The effects of histone acetylation on estrogen responsiveness in MCF-7 cells

Estrogen-induced chromatin looping changes identify a subset of functional regulatory elements

Transcriptional enhancers can regulate individual or multiple genes through long-range three-dimensional (3D) genome interactions, and these interactions are commonly altered in cancer. Yet, the functional relationship between changes in 3D genome interactions associated with regulatory regions and differential gene expression appears context-dependent. In this study, we used HiChIP to capture changes in 3D genome interactions between active regulatory regions of endometrial cancer cells in response to estrogen treatment and uncovered significant differential long-range interactions strongly enriched for estrogen receptor alpha (ER, also known as ESR1)-bound sites (ERBSs). The ERBSs anchoring differential chromatin loops with either a gene's promoter or distal regions were correlated with larger transcriptional responses to estrogen compared with ERBSs not involved in differential 3D genome interactions. To functionally test this observation, CRISPR-based Enhancer-i was used to deactivate specific ERBSs, which revealed a wide range of effects on the transcriptional response to estrogen. However, these effects are only subtly and not significantly stronger for ERBSs in differential chromatin loops. In addition, we observed an enrichment of 3D genome interactions between the promoters of estrogen-upregulated genes and found that looped promoters can work together cooperatively. Overall, our work reveals that estrogen treatment causes large changes in 3D genome structure in endometrial cancer cells; however, these changes are not required for a regulatory region to contribute to an estrogen transcriptional response.

On the origin of information in epigenetic structures in metazoans

Epigenetic inheritance implies the existence of epigenetic information. Great progress has been made in recent years in understanding the role of the changes in epigenetic structures (methylated DNA, histone acetylation/deacetylation and chromatin remodelling) as well as the role of miRNA (MIR) expression patterns in epigenetic processes. However, as of yet, we do not have a satisfactory understanding of the origin of epigenetic information stored in, and conveyed by, these structures. We do not know whether these structures are the ultimate source of the information or whether they are simply media for storing and transmitting epigenetic information for gene expression from upstream sources to the phenotype. Herein an attempt is made to ascertain the ultimate sources of the epigenetic information they contain and transmit by tracing back the causal chain leading to the changes in epigenetic structures.

Epigenetic regulation of Progesterone Receptor isoforms: from classical models to the sexual brain

Progesterone Receptor is a member of the nuclear receptor superfamily, which regulates several functions in both reproductive and non-reproductive tissues. Progesterone Receptor gene encodes for two main isoforms, A and B, and contains two specific promoters with their respective transcription start sites. The mRNA expression of both isoforms is mainly regulated by estrogens and specifically via the Estrogen Receptor Alpha, in a context specific manner. Furthermore, it has been reported in extensive physiological and pathological models that Progesterone Receptor isoforms regulation is related to the epigenetic state of their respective promoters. Epigenetic regulation of Progesterone Receptor isoforms in the brain is a recent and scarcely explored field in neurosciences. This review focuses on the epigenetic mechanisms involved in Progesterone Receptor regulation, emphasizing the implications for the sexual brain. Future directions for research about this important field are also discussed.

The enhanced antiproliferative response to combined treatment of trichostatin A with raloxifene in MCF-7 breast cancer cells and its relevance to estrogen receptor β expression

Antiestrogen is one type of the endocrine therapeutic agents for estrogen receptor α (ERα)-positive breast cancer. Unfortunately, this treatment alone is insufficient. Here we reported a novel potential anticancer strategy by using histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor to enhance the action of endocrine therapy in ERα-positive breast cancer cell. The well-described HDAC inhibitor, trichostatin A (TSA), and antiestrogen raloxifene were found to, respectively, inhibit E2-induced proliferation of MCF-7 breast cancer cell in a dose-responsive and time-dependent manner. TSA and raloxifene enhanced the antiproliferative activity of each other by promoting cell death via apoptosis and cell cycle arrest. Thus, they displayed better antiproliferative effects in combined treatment than that with either agent alone. The expression level of estrogen receptor β (ERβ) showed a marked increase after TSA or/and raloxifene treatment. Treatments with TSA or/and raloxifene resulting in the up-regulation of ERβ are in accordance with the antiproliferative effects of the two agents. Furthermore, the over-expression of ERβ by adenovirus delivery could inhibit the proliferation of MCF-7 tumor cells and drastically enhanced the antiproliferative effects of TSA and raloxifene. These results demonstrated that the interference of ERβ on the antiproliferative effects of HDAC inhibitor and antiestrogen constitutes a promising approach for breast cancer treatment.

Activating gene expression in mammalian cells with promoter-targeted duplex RNAs

The ability to selectively activate or inhibit gene expression is fundamental to understanding complex cellular systems and developing therapeutics. Recent studies have demonstrated that duplex RNAs complementary to promoters within chromosomal DNA are potent gene silencing agents in mammalian cells. Here we report that chromosome-targeted RNAs also activate gene expression. We have identified multiple duplex RNAs complementary to the progesterone receptor (PR) promoter that increase expression of PR protein and RNA after transfection into cultured T47D or MCF7 human breast cancer cells. Upregulation of PR protein reduced expression of the downstream gene encoding cyclooygenase 2 but did not change concentrations of estrogen receptor, which demonstrates that activating RNAs can predictably manipulate physiologically relevant cellular pathways. Activation decreased over time and was sequence specific. Chromatin immunoprecipitation assays indicated that activation is accompanied by reduced acetylation at histones H3K9 and H3K14 and by increased di- and trimethylation at histone H3K4. These data show that, like proteins, hormones and small molecules, small duplex RNAs interact at promoters and can activate or repress gene expression.

ERalpha and ERbeta expression and transcriptional activity are differentially regulated by HDAC inhibitors

The proliferative action of ERalpha largely accounts for the carcinogenic activity of estrogens. By contrast, recent data show that ERbeta displays tumor-suppressor properties, thus supporting the interest to identify compounds that could increase its activity. Here, we show that histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDI) upregulated ERbeta protein levels, whereas it decreased ERalpha expression. Part of this regulation took place at the mRNA level through a mechanism independent of de novo protein synthesis. In addition, we found that, in various cancer cells, the treatment with different HDI enhanced the ligand-dependent activity of ERbeta more strongly than that of ERalpha. On the other hand, in MDA-MB231 and HeLa cells, the expression of ERs modified the transcriptional response to HDI. The use of deletion mutants of both receptors demonstrated that AF1 domain of the receptors was required. Finally, we show that ERbeta expression led to a dramatic increased in the antiproliferative activity of HDI, which correlated with a modification of the transcription of genes involved in cell cycle control by HDI. Altogether, these data demonstrate that the interference of ERbeta and HDAC on the control of transcription and cell proliferation constitute a promising approach for cancer therapy.

Opposite effects of histone deacetylase inhibitors on glucocorticoid and estrogen signaling in human endometrial Ishikawa cells

Histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi), which have emerged as a new class of anticancer agents, act by modulating expression of genes controlling apoptosis or cell proliferation. Here, we compared the effect of HDACi on transcriptional activation by estrogen or glucocorticoid receptors (ER and GR, respectively), two members of the steroid receptor family with cell growth regulatory properties. Like other transcription factors, steroid receptors modulate histone acetylation on target promoters. Using episomal reporter vectors containing minimal promoters to avoid promoter-specific effects, we observed that long-term (24-h) incubation with HDACi strongly stimulated GR-dependent but markedly repressed ER-dependent signaling in ER+/GR+ human endometrial carcinoma Ishikawa cells. These effects were reproduced on endogenous target genes and required incubation periods with HDACi substantially longer than necessary to increase global histone acetylation. Repression of estrogen signaling was due to direct inhibition of transcription from multiple ERalpha promoters and correlated with decreased histone acetylation of these promoters. In contrast, the strong HDACi stimulation of GR-dependent gene regulation was not accounted for by increased GR expression, but it was mimicked by overexpression of the histone acetyltransferase complex component transcriptional intermediary factor 2. Together, our results demonstrate striking and opposite effects of HDACi on ER and GR signaling that involve regulatory events independent of histone hyperacetylation on receptor target promoters.

Histone deacetylase inhibitors induce differentiation of human endometrial adenocarcinoma cells through up-regulation of glycodelin

Histone reversible acetylation, which is controlled by histone acetyltransferases and deacetylases, plays a fundamental role in gene transcription. Histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACIs), such as trichostatin A (TSA) and suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), have been characterized not only as anticancer drugs, but also as cytodifferentiation-inducing agents. In human endometrium, postovulatory production of progesterone directs estrogen-primed endometrial glandular cells to differentiate and thereby produce a number of unique bioactive substances, including glycodelin, that are critical for implantation at the secretory phase of the menstrual cycle. In this study, we show that TSA and SAHA, belonging to the hydroxamic acid group of HDACIs, can induce the phenotype of a human endometrial adenocarcinoma cell line, Ishikawa (originally derived from the glandular component of the endometrium), to differentiate to closely resemble normal endometrial epithelium in a time- and dose-dependent manner, as determined by morphological changes, synthesis of glycogen, and expression of secretory phase-specific proteins, including glycodelin. The proliferation- and differentiation-modulating effects elicited by TSA and SAHA at their optimal concentrations were comparable or more potent than those exerted by combined treatment with progesterone and estradiol. Furthermore, the gene silencing of glycodelin by small interference RNA resulted in the blockade of HDACI-induced differentiation in Ishikawa cells, suggesting the requirement for glycodelin for endometrial epithelial differentiation. Our results collectively indicate that TSA and SAHA are potent differentiation inducers for endometrial glandular cells, providing a clue for a possible therapeutic strategy to modulate endometrial function by targeting glycodelin.

The expression of endothelial nitric-oxide synthase is controlled by a cell-specific histone code

Expression of endothelial nitric-oxide synthase (eNOS) mRNA is highly restricted to the endothelial cell layer of medium to large sized arterial blood vessels. Here we assessed the chromatin environment of the eNOS gene in expressing and nonexpressing cell types. Within endothelial cells, but not a variety of nonendothelial cells, the nucleosomes that encompassed the eNOS core promoter and proximal downstream coding regions were highly enriched in acetylated histones H3 and H4 and methylated lysine 4 of histone H3. This differentially modified chromatin domain was selectively associated with functionally competent RNA polymerase II complexes. Endothelial cells were particularly enriched in acetylated histone H3 lysine 9, histone H4 lysine 12, and di- and tri-methylated lysine 4 of histone H3 at the core promoter. Histone modifications at this region, which we have previously demonstrated to exhibit cell-specific DNA methylation, were functionally relevant to eNOS expression. Inhibition of histone deacetylase activity by trichostatin A increased acetylation of histones H3 and H4 at the eNOS proximal promoter in nonexpressing cell types and led to increased steady-state eNOS mRNA transcript levels. H3 lysine 4 methylation was also essential for eNOS expression, since treatment of endothelial cells with methylthioadenosine, a known lysine 4 methylation inhibitor, decreased eNOS RNA levels, H3 lysine 4 methylation, and RNA polymerase II loading at the eNOS proximal promoter. Importantly, methylthioadenosine also prevented the trichostatin A-mediated increase in eNOS mRNA transcript levels in nonendothelial cells. Taken together, these findings provide strong evidence that the endothelial cell-specific expression of eNOS is controlled by cell-specific histone modifications.

The interaction of the estrogen receptor with mononucleosomes

To directly activate specific gene expression, the estrogen receptor (ER) must bind to estrogen receptor response elements (EREs) in the context of nucleosomes. In order to investigate the interaction of the ER with mononucleosomes, we developed a mononucleosome gel shift assay. A 164 bp high specific activity [(32)P]probe DNA (32 bp consensus ERE with flanking regions separated by 23 nucleotides from an artificial nucleosome positioning sequence) was prepared. Nuclear extracts from MCF-7 cells or recombinant human ERalpha were incubated with the labeled ERE +/- excess ERE. A retarded band was seen which was completely obliterated with excess ERE, confirming the specificity of binding. This probe was then used to make reconstituted mononucleosomes by sequential dilution of a high salt histone preparation. The nucleosomes were purified by sucrose density gradients and footprinting analysis was performed to demonstrate that the mononucleosomes were rotationally phased as seen by a periodic digestion pattern (10 bp) of the nucleosomes versus ERE. Nucleosomes were incubated with nuclear extracts containing ER or recombinant ERalpha. Dose dependence in the shift of the mononucleosomes with increasing concentrations of ER was observed. Specificity was demonstrated in experiments with excess ERE and anti-ER antibody. Footprinting analysis was also performed. We also determined that addition of high mobility group protein-2 (HMGB-2, a protein closely related to HMGB-1) with the ER increased the interaction of ER with mononucleosomes. These studies will allow us to address the interactions of ER with core histones containing a multiplicity of variants and modifications in nucleosomal structure.

Binding of TATA binding protein to a naturally positioned nucleosome is facilitated by histone acetylation

The TATA sequence of the human, estrogen-responsive pS2 promoter is complexed in vivo with a rotationally and translationally positioned nucleosome (NUC T). Using a chromatin immunoprecipitation assay, we demonstrate that TATA binding protein (TBP) does not detectably interact with this genomic binding site in MCF-7 cells in the absence of transcriptional stimuli. Estrogen stimulation of these cells results in hyperacetylation of both histones H3 and H4 within the pS2 chromatin encompassing NUC T and the TATA sequence. Concurrently, TBP becomes associated with the pS2 promoter region. The relationship between histone hyperacetylation and the binding of TBP was assayed in vitro using an in vivo-assembled nucleosomal array over the pS2 promoter. With chromatin in its basal state, the binding of TBP to the pS2 TATA sequence at the edge of NUC T was severely restricted, consistent with our in vivo data. Acetylation of the core histones facilitated the binding of TBP to this nucleosomal TATA sequence. Therefore, we demonstrate that one specific, functional consequence of induced histone acetylation at a native promoter is the alleviation of nucleosome-mediated repression of the binding of TBP. Our data support a fundamental role for histone acetylation at genomic promoters in transcriptional activation by nuclear receptors and provide a general mechanism for rapid and reversible transcriptional activation from a chromatin template.