing to mRNA targets involved in stress tolerance and virulence. Although an arginine patch on the Sm core is needed for Hfq's RNA chaperone activity, the function of Hfq's intrinsically disordered C-terminal domain (CTD) has remained unclear. Here, we use stopped flow spectroscopy to show that the CTD of Escherichia coli Hfq is not needed to accelerate RNA base pairing but is required for the release of dsRNA. The Hfq CTD also mediates competition between sRNAs, offering a kinetic advantage to sRNAs that contact both the proximal and distal faces of the Hfq hexamer. The change in sRNA hierarchy caused by deletion of the Hfq CTD in E. coli alters the sRNA accumulation and the kinetics of sRNA regulation in vivo. We propose that the Hfq CTD displaces sRNAs and annealed sRNA⋅mRNA complexes from the Sm core, enabling Hfq to chaperone sRNA-mRNA interactions and rapidly cycle between competing targets in the cell.

Hfq assists small RNAs in binding to the coding sequence of ompD mRNA and in rearranging its structure

The bacterial protein Hfq participates in the regulation of translation by small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs). Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain the role of Hfq in the regulation by sRNAs binding to the 5'-untranslated mRNA regions. However, it remains unknown how Hfq affects those sRNAs that target the coding sequence. Here, the contribution of Hfq to the annealing of three sRNAs, RybB, SdsR, and MicC, to the coding sequence of Salmonella ompD mRNA was investigated. Hfq bound to ompD mRNA with tight, subnanomolar affinity. Moreover, Hfq strongly accelerated the rates of annealing of RybB and MicC sRNAs to this mRNA, and it also had a small effect on the annealing of SdsR. The experiments using truncated RNAs revealed that the contributions of Hfq to the annealing of each sRNA were individually adjusted depending on the structures of interacting RNAs. In agreement with that, the mRNA structure probing revealed different structural contexts of each sRNA binding site. Additionally, the annealing of RybB and MicC sRNAs induced specific conformational changes in ompD mRNA consistent with local unfolding of mRNA secondary structure. Finally, the mutation analysis showed that the long AU-rich sequence in the 5'-untranslated mRNA region served as an Hfq binding site essential for the annealing of sRNAs to the coding sequence. Overall, the data showed that the functional specificity of Hfq in the annealing of each sRNA to the ompD mRNA coding sequence was determined by the sequence and structure of the interacting RNAs.

Acidic Residues in the Hfq Chaperone Increase the Selectivity of sRNA Binding and Annealing

Hfq facilitates gene regulation by small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs), thereby affecting bacterial attributes such as biofilm formation and virulence. Escherichia coli Hfq recognizes specific U-rich and AAN motifs in sRNAs and target mRNAs, after which an arginine patch on the rim promotes base pairing between their complementary sequences. In the cell, Hfq must discriminate between many similar RNAs. Here, we report that acidic amino acids lining the sRNA binding channel between the inner pore and rim of the Hfq hexamer contribute to the selectivity of Hfq's chaperone activity. RNase footprinting, in vitro binding and stopped-flow fluorescence annealing assays showed that alanine substitution of D9, E18 or E37 strengthened RNA interactions with the rim of Hfq and increased annealing of non-specific or U-tailed RNA oligomers. Although the mutants were less able than wild-type Hfq to anneal sRNAs with wild-type rpoS mRNA, the D9A mutation bypassed recruitment of Hfq to an (AAN)4 motif in rpoS, both in vitro and in vivo. These results suggest that acidic residues normally modulate access of RNAs to the arginine patch. We propose that this selectivity limits indiscriminate target selection by E. coli Hfq and enforces binding modes that favor genuine sRNA and mRNA pairs.

Structure of bacterial regulatory RNAs determines their performance in competition for the chaperone protein Hfq

Bacterial regulatory RNAs require the chaperone protein Hfq to enable their pairing to mRNAs. Recent data showed that there is a hierarchy among sRNAs in the competition for access to Hfq, which could be important for the tuning of sRNA-dependent translation regulation. Here, seven structurally different sRNAs were compared using filter-based competition assays. Moreover, chimeric sRNA constructs were designed to identify structure elements important for competition performance. The data showed that besides the 3'-terminal oligouridine sequences also the 5'-terminal structure elements of sRNAs were essential for their competition performance. When the binding of sRNAs to Hfq mutants was compared, the data showed the important role of the proximal and rim sites of Hfq for the binding of six out of seven sRNAs. However, ChiX sRNA, which was the most efficient competitor, bound Hfq in a unique way using the opposite-distal and proximal-faces of this ring-shaped protein. The data indicated that the simultaneous binding to the opposite faces of Hfq was enabled by separate adenosine-rich and uridine-rich sequences in the long, single-stranded region of ChiX. Overall, the results suggest that the individual structural composition of sRNAs serves to tune their performance to different levels resulting in a hierarchy of sRNAs in the competition for access to the Hfq protein.

Improving the gene-regulation ability of small RNAs by scaffold engineering in Escherichia coli

Noncoding small RNAs are involved in transcriptional and post-transcriptional gene regulation of target mRNAs by modulating mRNA elongation, stability, or translational efficiency. Many natural trans-encoded small RNAs contain a scaffold that allows binding of the RNA chaperone protein Hfq for conditional gene regulation. Here, we improved the gene regulation abilities of small RNAs by directly fusing the natural Escherichia coli trans-encoded small RNA-derived scaffolds, including Hfq-binding and rho-independent transcription terminator sequences, to the 3' end of the small RNAs that mediate RNA-based gene regulation. As target small RNAs to improve their gene regulation abilities, we selected small RNAs of artificial post-transcriptional riboregulators and transcriptional attenuators. Four different small RNA scaffolds were fused to the riboregulator and attenuator-derived small RNAs. Mutations were introduced into the best small RNA scaffold to improve its gene-regulation ability further. As a result, mutations predicted to stabilize the secondary structures of the small RNA scaffolds dramatically increased its ability to regulate gene expression of both the post-transcriptional riboregulator and transcriptional attenuator systems. We believe our engineered small RNA scaffolds are applicable to other RNA regulators for improving regulatory activity, and engineered small RNA scaffolds may present a valuable strategy to regulate target gene expression strongly.

Duplex formation between the sRNA DsrA and rpoS mRNA is not sufficient for efficient RpoS synthesis at low temperature

At low temperatures the Escherichia coli rpoS mRNA, encoding the stationary phase sigma factor RpoS, forms an intramolecular secondary structure (iss) that impedes translation initiation. Under these conditions the small RNA DsrA, which is stabilzed by Hfq, forms a duplex with rpoS mRNA sequences opposite of the ribosome-binding site (rbs). Both the DEAD box helicase CsdA and Hfq have been implicated in DsrA·rpoS duplex formation. Hfq binding to A-rich sequences in the rpoS leader has been suggested to restructure the mRNA, and thereby to accelerate DsrA·rpoS duplex formation, which, in turn, was deemed to free the rpoS rbs and to permit ribosome loading on the mRNA. Several experiments designed to elucidate the role of Hfq in DsrA-mediated translational activation of rpoS mRNA have been conducted in vitro. Here, we assessed RpoS synthesis in vivo to further study the role of Hfq in rpoS regulation. We show that RpoS synthesis was reduced when DsrA was ectopically overexpressed at 24 °C in the absence of Hfq despite of DsrA·rpoS duplex formation. This observation indicated that DsrA·rpoS annealing may not be sufficient for efficient ribosome loading on rpoS mRNA. In addition, a HfqG29A mutant protein was employed, which is deficient in binding to A-rich sequences present in the rpoS leader but proficient in DsrA binding. We show that DsrA·rpoS duplex formation occurs in the presence of the HfqG29A mutant protein at low temperature, whereas synthesis of RpoS was greatly diminished. RNase T1 footprinting studies of DsrA·rpoS duplexes in the absence and presence of Hfq or HfqG29A indicated that Hfq is required to resolve a stem-loop structure in the immediate coding region of rpoS mRNA. These in vivo studies corroborate the importance of the A-rich sequences in the rpoS leader and strongly suggest that Hfq, besides stabilizing DsrA and accelerating DsrA·rpoS duplex formation, is also required to convert the rpoS mRNA into a translationally competent form.

Hfq binding changes the structure of Escherichia coli small noncoding RNAs OxyS and RprA, which are involved in the riboregulation of rpoS

OxyS and RprA are two small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) that modulate the expression of rpoS, encoding an alternative sigma factor that activates transcription of multiple Escherichia coli stress-response genes. While RprA activates rpoS for translation, OxyS down-regulates the transcript. Crucially, the RNA binding protein Hfq is required for both sRNAs to function, although the specific role played by Hfq remains unclear. We have investigated RprA and OxyS interactions with Hfq using biochemical and biophysical approaches. In particular, we have obtained the molecular envelopes of the Hfq-sRNA complexes using small-angle scattering methods, which reveal key molecular details. These data indicate that Hfq does not substantially change shape upon complex formation, whereas the sRNAs do. We link the impact of Hfq binding, and the sRNA structural changes induced, to transcript stability with respect to RNase E degradation. In light of these findings, we discuss the role of Hfq in the opposing regulatory functions played by RprA and OxyS in rpoS regulation.

Conserved arginines on the rim of Hfq catalyze base pair formation and exchange

The Sm-like protein Hfq is required for gene regulation by small RNAs (sRNAs) in bacteria and facilitates base pairing between sRNAs and their mRNA targets. The proximal and distal faces of the Hfq hexamer specifically bind sRNA and mRNA targets, but they do not explain how Hfq accelerates the formation and exchange of RNA base pairs. Here, we show that conserved arginines on the outer rim of the hexamer that are known to interact with sRNA bodies are required for Hfq’s chaperone activity. Mutations in the arginine patch lower the ability of Hfq to act in sRNA regulation of rpoS translation and eliminate annealing of natural sRNAs or unstructured oligonucleotides, without preventing binding to either the proximal or distal face. Stopped-flow FRET and fluorescence anisotropy show that complementary RNAs transiently form a ternary complex with Hfq, but the RNAs are not released as a double helix in the absence of rim arginines. RNAs bound to either face of Hfq quench the fluorescence of a tryptophan adjacent to the arginine patch, demonstrating that the rim can simultaneously engage two RNA strands. We propose that the arginine patch overcomes entropic and electrostatic barriers to helix nucleation and constitutes the active site for Hfq’s chaperone function.

Identifying and characterizing Hfq-RNA interactions

To regulate stress responses and virulence, bacteria use small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs). These RNAs can up or down regulate target mRNAs through base pairing by influencing ribosomal access and RNA decay. A large class of these sRNAs, called trans-encoded sRNAs, requires the RNA binding protein Hfq to facilitate base pairing between the regulatory RNA and its target mRNA. The resulting network of regulation is best characterized in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, but the importance of Hfq dependent sRNA regulation is recognized in a diverse population of bacteria. In this review we present the approaches and methods used to discover Hfq binding RNAs, characterize their interactions and elucidate their functions.

Hfq restructures RNA-IN and RNA-OUT and facilitates antisense pairing in the Tn10/IS10 system

Hfq functions in post-transcriptional gene regulation in a wide range of bacteria, usually by promoting base-pairing of mRNAs and trans-encoded sRNAs that share partial sequence complementarity. It is less clear if Hfq is required for pairing of cis-encoded RNAs (i.e., antisense RNAs) with their target mRNAs. In the current work, we have characterized the interactions between Escherichia coli Hfq and the components of the Tn10/IS10 antisense system, RNA-IN and RNA-OUT. We show that Hfq interacts with RNA-OUT through its proximal RNA-binding surface, as is typical for Hfq and trans-encoded sRNAs. In contrast, RNA-IN binds both proximal and distal RNA-binding surfaces in Hfq with a higher affinity for the latter, as is typical for mRNA interactions in canonical sRNA-mRNA pairs. Importantly, an amino acid substitution in Hfq that interferes with RNA binding to the proximal site negatively impacts RNA-IN:OUT pairing in vitro and suppresses the ability of Hfq to negatively regulate IS10 transposition in vivo. We also show that Hfq binding to RNA-IN and RNA-OUT alters secondary structure elements in both of these RNAs and speculate that this could be important in how Hfq facilitates RNA-IN:OUT pairing. Based on the results presented here, we suggest that Hfq could be involved in regulating RNA pairing in other antisense systems, including systems encoded by other transposable elements.

Hfq-bridged ternary complex is important for translation activation of rpoS by DsrA

The rpoS mRNA, which encodes the master regulator σ(S) of general stress response, requires Hfq-facilitated base pairing with DsrA small RNA for efficient translation at low temperatures. It has recently been proposed that one mechanism underlying Hfq action is to bridge a transient ternary complex by simultaneously binding to rpoS and DsrA. However, no structural evidence of Hfq simultaneously bound to different RNAs has been reported. We detected simultaneous binding of Hfq to rpoS and DsrA fragments. Crystal structures of AU6A•Hfq•A7 and Hfq•A7 complexes were resolved using 1.8- and 1.9-Å resolution, respectively. Ternary complex has been further verified in solution by NMR. In vivo, activation of rpoS translation requires intact Hfq, which is capable of bridging rpoS and DsrA simultaneously into ternary complex. This ternary complex possibly corresponds to a meta-stable transition state in Hfq-facilitated small RNA-mRNA annealing process.

Archaeal and eukaryotic homologs of Hfq: A structural and evolutionary perspective on Sm function

Hfq and other Sm proteins are central in RNA metabolism, forming an evolutionarily conserved family that plays key roles in RNA processing in organisms ranging from archaea to bacteria to human. Sm-based cellular pathways vary in scope from eukaryotic mRNA splicing to bacterial quorum sensing, with at least one step in each of these pathways being mediated by an RNA-associated molecular assembly built upon Sm proteins. Though the first structures of Sm assemblies were from archaeal systems, the functions of Sm-like archaeal proteins (SmAPs) remain murky. Our ignorance about SmAP biology, particularly vis-à-vis the eukaryotic and bacterial Sm homologs, can be partly reduced by leveraging the homology between these lineages to make phylogenetic inferences about Sm functions in archaea. Nevertheless, whether SmAPs are more eukaryotic (RNP scaffold) or bacterial (RNA chaperone) in character remains unclear. Thus, the archaeal domain of life is a missing link, and an opportunity, in Sm-based RNA biology.

Structure and RNA-binding properties of the bacterial LSm protein Hfq

Over the past years, small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs) emerged as important modulators of gene expression in bacteria. Guided by partial sequence complementarity, these sRNAs interact with target mRNAs and eventually affect transcript stability and translation. The physiological function of sRNAs depends on the protein Hfq, which binds sRNAs in the cell and promotes the interaction with their mRNA targets. This important physiological function of Hfq as a central hub of sRNA-mediated regulation made it one of the most intensely studied proteins in bacteria. Recently, a new model for sRNA binding by Hfq has been proposed that involves the direct recognition of the sRNA 3' end and interactions of the sRNA body with the lateral RNA-binding surface of Hfq. This review summarizes the current understanding of the RNA binding properties of Hfq and its (s)RNA complexes. Moreover, the implications of the new binding model for sRNA-mediated regulation are discussed.

Bacterial small RNA-based negative regulation: Hfq and its accomplices

A large group of bacterial small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) use the Hfq chaperone to mediate pairing with and regulation of mRNAs. Recent findings help to clarify how Hfq acts and highlight the role of the endonuclease RNase E and its associated proteins (the degradosome) in negative regulation by these sRNAs. sRNAs frequently uncouple transcription and translation by blocking ribosome access to the mRNA, allowing other proteins access to the mRNA. As more examples of sRNA-mediated regulation are studied, more variations on how Hfq, RNase E, and other proteins collaborate to bring about sRNA-based regulation are being found.

Identification of small RNAs in Mycobacterium smegmatis using heterologous Hfq

Gene regulation by small RNAs (sRNAs) has been extensively studied in various bacteria. However, the presence and roles of sRNAs in mycobacteria remain largely unclear. Immunoprecipitation of RNA chaperone Hfq to enrich for sRNAs is one of the effective methods to isolate sRNAs. However, the lack of an identified mycobacterial hfq restricts the feasibility of this approach. We developed a novel method that takes advantage of the conserved inherent sRNAs-binding capability of heterologous Hfq from Escherichia coli to enrich sRNAs from Mycobacterium smegmatis, a model organism for studying Mycobacterium tuberculosis. We validated 12 trans-encoded and 12 cis-encoded novel sRNAs in M. smegmatis. Many of these sRNAs are differentially expressed at exponential phase compared with stationary phase, suggesting that sRNAs are involved in the growth of mycobacteria. Intriguingly, five of the cis-encoded novel sRNAs target known transposases. Phylogenetic conservation analysis shows that these sRNAs are pathogenicity dependent. We believe that our findings will serve as an important reference for future analysis of sRNAs regulation in mycobacteria and will contribute significantly to the development of sRNAs prediction programs. Moreover, this novel method of using heterologous Hfq for sRNAs enrichment can be of general use for the discovery of bacterial sRNAs in which no endogenous Hfq is identified.

Study of E. coli Hfq's RNA annealing acceleration and duplex destabilization activities using substrates with different GC-contents

Folding of RNA molecules into their functional three-dimensional structures is often supported by RNA chaperones, some of which can catalyse the two elementary reactions helix disruption and helix formation. Hfq is one such RNA chaperone, but its strand displacement activity is controversial. Whereas some groups found Hfq to destabilize secondary structures, others did not observe such an activity with their RNA substrates. We studied Hfq’s activities using a set of short RNAs of different thermodynamic stabilities (GC-contents from 4.8% to 61.9%), but constant length. We show that Hfq’s strand displacement as well as its annealing activity are strongly dependent on the substrate’s GC-content. However, this is due to Hfq’s preferred binding of AU-rich sequences and not to the substrate’s thermodynamic stability. Importantly, Hfq catalyses both annealing and strand displacement with comparable rates for different substrates, hinting at RNA strand diffusion and annealing nucleation being rate-limiting for both reactions. Hfq’s strand displacement activity is a result of the thermodynamic destabilization of the RNA through preferred single-strand binding whereas annealing acceleration is independent from Hfq’s thermodynamic influence. Therefore, the two apparently disparate activities annealing acceleration and duplex destabilization are not in energetic conflict with each other.

Structural flexibility of RNA as molecular basis for Hfq chaperone function

In enteric bacteria, many small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) associate with the RNA chaperone host factor Q (Hfq) and often require the protein for regulation of target mRNAs. Previous studies suggested that the hexameric Escherichia coli Hfq (Hfq(Ec)) binds sRNAs on the proximal site, whereas the distal site has been implicated in Hfq-mRNA interactions. Employing a combination of small angle X-ray scattering, nuclear magnetic resonance and biochemical approaches, we report the structural analysis of a 1:1 complex of Hfq(Ec) with a 34-nt-long subsequence of a natural substrate sRNA, DsrA (DsrA(34)). This sRNA is involved in post-transcriptional regulation of the E. coli rpoS mRNA encoding the stationary phase sigma factor RpoS. The molecular envelopes of Hfq(Ec) in complex with DsrA(34) revealed an overall asymmetric shape of the complex in solution with the protein maintaining its doughnut-like structure, whereas the extended DsrA(34) is flexible and displays an ensemble of different spatial arrangements. These results are discussed in terms of a model, wherein the structural flexibility of RNA ligands bound to Hfq stochastically facilitates base pairing and provides the foundation for the RNA chaperone function inherent to Hfq.

Hfq proximity and orientation controls RNA annealing

Regulation of bacterial gene networks by small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs) requires base pairing with messenger RNA (mRNA) targets, which is facilitated by Hfq protein. Hfq is recruited to sRNAs and mRNAs through U-rich- and A-rich-binding sites, respectively, but their distance from the sRNA–mRNA complementary region varies widely among different genes. To determine whether distance and binding orientation affect Hfq’s chaperone function, we engineered ‘toy’ RNAs containing strong Hfq-binding sites at defined distances from the complementary target site. We show that RNA annealing is fastest when the distal face of Hfq binds an A-rich sequence immediately 3′ of the target. This recruitment advantage is lost when Hfq binds >20 nt away from the target, but is partially restored by secondary structure that shortens this distance. Although recruitment through Hfq’s distal face accelerates RNA annealing, tight binding of six Us to Hfq’s proximal face inhibits annealing. Finally, we show that ectopic A-rich motifs dramatically accelerate base pairing between DsrA sRNA and a minimal rpoS mRNA in the presence of Hfq, demonstrating that proximity and orientation predict the activity of Hfq on long RNAs.

Requirement of upstream Hfq-binding (ARN)x elements in glmS and the Hfq C-terminal region for GlmS upregulation by sRNAs GlmZ and GlmY

Hfq is an important RNA-binding protein that helps bacteria adapt to stress. Its primary function is to promote pairing between trans-acting small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs) and their target mRNAs. Identification of essential Hfq-binding motifs in up-stream regions of rpoS and fhlA led us to ask the question whether these elements are a common occurrence among other Hfq-dependent mRNAs as well. Here, we confirm the presence of a similar (ARN)_x motif in glmS RNA, a gene controlled by two sRNAs (GlmZ and GlmY) in an Hfq-dependent manner. GlmZ represents a canonical sRNA:mRNA pairing system, whereas GlmY is non-canonical, interfacing with the RNA processing protein YhbJ. We show that glmS interacts with both Hfq-binding surfaces in the absence of sRNAs. Even though two (ARN)_x motifs are present, using a glmS:gfp fusion system, we determined that only one specific (ARN)_x element is essential for regulation. Furthermore, we show that residues 66–72 in the C-terminal extension of Escherichia coli Hfq are essential for activation of GlmS expression by GlmY, but not with GlmZ. This result shows that the C-terminal extension of Hfq may be required for some forms of non-canonical sRNA regulation involving ancillary components such as additional RNAs or proteins.

Small RNA binding to the lateral surface of Hfq hexamers and structural rearrangements upon mRNA target recognition

The bacterial Sm-like protein Hfq is a central player in the control of bacterial gene expression. Hfq forms complexes with small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) that use complementary "seed" sequences to target specific mRNAs. Hfq forms hexameric rings, which preferably bind uridine-rich RNA 3' ends on their proximal surface and adenine-rich sequences on their distal surface. However, many reported properties of Hfq/sRNA complexes could not be explained by these RNA binding modes. Here, we use the RybB sRNA to identify the lateral surface of Hfq as a third, independent RNA binding surface. A systematic mutational analysis and competition experiments demonstrate that the lateral sites have a preference for and are sufficient to bind the sRNA "body," including the seed sequence. Furthermore, we detect significant structural rearrangements of the Hfq/sRNA complex upon mRNA target recognition that lead to a release of the seed sequence, or of the entire sRNA molecule in case of an unfavorable 3' end. Consequently, we propose a molecular model for the Hfq/sRNA complex, where the sRNA 3' end is anchored in the proximal site of Hfq, whereas the sRNA body, including the seed sequence, is bound by up to six of the lateral sites. In contrast to previously proposed arrangements, the presented model explains how Hfq can protect large parts of the sRNA body while still allowing a rapid recycling of sRNAs. Furthermore, our model suggests molecular mechanisms for the function of Hfq as an RNA chaperone and for the molecular events that are initiated upon mRNA target recognition.

The functional Hfq-binding module of bacterial sRNAs consists of a double or single hairpin preceded by a U-rich sequence and followed by a 3' poly(U) tail

Hfq-dependent sRNAs contain, at least, an mRNA base-pairing region, an Hfq-binding site, and a Rho-independent terminator. Recently, we found that the terminator poly(U) of Escherichia coli sRNAs is essential for Hfq binding and therefore for riboregulation. In this study, we tried to identify additional components within Hfq-binding sRNAs required for efficient Hfq binding by using SgrS as a model. We demonstrate by mutational and biochemical studies that an internal hairpin and an immediately upstream U-rich sequence also are required for efficient Hfq binding. We propose that the functional Hfq-binding module of SgrS consists of an internal hairpin preceded by a U-rich sequence and a Rho-independent terminator with a long poly(U) tail. We also show that the Rho-independent terminator alone can act as a functional Hfq-binding module when it is preceded by an internal U-rich sequence. The 3' region of most known sRNAs share the features corresponding to either a double- or single-hairpin-type Hfq-binding module. We also demonstrate that increasing the spacing between the base-pairing region and the Hfq-binding module reduces or impairs the silencing ability. These findings allowed us to design synthetic Hfq-binding sRNAs to target desired mRNAs.

Characterization of Vibrio cholerae Hfq provides novel insights into the role of the Hfq C-terminal region

Hfq is a bacterial RNA binding protein that facilitates small RNA-mediated posttranscriptional gene regulation. In Vibrio cholerae, Hfq and four Hfq-dependent small RNAs are essential for the expression of virulence genes, but little is known about this mechanism at the molecular level. To better understand V. cholerae Hfq structure and mechanism, we characterized the protein, alongside Escherichia coli Hfq for comparison, using biochemical and biophysical techniques. The N-terminal domain (NTD) of the two proteins is highly conserved, but the C-terminal regions (CTRs) vary in both sequence and length. Small-angle X-ray scattering studies showed that both proteins adopt a star-shaped hexameric structure in which the conserved NTD adopts the expected Sm fold while the variable CTR is disordered and extends radially outwards from the folded core. Despite their structural similarity, SDS-PAGE stability assays and collision-induced dissociation mass spectrometry revealed that the V. cholerae hexamer is less stable than that of E. coli. We propose that this is due to minor differences between the intersubunit interface formed by the NTDs and the ability of the E. coli CTR to stabilize this interface. However, based on electrophoretic mobility shift assays, the divergent CTRs do appear to perform a common function with regard to RNA-binding specificity. Overall, the similarities and differences in the fundamental properties of V. cholerae and E. coli Hfq provide insight into their assembly and molecular mechanisms.

The RNA chaperone Hfq regulates antibiotic biosynthesis in the rhizobacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa M18

The rhizosphere microbe Pseudomonas aeruginosa M18 shows strong antifungal activities, mainly due to the biosynthesis of antibiotics like pyoluteorin (Plt) and phenazine-1-carboxylic acid (PCA). The ubiquitous RNA chaperone Hfq regulates bacterial virulence and stress tolerance through global posttranscriptional regulation. Here, we explored the molecular mechanism by which Hfq controls antibiotic biosynthesis in P. aeruginosa M18. The robust downregulation of Plt biosynthesis by Hfq was mediated exclusively by the posttranscriptional downregulation of the plt transcriptional activator PltR. Hfq posttranscriptionally repressed phzM expression and consequently reduced the conversion of PCA to pyocyanin. However, Hfq positively controlled the phz2 operon and PCA biosynthesis through both QscR-mediated transcriptional regulation at the promoter and an unknown regulation at the operator. Also, Hfq was shown to directly bind at the mRNA 5' untranslated leaders of pltR, qscR, and phzM. These three negatively regulated target genes of Hfq shared a similar secondary structure with a short single-stranded AU-rich spacer (a potential Hfq-binding motif) linking two stem-loops. Taken together, these results indicate that Hfq, potentially in collaboration with unknown small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs), tightly controls antibiotic biosynthesis through both direct posttranscriptional inhibition and indirect transcriptional regulation.

Hexamer to monomer equilibrium of E. coli Hfq in solution and its impact on RNA annealing

The bacterial Sm-like protein Hfq forms a ring-shaped homo-hexamer that is necessary for Hfq to bind nucleic acids and to act in small noncoding RNA regulation. Using semi-native gels and fluorescence anisotropy, we show that Hfq undergoes a cooperative conformational change from monomer to hexamer around 1 μM protein, which is comparable to the in vivo concentration of Hfq and above the dissociation constant of the Hfq hexamer from many RNA substrates. Above 2 μM protein, Hfq hexamers associate in high-molecular-weight complexes. Mutations that impair RNA binding to the proximal face strongly destabilize the hexamer, while the mutation R16A near the outer rim prevents hexamer association. Stopped-flow fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments showed that Hfq subunits interact within a few seconds, suggesting that Hfq monomers, hexamers and multi-hexamer complexes are in dynamic equilibrium. Finally, we show that Hfq is most active in RNA annealing when the hexamer is present. These results suggest that RNA binding is coupled to hexamer assembly and that the biochemical activity of Hfq reflects the equilibrium between different quaternary structures.

Engineering artificial small RNAs for conditional gene silencing in Escherichia coli

It has become increasingly evident that noncoding small RNAs (sRNAs) play a significant and global role in bacterial gene regulation. A majority of the trans-acting sRNAs in bacteria interact with the 5' untranslated region (UTR) and/or the translation initiation region of the targeted mRNAs via imperfect base pairing, resulting in reduced translation efficiency and/or mRNA stability. Additionally, bacterial sRNAs often contain distinct scaffolds that recruit RNA chaperones such as Hfq to facilitate gene regulation. In this study, we describe a strategy to engineer artificial sRNAs that can regulate desired endogenous genes in Escherichia coli. Using a fluorescent reporter gene that was translationally fused to a native 5' mRNA leader sequence, active artificial sRNAs were screened from libraries in which natural sRNA scaffolds were fused to a randomized antisense domain. Artificial sRNAs that posttranscriptionally repress two endogenous genes ompF and fliC were isolated and characterized. We anticipate that the artificial sRNAs will be useful for dynamic control and fine-tuning of endogenous gene expression in bacteria for applications in synthetic biology.

RNase footprinting of protein binding sites on an mRNA target of small RNAs

Endoribonuclease footprinting is an important technique for probing RNA-protein interactions with single nucleotide resolution. The susceptibility of RNA residues to enzymatic digestion gives information about the RNA secondary structure, the location of protein binding sites, and the effects of protein binding on the RNA structure. Here we present a detailed protocol for using RNase T2, which cleaves single stranded RNA with a preference for A nucleotides, to footprint the protein Hfq on the rpoS mRNA leader. This protocol covers how to form the RNP complex, determine the correct dose of enzyme, footprint the protein, and analyze the cleavage pattern using primer extension.

Cooperation of Escherichia coli Hfq hexamers in DsrA binding

Hfq is a bacterial post-transcriptional regulator. It facilitates base-pairing between sRNA and target mRNA. Hfq mediates DsrA-dependent translational activation of rpoS mRNA at low temperatures. rpoS encodes the stationary-phase σ factor σ(S), which is the central regulator in general stress response. However, structural information on Hfq-DsrA interaction is not yet available. Although Hfq is reported to hydrolyze ATP, the ATP-binding site is still unknown. Here, we report a ternary crystal complex structure of Escherichia coli Hfq bound to a major Hfq recognition region on DsrA (AU(6)A) together with ADP, and a crystal complex structure of Hfq bound to ADP. AU(6)A binds to the proximal and distal sides of two Hfq hexamers. ADP binds to a purine-selective site on the distal side and contacts conserved arginine or glutamine residues on the proximal side of another hexamer. This binding mode is different from previously postulated. The cooperation of two different Hfq hexamers upon nucleic acid binding in solution is verified by fluorescence polarization and solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments using fragments of Hfq and DsrA. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer conducted with full-length Hfq and DsrA also supports cooperation of Hfq hexamers upon DsrA binding. The implications of Hfq hexamer cooperation have been discussed.

The influence of Escherichia coli Hfq mutations on RNA binding and sRNA•mRNA duplex formation in rpoS riboregulation

The Escherichia coli RNA binding protein Hfq plays an important role in regulating mRNA translation through its interactions with small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs) and specific mRNAs sites. The rpoS mRNA, which codes for a transcription factor, is regulated by several sRNAs. DsrA and RprA enhance translation by pairing to a site on this mRNA, while OxyS represses rpoS mRNA translation. To better understand how Hfq interacts with these sRNAs and rpoS mRNA, the binding of wt Hfq and eleven mutant Hfqs to DsrA, RprA, OxyS and rpoS mRNA was examined. Nine of the mutant Hfq had single-residue mutations located on the proximal, distal, and outer-edge surfaces of the Hfq hexamer, while two Hfq had truncated C-terminal ends. Hfq with outer-edge mutations and truncated C-terminal ends behaved similar to wt Hfq with regard to binding the sRNAs, rpoS mRNA segments, and stimulating DsrA•rpoS mRNA formation. Proximal surface mutations decreased Hfq binding to the three sRNAs and the rpoS mRNA segment containing the translation initiation region. Distal surface mutations lowered Hfq's affinity for the rpoS mRNA segment containing the (ARN)(4) sequence. Strong Hfq binding to both rpoS mRNA segments appears to be needed for maximum enhancement of DsrA•rpoS mRNA annealing. OxyS bound tightly to Hfq but exhibited weak affinity for rpoS mRNA containing the leader region and 75 nt of coding sequence in the absence or presence of Hfq. This together with other results suggest OxyS represses rpoS mRNA translation by sequestering Hfq rather than binding to rpoS mRNA.

Isoenergetic microarrays to study the structure and interactions of DsrA and OxyS RNAs in two- and three-component complexes

Information on the secondary structure and interactions of RNA is important to understand the biological function of RNA as well as in applying RNA as a tool for therapeutic purposes. Recently, the isoenergetic microarray mapping method was developed to improve the prediction of RNA secondary structure. Herein, for the first time, isoenergetic microarrays were used to study the binding of RNA to protein or other RNAs as well as the interactions of two different RNAs and protein in a three-component complex. The RNAs used as models were the regulatory DsrA and OxyS RNAs from Escherichia coli, the fragments of their target mRNAs (fhlA and rpoS), and their complexes with Hfq protein. The collected results showed the advantages and some limitations of microarray mapping.

Hfq and its constellation of RNA

Hfq is an RNA-binding protein that is common to diverse bacterial lineages and has key roles in the control of gene expression. By facilitating the pairing of small RNAs with their target mRNAs, Hfq affects the translation and turnover rates of specific transcripts and contributes to complex post-transcriptional networks. These functions of Hfq can be attributed to its ring-like oligomeric architecture, which presents two non-equivalent binding surfaces that are capable of multiple interactions with RNA molecules. Distant homologues of Hfq occur in archaea and eukaryotes, reflecting an ancient origin for the protein family and hinting at shared functions. In this Review, we describe the salient structural and functional features of Hfq and discuss possible mechanisms by which this protein can promote RNA interactions to catalyse specific and rapid regulatory responses in vivo.

Major role for mRNA binding and restructuring in sRNA recruitment by Hfq

Bacterial small RNAs (sRNAs) modulate gene expression by base-pairing with target mRNAs. Many sRNAs require the Sm-like RNA binding protein Hfq as a cofactor. Well-characterized interactions between DsrA sRNA and the rpoS mRNA leader were used to understand how Hfq stimulates sRNA pairing with target mRNAs. DsrA annealing stimulates expression of rpoS by disrupting a secondary structure in the rpoS leader, which otherwise prevents translation. Both RNAs bind Hfq with similar affinity but interact with opposite faces of the Hfq hexamer. Using mutations that block interactions between two of the three components, we demonstrate that Hfq binding to a functionally critical (AAN)(4) motif in rpoS mRNA rescues DsrA binding to a hyperstable rpoS mutant. We also show that Hfq cannot stably bridge the RNAs. Persistent ternary complexes only form when the two RNAs are complementary. Thus, Hfq mainly acts by binding and restructuring the rpoS mRNA. However, Hfq binding to DsrA is needed for maximum annealing in vitro, indicating that transient interactions with both RNAs contribute to the regulatory mechanism.

PolyU tail of rho-independent terminator of bacterial small RNAs is essential for Hfq action

Major bacterial small RNAs (sRNAs) regulate the translation and stability of target mRNAs through base pairing with the help of the RNA chaperone Hfq. The Hfq-dependent sRNAs consist of three basic elements, mRNA base-pairing region, Hfq-binding site, and rho-independent terminator. Although the base-pairing region and the terminator are well documented in many sRNAs, the Hfq-binding site is less well-defined except that Hfq binds RNA with a preference for AU-rich sequences. Here, we performed mutational and biochemical studies to define the sRNA site required for Hfq action using SgrS as a model sRNA. We found that shortening terminator polyU tail eliminates the ability of SgrS to bind to Hfq and to silence ptsG mRNA. We also demonstrate that the SgrS terminator can be replaced with any foreign rho-independent terminators possessing a polyU tail longer than 8 without losing the ability to silence ptsG mRNA in an Hfq-dependent manner. Moreover, we found that shortening the terminator polyU tail of several other sRNAs also eliminates the ability to bind to Hfq and to regulate target mRNAs. We conclude that the polyU tail of sRNAs is essential for Hfq action in general. The data also indicate that the terminator polyU tail plays a role in Hfq-dependent stabilization of sRNAs.

Despite similar binding to the Hfq protein regulatory RNAs widely differ in their competition performance

The binding of nine noncoding regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) to the E. coli Hfq protein was compared using a high-throughput double filter retention assay. Despite the fact that these sRNAs have different lengths, sequences and secondary structures their Hfq binding affinities were surprisingly uniform. The analysis of sRNAs binding to Hfq mutants showed that the proximal face of Hfq, known as the binding site for DsrA RNA, is a universal sRNA binding site. Moreover, all sRNAs bound Hfq with similar association rates limited only by the rate of diffusion, while the rates of dissociation, measured in the dilution experiments, were uniformly slow. Despite that, the data showed that there was a hierarchy of sRNAs in regard to their performance in competition for access to Hfq and in their ability to facilitate the dissociation of other sRNAs from Hfq. The sRNAs also differed in their salt dependence of binding to this protein. Overall, the results suggest that despite the uniform binding of different sRNAs to the same site on Hfq their exchange on this protein is dependent on the identities of the competing sRNAs.

Mutation of GOGAT prevents pea bacteroid formation and N2 fixation by globally downregulating transport of organic nitrogen sources

Mutation of gltB (encoding glutamate oxoglutarate amidotransferase or GOGAT) in RU2307 increased the intracellular Gln:Glu ratio and inhibited amino acid transport via Aap and Bra. The mechanism probably involves global post-translational inhibition independent of Ntr. Transport was separately restored by increased gene expression of Aap or heterologous transporters. Likewise, second site suppressor mutations in the RNA chaperone Hfq elevated transport by Aap and Bra by increasing mRNA levels. Microarrays showed Hfq regulates 34 ABC transporter genes, including aap, bra and opp. The genes coding for integral membrane proteins and ABC subunits aapQMP braDEFGC were more strongly elevated in the hfq mutants than solute-binding proteins (aapJ braC). aapQMP and braDEFG are immediately downstream of stem-loops, indicating Hfq attenuates downstream translation and stability of mRNA, explaining differential expression of ABC genes. RU2307 nodulated peas and bacteria grew down infection threads, but bacteroid development was arrested and N(2) was not fixed. This probably results from an inability to synthesize or transport amino acids. However, GOGAT and GOGAT/AldA double mutants carrying suppressor mutations that increased amino acid uptake fixed N(2) on pea plants. Thus de novo ammonium assimilation into amino acids is unnecessary in bacteroids demonstrating sufficient amino acids are supplied by plants.

ProQ is an RNA chaperone that controls ProP levels in Escherichia coli

Transporter ProP mediates osmolyte accumulation in Escherichia coli cells exposed to high osmolality media. The cytoplasmic ProQ protein amplifies ProP activity by an unknown mechanism. The N- and C-terminal domains of ProQ are predicted to be structurally similar to known RNA chaperone proteins FinO and Hfq from E. coli. Here we demonstrate that ProQ is an RNA chaperone, binding RNA and facilitating both RNA strand exchange and RNA duplexing. Experiments performed with the isolated ProQ domains showed that the FinO-like domain serves as a high-affinity RNA-binding domain, whereas the Hfq-like domain is largely responsible for RNA strand exchange and duplexing. These data suggest that ProQ may regulate ProP production. Transcription of proP proceeds from RpoD- and RpoS-dependent promoters. Lesions at proQ affected ProP levels in an osmolality- and growth phase-dependent manner, decreasing ProP levels when proP was expressed from its own chromosomal promoters or from a heterologous plasmid-based promoter. Small RNA molecules are known to regulate cellular levels of sigma factor RpoS. ProQ did not act by changing RpoS levels since proQ lesions did not influence RpoS-dependent stationary phase thermotolerance and they affected ProP production and activity similarly in bacteria without and with an rpoS defect. Taken together, these results suggest that ProQ does not regulate proP transcription. It may act as an RNA-binding protein to regulate proP translation.