Comparison of Distal Radius Autograft Technique with Iliac Crest Autograft Technique in Solitary Finger Enchondromas

Simple curettage and allogeneic cancellous bone chip impaction grafting in solitary enchondroma of the short tubular bones of the hand

Enchondroma is the most common bone tumor in the hand. While standard surgical procedure is intra-lesional excision and bone grafting, there is a dispute between allogeneic bone, autogenous bone, and synthetic bone substitute grafting. Diverse adjuvant treatments have been introduced to reduce recurrence, but results are mixed with controversies. Meanwhile, whether existing descriptive classification could predict treatment outcome remains unclear. Thus, we reviewed patients with solitary enchondroma of the hand who underwent simple curettage followed by allogeneic cancellous bone chip impaction grafting. Eighty-eight patients with more than 5 years of follow-up were enrolled. Demographic data, local recurrence, and complications were reviewed. Duration of consolidation and the difference according to Takigawa classification were assessed. Range of motion (ROM), and functional scores were also evaluated. There were 51 women and 37 men, with a mean age of 37.9 years. Mean follow-up was 10.2 years. Recurrence occurred only in one patient. There was no complication. Mean postoperative total active motions of fingers and thumb were 239° and 132.9°. Mean modified Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, Hand score, and Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Score were 1.63, and 99.2 at the last follow-up. Consolidation, ROM, and functional scores according to Takigawa classification showed no significant differences. This study suggests that simple curettage with impaction grafting of allogeneic cancellous bone chip is a feasible method for treating solitary enchondromas involving short tubular bone of the hand with good long-term outcomes. Postoperative recurrence and complication rates were very low. Radiographic and clinical results were good regardless of the previous radiological classification.