Efficacy, safety and complications of autologous fat grafting to the eyelids and periorbital area: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Correction of Infraorbital Dark Circles Using Autologous Adipose-Derived Collagen Filler: A Novel Regenerative Option

BACKGROUND

Numerous intrinsic and extrinsic factors, notably the aging process, contribute to the development of infraorbital dark circles. These features, commonly associated with old age and fatigue, are caused by a disruption of dermal melanin and impairment of skin barrier function. Common aesthetic concerns affecting patients with infraorbital dark circles are primarily owing to lean and translucent lower eyelid skin overlying the orbicularis oculi muscle. This study aimed to present a novel technique for correcting infraorbital dark circles utilizing an adipose-derived extracellular matrix concentrate-adipose collagen fragment (ACF)-to correct infraorbital dark circles.

METHODS

Female patients (n = 94) aged 20-38 who presented infraorbital dark circles were enrolled to assess the efficacy of this technique for an eight-month follow-up. Following intradermal injections with ACF filler, the clinical outcome was determined by responses to GAIS and patient satisfaction surveys. Statistical analysis was performed with the one-way ANOVA test, and a p value of < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

Patients (n = 92) completed a single treatment session and underwent an eight-month follow-up. Eighty patients (86%) reported being "highly satisfied" or "satisfied" with the outcome and responded that the technique resulted in brighter, tighter, and smoother infraorbital skin. Over 97% of patients were rated as "improved," "much improved" and "Very much improved" throughout the follow-up on GAIS by three independent surgeons (p < 0.05). The statistical analyses demonstrated the percentage differences among groups are highly significant (p < 0.0001). No irregularity or lump was observed during the follow-up. Two patients were excluded from the study due to having undergone cosmetic eyelid surgery.

CONCLUSION

Intradermal ACF filler represents a novel approach to addressing infraorbital dark circles and yields significantly high patient satisfaction. ACF fillers provide a degree of bio-stimulation, and adipose-derived concentrate is a natural filler with regenerative effects used in periorbital rejuvenation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

A Simple Procedure of Fascia-Fat Grafting and Blepharoplasty as a Single-Stage Procedure for the Correction of Sunken Eyelids in Vietnamese Population

PURPOSES

Upper sunken eyelids, which are characterized by the hollowness of the upper eyelids, often cause a poor aesthetic appearance. Herein, we present a simplified technique using fascia-fat grafts for volume augmentation combined with blepharoplasty as a single-stage procedure.

METHODS

From January 2021 to December 2021, 30 patients with sunken eyelids visiting our clinic for hollow eyelid treatment underwent a fascia-fat grafting derived from the inguinal crease combined with simultaneous eyelid reconstruction. A modified classification of sunken eyelids that was more suitable for the Asian population was proposed.

RESULTS

Postoperatively, edema and ptosis were transient and addressed thanks to proper massage and compresses. Two cases had scar fibers leading to a slight tension of upper eyelids at 6-month follow-up. This event was addressed by triamcinolone acetonide injections at 4-6-week intervals with satisfactory results. The orbital volume of all patients was satisfying and stable up to 12 months after the surgery. The satisfaction rate was 100% and 88.8% in group 1 and group 2, respectively, at 12-month follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Fascia-fat grafting combined with blepharoplasty as a single-stage procedure was a simplified method that did not require varied types of surgical tools but brought satisfactory results. This method facilitated the routine procedure and eased surgeons in the clinical practices.

Fat or fillers: The dilemma in eyelid surgery

The aging of the periocular region has always aroused great interest. A fresh, young, and attractive sight determined an ever-greater attention to surgical and non-surgical techniques to obtain this result. In particular, the change in the concept of a young look, considered then "full", led to the increasing use of surgical (fat grafting) or medical (hyaluronic acid) filling techniques. Eyelid rejuvenation became increasingly popular in the field of cosmetic treatments, with a focus on achieving a youthful and refreshed appearance. Among the various techniques available, the choice between using fat grafting or fillers presented a clinical dilemma. In particular, what surgery considered of fundamental importance was a long-lasting result over time. On the other hand, aesthetic medicine considered it fundamental not to have to resort to invasive treatments. But what was the reality? Was there one path better than the other, and above all, was there a better path for patients? The minireview aims to explore the physiopathology, diagnosis, treatment options, prognosis, and future studies regarding this dilemma. We analyzed the literature produced in the last 20 years comparing the two techniques. Current literature reveals advancements in biomaterials, stem cell research and tissue engineering held promise for further enhancing the field of eyelid rejuvenation. The choice between fat grafting and fillers in eyelid cosmetic treatments presented a clinical dilemma. Understanding physiopathology, accurately diagnosing eyelid aging, exploring treatment options, assessing prognosis, and conducting future studies were essential for providing optimal care to patients seeking eyelid rejuvenation.

Quantitative Assessment of Periocular Autologous Fat Transfer Survival Using 3D Stereophotogrammetric Imaging

PURPOSE

To assess periocular autologous fat transfer (AFT) survival by assessment of volume change with sequential 3D VECTRA imaging.

OBJECTIVE

Little is known about the patterns of graft survival of AFT in the periorbital region, especially in cases involving prior radiotherapy or trauma. The aim of this pilot study was to characterize fat survival following AFT in patients with a broad range of clinical indications, with and without a history of prior radiotherapy, for both periocular and orbital AFT, and in a subgroup of patients with an anophthalmic socket.

METHOD

A single-institution, prospective cohort study involving 18 applications of AFT for volume augmentation in the periocular and orbital area. All patients had sequential 3D VECTRA photographs following a validated standardized protocol. Patient demographics, including gender, age, ethnicity, underlying diagnosis, and volume of fat injected, were also collected.

RESULTS

In total 13 patients were enrolled, 9 female (69.2%) and 4 male (31.0%). Mean age at the time of surgery was 47.8 years. Patients had volume deficiency secondary to a variety of causes; the most common cause was postenucleation socket syndrome following trauma in 6 patients (46.2%). The mean fat survival volume at the 1-month postoperative point was 70% and 55% by 6 months. AFT conducted with a multiport cannula for fat harvesting use had an initial higher rate of fat reabsorption with ANOVA p = 0.002, however, this was not observed at the later follow-up periods. There was no statistically significant difference in fat survival between abdominal or thigh donor fat sites. There was no statistically significant difference in residual injected volume at the early follow-up period between patients who had prior radiotherapy and those who did not p = 0.8496.

CONCLUSION

AFT is an effective treatment for periorbital volume compromise with an acceptable survival rate in all categories of patients. Complex etiologies such as radiotherapy-related orbital and midface dysgenesis should not be a contraindication for AFT, with no difference in outcomes.

Therapeutic potential of adipose tissue derivatives in skin photoaging

Photoaging, the primary cause of exogenous skin aging and predominantly caused by ultraviolet radiation, is an essential type of skin aging characterized by chronic skin inflammation. Recent studies have shown that oxidative stress, inflammation, skin barrier homeostasis, collagen denaturation and pigmentation are the main contributors to it. As a composite tissue rich in matrix and vascular components, adipose tissue derivatives have been recently gaining attention as potential therapeutic agents for various human diseases with fat-processing technology upgrades. This review analyzes both 'minimally treated' and 'nonminimally treated' fat derivatives to give an overview of the preclinical and clinical relevance of adipose tissue derivatives for antiphotoaging application, highlighting their good clinical prospects as well as discussing their safety and potential risks.

Letter in reply to Letter to the Editor: Fat injection as a valuable tool for lower eyelid retraction management: a retrospective, observational, single blind, case-control study

DEAR EDITOR

We have read Dr Riccardo Fondrini and Colleagues commentary on our paper, and we are grateful for their remarks. We herewith would clarify the critical points mentioned about fat reabsorption and survival, along with the risk of periorbital chronic oedema as per the recorded outcomes in the presented case series. Lastly, we have unfortunately to disagree with the commentary's point related to recommended injection depth as it is mandatory to point out that in our experience the superficial injection of nano-fat is a crucial step for lower eyelid retraction management, otherwise a retraction may persist due to the untreated scar in the anterior lamella, thus missing the therapeutic goal that we aim to achieve.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE V

This journal requires that authors assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, please refer to the Table of Contents or the online Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

Correction of Mild-to-Moderate Sunken Upper Eyelids of Asians with Stromal Vascular Fraction Gel

INTRODUCTION

Fat grafting is an efficient and safe procedure for the correction of upper eyelid sulcus deepening. Stromal vascular fraction (SVF) gel has been proven to be an ideal fat derivative and can be widely used for facial augmentation. We aimed to determine the efficacy of SVF gel for the correction of a mild-to-moderate sunken superior sulcus among Asian patients.

METHODS

Patients with a mild-to-moderate sunken superior sulcus underwent SVF gel grafting of the sunken upper periorbital area. The primary result was the quantitative volume difference in the superior sulcus region before and after grafting. This was evaluated through three-dimensional VECTRA^® imaging. The secondary results included the aesthetic quantitative evaluation results (upper lid area and pretarsal space ratio), global aesthetic improvement scale (GAIS) score, and complications.

RESULTS

Thirty-one patients with mild-to-moderate sunken upper eyelids were included in this study. The average unilateral injected amount was 1.235 mL (± 0.171 mL). The 1-year delta volume was 0.801 ± 0.086 mL, and the effective survival volume was 65.3% (± 6.1%). The median preoperative pretarsal space and upper lid area ratio was 1.010 (± 0.150). The median postoperative pretarsal space and upper lid area ratio at 1 year was 0.159 (± 0.031) (n = 62; P < 0.0001), indicating a significantly reduced sunken appearance. The average GAIS score was 2.174 (± 0.391). All patients were satisfied with their surgical outcomes. The reoperation rate was 12.9%.

CONCLUSIONS

SVF gel is safe and effective for the treatment of a mild-to-moderate sunken superior sulcus and is associated with satisfactory clinical outcomes and short recovery times.

Intraoral Approach to Fat Grafting Based on the Mimetic Muscle Unit

BACKGROUND

Recently, the concepts of anatomic-based fat grafting and mid-facial anatomy have been studied. However, there is no clear consensus on the optimal fat grafting technique. We aimed to introduce a novel intraoral approach to fat grafting based on mid-facial mimetic muscles, wherein a substantial amount of fat was injected into appropriate locations to increase patient satisfaction and decrease the need for additional surgical techniques.

METHODS

Sixty-four Asian women (mean age, 41.2 y) who had undergone fat grafting through the intraoral approach between 2014 and 2019 were enrolled. We sequentially performed the following steps: fat harvesting, centrifugation, and fat injection. All patients were followed at an outpatient clinic for 6 to 12 months. We obtained photographs of their face before and at 3 and 6 months postoperatively and conducted a 5-point scale questionnaire survey at the 2 time points postoperatively to evaluate the satisfaction of patients and surgeons. We divided the mid-facial areas into malar eminence, infraorbital, and nasolabial fold areas and evaluated the following items: volume consistency, softness, irregularity, and overall satisfaction.

RESULTS

Patients reported "satisfactory" for the postoperative results. There were only 2 cases of complication among the 64 cases which resolved spontaneously. The highest and lowest satisfaction were reported for the malar eminence and nasolabial fold areas, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Fat grafting through the intraoral approach based on the mimetic muscle unit is an effective and safe method for mid-facial rejuvenation.

The Postsurgical Clavien–Dindo Classification in Minor Surgery Can Improve Perception and Communication (Investigation on Blepharoplasty)

The postsurgical Clavien–Dindo classification in minor surgery can improve perception and communication (Investigation on Blepharoplasty). Background: Minor surgery lacks a standardized postoperative complication classification. This leads to the presentation of inaccurate postsurgical complication rates and makes comparisons challenging, especially for patients seeking information. This study aims to evaluate a standardized five-step complication grading system (Clavien–Dindo Classification, CDC) on the example of blepharoplasty, which is the most performed minor aesthetic surgery worldwide. Methods: A retrospective observational exploratory study of patients (N = 344) who received a bilateral upper eyelid blepharoplasty under local anesthesia from the same surgical staff was performed. Data were retrieved from the electronic patient record: the CDC grading and the surgeon-reported complications (N = 128) at the first follow-up on day 7. In addition, a telephone survey with patients (N = 261) after 6 months was performed, which consisted of 7 complication-related yes/no questions. Results: Based on the CDC, 41.6% of patients were classified as having no complications, and 58.4% had one. Furthermore, 1 patient (0.3%) received a revision under general anesthesia (CDC IIIb), 18 patients (5.2%) were re-operated under local anesthesia (CDC IIIa), 23 patients (6.7%) required pharmacological intervention (CDC II), and 159 patients (46.2%) had a complication from the normal postoperative course and received supportive treatment (CDC I). Moreover, 90.5% of the mentioned complications accounted for Grade I and II; 94% of the patients subjectively experienced no complications; 51% of patients were pleased with the surgery even though a complication occurred according to the CDC; 34% of complications escaped the awareness of the surgeon. Conclusions: Grade I and II complications occurred frequently. Complications escaped the perception of the patients and surgeons. The classification identifies a wide variety of postsurgical complications and allows a standardized comparison in minor surgery objectively. Potential: The CDC in minor procedures can improve the (institutional) preoperative communication with patients regarding potential postoperative expectations. Furthermore, the classification can be a useful tool to detect complication-related costs, identify insurance-related requests, and support evidence in medicolegal disputes. The example of blepharoplasty can be translated to various other and even less invasive procedures.

Outcomes of Vascularized Versus Nonvascularized Adipofascial Grafts for Parotidectomy Reconstruction

Objectives: Parotidectomy defects can leave patients with considerable functional and cosmetic deformities. We aim to compare the success rates and complications associated with vascularized versus nonvascularized adipofascial grafts for reconstruction, including flap failure, return to surgery, infection, and delay to adjuvant treatment. Methods: Retrospective case series of patients undergoing either adipofascial anterolateral thigh (AFALT) free tissue transfer or free fat transfer (FFT) after parotidectomy from January 2010 to January 2020. Group comparisons and logistic regression were used to determine predictors of outcome measures. Results: Seventy-six patients underwent AFALT reconstruction, and 73 patients underwent FFT reconstruction. Patients treated with AFALT reconstruction had more aggressive tumor characteristics and underwent more complex resections, most commonly radical parotidectomy (n = 55, 72.4%). Postoperative complications at both the donor and recipient sites were more common in the FFT group (N = 20, 27.4% in FFT vs. N = 11, 14.5% in AFALT, odds ratio = 0.45, 95% confidence interval = 0.20-1.02, p = 0.052). Conclusions: Although used in more advanced disease and in a more heavily treated wound bed, the AFALT free flap was safe and associated with fewer infectious complications than that offered by FFT.

Correction of temporal hollowing after pterional craniotomy by autologous fat grafting. A single-center experience

OBJECTIVE

Aesthetic complications following neurosurgical procedures impact patient quality of life and self-perception. Postoperative temporal hollowing is frequently seen after temporal craniotomy, resulting mainly from atrophy of the temporal muscle. Autologous fat grafting is a tailorable method to correct such approach-related sequelae. We herein present our clinical patient series and discuss pearls and pitfalls of this method.

METHODS

In this retrospective single-center study, correction of postoperative temporal hollowing using autologous fat grafting was performed in 16 patients. Temporal tissue thickness ratio was measured using magnetic resonance tomography images to visualize the graft. Patients, plastic surgeons and neurosurgeons evaluated the results independently using the herein presented scale.

RESULTS

The mean interval between the neurosurgical procedure and fat grafting was 62 months. A mean volume of 11.5 ml autologous fat was injected in an average of 2.5 sessions after initial rigotomy. Temporal tissue thickness was significantly augmented at a mean of 2.2 years after the operation (mean 0.71 ± 0.25, range 0.43-1.1; p=0.0214) as compared to the preoperative finding (mean 0.48 ± 0.1, range 0.32-0.6). Patients were more satisfied with the results than were surgeons, reflecting the significant impact of the deformity on patient self-esteem.

CONCLUSIONS

Autologous fat grafting is a valuable method for correcting postoperative temporal hollowing that provides stable results, high patient and surgeon satisfaction and can be tailored to the patient's individual needs. It should not be considered a merely aesthetic operation, but an important rehabilitation step towards restoring the patient's quality of life.

Nanofat: A therapeutic paradigm in regenerative medicine

Adipose tissue is a compact and well-organized tissue containing a heterogeneous cellular population of progenitor cells, including mesenchymal stromal cells. Due to its availability and accessibility, adipose tissue is considered a "stem cell depot." Adipose tissue products possess anti-inflammatory, anti-fibrotic, anti-apoptotic, and immunomodulatory effects. Nanofat, being a compact bundle of stem cells with regenerative and tissue remodeling potential, has potential in translational and regenerative medicine. Considering the wide range of applicability of its reconstructive and regenerative potential, the applications of nanofat can be used in various disciplines. Nanofat behaves on the line of adipose tissue-derived mesenchymal stromal cells. At the site of injury, these stromal cells initiate a site-specific reparative response comprised of remodeling of the extracellular matrix, enhanced and sustained angiogenesis, and immune system modulation. These properties of stromal cells provide a platform for the usage of regenerative medicine principles in curbing various diseases. Details about nanofat, including various preparation methods, characterization, delivery methods, evidence on practical applications, and ethical concerns are included in this review. However, appropriate guidelines and preparation protocols for its optimal use in a wide range of clinical applications have yet to be standardized.