Community leg ulcer clinics and the effectiveness of care

Older patients’ experience of dressing changes on venous leg ulcers: more than just a docile patient

AIM AND OBJECTIVE

The aim of this paper was to describe the lived experiences of older patients with venous leg ulcers, during dressing changes as out patients with a focus of their concerns about care interventions. Research on wound care management has focused on treatment of venous leg ulcer, wound assessments and the choice of dressing material. Few studies have focused on the patients' experience of dressing changes.

DESIGN

Fifteen older people with verified venous leg ulcers were recruited in a metropolitan area of Sweden. Data were collected with research interviews in the form of dialogue.

METHOD

Data were analysed with an interpretative phenomenological method developed by Benner.

RESULTS

Twelve women and three men participated. The themes were: 'being cared for with a skillful touch', 'feelings of belonging, continuity and affinity', and 'being suppressed into a state where one loses control, leading to feelings of discomfort'. The participants' experiences varied. Some were satisfied and felt that there was a mutual understanding between caregivers and patients, while others were dissatisfied and felt objectified. Understanding the patients as human beings and considering illness as lived experience helped the care providers to perform skillful wound care, in an atmosphere of mutual understanding.

CONCLUSION

The patients suffering from venous leg ulcers wanted to feel worthy of wound treatment and to meet skillful, confident and gentle nurses in a sharing atmosphere. Nurses must be perceptive to the individual's bodily experience of the leg ulcer.

RELEVANCE TO CLINICAL PRACTICE

Wound care requires a multidimensional clinical approach that involves not only medical and technical care strategies of dressings and bandages, but also aspects that concern the situated-based illness experience that persons suffering from leg ulcers may face.

Community leg ulcer clinics vs home visits: which is more effective?

District nurses manage the care of the majority of patients with leg ulcers, but there have been reports of variations in the practice and effectiveness of treatment provided by district nurses (Audit Commission, 1999). Evidence-based health care aims to promote clinical and cost-effective care/treatment through the explicit, conscientious, and judicious use of the currently available best evidence from research to guide decisions (Sackett et al, 1996). Following the method of Griffiths (2002), a mini-systematic review was undertaken, to find out whether leg ulcer clinics provide more effective treatment to patients with leg ulcers than care provided in patients' homes by district nurses. Five databases were searched to find valid randomised controlled trials (RCTs) or systematic reviews to answer the question. The search was supplemented by hand searching of relevant publications. Only one trial met the inclusion criteria of the review. Although it concluded that leg ulcer clinics delivered improved outcomes the evidence provided was limited due to the comparison treatment being outdated, inadequate information regarding costs, and that as a relatively small isolated RCT it provided insufficient evidence to answer the question.

Community nurses', home carers' and patients' perceptions of factors affecting venous leg ulcer recurrence and management of services

AIM

This study examines the feasibility of utilizing social service home carers (SSHC) to provide a collaborative approach with community nurses for the provision of leg ulcer aftercare in four National Health Service (NHS) Trusts. The purpose of this study was to gain insight into what community nurses and people with healed venous leg ulcers felt influenced leg ulcer recurrence.

BACKGROUND

Studies have demonstrated that provision of community-based leg ulcer clinics has improved healing rates of venous leg ulcers, yet recurrence remains a problem. The reasons for this are far from clear, and further research is required before unequivocal support can be given to one approach to the provision of care for this client group. Collaborative approaches to the provision of leg ulcer aftercare are beginning to receive more attention. It has been recognized that social service health carers could be co-opted to provide essential aftercare once healing has occurred, although the logistics of this approach have not been fully explored.

METHODS

This study was conducted in four NHS Trusts. Stage one used focus groups to explore the perceptions of district nurses (n = 15) and social service health carers (n = 15) of a leg ulcer shared care project and to gain insight into factors that they felt influenced recurrence. The second stage used semistructured interviews (n = 12) to explore the perceptions that people with healed leg ulcers have about factors influencing ulcer recurrence.

FINDINGS

Key themes emerging from this study were: health promotion is perceived by community nurses and patients to be ineffective and leg ulcer aftercare services are fragmented. Organizational factors such as time constraints and limited resources were cited by community nurses and home carers as being responsible for high leg ulcer recurrence rates. Community nurses expressed a desire to delegate preventative aspects of leg ulcer care to home carers rather than participate in health promotion strategies to support healing behaviours.

CONCLUSIONS

A strategy aimed at supporting healing behaviour in elderly people has the potential to reduce the recurrence of leg ulceration and improve quality of life. The findings suggest that such a strategy needs to rationalize delivery of leg ulcer aftercare to provide seamless care. It needs to improve carers' and patients' understanding of factors influencing leg ulcer recurrence and facilitate development of a more balanced professional--patient relationship.

Preventing unnecessary suffering: an audit of a leg ulcer clinic

Unnecessary patient suffering and increased costs in leg ulcer care were reported in an Effective Health Care bulletin (NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination (NHSCRD), 1997). Follow-up assessment of patients with a history of venous ulceration has beneficial effects for patients' quality of life, and for effective and efficient management of resources for community nurses. This article describes the process of implementing evidence-based practice in a leg ulcer clinic in South London within existing resources, which resulted in the successful prevention of leg ulcer recurrence.