On the encoding of proteins for disordered regions prediction

Deep learning in prediction of intrinsic disorder in proteins

Intrinsic disorder prediction is an active area that has developed over 100 predictors. We identify and investigate a recent trend towards the development of deep neural network (DNN)-based methods. The first DNN-based method was released in 2013 and since 2019 deep learners account for majority of the new disorder predictors. We find that the 13 currently available DNN-based predictors are diverse in their topologies, sizes of their networks and the inputs that they utilize. We empirically show that the deep learners are statistically more accurate than other types of disorder predictors using the blind test dataset from the recent community assessment of intrinsic disorder predictions (CAID). We also identify several well-rounded DNN-based predictors that are accurate, fast and/or conveniently available. The popularity, favorable predictive performance and architectural flexibility suggest that deep networks are likely to fuel the development of future disordered predictors. Novel hybrid designs of deep networks could be used to adequately accommodate for diversity of types and flavors of intrinsic disorder. We also discuss scarcity of the DNN-based methods for the prediction of disordered binding regions and the need to develop more accurate methods for this prediction.

Surveying over 100 predictors of intrinsic disorder in proteins

INTRODUCTION

Intrinsic disorder prediction field develops, assesses, and deploys computational predictors of disorder in protein sequences and constructs and disseminates databases of these predictions. Over 40 years of research resulted in the release of numerous resources.

AREAS COVERED

We identify and briefly summarize the most comprehensive to date collection of over 100 disorder predictors. We focus on their predictive models, availability and predictive performance. We categorize and study them from a historical point of view to highlight informative trends.

EXPERT OPINION

We find a consistent trend of improvements in predictive quality as newer and more advanced predictors are developed. The original focus on machine learning methods has shifted to meta-predictors in early 2010s, followed by a recent transition to deep learning. The use of deep learners will continue in foreseeable future given recent and convincing success of these methods. Moreover, a broad range of resources that facilitate convenient collection of accurate disorder predictions is available to users. They include web servers and standalone programs for disorder prediction, servers that combine prediction of disorder and disorder functions, and large databases of pre-computed predictions. We also point to the need to address the shortage of accurate methods that predict disordered binding regions.

An improved deep learning model for hierarchical classification of protein families

Although genes carry information, proteins are the main role player in providing all the functionalities of a living organism. Massive amounts of different proteins involve in every function that occurs in a cell. These amino acid sequences can be hierarchically classified into a set of families and subfamilies depending on their evolutionary relatedness and similarities in their structure or function. Protein characterization to identify protein structure and function is done accurately using laboratory experiments. With the rapidly increasing huge amount of novel protein sequences, these experiments have become difficult to carry out since they are expensive, time-consuming, and laborious. Therefore, many computational classification methods are introduced to classify proteins and predict their functional properties. With the progress of the performance of the computational techniques, deep learning plays a key role in many areas. Novel deep learning models such as DeepFam, ProtCNN have been presented to classify proteins into their families recently. However, these deep learning models have been used to carry out the non-hierarchical classification of proteins. In this research, we propose a deep learning neural network model named DeepHiFam with high accuracy to classify proteins hierarchically into different levels simultaneously. The model achieved an accuracy of 98.38% for protein family classification and more than 80% accuracy for the classification of protein subfamilies and sub-subfamilies. Further, DeepHiFam performed well in the non-hierarchical classification of protein families and achieved an accuracy of 98.62% and 96.14% for the popular Pfam dataset and COG dataset respectively.

The Order-Disorder Continuum: Linking Predictions of Protein Structure and Disorder through Molecular Simulation

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and intrinsically disordered regions within proteins (IDRs) serve an increasingly expansive list of biological functions, including regulation of transcription and translation, protein phosphorylation, cellular signal transduction, as well as mechanical roles. The strong link between protein function and disorder motivates a deeper fundamental characterization of IDPs and IDRs for discovering new functions and relevant mechanisms. We review recent advances in experimental techniques that have improved identification of disordered regions in proteins. Yet, experimentally curated disorder information still does not currently scale to the level of experimentally determined structural information in folded protein databases, and disorder predictors rely on several different binary definitions of disorder. To link secondary structure prediction algorithms developed for folded proteins and protein disorder predictors, we conduct molecular dynamics simulations on representative proteins from the Protein Data Bank, comparing secondary structure and disorder predictions with simulation results. We find that structure predictor performance from neural networks can be leveraged for the identification of highly dynamic regions within molecules, linked to disorder. Low accuracy structure predictions suggest a lack of static structure for regions that disorder predictors fail to identify. While disorder databases continue to expand, secondary structure predictors and molecular simulations can improve disorder predictor performance, which aids discovery of novel functions of IDPs and IDRs. These observations provide a platform for the development of new, integrated structural databases and fusion of prediction tools toward protein disorder characterization in health and disease.

AUCpreD: proteome-level protein disorder prediction by AUC-maximized deep convolutional neural fields

MOTIVATION

Protein intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) play an important role in many biological processes. Two key properties of IDRs are (i) the occurrence is proteome-wide and (ii) the ratio of disordered residues is about 6%, which makes it challenging to accurately predict IDRs. Most IDR prediction methods use sequence profile to improve accuracy, which prevents its application to proteome-wide prediction since it is time-consuming to generate sequence profiles. On the other hand, the methods without using sequence profile fare much worse than using sequence profile.

METHOD

This article formulates IDR prediction as a sequence labeling problem and employs a new machine learning method called Deep Convolutional Neural Fields (DeepCNF) to solve it. DeepCNF is an integration of deep convolutional neural networks (DCNN) and conditional random fields (CRF); it can model not only complex sequence-structure relationship in a hierarchical manner, but also correlation among adjacent residues. To deal with highly imbalanced order/disorder ratio, instead of training DeepCNF by widely used maximum-likelihood, we develop a novel approach to train it by maximizing area under the ROC curve (AUC), which is an unbiased measure for class-imbalanced data.

RESULTS

Our experimental results show that our IDR prediction method AUCpreD outperforms existing popular disorder predictors. More importantly, AUCpreD works very well even without sequence profile, comparing favorably to or even outperforming many methods using sequence profile. Therefore, our method works for proteome-wide disorder prediction while yielding similar or better accuracy than the others.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

http://raptorx2.uchicago.edu/StructurePropertyPred/predict/

CONTACT

wangsheng@uchicago.edu, jinboxu@gmail.com

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

DeepCNF-D: Predicting Protein Order/Disorder Regions by Weighted Deep Convolutional Neural Fields

Intrinsically disordered proteins or protein regions are involved in key biological processes including regulation of transcription, signal transduction, and alternative splicing. Accurately predicting order/disorder regions ab initio from the protein sequence is a prerequisite step for further analysis of functions and mechanisms for these disordered regions. This work presents a learning method, weighted DeepCNF (Deep Convolutional Neural Fields), to improve the accuracy of order/disorder prediction by exploiting the long-range sequential information and the interdependency between adjacent order/disorder labels and by assigning different weights for each label during training and prediction to solve the label imbalance issue. Evaluated by the CASP9 and CASP10 targets, our method obtains 0.855 and 0.898 AUC values, which are higher than the state-of-the-art single ab initio predictors.

DisoMCS: Accurately Predicting Protein Intrinsically Disordered Regions Using a Multi-Class Conservative Score Approach

The precise prediction of protein intrinsically disordered regions, which play a crucial role in biological procedures, is a necessary prerequisite to further the understanding of the principles and mechanisms of protein function. Here, we propose a novel predictor, DisoMCS, which is a more accurate predictor of protein intrinsically disordered regions. The DisoMCS bases on an original multi-class conservative score (MCS) obtained by sequence-order/disorder alignment. Initially, near-disorder regions are defined on fragments located at both the terminus of an ordered region connecting a disordered region. Then the multi-class conservative score is generated by sequence alignment against a known structure database and represented as order, near-disorder and disorder conservative scores. The MCS of each amino acid has three elements: order, near-disorder and disorder profiles. Finally, the MCS is exploited as features to identify disordered regions in sequences. DisoMCS utilizes a non-redundant data set as the training set, MCS and predicted secondary structure as features, and a conditional random field as the classification algorithm. In predicted near-disorder regions a residue is determined as an order or a disorder according to the optimized decision threshold. DisoMCS was evaluated by cross-validation, large-scale prediction, independent tests and CASP (Critical Assessment of Techniques for Protein Structure Prediction) tests. All results confirmed that DisoMCS was very competitive in terms of accuracy of prediction when compared with well-established publicly available disordered region predictors. It also indicated our approach was more accurate when a query has higher homologous with the knowledge database.