Surgery and protontherapy in Grade I and II skull base chondrosarcoma: A comparative retrospective study

Chondrosarcomas: Multidisciplinary review and practical recommendations, on behalf of GroupOs

Chondrosarcomas are rare tumors occurring in middle age and older adults, defined by malignant cartilaginous matrix-producing neoplasms. Chondrosarcomas represent a heterogeneous group of tumors with diverse characteristics, management strategies and prognosis. The aim is to establish recommendations to support optimal practice for the diagnosis and treatment of chondrosarcomas within the framework of an expert group at the request of GroupOs and the French Sarcoma Group. The recommendations were developed by a multidisciplinary working and underwent thorough proofreading. The level of evidence in scientific literature and the grading of recommendations by the French Haute Autorité de santé (HAS) were taken into account. Key recommendations cover: (i) diagnosis, management and follow-up enchondromatosis; (ii) initial assessment, diagnosis and staging of cartilaginous tumor; (iii) management of low-grade, clear cell and high-grade, localized resectable chondrosarcomas; (iv) indications for radiotherapy in chondrosarcomas; (v) management of locally advanced and metastatic disease; (vi) management of mesenchymal chondrosarcomas. Surgical resection at a specialized center remains the mainstay for localized chondrosarcomas management, tailored to grade and anatomical location. Limited evidence supports the use of neoadjuvant or adjuvant treatment in chondrosarcomas, except in mesenchymal chondrosarcomas. For patients with dedifferentiated chondrosarcomas, neo or adjuvant treatment with osteosarcoma-like regimens may be proposed. In cases of recurrence or metastasis, local treatment should be prioritized or participation in clinical trials including new targeted or immune therapies should be considered. This article presents consensus recommandations from adult and pediatric sarcoma experts of various disciplines on the practical management of chondrosarcomas patients.

Surgical management of chondrosarcomas of the skull-base and temporal bone

OBJECTIVES

To analyze the overall long-term outcome of surgically treated skull base and temporal bone chondrosarcomas.

METHODS

The medical records of patients with surgically treated skull base and temporal bone chondrosarcomas between 1983 and 2024 were thoroughly evaluated.

RESULTS

Out of a total of over 5000 skull base surgeries performed at our center, only 29 patients had histopathologically confirmed chondrosarcomas of the skull base and temporal bone. The mean of patients age was 45.6, and the male-to-female ratio was 1.9:1. The most common symptoms included hearing loss (58.6%), tinnitus (41.4%), diplopia (31%), dysphonia (24.1%), dysphagia (20.7%), vertigo (10.3%), and dizziness (10.3%). The most frequent locations of lesions among the 29 patients are as follows: petroclival region (34.5%), jugular foramen (27.6%), petrous apex (17.2%), middle ear (13.8%), others (3.4%). TO, IFTA, IFTB, IFTC, POTS, and combined surgical approaches were commonly used. The rate of gross total removal and recurrence was 82.6% and 13.8% respectively. The follow-up duration of 6 patients was more than five years and less than ten years whereas ten patients had more than ten years of follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Chondrosarcoma of the skull base and temporal bone is a very rare pathology. Due to its multiple potential sites of origin and histological specificity, it presents us with significant challenges. Gross total removal is the primary treatment for chondrosarcoma of the skull base and temporal bone. Personalized decision-making should be considered based on the following aspects: tumor, patient, and surgeon's factors. Postoperative radiation therapy is complementary to surgical treatment in grades II and III lesions to achieve long-term survival.

Complete excision of a giant chondrosarcoma within the cavernous sinus: a case report and literature review

BACKGROUND

Primary skull base chondrosarcoma (SBC) is a rare malignant central nervous system tumor, often involving the cavernous sinus. Complete excision of tumors invading this region is exceptionally challenging due to the presence of the internal carotid artery and numerous nerves within the cavernous sinus, particularly in cases with substantial tumor volume.

CASE PRESENTATION

This report describes a rare case of a massive primary SBC pushing the lateral wall of the cavernous sinus, measuring approximately 6.6 cm × 4.5 cm × 4.4 cm. Utilizing neurophysiological monitoring and intraoperative navigation, we successfully achieved complete tumor resection along the membranous structure via a left modified pterional approach (pterional-zygomatic arch-subdural-infratemporal approach), employing tools such as a cavitron ultrasonic surgical aspirator (CUSA) and piezosurgery. During the excision, localized rupture and bleeding of the internal carotid artery occurred, but prompt repair and anastomosis were performed. Postoperatively, the patient's symptoms markedly improved, and good reperfusion of the internal carotid artery was observed without new severe complications. The postoperative pathological diagnosis, according to the World Health Organization classification, was Grade 1 chondrosarcoma; therefore, radiotherapy was not administered. Magnetic resonance imaging at the 8-month follow-up showed no residual tumor or recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

This case highlights that surgical complete excision of large intracavernous SBCs, while preserving vital neurovascular functions, is feasible and paramount for achieving favorable outcomes, particularly for Grade 1 and 2 SBCs, which comprise 82.4% of all subtypes. The use of a modified left pterional approach, intra-capsular tumor resection techniques, alongside CUSA and piezosurgery, provides valuable insights and serves as a reference for achieving complete excision of SBCs within the cavernous sinus.

Surgical management of skull base chordomas and chondrosarcomas: insights from a national cohort study

Objective

Skull base chordoma and chondrosarcoma are distinct sarcomas of the skull base but share significant therapeutic challenges due to their proximity to critical neurovascular structures, making surgical resection difficult. We sought to establish factors associated with outcome predictors in a national cohort of patients.

Methods and analysis

Data for all patients referred with a diagnosis of skull base chordoma or chondrosarcoma from April 2017 to December 2022 were obtained. We performed analyses of data pertaining to the first cohort of patients treated in the UK with proton beam therapy (PBT) to determine factors associated with obtaining gross total resection (GTR) and adequate clearance of the brainstem and optic apparatus.

Results

Of 230 patients with skull base chordoma or chondrosarcoma referred for PBT, 71% were accepted for PBT, with a wide regional variation between referring neurosurgical units (29%-93%). Of the first 75 consecutive patients treated with PBT, the only factor predictive of obtaining GTR was surgical resection at a unit with higher volumes of patients accepted for PBT (OR 1.32, 95% CI 1.11 to 1.63, p=0.004). Use of intraoperative MRI (OR 4.84, 95% CI 1.21 to 27.83, p=0.04) and resection at a higher volume unit (OR 1.29, 95% CI 1.07 to 1.64, p=0.013) were associated with increased rates of tumour clearance from the brainstem/optic apparatus.

Conclusions

Treatment at a higher volume centre was a key determinant of the optimal surgical outcome in this cohort. These data support the management of skull base chordomas and chondrosarcomas in higher volume centres where multidisciplinary experience can be accumulated.

Evaluation of cranial nerve involvement in chordomas and chondrosarcomas: a retrospective imaging study

PURPOSE

Cranial nerve involvement (CNI) influences the treatment strategies and prognosis of head and neck tumors. However, its incidence in skull base chordomas and chondrosarcomas remains to be investigated. This study evaluated the imaging features of chordoma and chondrosarcoma, with a focus on the differences in CNI.

METHODS

Forty-two patients (26 and 16 patients with chordomas and chondrosarcomas, respectively) treated at our institution between January 2007 and January 2023 were included in this retrospective study. Imaging features, such as the maximum diameter, tumor location (midline or off-midline), calcification, signal intensity on T2-weighted image, mean apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) values, contrast enhancement, and CNI, were evaluated and compared using Fisher's exact test or the Mann-Whitney U-test. The odds ratio (OR) was calculated to evaluate the association between the histological type and imaging features.

RESULTS

The incidence of CNI in chondrosarcomas was significantly higher than that in chordomas (63% vs. 8%, P < 0.001). An off-midline location was more common in chondrosarcomas than in chordomas (86% vs. 13%; P < 0.001). The mean ADC values of chondrosarcomas were significantly higher than those of chordomas (P < 0.001). Significant associations were identified between chondrosarcomas and CNI (OR = 20.00; P < 0.001), location (OR = 53.70; P < 0.001), and mean ADC values (OR = 1.01; P = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

The incidence of CNI and off-midline location in chondrosarcomas was significantly higher than that in chordomas. CNI, tumor location, and the mean ADC can help distinguish between these entities.

An Unusual Presentation of a Primary Chondrosarcoma of the Cranial Vault

Chondrosarcomas are malignant cartilaginous tumors that usually affect the pelvic bone and long bones. Primary chondrosarcomas of the skull are rare, with the cranial vault being an even more unusual localization. We report a case of a 75-year-old man presenting with headaches and outgrowth of the parietal scalp. CT scan of the head showed an extracranial cystic well-rounded mass originating at the parietal suture and eroding through the adjacent parietal bone. The patient underwent an en bloc surgical resection of the mass, and histological examination confirmed a grade I chondrosarcoma.

A systematic review and meta-analysis of radiotherapy and particle beam therapy for skull base chondrosarcoma: TRP-chondrosarcoma 2024

Introduction

Chondrosarcoma is a rare malignant bone tumor. Particle beam therapy (PT) can concentrate doses to targets while reducing adverse events. A meta-analysis based on a literature review was performed to examine the efficacy of PT and photon radiotherapy for skull base chondrosarcoma.

Methods

The meta-analysis was conducted using 21 articles published from 1990 to 2022.

Results

After PT, the 3- and 5-year overall survival (OS) rates were 94.1% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 91.0-96.2%) and 93.9% (95% CI: 90.6-96.1%), respectively, and the 3- and 5-year local control rates were 95.4% (95% CI: 92.0-97.4%) and 90.1% (95% CI: 76.8-96.0%), respectively. Meta-regression analysis revealed a significant association of PT with a superior 5-year OS rate compared to three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy (p < 0.001). In the studies used in the meta-analysis, the major adverse event of grade 2 or higher was temporal lobe necrosis (incidence 1-18%, median 7%).

Conclusion

PT for skull base chondrosarcoma had a good outcome and may be a valuable option among radiotherapy modalities. However, high-dose postoperative irradiation of skull base chondrosarcoma can cause adverse events such as temporal lobe necrosis.

Skull-Base Chondrosarcoma: A Systematic Review of the Role of Postoperative Radiotherapy

Surgery and radiotherapy are key elements to the treatment of skull-base chondrosarcomas; however, there is currently no consensus regarding whether or not adjuvant radiotherapy has to be administered. This study searched the EMBASE, Cochrane, and PubMed databases for clinical studies evaluating the long-term prognosis of surgery with or without adjuvant radiotherapy. After reviewing the search results, a total of 22 articles were selected for this review. A total of 1388 patients were included in this cohort, of which 186 received surgery only. With mean follow-up periods ranging from 39.1 to 86 months, surgical treatment provided progression-free survival (PFS) rates ranging from 83.7 to 92.9% at 3 years, 60.0 to 92.9% at 5 years, and 58.2 to 64.0% at 10 years. Postoperative radiotherapy provides PFS rates ranging between 87 and 96.2% at 3 years, 57.1 and 100% at 5 years, and 67 and 100% at 10 years. Recurrence rates varied from 5.3% to 39.0% in the surgery-only approach and between 1.5% and 42.90% for the postoperative radiotherapy group. When considering prognostic variables, higher age, brainstem/optic apparatus compression, and larger tumor volume prior to radiotherapy were found to be significant factors for local recurrence.

International Consensus Statement on Allergy and Rhinology: Sinonasal Tumors

BACKGROUND

Sinonasal neoplasms, whether benign and malignant, pose a significant challenge to clinicians and represent a model area for multidisciplinary collaboration in order to optimize patient care. The International Consensus Statement on Allergy and Rhinology: Sinonasal Tumors (ICSNT) aims to summarize the best available evidence and presents 48 thematic and histopathology-based topics spanning the field.

METHODS

In accordance with prior International Consensus Statement on Allergy and Rhinology documents, ICSNT assigned each topic as an Evidence-Based Review with Recommendations, Evidence-Based Review, and Literature Review based on the level of evidence. An international group of multidisciplinary author teams were assembled for the topic reviews using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses format, and completed sections underwent a thorough and iterative consensus-building process. The final document underwent rigorous synthesis and review prior to publication.

RESULTS

The ICSNT document consists of four major sections: general principles, benign neoplasms and lesions, malignant neoplasms, and quality of life and surveillance. It covers 48 conceptual and/or histopathology-based topics relevant to sinonasal neoplasms and masses. Topics with a high level of evidence provided specific recommendations, while other areas summarized the current state of evidence. A final section highlights research opportunities and future directions, contributing to advancing knowledge and community intervention.

CONCLUSION

As an embodiment of the multidisciplinary and collaborative model of care in sinonasal neoplasms and masses, ICSNT was designed as a comprehensive, international, and multidisciplinary collaborative endeavor. Its primary objective is to summarize the existing evidence in the field of sinonasal neoplasms and masses.

Risk Factors for Radiation Necrosis and Local Recurrence after Proton Beam Therapy for Skull Base Chordoma or Chondrosarcoma

[Proposal] Here, we retrospectively evaluate risk factors for radiation necrosis and local recurrence after PBT for skull base chordoma or chondrosarcoma. [Patients and Methods] We analyzed 101 patients who received PBT for skull base chordomas and chondrosarcomas from January 1989 to February 2021. Multivariable logistic regression models were applied for local recurrence, temporal lobe radiation necrosis rates, and temporal lobe radiation necrosis. [Results] In multivariate analysis, chordoma and large tumor size were independent significant factors for local recurrence. The 1-, 2-, 3-, 4- and 5-year local recurrence rates were 3.9%, 16.9%, 20.3%, 28.5% and 44.0% for chordoma and 0%, 0%, 0%, 0% and 7.1% for chondrosarcoma, respectively. The local recurrence rates of small tumors (<30 mm) were 4.3%, 14.7%, 17.7%, 17.7% and 25.9%, and those for large tumors were 3.6%, 15.1%, 19.2%, 32.7% and 59.6%, respectively. In multivariate analysis, BED Gy10 and total dose were risk factors for radiation necrosis. [Conclusions] For skull base chordoma and chondrosarcoma, the risk factors of local recurrence were chordoma and large tumor size, and those of radiation necrosis were BED Gy10 and total dose, respectively. DVH analysis is needed to investigate the risk factors for brain necrosis in more detail.

Proton Therapy for Skull Base Chondrosarcoma

Chondrosarcoma is a type of an endochondral bone malignancy that is primarily treated surgically with radiation therapy used in the adjuvant setting or in cases of unresectable disease. Proton therapy has potential advantages compared with traditional photon therapy for the treatment of tumors in close proximity to critical structures due to the theoretic lower exit dose. Studies have shown improved survival in patients with skull base chondrosarcoma who undergo proton therapy. However, there is a lack of randomized data. Further studies are needed to define the role of proton therapy in the treatment of skull base chondrosarcoma.

Chondrosarcoma of the petrous apex with nerve abducens involvement in a woman with pre-existing contralateral amblyopia

We report about a case of a woman in her 50s with a chondrosarcoma of the petrous apex. She has a strabism due to a right-sided amblyopia since childhood and noticed a slowly progressive squint angle in the last months. Her general practitioner (GP) referred her to an ophthalmologist who diagnosed a left abducens paresis and initiated an MRI demonstrating a mass in the left petrous apex. A transnasal endoscopic transsphenoidal biopsy revealed a grade I chondrosarcoma. The patient underwent an endoscopic transsphenoidal anterior petrosectomy approach with complete removal of the tumour. After surgery the squint angle gradually improved to previous levels, so that the patient was able to resume her work. This report demonstrates that even slight changes of a squint angle without diplopia, in this case because of pre-existing amblyopia, could be a hallmark of an intracranial process.

A multicenter retrospective analysis of clinical outcomes of intracranial chondrosarcoma in 26 patients

Intracranial chondrosarcoma is a rare tumor with limited reports. We reviewed the clinical outcomes, imaging findings, and pathological characteristics at three centers to improve the diagnosis and treatment of intracranial chondrosarcoma. We retrospectively analyzed 26 patients with intracranial chondrosarcoma who had undergone surgical treatment at Tangdu Hospital of Air Force Military Medical University, Mianyang Central Hospital, and Nanchong Central Hospital from January 2010 to July 2022. Clinical manifestations, imaging features, surgical treatment, prognosis, and overall survival (OS) were analyzed. All 26 chondrosarcomas were located at the skull base. Gross total resection (GTR), subtotal resection (STR), and partial resection (PR) were performed in 14, 10, and 2 cases, respectively. Four cases underwent endoscopic transnasal surgery, while the remaining cases underwent craniotomy. The clinical symptoms were evaluated 1 week after surgery, and 15 cases were relieved to varying degrees. Postoperative complications included pulmonary infection, subcutaneous hydrops, dysphagia and choking, facial numbness, abducens paralysis, and intracranial infection (ICI). Fifteen cases received postoperative adjuvant radiotherapy. Seven cases showed recurrence: two with PR, four with STR, and one with GTR. Six cases received reoperation or radiotherapy after tumor progression, and one untreated patient died 5 months after tumor recurrence. The extent of tumor resection (HR 21.74, 95% CI 1.25-376.6, P = 0.03) and pathological grading (HR 131.99, 95% CI 4.05-4300.5, P = 0.006) were associated with improved OS. We presented our experience in the treatment of intracranial chondrosarcoma at three centers in the past 12 years. Intracranial chondrosarcoma lacked typical imaging features and are difficult to differentiate from other skull base lesions. Maximum extent of tumor resection with minimal injury to neurological function remains the most important treatment strategy. The extent of surgical resection and pathological grading were found to be predictors for OS.

Functional and oncological outcome of petroclival chondrosarcoma operated on through an extradural anterior petrosectomy approach. A single center experience

BACKGROUND

Management of skull base chondrosarcoma (SBC) remains challenging due to its deep location and complex growth pattern. Non-total resection and postoperative residual mass are common features, with controversy regarding the need to offer systematic postoperative radiation therapy or additional surgery.

METHODS

A single-center retrospective cohort study was conducted on 10 consecutive patients harboring petroclival chondrosarcomas that were operated on between May 2007 and March 2019. After resection, the patients were allocated to a wait-and-rescan policy.

RESULTS

Patients were operated on through an extradural anterior petrosectomy (EAP). Subtotal tumor resection was achieved in all patients. The mean duration of follow-up was 70 months (range 25-137/median 67 months). Clinical outcomes dramatically improved in three (30%) patients, while five patients retained preoperative cranial nerve (CN) disturbances after surgery (50%). Two patients reported transient postoperative worsening of their symptoms (20%). All of the postoperative CN new deficits improved within one year, except in one patient who showed permanent facial nerve palsy. The preoperative median Karnofsky Performance Scale (KPS) score was 80 (range 70-100), and then it became 90 (range 70-100) postoperatively. Patients harboring a tumor residue were included in a wait-and-rescan policy. With this regimen, tumor control was obtained in seven patients (70% of cases until the last follow-up). Three patients (30%) showed progression of the residual; two of them were treated with adjuvant therapy, while an extra cranial growth residue was observed in the third.

CONCLUSION

Optimal and reasonable surgical resection of petroclival chondrosarcomas could be achieved with good to excellent functional outcomes through an EAP. In spite of a significant percentage of regrowth, only one patient required additional salvage surgery.

Outcomes of Gamma Knife radiosurgery for skull base chondrosarcomas: a multi-institutional retrospective study

OBJECTIVE

Radiotherapy has an essential role in the management of skull base chondrosarcomas (SBCs) after resection. This multi-institutional study evaluated the outcomes of Gamma Knife radiosurgery (GKRS) for histopathologically proven SBCs.

METHODS

Data of patients who underwent GKRS for SBCs at Gamma Knife centers in Japan were retrospectively collected. Patients without a histopathological diagnosis and those who had intracranial metastases from extracranial chondrosarcomas were excluded. Histologically, grade III and some nonconventional variants were identified as aggressive types. The cumulative local control rates (LCRs) and disease-specific survival (DSS) rates were calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method. Factors potentially affecting the LCR were evaluated using the Cox proportional hazards model for bivariate and multivariate analyses. The incidence of radiation-induced adverse effects (RAEs) was calculated as crude rates, and factors associated with RAEs were examined using Fisher's exact test.

RESULTS

Fifty-one patients were enrolled, with a median age of 38 years. Thirty patients (59%) were treated with upfront GKRS for residual SBCs after resection (n = 27) or biopsy (n = 3), and 21 (41%) underwent GKRS as a salvage treatment for recurrence. The median tumor volume was 8 cm3. The overall LCRs were 87% at 3 years, 78% at 5 years, and 67% at 10 years after GKRS. A better LCR was associated with a higher prescription dose (p = 0.039) and no history of repeated recurrence before GKRS (p = 0.024). The LCRs among patients with the nonaggressive histological type and treatment with ≥ 16 Gy were 88% at 3 years, 83% at 5 years, and 83% at 10 years. The overall survival rates after GKRS were 96% at 5 years and 83% at 10 years. Although RAEs were observed in 3 patients (6%), no severe RAEs with Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events grade 3 or higher were identified. No significant factor was associated with RAEs.

CONCLUSIONS

GKRS for SBCs has a favorably low risk of RAEs and could be a reasonable therapeutic option for SBC in multimodality management. A sufficient GKRS prescription dose is necessary for higher LCRs. Histological grading and subtype evaluations are important for excluding exceptional SBCs. Patients with conventional SBCs have a long life expectancy and should be observed for life after treatment.

MRI-Based Radiomics Differentiates Skull Base Chordoma and Chondrosarcoma: A Preliminary Study

Simple Summary

In this study, we created a novel MRI-based machine learning model to differentiate skull base chordoma and chondrosarcoma with multiparametric signatures. While these tumors share common radiographic characteristics, clinical behavior is distinct. Therefore, distinguishing these tumors before initial surgical intervention would be useful, potentially impacting the surgical strategy. Although there are some limitations, such as the risk of overfitting and the lack of an extramural cohort for truly independent final validation, our machine learning model distinguishing chordoma from chondrosarcoma yielded superior diagnostic accuracy to that achieved by 20 board-certified neurosurgeons.

Abstract

Chordoma and chondrosarcoma share common radiographic characteristics yet are distinct clinically. A radiomic machine learning model differentiating these tumors preoperatively would help plan surgery. MR images were acquired from 57 consecutive patients with chordoma (N = 32) or chondrosarcoma (N = 25) treated at the University of Tokyo Hospital between September 2012 and February 2020. Preoperative T1-weighted images with gadolinium enhancement (GdT1) and T2-weighted images were analyzed. Datasets from the first 47 cases were used for model creation, and those from the subsequent 10 cases were used for validation. Feature extraction was performed semi-automatically, and 2438 features were obtained per image sequence. Machine learning models with logistic regression and a support vector machine were created. The model with the highest accuracy incorporated seven features extracted from GdT1 in the logistic regression. The average area under the curve was 0.93 ± 0.06, and accuracy was 0.90 (9/10) in the validation dataset. The same validation dataset was assessed by 20 board-certified neurosurgeons. Diagnostic accuracy ranged from 0.50 to 0.80 (median 0.60, 95% confidence interval 0.60 ± 0.06%), which was inferior to that of the machine learning model (p = 0.03), although there are some limitations, such as the risk of overfitting and the lack of an extramural cohort for truly independent final validation. In summary, we created a novel MRI-based machine learning model to differentiate skull base chordoma and chondrosarcoma from multiparametric signatures.

Primary Skull Base Chondrosarcomas: A Systematic Review

Simple Summary

Primary skull base chondrosarcomas (SBCs) may carry significant tumor-burden by causing severe cranial nerve neuropathies. Current treatment strategies mainly focus on surgical resection and radiotherapy protocols, with a wide range of findings in terms of efficacy and safety. The aim of our systematic review was to comprehensively analyze the current literature on primary SBCs, describing clinical and radiological characteristics, available management strategies, treatment outcomes, and prognoses. We found that most primary SBCs show benign slow-growing patterns but may cause neurological deficits by compressing critical neurovascular structures. Open surgical approaches favor maximal resection with acceptable complication rates, but only a few studies reported the use of newer endoscopic approaches. Proton-based, photon-based, and carbon-based radiotherapy protocols may also allow safe and effective local tumor control as adjuvant treatments or stand-alone strategies in patients not eligible to undergo surgery. Overall, primary SBCs’ prognoses proved to be favorable and comparable to benign skull base neoplasms.

Abstract

Background: Primary skull base chondrosarcomas (SBCs) can severely affect patients’ quality of life. Surgical-resection and radiotherapy are feasible but may cause debilitating complications. We systematically reviewed the literature on primary SBCs. Methods: PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, Web-of-Science, and Cochrane were searched following the PRISMA guidelines to include studies of patients with primary SBCs. Clinical characteristics, management strategies, and treatment outcomes were analyzed. Results: We included 33 studies comprising 1307 patients. Primary SBCs mostly involved the middle-fossa (72.7%), infiltrating the cavernous-sinus in 42.4% of patients. Cranial-neuropathies were reported in 810 patients (62%). Surgical-resection (93.3%) was preferred over biopsy (6.6%). The most frequent open surgical approaches were frontotemporal-orbitozygomatic (17.6%) and pterional (11.9%), and 111 patients (21.3%) underwent endoscopic-endonasal resection. Post-surgical cerebrospinal-fluid leaks occurred in 36 patients (6.5%). Radiotherapy was delivered in 1018 patients (77.9%): photon-based (41.4%), proton-based (64.2%), and carbon-based (13.1%). Severe post-radiotherapy complications, mostly hypopituitarism (15.4%) and hearing loss (7.1%) were experienced by 251 patients (30.7%). Post-treatment symptom-improvement (46.7%) and reduced/stable tumor volumes (85.4%) showed no differences based on radiotherapy-protocols (p = 0.165; p = 0.062). Median follow-up was 67-months (range, 0.1–376). SBCs recurrences were reported in 211 cases (16.1%). The 5-year and 10-year progression-free survival rates were 84.3% and 67.4%, and overall survival rates were 94% and 84%. Conclusion: Surgical-resection and radiotherapy are effective treatments in primary SBCs, with acceptable complication rates and favorable local tumor control.

Determinants of Survival in Skull Base Chondrosarcoma: A National Cancer Database Study

OBJECTIVE

Chondrosarcomas of the skull base are rare tumors most commonly treated surgically with or without adjuvant radiation therapy. Using the National Cancer Database (NCDB), we analyzed overall survival (OS), treatment modalities, and prognosticators.

METHODS

The NCDB was queried for all cases of histologically confirmed skull base chondrosarcoma treated between 2004 and 2015, excluding patients with more than 1 malignant tumor, on palliative care, receiving unrelated concurrent treatments, or having less than 1 month of follow-up. The χ² test for categorical variables, Cox proportional hazards models, and Kaplan-Meier log-rank analysis were used to test associations with the use of adjuvant radiation, OS, and survival time.

RESULTS

A total of 498 patients with skull base chondrosarcoma were identified in the NCDB. Of them, 224 (45.0%) and 198 (39.8%) were treated with either surgery alone or surgery with adjuvant radiation therapy, respectively. Patients more likely to undergo surgery with adjuvant radiation had higher tumor grade (P = 0.008), later year of diagnosis (P = 0.002), positive surgical margins (P < 0.001), and treatment at an academic institution (P = 0.02). Patient, tumor, and socioeconomic factors associated with worse OS on multivariate analysis included the Charlson/Deyo Comorbidity Score ≥2 (P = 0.017), as well as clear cell (P = 0.02) and dedifferentiated (P = 0.006) histology. Age, tumor grade, tumor size, treatment modality, insurance status, facility type, and urban/rural population did not show a statistically significant impact on OS.

CONCLUSION

The mainstay of treatment for skull base chondrosarcoma is surgery, with consideration of adjuvant radiation. This study demonstrated worse overall survival associated with more frail patients and aggressive histology types. It is important to consider these factors when planning the clinical management of these patients.

Giant Ossified Clival Chondrosarcoma Resection: 2-Dimensional Operative Video

Chondrosarcomas are a spectrum of tumors with variable clinical behavior, histologically classified as grades I, II, and III.1 Maximal surgical resection with adjuvant radiation is the gold standard for grade III malignant tumors.2,3 Lower-grade skull base chondrosarcomas have a slow progressive local growth pattern with an overall benign profile.1,4 In these grade I and II tumors, radical resection can be sufficient in achieving long-term control of the disease without the need for adjuvant therapy, thus avoiding the long-term side effects of irradiation in relatively young patients.4,5 As a slow-growing tumor, skull base chondrosarcoma might reach a giant size with progressive neurological deficits prior to diagnosis. In these cases, to achieve maximal resection, skull base approaches tailored to the patient's anatomy are essential.4,6 Cranial approach is frequently needed due to the calcified nature of part of the tumor that is not amenable to resection through the endonasal approach. The endoscope is extremely helpful combined with the microscopic resection. We demonstrate these techniques through in the surgery of a 39-yr-old female who presented with progressive neurological deficits from a giant ossified chondrosarcoma and underwent a combined petrosal approach for the resection of her tumor. A postoperative small enhancement remained stable on the 4-yr follow-up exam. The pathology confirmed grade II chondrosarcoma, with the patient recovering from her neurological deficit except the third nerve. The patient consented to the surgery and publication of images.  Image at 1:36 reprinted with permission from Al-Mefty O, Operative Atlas of Meningiomas. Vol 1, ©LWW, 1998.

Determinants of survival in sinonasal and skull base chondrosarcoma: An analysis of the National Cancer Database

BACKGROUND

Chondrosarcomas are rare, malignant chondroid tumors that can occur in the sinonasal and skull base regions. Surgery is a mainstay of treatment, but complete resection can be challenging because of the close proximity of critical neurovascular structures. Because of their rarity and relatively indolent nature, optimal treatment regimens are not established. Our objective was to assess determinants of survival for sinonasal and skull base chondrosarcomas utilizing the National Cancer Database (NCDB).

METHODS

The NCDB (2004-2017) was queried for cases of sinonasal and skull base chondrosarcoma. Multivariate hazard regression modeling was used to identify significant predictors of 60-month and 120-month overall survival (OS).

RESULTS

Seven hundred thirty-six cases met inclusion criteria. OS for all treatment types was 84.7% [SE±0.02] at 60 months and 75.6% [SE±0.02] at 120 months. Surgery with or without adjuvant treatment was found to associate with highest OS at 60 and 120 months. For patients receiving adjuvant radiation during treatment, proton therapy had significantly better OS at 60 months (95.4% [SE±0.03] vs 82.3% [SE±0.03], -²  = 5.27; p = 0.02) and 120 months (85.1% [SE±0.08] vs 72.8% [SE±0.05], -²  = 4.11; p = 0.04) compared with conventional external beam. After adjustment for primary site, multivariate Cox regression modeling (n = 561) identified cofactors significantly associated with variation in mortality risk at 60 and 120 months, including age, Charlson-Deyo total score ≥ 3, insurance provision status, and tumor grade.

CONCLUSIONS

Sinonasal and skull base chondrosarcoma are primarily treated with surgery with favorable OS. Adjuvant treatment may be required and proton radiation was associated with improved 60-month and 120-month survival compared with conventional radiation.

Long-term outcomes of grade I/II skull base chondrosarcoma: an insight into the role of surgery and upfront radiotherapy

PURPOSE

To clarify the need for post-operative radiation treatment in skull base chondrosarcomas (SBCs).

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of patients with grade I or II SBC. Patients were divided according to post-surgical treatment strategies: (A) planned upfront radiotherapy and (B) watchful waiting. Tumor control and survival were compared between the treatment groups. The median follow-up after resection was 105 months (range, 9-376).

RESULTS

Thirty-two patients (Grade 1, n = 16; Grade 2, n = 16) were included. The most frequent location was petroclival (21, 64%). A gross total resection (GTR) was achieved in 11 patients (34%). Fourteen (44%) underwent upfront radiotherapy (group A) whereas 18 (56%) were followed with serial MRI alone (group B). The tumor control rate for the entire group was 77% and 69% at 10- and 15-year, respectively. Upfront radiotherapy (P = 0.25), extent of resection (P = 0.11) or tumor grade (P = 0.83) did not affect tumor control. The majority of Group B patients with recurrent tumors (5/7) obtained tumor control with repeat resection (n = 2), salvage radiotherapy (n = 2), or a combination of both (n = 1). The 10-year disease-specific survival was 95% with no difference between the group A and B (P = 0.50).

CONCLUSION

For patients with grade I/II SBC, a reasonable strategy is deferral of radiotherapy after maximum safe resection until tumor progression or recurrence. At that time, most patients can be successfully managed with salvage radiotherapy or surgery. Late recurrences may occur, and life-long follow-up is advisable.

A preoperative risk classifier that predicts tumor progression in patients with cranial base chondrosarcomas

OBJECTIVE

The authors conducted a study to identify clinical features of cranial base chondrosarcomas that will predict tumor progression after resection.

METHODS

The authors performed a retrospective study at a tertiary referral cranial base center. Patients who underwent resection of cranial base chondrosarcomas between January 2004 and December 2018 were followed longitudinally. The main outcome measure was progression-free survival (PFS).

RESULTS

A total of 41 patients were treated for histopathologically proven "conventional" cranial base chondrosarcomas during the study period, and the median PFS was 123 months for the cohort. Univariate analysis was performed on clinical, anatomical, and radiographic parameters collected for each patient. Features that were statistically significant were fed into a multivariate regression model, which revealed two independent predictors of PFS: patient age and encasement of 3-4 major arteries (> 25% of the vessel wall surrounded by tumor). Using these two variables of age and multiple arterial vessel encasement, the authors generated a risk stratification model using a simple point system to predict PFS in patients with cranial base chondrosarcomas. Based on these two factors known preoperatively, this model could stratify patients into high-risk (10% of patients), intermediate-risk (68% of patients), and low-risk (22% of patients) subgroups corresponding to dramatically distinct median PFS (1.8 years, 10.2 years, and no progression, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with cranial base chondrosarcomas, age and artery encasement are variables known preoperatively that can powerfully predict tumor progression, define operative goals, and aid in selecting postoperative adjuvant therapy.

Chondrosarcoma of the Skull Base: A Case Study and Literature Review

Chondrosarcomas (CSs) are rare malignant tumors composed of cells derived from the transformed chondrocytes. Only 2% of the total cases of CS are found at the skull base, thus representing a 0.1-0.2% prevalence. We present the case of a patient with CS at the middle cranial fossa who was admitted for surgery to the Burdenko National Medical Research Center of Neurosurgery. In addition, we engage in a review of the literature to discuss the current approaches to the diagnostics and surgery of CS and delve deep into its embryo- and oncogenesis.

Advances in the management of primary bone sarcomas of the skull base

Skull base primary malignancies represent a heterogeneous group of histologic diagnoses and sarcomas of the skull base are specific malignant tumors that arise from mesenchymal cells and can be classified by site of origin into bony and soft tissue sarcomas. The most common bony sarcomas include: chondrosarcoma, osteosarcoma, chordoma, Ewing's sarcoma. Given the relative rarity of each histologic diagnosis, especially in the skull base, there is limited published data to guide the management of patients with skull base sarcomas. An electronic search of the literature was performed to obtain key publications in the management of bony sarcomas of the skull base published within the last decade. This article is thus a review of the multi-disciplinary management principles of primary bony sarcomas of the skull base. Of note, there have been several recent advancements in the realm of skull base sarcoma management that have resulted in improved survival. These include advances in: imaging and diagnostic techniques, surgical techniques that incorporate oncologic surgical principles, conformal radiation paradigms and targeted systemic therapies. Early access to coordinated multi-disciplinary subspecialty care immediately at suspicion of diagnosis has further improved outcomes. There are several ongoing trials in the realms of radiation therapy and systemic therapy that will hopefully provide further insight about the optimal management of bony sarcomas of the skull base.

Postoperative Radiation Therapy in Patients with Extracranial Chondrosarcoma: A Joint Study of the French Sarcoma Group and Rare Cancer Network

PURPOSE

Postoperative radiation therapy (poRT) of intracranial/skull base chondrosarcomas (CHSs) is standard treatment. However, consensus is lacking for poRT in extracranial CHS (eCHS) owing to their easier resectability and intrinsic radioresistance. We assessed the practice and efficacy of poRT in eCHS.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This multicentric retrospective study of the French Sarcoma Group/Rare Cancer Network included patients with eCHS who were operated on between 1985 and 2015. Inverse propensity score weighting (IPTW) was used to minimize poRT allocation biases.

RESULTS

Of 182 patients, 60.4% had bone and 39.6% had soft-tissue eCHS. eCHS were of conventional (31.9%), myxoid (28.6%; 41 extraskeletal, 11 skeletal), mesenchymal (9.9%), or other subtypes. En-bloc surgery with complete resection was performed in 52.6% and poRT in 36.8% of patients (median dose, 54 Gy). Irradiated patients had unfavorable initial characteristics, with higher grade and incomplete resection. Median follow-up time was 61 months. Five-year incidence of local relapse was 10% with poRT versus 21.6% without (P = .050). Using the IPTW method, poRT reduced the local relapse risk (hazard ratio, 0.27; 95% confidence interval, 0.14-0.52; P < .001). Five-year disease-free survival (DFS) was 71.8% with poRT and 64.2% without (P = .680). Using the IPTW method, poRT improved DFS (hazard ratio, 0.51; 95% confidence interval, 0.30-0.85; P = .010). The benefit of poRT on local relapse and DFS was confirmed after exclusion of the extraskeletal subtype. There was no difference in overall survival. Prognostic factors of poorer DFS in multivariate analysis were deeper location, higher grade, incomplete resection, and no poRT.

CONCLUSIONS

poRT should be offered in patients with eCHS and high-grade or incomplete resection, regardless of the histologic subtype.

Clinical applications of proton and carbon ion therapy

Treatment of cancer patients with charged particles like proton and carbon ions landmarks a new era in high-precision medicine. This review aims to summarize the physical and biological advantages of charged particle beams over conventional photon irradiation, presents some highlights in the treatment of selected tumor entities, and gives an update on previous and ongoing clinical trials.

Nasal Chondrosarcoma of the Lower Lateral Cartilage

Head and neck chondrosarcomas are incredibly rare with documented cases arising from skull base, maxilla, larynx, and nasal septum. We present the first reported case of chondrosarcoma arising from the lower lateral cartilage of the nose treated with surgical resection and primary reconstruction.