Evolution of the nonsense-mediated decay pathway is associated with decreased cytolytic immune infiltration

Nonsense-Mediated mRNA Decay in Human Health and Diseases: Current Understanding, Regulatory Mechanisms and Future Perspectives

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is a surveillance mechanism that is conserved across all eukaryotes ensuring the quality of transcripts by targeting messenger RNA (mRNA) harbouring premature stop codons. It regulates the gene expression by targeting aberrant mRNA carrying pre-termination codons (PTCs) and eliminates C-terminal truncated proteins. NMD distinguishes aberrant and non-aberrant transcript by looking after long 3' UTRs and exon-junction complex (EJC) downstream of stop codon that indicate the presence of PTC. Therefore, NMD modulates cellular surveillance and eliminates the truncated proteins but if the PTC escapes the surveillance pathway it can lead to potential negative phenotype resulting in genetic diseases. The alternative splicing also contributes in formation of NMD-sensitive isoforms by introducing PTC. NMD plays a complex role in cancer, it can either aggravate or downregulates the tumour. Some tumours agitate NMD to deteriorate mRNAs encoding tumour suppressor proteins, stress response proteins and neoantigens. In other case, tumours suppress the NMD to encourage the expression of oncoproteins for tumour growth and survival. This mechanism augmented in the development of new therapeutics by PTC read-through mechanism and personalized medicine. Detailed studies on NMD surveillance will possibly lead towards development of strategies for improving human health aligning with United Nations sustainable development goals (SDG 3: Good health and well-being). The potential therapeutic applications of NMD pose a challenge in terms of safe and effective modulation. Understanding the complexities of NMD regulation and its interaction with other cellular processes can lead to the development of new interventions for various diseases.

Inhibition of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay reduces the tumorigenicity of human fibrosarcoma cells

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is a eukaryotic RNA decay pathway with roles in cellular stress responses, differentiation, and viral defense. It functions in both quality control and post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression. NMD has also emerged as a modulator of cancer progression, although available evidence supports both a tumor suppressor and a pro-tumorigenic role, depending on the model. To further investigate the role of NMD in cancer, we knocked out the NMD factor SMG7 in the HT1080 human fibrosarcoma cell line, resulting in suppression of NMD function. We then compared the oncogenic properties of the parental cell line, the SMG7-knockout, and a rescue cell line in which we re-introduced both isoforms of SMG7. We also tested the effect of a drug inhibiting the NMD factor SMG1 to distinguish NMD-dependent effects from putative NMD-independent functions of SMG7. Using cell-based assays and a mouse xenograft tumor model, we showed that suppression of NMD function severely compromises the oncogenic phenotype. Molecular pathway analysis revealed that NMD suppression strongly reduces matrix metalloprotease 9 (MMP9) expression and that MMP9 re-expression partially rescues the oncogenic phenotype. Since MMP9 promotes cancer cell migration and invasion, metastasis and angiogenesis, its downregulation may contribute to the reduced tumorigenicity of NMD-suppressed cells. Collectively, our results highlight the potential value of NMD inhibition as a therapeutic approach.

Characterization of a rhabdomyosarcoma reveals a critical role for SMG7 in cancer cell viability and tumor growth

Soft-tissue sarcomas (STSs) are a rare and diverse group of mesenchymal cancers plagued with aggression, poor response to systemic therapy, and high rates of recurrence. Although STSs generally have low mutational burdens, the most commonly mutated genes are tumor suppressors, which frequently acquire mutations inducing nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). This suggests that STS cells may exploit NMD to suppress these anti-cancer genes. To examine the role that the NMD factor SMG7 plays in STS, we developed an inducible knockout mouse model in the Trp53-/- background. Here, we isolated a subcutaneous STS and identified it as a rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS). We report that knockout of SMG7 significantly inhibited NMD in our RMS cells, which led to the induction of NMD targets GADD45b and the tumor suppressor GAS5. The loss of NMD and upregulation of these anti-cancer genes were concomitant with the loss of RMS cell viability and inhibited tumor growth. Importantly, SMG7 was dispensable for homeostasis in our mouse embryonic fibroblasts and adult mice. Overall, our data show that the loss of SMG7 induces a strong anti-cancer effect both in vitro and in vivo. We present here the first evidence that disrupting SMG7 function may be tolerable and provide a therapeutic benefit for STS treatment.

Targeting RNA Exonuclease XRN1 Potentiates Efficacy of Cancer Immunotherapy

Despite the remarkable clinical responses achieved with immune checkpoint blockade therapy, the response rate is relatively low and only a subset of patients can benefit from the treatment. Aberrant RNA accumulation can mediate IFN signaling and stimulate an immune response, suggesting that targeting RNA decay machinery might sensitize tumor cells to immunotherapy. With this in mind, we identified an RNA exoribonuclease, XRN1, as a potential therapeutic target to suppress RNA decay and stimulate antitumor immunity. Silencing of XRN1 suppressed tumor growth in syngeneic immunocompetent mice and potentiated immunotherapy efficacy, while silencing of XRN1 alone did not affect tumor growth in immunodeficient mice. Mechanistically, XRN1 depletion activated IFN signaling and the viral defense pathway; both pathways play determinant roles in regulating immune evasion. Aberrant RNA-sensing signaling proteins (RIG-I/MAVS) mediated the expression of IFN genes, as depletion of each of them blunted the elevation of antiviral/IFN signaling in XRN1-silenced cells. Analysis of pan-cancer CRISPR-screening data indicated that IFN signaling triggered by XRN1 silencing is a common phenomenon, suggesting that the effect of XRN1 silencing may be extended to multiple types of cancers. Overall, XRN1 depletion triggers aberrant RNA-mediated IFN signaling, highlighting the importance of the aberrant RNA-sensing pathway in regulating immune responses. These findings provide the molecular rationale for developing XRN1 inhibitors and exploring their potential clinical application in combination with cancer immunotherapy.

SIGNIFICANCE

Targeting XRN1 activates an intracellular innate immune response mediated by RNA-sensing signaling and potentiates cancer immunotherapy efficacy, suggesting inhibition of RNA decay machinery as a novel strategy for cancer treatment.

IL-6/STAT3 signaling in tumor cells restricts the expression of frameshift-derived neoantigens by SMG1 induction

BACKGROUND

The quality and quantity of tumor neoantigens derived from tumor mutations determines the fate of the immune response in cancer. Frameshift mutations elicit better tumor neoantigens, especially when they are not targeted by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). For tumor progression, malignant cells need to counteract the immune response including the silencing of immunodominant neoantigens (antigen immunoediting) and promoting an immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment. Although NMD inhibition has been reported to induce tumor immunity and increase the expression of cryptic neoantigens, the possibility that NMD activity could be modulated by immune forces operating in the tumor microenvironment as a new immunoediting mechanism has not been addressed.

METHODS

We study the effect of SMG1 expression (main kinase that initiates NMD) in the survival and the nature of the tumor immune infiltration using TCGA RNAseq and scRNAseq datasets of breast, lung and pancreatic cancer. Different murine tumor models were used to corroborate the antitumor immune dependencies of NMD. We evaluate whether changes of SMG1 expression in malignant cells impact the immune response elicited by cancer immunotherapy. To determine how NMD fluctuates in malignant cells we generated a luciferase reporter system to track NMD activity in vivo under different immune conditions. Cytokine screening, in silico studies and functional assays were conducted to determine the regulation of SMG1 via IL-6/STAT3 signaling.

RESULTS

IL-6/STAT3 signaling induces SMG1, which limits the expression of potent frameshift neoantigens that are under NMD control compromising the outcome of the immune response.

CONCLUSION

We revealed a new neoantigen immunoediting mechanism regulated by immune forces (IL-6/STAT3 signaling) responsible for silencing otherwise potent frameshift mutation-derived neoantigens.

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay inhibition synergizes with MDM2 inhibition to suppress TP53 wild-type cancer cells in p53 isoform-dependent manner

The restoration of the normal function of the tumour suppressors, such as p53, is an important strategy in tumour therapeutics. Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) inhibition by NMD inhibitor (NMDi) upregulates functional p53 isoforms, p53β and p53γ, and activates the p53 pathway. XR-2, a novel mouse double minute 2 homolog (MDM2) inhibitor, can disrupt the interaction between p53 and MDM2, thus decreasing the MDM2-mediated degradation of p53 and increasing the p53 protein levels. However, the combined effects of these two agents have not been thoroughly explored. This study combined XR-2 and NMDi in four TP53 wild-types and four TP53-mutated cancer cell lines. The combination of these two agents achieved significant synergistic effects on TP53 wild-type cancer cell lines by transactivating p53 target genes, inducing apoptosis, cell-cycle arrest and DNA damage repair. The p53β isoform induced by NMDi enhances the transactivation ability of p53α induced by XR-2, which partially explains the mechanism of the synergistic effects of XR-2 and NMDi. This study identified a combination treatment of NMDi and XR-2 which could serve as a novel cancer therapeutic approach for MDM2-overexpressed TP53 wild-type cancers and delineated a future therapy based on the further reactivation of p53.

A pan-tumor-siRNA aptamer chimera to block nonsense-mediated mRNA decay inflames and suppresses tumor progression

Immune-checkpoint blockade (ICB) therapy has changed the clinical outcome of many types of aggressive tumors, but there still remain many cancer patients that do not respond to these treatments. There is an unmet need to develop a feasible clinical therapeutic platform to increase the rate of response to ICB. Here we use a previously described clinically tested aptamer (AS1411) conjugated with SMG1 RNAi (AS1411-SMG1 aptamer-linked siRNA chimeras [AsiCs]) to inhibit the nonsense-mediated RNA decay pathway inducing tumor inflammation and improving response to ICB. The aptamer AS1411 shows binding to numerous mouse and human tumor cell lines tested. AS1411 induces tumor cytotoxicity in long incubation times, which allows for the use of the aptamer as a carrier to target the RNAi inhibition to the tumor. The AS1411-SMG1 AsiCs induce a strong antitumor response in local and systemic treatment in different types of tumors. Finally, AS1411-SMG1 AsiCs are well tolerated with no detected side effects.

Nonsense-mediated RNA decay: an emerging modulator of malignancy

Nonsense-mediated RNA decay (NMD) is a highly conserved RNA turnover pathway that selectively degrades RNAs harbouring truncating mutations that prematurely terminate translation, including nonsense, frameshift and some splice-site mutations. Recent studies show that NMD shapes the mutational landscape of tumours by selecting for mutations that tend to downregulate the expression of tumour suppressor genes but not oncogenes. This suggests that NMD can benefit tumours, a notion further supported by the finding that mRNAs encoding immunogenic neoantigen peptides are typically targeted for decay by NMD. Together, this raises the possibility that NMD-inhibitory therapy could be of therapeutic benefit against many tumour types, including those with a high load of neoantigen-generating mutations. Complicating this scenario is the evidence that NMD can also be detrimental for many tumour types, and consequently tumours often have perturbed NMD. NMD may suppress tumour generation and progression by degrading subsets of specific normal mRNAs, including those encoding stress-response proteins, signalling factors and other proteins beneficial for tumours, as well as pro-tumour non-coding RNAs. Together, these findings suggest that NMD-modulatory therapy has the potential to provide widespread therapeutic benefit against diverse tumour types. However, whether NMD should be stimulated or repressed requires careful analysis of the tumour to be treated.

Exploiting Tumor Neoantigens to Target Cancer Evolution: Current Challenges and Promising Therapeutic Approaches

Immunotherapeutic manipulation of the antitumor immune response offers an attractive strategy to target genomic instability in cancer. A subset of tumor-specific somatic mutations can be translated into immunogenic and HLA-bound epitopes called neoantigens, which can induce the activation of helper and cytotoxic T lymphocytes. However, cancer immunoediting and immunosuppressive mechanisms often allow tumors to evade immune recognition. Recent evidence also suggests that the tumor neoantigen landscape extends beyond epitopes originating from nonsynonymous single-nucleotide variants in the coding exome. Here we review emerging approaches for identifying, prioritizing, and immunologically targeting personalized neoantigens using polyvalent cancer vaccines and T-cell receptor gene therapy. SIGNIFICANCE: Several major challenges currently impede the clinical efficacy of neoantigen-directed immunotherapy, such as the relative infrequency of immunogenic neoantigens, suboptimal potency and priming of de novo tumor-specific T cells, and tumor cell-intrinsic and -extrinsic mechanisms of immune evasion. A deeper understanding of these biological barriers could help facilitate the development of effective and durable immunotherapy for any type of cancer, including immunologically "cold" tumors that are otherwise therapeutically resistant.

Aberrant splicing isoforms detected by full-length transcriptome sequencing as transcripts of potential neoantigens in non-small cell lung cancer

BACKGROUND

Long-read sequencing of full-length cDNAs enables the detection of structures of aberrant splicing isoforms in cancer cells. These isoforms are occasionally translated, presented by HLA molecules, and recognized as neoantigens. This study used a long-read sequencer (MinION) to construct a comprehensive catalog of aberrant splicing isoforms in non-small-cell lung cancers, by which novel isoforms and potential neoantigens are identified.

RESULTS

Full-length cDNA sequencing is performed using 22 cell lines, and a total of 2021 novel splicing isoforms are identified. The protein expression of some of these isoforms is then validated by proteome analysis. Ablations of a nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) factor, UPF1, and a splicing factor, SF3B1, are found to increase the proportion of aberrant transcripts. NetMHC evaluation of the binding affinities to each type of HLA molecule reveals that some of the isoforms potentially generate neoantigen candidates. We also identify aberrant splicing isoforms in seven non-small-cell lung cancer specimens. An enzyme-linked immune absorbent spot assay indicates that approximately half the peptide candidates have the potential to activate T cell responses through their interaction with HLA molecules. Finally, we estimate the number of isoforms in The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) datasets by referring to the constructed catalog and found that disruption of NMD factors is significantly correlated with the number of splicing isoforms found in the TCGA-Lung Adenocarcinoma data collection.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results indicate that long-read sequencing of full-length cDNAs is essential for the precise identification of aberrant transcript structures in cancer cells.

The Branched Nature of the Nonsense-Mediated mRNA Decay Pathway

Nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) is a conserved translation-coupled quality control mechanism in all eukaryotes that regulates the expression of a significant fraction of both the aberrant and normal transcriptomes. In vertebrates, NMD has become an essential process owing to expansion of the diversity of NMD-regulated transcripts, particularly during various developmental processes. Surprisingly, however, some core NMD factors that are essential for NMD in simpler organisms appear to be dispensable for vertebrate NMD. At the same time, numerous NMD enhancers and suppressors have been identified in multicellular organisms including vertebrates. Collectively, the available data suggest that vertebrate NMD is a complex, branched pathway wherein individual branches regulate specific mRNA subsets to fulfill distinct physiological functions.

Activation and inhibition of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay control the abundance of alternative polyadenylation products

Alternative polyadenylation (APA) produces transcript 3' untranslated regions (3'UTRs) with distinct sequences, lengths, stabilities and functions. We show here that APA products include a class of cryptic nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) substrates with extended 3'UTRs that gene- or transcript-level analyses of NMD often fail to detect. Transcriptome-wide, the core NMD factor UPF1 preferentially recognizes long 3'UTR products of APA, leading to their systematic downregulation. Counteracting this mechanism, the multifunctional RNA-binding protein PTBP1 regulates the balance of short and long 3'UTR isoforms by inhibiting NMD, in addition to its previously described modulation of co-transcriptional polyadenylation (polyA) site choice. Further, we find that many transcripts with altered APA isoform abundance across multiple tumor types are controlled by NMD. Together, our findings reveal a widespread role for NMD in shaping the outcomes of APA.