PCR artifact in testing for homologous recombination in genomic editing in zebrafish

Efficient non-viral immune cell engineering using circular single-stranded DNA-mediated genomic integration

The use of adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) as donors for homology-directed repair (HDR)-mediated genome engineering is limited by safety issues, manufacturing constraints and restricted packaging limits. Non-viral targeted genetic knock-ins rely primarily on double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) and linear single-stranded DNA (lssDNA) donors. dsDNA is known to have low efficiency and high cytotoxicity, while lssDNA is challenging for scaled manufacture. In this study, we developed a non-viral genome writing catalyst (GATALYST) system that allows production of circular single-stranded DNAs (cssDNAs) up to approximately 20 kilobases as donor templates for highly efficient precision transgene integration. cssDNA donors enable knock-in efficiency of up to 70% in induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) and improved efficiency in multiple clinically relevant primary immune cell types and at multiple genomic loci implicated for clinical applications with various nuclease editor systems. The high precision and efficiency in chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-T and natural killer (NK) cells, improved safety, payload flexibility and scalable manufacturability of cssDNA shows potential for future applications of genome engineering.

Generation and application of endogenously floxed alleles for cell-specific knockout in zebrafish

The zebrafish is amenable to a variety of genetic approaches. However, lack of conditional deletion alleles limits stage- or cell-specific gene knockout. Here, we applied an existing protocol to establish a floxed allele for gata2a but failed to do so due to off-target integration and incomplete knockin. To address these problems, we applied simultaneous co-targeting with Cas12a to insert loxP sites in cis, together with transgenic counterscreening and comprehensive molecular analysis, to identify off-target insertions and confirm targeted knockins. We subsequently used our approach to establish endogenously floxed alleles of foxc1a, rasa1a, and ruvbl1, each in a single generation. We demonstrate the utility of these alleles by verifying Cre-dependent deletion, which yielded expected phenotypes in each case. Finally, we used the floxed gata2a allele to demonstrate an endothelial autonomous requirement in lymphatic valve development. Together, our results provide a framework for routine generation and application of endogenously floxed alleles in zebrafish.

Efficient single copy integration via homology-directed repair (scHDR) by 5'modification of large DNA donor fragments in mice

CRISPR/Cas-based approaches have largely replaced conventional gene targeting strategies. However, homology-directed repair (HDR) in the mouse genome is not very efficient, and precisely inserting longer sequences using HDR remains challenging given that donor constructs preferentially integrate as concatemers. Here, we showed that injecting 5' biotinylated donor DNA into mouse embryos at the two-cell stage led to efficient single-copy HDR (scHDR) allele generation. Our dedicated genotyping strategy showed that these alleles occurred with frequencies of 19%, 20%, and 26% at three independent gene loci, indicating that scHDR was dramatically increased by 5' biotinylation. Thus, we suggest that the combination of a 5' biotinylated donor and diligent analysis of concatemer integration are prerequisites for efficiently and reliably generating conditional alleles or other large fragment knock-ins in the mouse genome.

Homology-Directed Repair by CRISPR-Cas9 Mutagenesis in Xenopus Using Long Single-Stranded Donor DNA Templates via Simple Microinjection of Embryos

We describe a step-by-step procedure to perform homology-directed repair (HDR)-mediated precise gene editing in Xenopus embryos using long single-stranded DNA (lssDNA) as a donor template for HDR in conjunction with the CRISPR-Cas9 system. A key advantage of this method is that it relies on simple microinjection of fertilized Xenopus eggs, resulting in high yield of healthy founder embryos. These embryos are screened for those animals carrying the precisely mutated locus to then generate homozygous and/or heterozygous mutant lines in the F₁ generation. Therefore, we can avoid the more challenging "oocyte host transfer" technique, which is particularly difficult for Xenopus tropicalis, that is required for an alternate HDR approach. Several key points of this protocol are (1) to use efficiently active single-guide RNAs for targeting, (2) to use properly designed lssDNAs, and (3) to use 5'-end phosphorothioate-modification to obtain higher-efficiency HDR.

Conditional mutagenesis strategies in zebrafish

Gene disruption or knockout is an essential tool for elucidating gene function. Conditional knockout methodology was developed to further advance these studies by enabling gene disruption at a predefined time and/or in discrete cells. While the conditional knockout method is widely used in the mouse, technical limitations have stifled direct adoption of this methodology in other animal models including the zebrafish. Recent advances in genome editing have enabled engineering of distinct classes of conditional mutants in zebrafish. To further accelerate the development and application of conditional mutants, we will review diverse methods of conditional knockout engineering and discuss the advantages of different conditional alleles.

The Spermidine Synthase Gene SPD1: A Novel Auxotrophic Marker for Chlamydomonas reinhardtii Designed by Enhanced CRISPR/Cas9 Gene Editing

Biotechnological application of the green microalga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii hinges on the availability of selectable markers for effective expression of multiple transgenes. However, biological safety concerns limit the establishment of new antibiotic resistance genes and until today, only a few auxotrophic markers exist for C. reinhardtii. The recent improvements in gene editing via CRISPR/Cas allow directed exploration of new endogenous selectable markers. Since editing frequencies remain comparably low, a Cas9-sgRNA ribonucleoprotein (RNP) delivery protocol was strategically optimized by applying nitrogen starvation to the pre-culture, which improved successful gene edits from 10% to 66% after pre-selection. Probing the essential polyamine biosynthesis pathway, the spermidine synthase gene (SPD1) is shown to be a potent selectable marker with versatile biotechnological applicability. Very low levels of spermidine (0.75 mg/L) were required to maintain normal mixotrophic and phototrophic growth in newly designed spermidine auxotrophic strains. Complementation of these strains with a synthetic SPD1 gene was achieved when the mature protein was expressed in the cytosol or targeted to the chloroplast. This work highlights the potential of new selectable markers for biotechnology as well as basic research and proposes an effective pipeline for the identification of new auxotrophies in C. reinhardtii.

Endogenous protein tagging in medaka using a simplified CRISPR/Cas9 knock-in approach

The CRISPR/Cas9 system has been used to generate fluorescently labelled fusion proteins by homology-directed repair in a variety of species. Despite its revolutionary success, there remains an urgent need for increased simplicity and efficiency of genome editing in research organisms. Here, we establish a simplified, highly efficient, and precise strategy for CRISPR/Cas9-mediated endogenous protein tagging in medaka (Oryzias latipes). We use a cloning-free approach that relies on PCR-amplified donor fragments containing the fluorescent reporter sequences flanked by short homology arms (30–40 bp), a synthetic single-guide RNA and Cas9 mRNA. We generate eight novel knock-in lines with high efficiency of F0 targeting and germline transmission. Whole genome sequencing results reveal single-copy integration events only at the targeted loci. We provide an initial characterization of these fusion protein lines, significantly expanding the repertoire of genetic tools available in medaka. In particular, we show that the mScarlet-pcna line has the potential to serve as an organismal-wide label for proliferative zones and an endogenous cell cycle reporter.

GeneWeld: Efficient Targeted Integration Directed by Short Homology in Zebrafish

Efficient precision genome engineering requires high frequency and specificity of integration at the genomic target site. Multiple design strategies for zebrafish gene targeting have previously been reported with widely varying frequencies for germline recovery of integration alleles. The GeneWeld protocol and pGTag (plasmids for Gene Tagging) vector series provide a set of resources to streamline precision gene targeting in zebrafish. Our approach uses short homology of 24-48 bp to drive targeted integration of DNA reporter cassettes by homology-mediated end joining (HMEJ) at a CRISPR/Cas induced DNA double-strand break. The pGTag vectors contain reporters flanked by a universal CRISPR sgRNA sequence to liberate the targeting cassette in vivo and expose homology arms for homology-driven integration. Germline transmission rates for precision-targeted integration alleles range 22-100%. Our system provides a streamlined, straightforward, and cost-effective approach for high-efficiency gene targeting applications in zebrafish. Graphic abstract: GeneWeld method for CRISPR/Cas9 targeted integration.

CRISPR/Cas9-Mediated Multi-Allelic Gene Targeting in Sugarcane Confers Herbicide Tolerance

Sugarcane is the source of 80% of the sugar and 26% of the bioethanol produced globally. However, its complex, highly polyploid genome (2n = 100 - 120) impedes crop improvement. Here, we report efficient and reproducible gene targeting (GT) in sugarcane, enabling precise co-editing of multiple alleles via template-mediated and homology-directed repair (HDR) of DNA double strand breaks induced by the programmable nuclease CRISPR/Cas9. The evaluation of 146 independently transformed plants from five independent experiments revealed a targeted nucleotide replacement that resulted in both targeted amino acid substitutions W574L and S653I in the acetolactate synthase (ALS) in 11 lines in addition to single, targeted amino acid substitutions W574L or S653I in 25 or 18 lines, respectively. Co-editing of up to three ALS copies/alleles that confer herbicide tolerance was confirmed by Sanger sequencing of cloned long polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplicons. This work will enable crop improvement by conversion of inferior alleles to superior alleles through targeted nucleotide substitutions.

Overcoming diverse homologous recombinations and single chimeric guide RNA competitive inhibition enhances Cas9-based cyclical multiple genes coediting in filamentous fungi

Deciphering the complex cellular behaviours and advancing the biotechnology applications of filamentous fungi increase the requirement for genetically manipulating a large number of target genes. The current strategies cannot cyclically coedit multiple genes simultaneously. In this study, we firstly revealed the existence of diverse homologous recombination (HR) types in marker-free editing of filamentous fungi, and then, demonstrated that sgRNA efficiency-mediated competitive inhibition resulted in the low integration of multiple genetic sites during coediting, which are the two major obstacles to limit the efficiency of cyclically coediting of multiple genes. To overcome these obstacles, we developed a biased cutting strategy by Cas9 to greatly enhance the desired HR type and applied a new selection marker labelling strategy for multiple donor DNAs, in which only the donor DNA with the lowest sgRNA efficiency was labelled. Combined with these strategies, we successfully developed a convenient method for cyclically coediting multiple genes in different filamentous fungi. In addition, diverse HRs resulted in a useful and convenient one-step approach for gene functional study combining both gene disruption and complementation. This research provided both a useful one-step approach for gene functional study and an efficient strategy for cyclically coediting multiple genes in filamentous fungi.

DNA templates with blocked long 3' end single-stranded overhangs (BL3SSO) promote bona fide Cas9-stimulated homology-directed repair of long transgenes into endogenous gene loci

Knock-in of large transgenes by Cas9-mediated homology-directed repair (HDR) is an extremely inefficient process. Although the use of single-stranded oligonucleotides (ssODN) as an HDR donor has improved the integration of smaller transgenes, they do not support efficient insertion of large DNA sequences. In an effort to gain insights into the mechanism(s) governing the HDR-mediated integration of larger transgenes and to improve the technology, we conducted knock-in experiments targeting the human EMX1 locus and applied rigorous genomic PCR analyses in the human HEK293 cell line. This exercise revealed an unexpected molecular complication arising from the transgene HDR being initiated at the single homology arm and the subsequent genomic integration of plasmid backbone sequences. To pivot around this problem, we devised a novel PCR-constructed template containing blocked long 3' single-stranded overhangs (BL3SSO) that greatly improved the efficiency of bona fide Cas9-stimulated HDR at the EMX1 locus. We further refined BL3SSO technology and successfully used it to insert GFP transgenes into two important interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs) loci, Viperin/RSAD2, and ISG15. This study demonstrates the utility of the BL3SSO platform for inserting long DNA sequences into both constitutive and inducible endogenous loci to generate novel human cell lines for the study of important biological processes.

Targeted DNA insertion in plants

Conventional methods of DNA sequence insertion into plants, using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation or microprojectile bombardment, result in the integration of the DNA at random sites in the genome. These plants may exhibit altered agronomic traits as a consequence of disruption or silencing of genes that serve a critical function. Also, genes of interest inserted at random sites are often not expressed at the desired level. For these reasons, targeted DNA insertion at suitable genomic sites in plants is a desirable alternative. In this paper we review approaches of targeted DNA insertion in plant genomes, discuss current technical challenges, and describe promising applications of targeted DNA insertion for crop genetic improvement.

A cell cycle-dependent CRISPR-Cas9 activation system based on an anti-CRISPR protein shows improved genome editing accuracy

The development of genome editing systems based on the Cas9 endonuclease has greatly facilitated gene knockouts and targeted genetic alterations. Precise editing of target genes without off-target effects is crucial to prevent adverse effects in clinical applications. Although several methods have been reported to result in less off-target effects associated with the CRISPR technology, these often exhibit lower editing efficiency. Therefore, efficient, accurate, and innocuous CRISPR technology is still required. Anti-CRISPR proteins are natural inhibitors of CRISPR-Cas systems derived from bacteriophages. Here, the anti-CRISPR protein, AcrIIA4, was fused with the N terminal region of human Cdt1 that is degraded specifically in S and G2, the phases of the cell cycle when homology-directed repair (HDR) is dominant. Co-expression of SpyCas9 and AcrIIA4-Cdt1 not only increases the frequency of HDR but also suppress off-targets effects. Thus, the combination of SpyCas9 and AcrIIA4-Cdt1 is a cell cycle-dependent Cas9 activation system for accurate and efficient genome editing.

Cell Synchronization Enhances Nuclear Transformation and Genome Editing via Cas9 Enabling Homologous Recombination in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

In Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, the model organism for eukaryotic green algae and plants, the processes of nuclear transformation and genome editing in particular are still marked by a low level of efficiency, and so intensive work is required in order to create and identify mutants for the investigation of basic physiological processes, as well as the implementation of biotechnological applications. In this work, we show that cell synchronization during the stages of the cell cycle, obtained from long-term cultivation under specific growth conditions, greatly enhances the efficiency of transformation and allows the identification of DNA repair mechanisms that occur preferentially at different stages of the cell cycle. We demonstrate that the transformation of synchronized cells at different times was differentially associated with nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) and/or homologous recombination (HR), and makes it possible to knock-in specific foreign DNA at the genomic nuclear location desired by exploiting HR. This optimization greatly reduces the overall complexity of the genome editing procedure and creates new opportunities for altering genes and their products.

Rapid Tagging of Human Proteins with Fluorescent Reporters by Genome Engineering using Double-Stranded DNA Donors

Tagging proteins with fluorescent reporters such as green fluorescent protein (GFP) is a powerful method to determine protein localization, especially when proteins are tagged in the endogenous context to preserve native genomic regulation. However, insertion of fluorescent reporters into the genomes of mammalian cells has required the construction of plasmids containing selection markers and/or extended sequences homologous to the site of insertion (homology arms). Here we describe a streamlined protocol that eliminates all cloning steps by taking advantage of the high propensity of linear DNAs to engage in homology‐directed repair of DNA breaks induced by the Cas9 RNA‐guided endonuclease. The protocol uses PCR amplicons, or synthetic gene fragments, with short homology arms (30‐40 bp) to insert fluorescent reporters at specific genomic locations. The linear DNAs are introduced into cells with preassembled Cas9‐crRNA‐tracrRNA complexes using one of two transfection procedures, nucleofection or lipofection. The protocol can be completed under a week, with efficiencies ranging from 0.5% to 20% of transfected cells depending on the locus targeted. © 2019 The Authors.

Creation of zebrafish knock-in reporter lines in the nefma gene by Cas9-mediated homologous recombination

CRISPR/Cas9-based strategies are widely used for genome editing in many organisms, including zebrafish. Although most applications consist in introducing double strand break (DSB)-induced mutations, it is also possible to use CRISPR/Cas9 to enhance homology directed repair (HDR) at a chosen genomic location to create knock-ins with optimally controlled precision. Here, we describe the use of CRISPR/Cas9-targeted DSB followed by HDR to generate zebrafish transgenic lines where exogenous coding sequences are added in the nefma gene, in frame with the endogenous coding sequence. The resulting knock-in embryos express the added gene (fluorescent reporter or KalTA4 transactivator) specifically in the populations of neurons that express nefma, making them convenient tools for research on these populations.

Production of a mutant of large-scale loach Paramisgurnus dabryanus with skin pigmentation loss by genome editing with CRISPR/Cas9 system

CRISPR/Cas9 system has been developed as a highly efficient genome editing technology to specifically induce mutations in a few aquaculture species. In this study, we described induction of targeted gene (namely tyrosinase, tyr) mutations in large-scale loach Paramisgurnus dabryanus, an important aquaculture fish species and a potential model organism for studies of intestinal air-breathing function, using the CRISPR/Cas9 system. Tyr gene in large-scale loach was firstly cloned and then its expressions were investigated. Two guide RNAs (gRNAs) were designed and separately transformed with Cas9 in the loach. 89.4% and 96.1% of injected loach juveniles respectively displayed a graded loss of pigmentation for the two gRNAs, in other words, for target 1 and target 2. We classified the injected loach juveniles into five groups according to their skin color phenotypes, including four albino groups and one wild-type-like group. And one of them was clear albino group, which was of high ornamental and commercial value. More than 50 clones for each albino transformant with a visible phenotype in each target were randomly selected and sequenced. Results obtained here showed that along with the increase of pigmentation, wild-type alleles appeared in the injected loach juveniles more often and insertion/deletion alleles less frequently. This study demonstrated that CRISPR/Cas9 system could be practically performed to modify large-scale loach tyr to produce an albino mutant of high ornamental and commercial value, and for the first time showed successful use of the CRISPR/Cas9 system for genome editing in a Cobitidae species.

Knock-Down of a ligIV Homologue Enables DNA Integration via Homologous Recombination in the Marine Diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum

Genetic engineering of Phaeodactylum tricornutum as a model organism for diatoms is the basis of molecular and biochemical research, and can also be used in biotechnological approaches. So far, integration of foreign DNA into the genome happens randomly by nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ), if the classical method of particle bombardment is used, with the danger of negative physiological side effects. Here we show that a putative gene for a DNA ligase IV homologue ( ligIV) in P. tricornutum codes for a functional LigIV. The knock-down of ligIV in P. tricornutum via antisense RNA drastically enhances homologous recombination (HR) by interfering with the NHEJ pathway at its central DNA ligation step done by LigIV. This enables a specific integration of DNA at desired locations, greatly enhanced transformation rates and provides a new way of specifically altering the genome of P. tricornutum.

CRISPR/Cas9-mediated homology-directed repair by ssODNs in zebrafish induces complex mutational patterns resulting from genomic integration of repair-template fragments

Targeted genome editing by CRISPR/Cas9 is extremely well fitted to generate gene disruptions, although precise sequence replacement by CRISPR/Cas9-mediated homology-directed repair (HDR) suffers from low efficiency, impeding its use for high-throughput knock-in disease modeling. In this study, we used next-generation sequencing (NGS) analysis to determine the efficiency and reliability of CRISPR/Cas9-mediated HDR using several types of single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotide (ssODN) repair templates for the introduction of disease-relevant point mutations in the zebrafish genome. Our results suggest that HDR rates are strongly determined by repair-template composition, with the most influential factor being homology-arm length. However, we found that repair using ssODNs does not only lead to precise sequence replacement but also induces integration of repair-template fragments at the Cas9 cut site. We observed that error-free repair occurs at a relatively constant rate of 1-4% when using different repair templates, which was sufficient for transmission of point mutations to the F1 generation. On the other hand, erroneous repair mainly accounts for the variability in repair rate between the different repair templates. To further improve error-free HDR rates, elucidating the mechanism behind this erroneous repair is essential. We show that the error-prone nature of ssODN-mediated repair, believed to act via synthesis-dependent strand annealing (SDSA), is most likely due to DNA synthesis errors. In conclusion, caution is warranted when using ssODNs for the generation of knock-in models or for therapeutic applications. We recommend the application of in-depth NGS analysis to examine both the efficiency and error-free nature of HDR events.

This article has an associated First Person interview with the first author of the paper.

Summary: NGS-based analysis reveals that CRISPR/Cas9-induced double-strand-break repair using single-stranded repair templates is error prone in zebrafish, resulting in complex patterns of integrated repair-template fragments.

Efficient single-copy HDR by 5' modified long dsDNA donors

CRISPR/Cas9 efficiently induces targeted mutations via non-homologous-end-joining but for genome editing, precise, homology-directed repair (HDR) of endogenous DNA stretches is a prerequisite. To favor HDR, many approaches interfere with the repair machinery or manipulate Cas9 itself. Using Medaka we show that the modification of 5’ ends of long dsDNA donors strongly enhances HDR, favors efficient single-copy integration by retaining a monomeric donor conformation thus facilitating successful gene replacement or tagging.

CRISPR/Cas9 technology has revolutionized the ability of researchers to edit the DNA of any organism whose genome has already been sequenced. In the editing process, a section of RNA acts as a guide to match up to the location of the target DNA. The enzyme Cas9 then makes a cut in both strands of the DNA at this specific location. New segments of DNA can be introduced to the cell, incorporated into DNA ‘templates’. The cell uses the template to help it to heal the double-strand break, and in doing so adds the new DNA segment into the organism’s genome.

A drawback of CRISPR/Cas9 is that it often introduces multiple copies of the new DNA segment into the genome because the templates can bind to each other before being pasted into place. In addition, some parts of the new DNA segment can be missed off during the editing process. However, most applications of CRISPR/Cas9 – for example, to replace a defective gene with a working version – require exactly one whole copy of the desired DNA to be inserted into the genome.

In order to achieve more accurate CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing, Gutierrez-Triana, Tavhelidse, Thumberger et al. attached additional molecules to the end of the DNA template to shield the DNA from mistakes during editing. The modified template was used to couple a stem cell gene to a reporter that produces a green fluorescent protein into the genome of fish embryos. The fluorescent proteins made it easy to identify when the coupling was successful.

Gutierrez-Triana et al. found that the additional molecules prevented multiple templates from joining together end to end, and ensured the full DNA segment was inserted into the genome. Furthermore, the results of the experiments showed that only one copy of the template was inserted into the DNA of the fish. In the future, the new template will allow DNA to be edited in a more controlled way both in basic research and in therapeutic applications.

In vivo genome editing thrives with diversified CRISPR technologies

Prokaryotic type II adaptive immune systems have been developed into the versatile CRISPR technology, which has been widely applied in site-specific genome editing and has revolutionized biomedical research due to its superior efficiency and flexibility. Recent studies have greatly diversified CRISPR technologies by coupling it with various DNA repair mechanisms and targeting strategies. These new advances have significantly expanded the generation of genetically modified animal models, either by including species in which targeted genetic modification could not be achieved previously, or through introducing complex genetic modifications that take multiple steps and cost years to achieve using traditional methods. Herein, we review the recent developments and applications of CRISPR-based technology in generating various animal models, and discuss the everlasting impact of this new progress on biomedical research.