Interventions to Support the Return to Work for Individuals with Stroke: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

PURPOSE

An increasing number of individuals with stroke are having difficulties in returning to work, having a significant impact on both individuals and society. The aims of this meta-analysis were to summarize the interventions to support the return to work (RTW) for individuals with stroke and to quantitatively evaluate the efficacy of each type of intervention.

METHODS

A systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted according to PRISMA guidelines. PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, CINAHL, and PsycINFO were searched until 26 June 2023, and the list of references of the initially included articles was also searched. Two researchers independently performed the search, screening, selection, and data extraction. The primary outcome was RTW rate (the RTW rate was defined as the proportion of individuals who returned to work in each group (intervention and control) at the endpoint). Pooled risk ratio (RR) was estimated using a random-effects model with 95% confidence intervals (CIs).

RESULTS

A total of 13 studies representing 4,282 individuals with stroke were included in our study. Results showed that physiological interventions could improve the RTW rate of individuals with stroke (RR: 1.19, 95% CI: 1.01 to 1.42, I2 = 72%). And receiving intravenous thrombolytic therapy was beneficial in promoting the RTW in individuals with stroke. Subgroup analysis and meta-regression analysis showed that the individuals' functional status during hospitalization was the only source of heterogeneity. Psychological interventions had little or no effect on the RTW rate of individuals with stroke (RR: 1.20, 95% CI: 0.58 to 2.51, I2 = 30%). Work-related interventions had little or no effect on the RTW rate of the individuals with stroke (RR:1.36,95%CI: 0.99 to 1.88, I2 = 73%). The subgroup analysis showed that country, age, and follow-up method were the sources of heterogeneity.

CONCLUSION

Physiological intervention promoted the RTW of individuals with stroke. But, the effect of psychological and work-related interventions in promoting the RTW of individuals with stroke was not significant. We anticipate that these findings may inform the design of future interventions. For future research, we recommend that more high-quality randomized controlled trials be conducted to further promote the RTW of individuals with stroke.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION

PROSPERO Registration Number, CRD42023443668.

Return to work for adults following stroke: a scoping review of interventions, factors, barriers, and facilitators

OBJECTIVE

This scoping review aimed to map the literature on interventions, factors, barriers, and facilitators for return to work for adults post-stroke with or without communication disorders.

INTRODUCTION

Difficulties in returning to work can significantly impact individuals following a stroke (eg, their sense of purpose and self-esteem), not only financially, but also as they adjust to the change in their situation. Such difficulties may arise from communication disorders as well as physical impairments. Previous reviews on return to work post-stroke have focused on specific aspects, such as interventions, or barriers and facilitators, but have not provided a comprehensive map of the field. Further, no systematic or scoping reviews to date have focused on literature addressing return to work for people with communication disorders post-stroke.

INCLUSION CRITERIA

This review considered literature that reported on interventions, barriers, and facilitators for return to work for adults (aged 16 years or older) following an ischemic or hemorrhagic stroke. Records focusing on transient ischemic attacks or acquired brain injury were excluded, as were those in which a comorbidity or disability (eg, learning disability, dementia, respiratory disorder) had a significant impact on the individual's ability to work.

METHODS

This review followed the JBI scoping review methodology. Primary research of any type, systematic and non-systematic reviews, and gray literature from developed countries written in English from 2010 to the present day were identified from 7 databases, 2 gray literature repositories, JBI Evidence Synthesis , and an internet search. Records were screened for relevance to the review topic by 2 independent reviewers, and data relevant to the review questions were extracted. Findings were presented as narrative supported by tables.

RESULTS

Of the 106 sources included, 61 addressed demographic-based, socioeconomic-based, impairment-based, or recovery-based factors related to return to work. One of these 61 sources, a narrative review, focused on communication disorders. Thirty-eight sources explored barriers and facilitators for return to work from different stakeholders' perspectives; 3 of these 38 sources, including 2 qualitative studies and 1 narrative review, focused on post-stroke communication disorders. Eleven sources focused on interventions, including 7 studies (reported across 9 sources) that developed or tested return-to-work interventions. Of these primary studies, 1 randomized controlled trial and 1 retrospective cohort study were identified. The remaining intervention studies were case studies or case series. None of these intervention studies addressed communication disorders.

CONCLUSIONS

While there has been extensive research on factors, barriers, and facilitators for return to work post-stroke, there is a lack of research on interventions supporting return to work. There is also a significant gap in the evidence base on returning to work with a post-stroke communication disorder, highlighting the need for further research in this important area.

Utilizing multi-user virtual reality to bring clinical therapy into stroke survivors' homes

INTRODUCTION

Lifespans after the occurrence of a stroke have been lengthening, but most stroke survivors will experience chronic impairment. Directed, repetitive practice may reduce deficits, but clinical access is often limited by a variety of factors, such as transportation.

PURPOSE OF THE STUDY

To introduce a multiuser virtual reality platform that can be used to promote therapist-client interactions when the client is at home.

METHODS

The Virtual Environment for Rehabilitative Gaming Exercises encourages exploration of the hand workspace by enabling multiple participants, located remotely and colocated virtually, to interact with the same virtual objects in the shared virtual space. Each user controls an avatar by corresponding movement of his or her own body segments. System performance with stroke survivors was evaluated during longitudinal studies in a laboratory environment and in participants' homes. Active arm movement was tracked throughout therapy sessions for both studies.

RESULTS

Stroke survivors achieved considerable arm movement while using the system. Mean voluntary hand displacement, after accounting for trunk displacement, was greater than 350 m per therapy session for the Virtual Environment for Rehabilitative Gaming Exercises system. Compliance for home-based therapy was quite high, with 94% of all scheduled sessions completed. Having multiple players led to longer sessions and more arm movement than when the stroke survivors were trained alone.

CONCLUSIONS

Multiuser virtual reality offers a relatively inexpensive means of extending clinical therapy into home and enabling family and friends to support rehabilitation efforts, even when physically remote from each other.

Designing an intervention process that embeds work-focussed interventions within inpatient rehabilitation: An intervention mapping approach

INTRODUCTION

Returning to work is a goal for many people after brain injury. The failure to return to work after injury brings both economic and personal (quality of life) costs to those living with stroke or brain injury, their families, and society. This study explored the barriers to providing work-focused interventions during hospital-based rehabilitation and co-created solutions with rehabilitation providers to increase the provision of work-focused intervention during inpatient rehabilitation.

METHODS

This study used an Intervention Mapping approach (a six-step protocol that guides the design of complex interventions) based on an action research methodology. Focus group data, in addition to best evidence from systematic reviews, practice guidelines and key articles were combined with theoretical models for changing behaviour and clinician experience. This was then systematically operationalised into an intervention process using consensus among clinicians. The process was further refined through piloting and feedback from key stakeholders, and group consensus on the final process.

RESULTS

A detailed five phase return to work intervention process for inpatient rehabilitation was developed. The key features of the process include; having one key allied health clinician to coordinate the process, choosing assessments based on pre-injury work demands, emphasising the importance of core work skills and considering the most appropriate service for referral at the conclusion of rehabilitation.

CONCLUSION

We used a systematic approach, guided by the intervention mapping approach and behaviour change theory to tailor existing workfocused interventions to the inpatient setting.

Obstructive Sleep Apnea Risk and Stroke among Blacks with Metabolic Syndrome: Results from Metabolic Syndrome Outcome (MetSO) Registry

Introduction:

The American Stroke Association estimates that stroke is the fifth leading cause of death in the United States. According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention someone in the United States has a stoke every 40 seconds, affecting more than 795,000 people of which 140,000 result in death [1]. Emerging evidence suggests that obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a strong risk factor for stroke. This study using The Metabolic Syndrome Outcome (MetSO) registry explored whether blacks at risk for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) are at greater risk for a stroke.

Method:

The present study utilized data from the MetSO study, an NIH-funded cohort study of blacks with metabolic syndrome (MetS). Patients were diagnosed with MetS using standard criteria articulated in the joint interim statement for harmonizing the MetS. The study assessed OSA risk using the Apnea Risk Evaluation System (ARES); defining high risk as a total ARES score ≥6. Data was coded and analyzed by an experienced statistician using SPSS 20.0.

Results:

A total of 1035 participants were screened for MetS in the MetSO registry. During the data collection period 875 participants were enrolled during the time of analysis. The average age of the sample was 62±14 years (range: 20–97); 71% were female, and all were of black race/ethnicity. Seventy-one percent reported finishing high school, and 43% reported annual income <10K. Descriptive analyses showed 93% of the participants were diagnosed with hypertension; 61%, diabetes; 72%, dyslipidemia; 90% were overweight/obese; 33% had a history of heart disease and 10% had a stroke history. Using the ARES screener, we estimated that 48% were at high risk for OSA. Logistic regression analysis, adjusting for age and gender, showed that patients at high risk for OSA had a nearly three-fold increase in the odds of having a stroke (OR = 2.79, 95% CI: 1.64–4.73).

Conclusion:

In the MetSO registry, a cohort of blacks with MetS, the prevalence of stroke is greater than in the general US population. Blacks at risk for OSA are particularly vulnerable to experiencing a stroke.

A Systematic Scoping Review of Work Interventions for Hospitalised Adults with an Acquired Neurological Impairment

Purpose Addressing return to work early after neurological impairment from stroke or moderate and severe traumatic brain injury may improve likelihood of returning to employment, yet little is known about how best to organize work interventions for delivery in the inpatient hospital setting. The purpose of this scoping review was to identify knowledge gaps and inform program development in hospital-based work interventions. Method We searched MEDLINE, CINAHL, OTSeeker and Embase for English-language articles published from database inception until March 2018. Citations were then manually searched using reference lists of included papers and Google Scholar. Articles were included if they described programs providing return to work intervention within a hospital to adults with newly acquired neurological conditions, such as traumatic brain injury or stroke. After identifying and selecting relevant studies, we charted the data and then synthesized the results. Results Twenty-eight articles explored work intervention in an inpatient hospital setting. Interventions targeted a diagnostically heterogeneous population, mostly including adults who had suffered either a traumatic brain injury or stroke. Most interventions included a structured process for assessment, highlighted the importance of collaboration, and aimed to improve performance of work skills that could be facilitated within a hospital setting only (as opposed to all work skills). Thematic analysis of included studies resulted in four themes: structure, collaboration, clinician training, and belief in future work capacity. Conclusion Return to work intervention appears to be an important component of neurological rehabilitation. While studies to date have identified enablers for the integration of work interventions into the inpatient hospital setting, there is limited description of specific components of programs, and a lack of studies evaluating program effectiveness.

Self-perceived occupational performance of community-dwelling adults living with stroke

Background.

Stroke has long-term consequences for functional performance of daily activities. Evaluating client-perceived occupational performance provides insight for designing stroke-specific programs supporting home and community participation.

Purpose.

This study describes the personal characteristics and self-perceived occupational performance in community-dwelling adults with stroke.

Method.

A retrospective chart review was undertaken of 25 stroke survivors who sought services at a community-based centre. The outcome measures were the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure (COPM) to evaluate self-perceived occupational performance and the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) to screen for cognitive impairment. The analysis used descriptive statistics.

Findings.

Mean participant age was 64 years, and most participants were Caucasian males (72%). The mean cognitive function score was 22.1 on MoCA, and the mean COPM performance and satisfaction subscores were 4.1 and 3.9, respectively. The top three challenging daily activities were driving, seeking employment, and functional mobility.

Implications.

Stroke-specific community programs should emphasize the diverse performance concerns important to stroke survivors.

Return to Work After Stroke: A Survey of Occupational Therapy Practice Patterns

This descriptive study, consisting of a survey followed by semi-structured interviews, sought to describe the practice patterns and perceived competencies of occupational therapy practitioners in the provision of return to work (RTW) services for stroke survivors. Respondents (n = 119) were mostly occupational therapists (95%) working in outpatient settings (61%); 47% reported a caseload of mostly stroke survivors; and most addressing RTW (60%). Respondents focused predominantly on remediation of cognitive and physical skills and less on actual work performance and supports. Respondents assert occupational therapy's role in RTW for stroke survivors but generally reported limited competencies and low utilization of evidence-based approaches and theoretical models when addressing RTW. Systems, organizational support, and practitioner factors emerged as barriers and facilitators to RTW service provision. This study suggests there may be a critical gap in practitioners' RTW competencies with profound implications for entry-level education, professional development, advocacy, and research.

What are the correlates of cognition and participation to return to work after first ever mild stroke?

BACKGROUND

The percentage of working age people with mild stroke has risen. Evidence indicates that even mild stroke impact cognition, executive functioning, and daily functioning, consequently affecting participation, quality of life (QoL) and return to work (RTW).

OBJECTIVES

(1) Compare cognition, participation and QoL between people 3 months post-mild stroke who RTW and those who did not; and (2) To determine the correlates of these variables to RTW of participants 3 months post-stroke.

METHODS

We visited at home 163 stroke survivors (117 men, 46 women) 3 months post-mild stroke ranging from 50 to 89 years. Participants who returned to work (n = 114) and those who did not (n = 49). Data collection at home included measures for cognitive status (MoCA), executive functions (EFPT, DEX), depression (GDS), participation (RNL), and QoL (SIS recovery).

RESULTS

Significant differences were found between RTW participants and those who did not RTW in measures of cognition, depression, participation and QoL (t = 2.36 to - 5.62, P < 0.022-0.001). No difference was found on age or gender. Stepwise regression showed that significant correlates of RTW were participation (RNL), executive functions (EFPT), and QoL (SIS recovery).

CONCLUSIONS

To enable RTW after mild stroke, participation, executive functions and QoL must be considered in planning interventions.

Survey of survivors' perspective on return to work after stroke

PURPOSE

To describe the development and results of a detailed survey on return to work (RTW) after stroke completed by survivors at various stages of recovery.

METHOD

This study used a multi-method qualitative and quantitative research strategy to design and implement a 39-item survey for stroke survivors. Individual interviews, focus groups, and working committees were used to conceptualize the issues and translate them into a survey format. Surveys were distributed in regular and electronic mail. Groups of rehabilitation professionals, employers, and stroke survivors were assembled to review findings and obtain feedback to aide in interpretation.

RESULTS

Overall 715 surveys were completed. The respondents were on average 54 years of age, mostly white, well-educated, urban dwelling, and in skilled occupations. Results are described in seven areas: financial, stroke impairments, organizational, work and psychological issues, interpersonal support, and therapy. Several salient findings are described including the role of fatigue, under utilization of vocational rehabilitation (VR) services, and motivational factors related to finances, self-esteem, work, and workplace relationships.

CONCLUSION

Although earning an income is a strong motivation to RTW, salary decreases in importance when compared with other psychological benefits. Fatigue was rated as the second highest impairment barrier to RTW and persisted as a relevant impediment over time. Attitudes of co-workers and flexibility in work schedule were viewed as most helpful to the RTW process, whereas work stress was viewed as the greatest impediment to return. Only 24% of the sample received VR counseling with more respondents receiving counseling if they returned 6 months or longer after their stroke. Other trends and clinical and research implications are discussed.