Injuries and concussions among young children, ages 5-11, playing sports in recreational leagues in Florida

Epidemiology of adverse events related to sports among community people: a scoping review

OBJECTIVES

Numerous reports have described injuries and illnesses in competitive athletes, but studies on leisure-time physical activity and associated adverse events in the general population have not been adequately reviewed. This study aimed to summarise the previous findings on this topic.

DESIGN

Scoping review.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed and Ichushi-Web for articles in English and Japanese, respectively (13 April 2023).

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES

Articles on adverse events related to sports performed by 'individuals and groups active in the community' were included, whereas those on elite athletes, exercise therapy and rehabilitation, and school sports were excluded. Terms related to physical activity, exercise, sports and adverse events were used for the search strategies.

RESULTS

The literature search yielded 67 eligible articles. Most articles were from the USA, Japan and Australia. Running, scuba diving, rugby and soccer were the most commonly reported sports. Adults were the most common age category in the samples. The most commonly reported adverse events were injuries; only 10 articles reported diseases. 13 longitudinal studies reported the frequency of adverse events based on the number of events/participants×exposure.

CONCLUSION

Adverse events such as sports trauma, disability and certain diseases occur sometimes during sporting activities by residents; however, the articles identified in this review showed biases related to the countries and regions where they were published and the sports disciplines and types of adverse events reported, and articles reporting the frequency of adverse events were also limited. This highlights the need for more high-quality observational studies on diverse populations in the future.

Multidomain Predictors of Protracted Recovery following Concussion among 5- to 9-Year-Old Patients: A Preliminary Study

OBJECTIVE

To determine which components from a multidomain assessment best predict protracted recovery in pediatric patients with a concussion.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective cohort of patients aged 5-9 years who presented within 21 days of concussion to a specialty clinic were categorized into normal (≤30 days) and protracted (>30 days) recovery. Participants provided demographic and medical history information, and completed the Child Sport Concussion Assessment Tool-5 symptom report and balance assessment, the Vestibular/Ocular Motor Screen-Child (VOMS-C), and the Pediatric Immediate Post-concussion Assessment and Cognitive Testing. Univariate logistic regressions (LR) were used to inform a follow-up forward stepwise LR to identify the best predictors of protracted recovery. Receiver operating characteristic analysis of the area under the curve (AUC) was used to identify which predictors retained from the LR model best discriminated recovery.

RESULTS

The final sample included 68 patients (7.52 ± 2.3 years; 56% male), 36 (52.9%) with normal and 32 (47.1%) with protracted recovery. Results of the LR to identify protracted recovery were significant (P < .001) and accounted for 39% of the variance. The model accurately classified 78% of patients, with days to first clinic visit (OR, 1.2; 95% CI, 1.1-1.4; P = .003) and positive VOMS-C findings (OR, 8.32; 95% CI, 2.4-28.8; P < .001) as significant predictors. A receiver operating characteristic analysis of the AUC of this 2-factor model discriminated protracted from normal recovery (AUC, 0.82; 95% CI, 0.71-0.92; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Days to first clinic visit and positive findings on the VOMS-C were the most robust predictors of protracted recovery after concussion in young pediatric patients.

Discriminating Young Children with Concussion in an Outpatient Specialty Clinic from Healthy Controls Using the Child SCAT5

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the clinical utility of the Child SCAT5 in an outpatient specialty clinic sample of children ages 5-9.

STUDY DESIGN

Ninety-six children within 30 days of a concussion (M=8.90+5.78 days) and 43 age and sex-matched healthy controls completed the Child SCAT5, including balance items, cognitive screening, parent and child symptom and severity reports, as well as each individual parent- and child-rated symptom severity (0-3). A series of receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves with area under the curve (AUC) analysis were performed to evaluate the clinical utility of the Child SCAT5 components to discriminate concussion.

RESULTS

The AUC values were non-discriminate for cognitive screening (.32) and poor for balance (.61) items. The AUC values were acceptable for parent-reported symptoms worsening after physical activity (.73) and mental activity (.72). The AUCs for symptom severity items were excellent for parent (.89) and child-reported (.81) headaches, and were acceptable for parent-reported tired a lot (.75), and both parent (.72) and child-reported (.72) tired easily.

CONCLUSION

With the exception of parent and child-reported symptoms, the Child SCAT5 provides limited clinical utility for evaluating concussion in children aged 5-9 years seen at an outpatient concussion specialty clinic. The cognitive screening and balance testing items were not useful in discriminating concussion. Parent and child-reported headache were the only Child SCAT5 items with excellent ability to differentiate concussion from controls in the age group.

Lessons in Linkage: combining administrative data using deterministic linkage for surveillance of sports and recreation injuries in Florida, United States

Objectives

Previous and ongoing epidemiological surveillance of sports and recreation injuries (SRI) has been cross-sectional in nature, utilised a subset of injuries based on athletic trainer availability, or focused on elite and professional athletes. In the United States, surveillance is often prohibitively expensive and not well funded by national organisations or agencies, except for the case of some professional and elite sports. This paper details the methodology, barriers, and successes of using deterministic linkage to combine emergency department and hospitalisation data with a single identifier for use in surveilling sports injuries for persons aged 5 to 18 years.

Design

Data linkage of a population cohort.

Methods

We performed deterministic linkage of administrative emergency department and hospitalisation data from the state of Florida in the US. Data was acquired from the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration. With limited identifiers available due to privacy, we combined data across multiple years using a near universal identifier. We identified sport and recreation injuries using a modified External Cause of Injury Morbidity Matrix and ICD codes across all possible diagnoses. Finally, we obtained descriptive statistics of records that were successfully linked and those that were not to assess similarities between the groups.

Results

We found 384,731 visits for SRI over a seven-year period. We were able to link approximately 70% of the records using a single identifier. There were statistically significant differences by age, sex, payer, and race/ethnicity for the records that were linked compared to the records that were not linked.

Conclusions

This study is significant because while similar methods have been used to examine other conditions (e.g. asthma), few have linked multiple types of administrative data especially with nearly no identifiers to examine sports and recreation injuries. This method was found useful to identify injuries over time for the same individuals seeking care in emergency departments, or in hospital inpatient settings, though future work will need to address the limitations of this method. If we expect to move health surveillance forward as budgets for it become even more limited, we must develop and improve methods to do it with fewer resources, including using data that has great limitations.

An epidemiologic comparison of acute and overuse injuries in high school sports

Background

Acute and overuse injuries affect millions of high school athletes annually and a better understanding of differences between these injuries is needed to help guide prevention, treatment, and rehabilitation strategies. This study compares acute and overuse injuries using a nationally representative sample of high school athletes.

Methods

Injuries among United States high school athletes participating in 5 boys’ sports (football, soccer, basketball, wrestling, baseball) and 4 girls’ sports (soccer, volleyball, basketball, softball) reported in the High School RIO™ surveillance system during the 2006-07 through 2018-19 school years were classified as acute or overuse. National estimates and injury rates were calculated.

Results

Of 17 434 646 estimated injuries, 92.0 % were acute and 8.0 % were overuse. The acute injury rate was higher than the overuse injury rate among both male (Rate Ratio [RR] 16.38, 95 % CI: 15.70–17.10) and female (RR 8.14, 95 % CI: 7.71–8.60) athletes. The overuse injury rate per 10,000 athlete exposures among female athletes (1.8) was slightly higher than among males (1.4). The rate of acute injury compared with the rate of overuse injury was higher during competition (RR 32.00, 95 % CI: 29.93–34.22) than practice (RR 7.19, 95 % CI: 6.91–7.47). Boys’ football contributed the most acute (42.1 %) and overuse (23.7 %) injuries among the 9 sports. Among female sports, girls’ soccer contributed the most acute (15.6 % of all acute injuries) and overuse (19.4 % of all overuse injuries) injuries. The lower extremity was most commonly injured in acute (48.9 %) and overuse (65.9 %) injuries. Ligament sprain (31.7 %) and concussion (21.0 %) were the most common acute injury diagnoses, while muscle strain (23.3 %) and tendonitis (23.2 %) were the most common overuse injury diagnoses. Compared with acute injuries, overuse injuries were more likely to result in time loss from sports participation of < 1 week among both boys and girls and across most sports. Acute injuries were more likely than overuse injuries to cause a time loss of 1–3 weeks or medical disqualification from sports participation.

Conclusions

Acute and overuse injuries display many differences that provide opportunities for data-informed athlete preparation, treatment, and rehabilitation, which may reduce injuries and improve injury outcomes in high school athletics.