Synchronizing retinal activity in both eyes disrupts binocular map development in the optic tectum

Functional neuronal circuits emerge in the absence of developmental activity

The complex neuronal circuitry of the brain develops from limited information contained in the genome. After the genetic code instructs the birth of neurons, the emergence of brain regions, and the formation of axon tracts, it is believed that temporally structured spiking activity shapes circuits for behavior. Here, we challenge the learning-dominated assumption that spiking activity is required for circuit formation by quantifying its contribution to the development of visually-guided swimming in the larval zebrafish. We found that visual experience had no effect on the emergence of the optomotor response (OMR) in dark-reared zebrafish. We then raised animals while pharmacologically silencing action potentials with the sodium channel blocker tricaine. After washout of the anesthetic, fish could swim and performed with 75-90% accuracy in the OMR paradigm. Brain-wide imaging confirmed that neuronal circuits came 'online' fully tuned, without requiring activity-dependent plasticity. Thus, complex sensory-guided behaviors can emerge through activity-independent developmental mechanisms.

Recovery of dopaminergic amacrine cells after strobe light stimulation in the developing rat retina

Concerns regarding the impact of strobe light on human health and life have recently been raised. Sources of strobe light include visual display terminals, light-emitting diodes, and computer monitors. Strobe light exposure leads to visual discomfort, headaches, and poor visual performance and affects the number of dopaminergic amacrine cells (DACs) in the developing retina, as well as retinal dopamine levels in animals. DACs serve as the sole source of retinal dopamine, and dopamine release from the retina is activated by light exposure following a circadian rhythm. Using a Sprague-Dawley rat model, this study sought to determine whether changes in DACs caused by strobe light are recoverable after ceasing strobe light exposure during retinal development. From eye opening (postnatal 2 weeks), rats in the control group were reared under normal light (an unflickering 150 lux incandescent lamp with a 12 h light/dark cycle), whereas those in the experimental group (i.e., strobe-recovery group) were reared under strobe light (2 Hz for 12 h/day) exposure for 2 weeks. After postnatal week 4, normal light was provided to all animals to observe the reversibility of the effect of strobe light. Immunohistochemistry and immunoblot analysis for the rate limiting enzyme for dopamine synthesis, tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), as well as high-pressure liquid chromatography for measuring dopamine and 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic acid (DOPAC) were performed at postnatal weeks 4, 6, 8, and 10. The number of type I and type II TH-immunoreactive (TH-IR) cells across the entire retina was counted to evaluate whether changes in DACs induced by strobe light could recover after ceasing strobe light exposure. The number of type I TH-IR cells slightly decreased but remained at a constant level in the control group. In contrast, the number of type I TH-IR cells rapidly decreased up to postnatal week 6, but then increased after postnatal week 8 in the strobe-recovery group. Subsequently, the number of type I TH-IR cells eventually reached a number similar to that in the control group. In addition, the number of intermediate-sized TH-IR cells were increased at postnatal weeks 8 and 10 and the dopamine level was decreased at postnatal week 8 in the strobe-recovery group. However, the levels of DOPAC and TH proteins did not differ between the two groups. This suggests that changes in DACs caused by strobe light are reversible and that type II TH-IR cells may play a key role in this recovery.

Activity-dependent alteration of early myelin ensheathment in a developing sensory circuit

Myelination allows for the regulation of conduction velocity, affecting the precise timing of neuronal inputs important for the development and function of brain circuits. In turn, myelination may be altered by changes in experience, neuronal activity, and vesicular release, but the links between sensory experience, corresponding neuronal activity, and resulting alterations in myelination require further investigation. We thus studied the development of myelination in the Xenopus laevis tadpole, a classic model for studies of visual system development and function because it is translucent and visually responsive throughout the formation of its retinotectal system. We begin with a systematic characterization of the timecourse of early myelin ensheathment in the Xenopus retinotectal system using immunohistochemistry of myelin basic protein (MBP) along with third harmonic generation (THG) microscopy, a label-free structural imaging technique. Based on the mid-larval developmental progression of MBP expression in Xenopus, we identified an appropriate developmental window in which to assess the effects of early temporally patterned visual experience on myelin ensheathment. We used calcium imaging of axon terminals in vivo to characterize the responses of retinal ganglion cells over a range of stroboscopic stimulation frequencies. Strobe frequencies that reliably elicited robust versus dampened calcium responses were then presented to animals for 7 d, and differences in the amount of early myelin ensheathment at the optic chiasm were subsequently quantified. This study provides evidence that it is not just the presence but also to the specific temporal properties of sensory stimuli that are important for myelin plasticity.

Effects of strobe light stimulation on postnatal developing rat retina

The nature and intensity of visual stimuli have changed in recent years because of television and other dynamic light sources. Although light stimuli accompanied by contrast and strength changes are thought to have an influence on visual system development, little information is available on the effects of dynamic light stimuli such as a strobe light on visual system development. Thus, this study was designed to evaluate changes caused by dynamic light stimuli during retinal development. This study used 80 Sprague-Dawley rats. From eye opening (postnatal day 14), half of the rats were maintained on a daily 12-h light/dark cycle (control group) and the remaining animals were raised under a 12-h strobe light (2 Hz)/dark cycle (strobe light-reared group). Morphological analyses and electroretinogram (ERG) were performed at postnatal weeks 3, 4, 6, 8, and 10. Among retinal neurons, tyrosine hydroxylase-immunoreactive (TH-IR, dopaminergic amacrine cells) cells showed marked plastic changes, such as variations in numbers and soma sizes. In whole-mount preparations at 6, 8, and 10 weeks, type I TH-IR cells showed a decreased number and larger somata, while type II TH-IR cells showed an increased number in strobe-reared animals. Functional assessment by scotopic ERG showed that a-wave and b-wave amplitudes increased at 6 and 8 weeks in strobe-reared animals. These results show that exposure to a strobe light during development causes changes in TH-IR cell number and morphology, leading to a disturbance in normal visual functions.

An adaptive neuromorphic model of ocular dominance map using floating gate 'synapse'

A novel analogue CMOS design of a cortical cell, that computes weighted sum of inputs, is presented. The cell's feedback regime exploits the adaptation dynamics of floating gate pFET 'synapse' to perform competitive learning amongst input weights as time-staggered winner take all. A learning rate parameter regulates adaptation time and a bias enforces resource limitation by restricting the number of input branches and winners in a competition. When learning ends, the cell's response favours one input pattern over others to exhibit feature selectivity. Embedded in a 2-D RC grid, these feature selective cells are capable of performing a symmetry breaking pattern formation, observed in some reaction-diffusion models of cortical feature map formation, e.g. ocular dominance. Close similarity with biological networks in terms of adaptability and long term memory indicates that the cell's design is ideally suited for analogue VLSI implementation of Self-Organizing Feature Map (SOFM) models of cortical feature maps.

Design principles of insect and vertebrate visual systems

A century ago, Cajal noted striking similarities between the neural circuits that underlie vision in vertebrates and flies. Over the past few decades, structural and functional studies have provided strong support for Cajal's view. In parallel, genetic studies have revealed some common molecular mechanisms controlling development of vertebrate and fly visual systems and suggested that they share a common evolutionary origin. Here, we review these shared features, focusing on the first several layers-retina, optic tectum (superior colliculus), and lateral geniculate nucleus in vertebrates; and retina, lamina, and medulla in fly. We argue that vertebrate and fly visual circuits utilize common design principles and that taking advantage of this phylogenetic conservation will speed progress in elucidating both functional strategies and developmental mechanisms, as has already occurred in other areas of neurobiology ranging from electrical signaling and synaptic plasticity to neurogenesis and axon guidance.

Many paths to synaptic specificity

The most impressive structural feature of the nervous system is the specificity of its synaptic connections. Even after axons have navigated long distances to reach target areas, they must still choose appropriate synaptic partners from the many potential partners within easy reach. In many cases, axons also select a particular domain of the postsynaptic cell on which to form a synapse. Thus, synapse formation is selective at both cellular and subcellular levels. Unsurprisingly, the nervous system uses multiple mechanisms to ensure proper connectivity; these include complementary labels, coordinated growth of synaptic partners, sorting of afferents, prohibition or elimination of inappropriate synapses, respecification of targets, and use of short-range guidance mechanisms or intermediate targets. Specification of any circuit is likely to involve integration of multiple mechanisms. Recent studies of vertebrate and invertebrate systems have led to the identification of molecules that mediate a few of these interactions.

Intrinsic signal imaging of deprivation-induced contraction of whisker representations in rat somatosensory cortex

In classical sensory cortical map plasticity, the representation of deprived or underused inputs contracts within cortical sensory maps, whereas spared inputs expand. Expansion of spared inputs occurs preferentially into nearby cortical columns representing temporally correlated spared inputs, suggesting that expansion involves correlation-based learning rules at cross-columnar synapses. It is unknown whether deprived representations contract in a similar anisotropic manner, which would implicate similar learning rules and sites of plasticity. We briefly deprived D-row whiskers in 20-day-old rats, so that each deprived whisker had deprived (D-row) and spared (C- and E-row) neighbors. Intrinsic signal optical imaging revealed that D-row deprivation weakened and contracted the functional representation of deprived D-row whiskers in L2/3 of somatosensory (S1) cortex. Spared whisker representations did not strengthen or expand, indicating that D-row deprivation selectively engages the depression component of map plasticity. Contraction of deprived whisker representations was spatially uniform, with equal withdrawal from spared and deprived neighbors. Single-unit electrophysiological recordings confirmed these results, and showed substantial weakening of responses to deprived whiskers in layer 2/3 of S1, and modest weakening in L4. The observed isotropic contraction of deprived whisker representations during D-row deprivation is consistent with plasticity at intracolumnar, rather than cross-columnar, synapses.

Correlation model for joint development of refined retinotopic map and ocular dominance columns

We describe a modification to a standard correlation model for the development of the geniculocortical projection that relays visual input to the visual cortex. The modification is to include threshold-activation of cortical cells as opposed to linear activation and it is shown that this can account for topographic map refinement (TMR). This contrasts with other models that require cortical cells to compete for activation or for neurotrophic support. Simulations are conducted for the joint development of ocular dominance columns and TMR in normal animals and parameter variations are used to both confirm robustness and to simulate some experimental conditions.

Disruption of primary auditory cortex by synchronous auditory inputs during a critical period

In the primary auditory cortex (AI), the development of tone frequency selectivity and tonotopic organization is influenced by patterns of neural activity. Introduction of synchronous inputs into the auditory pathway achieved by exposing rat pups to pulsed white noise at a moderate intensity during P9-P28 resulted in a disrupted tonotopicity and degraded frequency-response selectivity for neurons in the adult AI. The latter was manifested by broader-than-normal tuning curves, multipeaks, and discontinuous, tone-evoked responses within AI-receptive fields. These effects correlated with the severe impairment of normal, developmental sharpening, and refinement of receptive fields and tonotopicity. In addition, paradoxically weaker than normal temporal correlations between the discharges of nearby AI neurons were recorded in exposed rats. In contrast, noise exposure of rats older than P30 did not cause significant change of auditory cortical maps. Thus, patterned auditory inputs appear to play a crucial role in shaping neuronal processing/decoding circuits in the primary auditory cortex during a critical period.

Nitric oxide, impulse activity, and neurotrophins in visual system development(1)

Topographic refinement of synaptic connections within the developing visual system involves a variety of molecules which interact with impulse activity in order to produce the precise retinotopic maps found in the adult brain. Nitric oxide (NO) has been implicated in this process, as have various growth factors. Within the subcortical visual system, we have recently shown that nitric oxide contributes to pathway refinement in the superior colliculus (SC). Long-term potentiation (LTP) and long-term depression (LTD) are also expressed in SC during the time that this pathway undergoes refinement. The role of NO has been demonstrated by showing that refinement of ipsilateral fibers in the retinocollicular pathway is significantly delayed in gene knockout mice in which both the endothelial and neuronal isoforms of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) have been disrupted. The effect also depends upon Ca(2+) channels because refinement of both the ipsilateral retinocollicular and retinogeniculate pathways is disrupted in genetic mutants in which the beta3 subunit of the Ca(2+) channel has been deleted. LTD may also be involved in this process, because the time course of its expression correlates with that of pathway refinement and LTD magnitude is depressed by nitrendipine, an L-type Ca(2+) channel blocker. LTP is also expressed during early postnatal development in the LGN and SC and may contribute to synaptic stabilization. The role of neurotrophins in pathway refinement in the visual system is also reviewed.

The development of abnormal axon trajectories after rotation of one eye in Xenopus

The targeting of isthmotectal axons in the Xenopus binocular pathway is guided by both activity-dependent cues and activity-independent cues. Abnormal visual activity induced by unilateral eye rotation overrides activity-independent cues and causes isthmotectal axons to arborize at new locations during a critical period of development that ends approximately 3 months postmetamorphosis (PM). Horseradish peroxidase staining of isthmotectal axons reveals that they normally run rostrocaudally in the tectum; in contrast, those axons in animals with early eye rotation have circuitous trajectories. In this paper, by studying the trajectories and branching patterns of isthmotectal axons at different times after eye rotation, we aimed to investigate when and how activity cues determine the projection pattern of isthmotectal axons. As suggested by electrophysiological recording, isthmotectal axons initially grow normally and make arbors according to activity-independent cues despite the presence of abnormal visual input. Our findings demonstrate that the development of abnormal trajectories starts by 2 weeks PM in response to eye rotation and is a protracted process. It begins in the tectal regions in which the initial connections of isthmotectal axons are first formed according to activity-independent cues. At transitional stages (5 and 10 weeks), axons with arbors at two different locations are observed, with locations corresponding to the old and new termination sites, respectively. Later, at 10 weeks of age, the fainter horseradish peroxidase staining in arbors at old termination sites suggests that the older arbors are undergoing withdrawal.

Plasticity in the tectum of Xenopus laevis: binocular maps

Xenopus frogs exhibit dramatic changes in the binocular projections to the tectum during a critical period of development. Their eyes change position in the head, moving from lateral to dorsal and creating an increasing region of binocular overlap. There is a corresponding shift of binocular projections to the tectum that keeps the two eyes' maps in register with each other throughout this period. The ipsilateral input is relayed via the nucleus isthmi. Two factors bring the ipsilateral projection into register with the contralateral projection. First, chemoaffinity cues establish a crude topographic map beginning when the shift of eye position begins. Approximately 1 month later, visual cues bring the ipsilateral map into register with the contralateral map. The role of visual input is demonstrated by the ability of the axons that bring the ipsilateral eye's map to the tectum to reorganize in response to a surgical rotation of one eye and to come into register with the contralateral eye's map. This plasticity can be blocked by NMDA receptor antagonists during the critical period. In normal adults, reorganization is minimal. Eye rotation fails to induce reorganization of the ipsilateral map. However, plasticity persists indefinitely in animals that are reared in the dark, and plasticity can be restored in normally-reared animals by treatment with NMDA. The working model to explain this plasticity posits that correlated input from the two eyes triggers opening of NMDA receptor channels and initiates events that stabilize appropriately-located isthmotectal connections. Specific tests of this model are discussed.

Brain waves and brain wiring: the role of endogenous and sensory-driven neural activity in development

Neural activity is critical for sculpting the intricate circuits of the nervous system from initially imprecise neuronal connections. Disrupting the formation of these precise circuits may underlie many common neurodevelopmental disorders, ranging from subtle learning disorders to pervasive developmental delay. The necessity for sensory-driven activity has been widely recognized as crucial for infant brain development. Recent experiments in neurobiology now point to a similar requirement for endogenous neural activity generated by the nervous system itself before sensory input is available. Here we use the formation of precise neural circuits in the visual system to illustrate the principles of activity-dependent development. Competition between the projections from lateral geniculate nucleus neurons that receive sensory input from the two eyes shapes eye-specific connections from an initially diffuse projection into ocular dominance columns. When the competition is altered during a critical period for these changes, by depriving one eye of vision, the normal ocular dominance column pattern is disrupted. Before ocular dominance column formation, the highly ordered projection from retina to lateral geniculate nucleus develops. These connections form before the retina can respond to light, but at a time when retinal ganglion cells spontaneously generate highly correlated bursts of action potentials. Blockade of this endogenous activity, or biasing the competition in favor of one eye, results in a severe disruption of the pattern of retinogeniculate connections. Similar spontaneous, correlated activity has been identified in many locations in the developing central nervous system and is likely to be used during the formation of precise connections in many other neural systems. Understanding the processes of activity-dependent development could revolutionize our ability to identify, prevent, and treat developmental disorders resulting from disruptions of neural activity that interfere with the formation of precise neural circuits.

Mechanisms involved in development of retinotectal connections: roles of Eph receptor tyrosine kinases, NMDA receptors and nitric oxide

Axons of retinal ganglion cells exhibit a specific pattern of connections with the brain. Within each visual nucleus in the brain, retinal connections are topographic such that axons from neighboring ganglion cells have neighboring synapses. Research is beginning to shed light on the mechanisms responsible for development of topographic connections in the visual system. Much of this research is focused on the axonal connections of the retina with the tectum. In vivo and in vitro experiments indicate that the pattern of retinotectal connections develops in part due to positional labels carried by the growing retinal axons and by the tectal cells. Evidence suggests that gradients of Eph receptor tyrosine kinases serve as positional labels on the growing retinal axons, and gradients of ligands for these receptors serve as positional labels in the tectum. Blocking expression of EphA3, a receptor tyrosine kinase, in the developing retina resulted in disruption of the topography of the retinotectal connections, further supporting the role of these, molecules. Although positional labels appear to be important, other mechanisms must also be involved. The initial pattern of retinotectal connections lacks the precision seen in the adult. The adult pattern of connections arises during development by activity dependent refinement of a roughly ordered prepattern. The refinement process results in elimination of projections to the wrong side of the brain, to non-visual nuclei and to inappropriate regions within a nucleus. Blocking NMDA receptors during the period of refinement preserved anomalous retinotectal projections, which suggests that elimination of these projections is mediated by NMDA receptors. Furthermore, tectal cells normally express high levels of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) during the period of refinement, and blocking nitric oxide (NO) synthesis also preserved inappropriate projections. Thus, both NMDA receptors and NO appear to be involved in refinement. Blocking NMDA receptor activation reduced NOS activity in tectal cells, which suggests the possibility that NO is the downstream mediator of NMDA function related to refinement. A quantitative comparison of blocking NMDA receptors, NO synthesis or both showed that all three treatments have comparable effects on refinement. This indicates that the role of NMDA receptor activation relative to refinement may be completely mediated through nitric oxide. Quantitative analysis also suggests that other mechanisms not involving NMDA receptors or NO must be involved in refinement. Other mechanisms appear to include cell death.

Neuronal activity during development: permissive or instructive?

Experimental studies over the past year have shown that neural activity has a range of effects on the development of neural pathways. Although activity appears unimportant for establishing many aspects of the gross morphology and topology of the brain, there are many cases where the presence of neural activity is essential for the formation of a mature system of neural connections; in some instances, the pattern of neural activity actually orchestrates the final arrangement of neural connections.

A critical window for cooperation and competition among developing retinotectal synapses

In the developing frog visual system, topographic refinement of the retinotectal projection depends on electrical activity. In vivo whole-cell recording from developing Xenopus tectal neurons shows that convergent retinotectal synapses undergo activity-dependent cooperation and competition following correlated pre- and postsynaptic spiking within a narrow time window. Synaptic inputs activated repetitively within 20 ms before spiking of the tectal neuron become potentiated, whereas subthreshold inputs activated within 20 ms after spiking become depressed. Thus both the initial synaptic strength and the temporal order of activation are critical for heterosynaptic interactions among convergent synaptic inputs during activity-dependent refinement of developing neural networks.