Conjoined twins and legal authorization for abortion

Medical Implications of Restricting Abortions on Women Diagnosed With Fetal Anomalies Following the Overturn of Roe v. Wade: A Scoping Review

This scoping review addresses the potential maternal health outcomes of abortion restrictions in the U.S. by studying and analyzing the reported effects of abortion bans or limitations globally. The goal was to examine the medical implications for pregnant women who are unable to abort fetuses that have severe medical anomalies due to imposed restrictions. EMBASE, Medline, and CINAHL databases were searched for studies published in English concerning the medical implications of abortion restrictions in any country prior to the overturn of Roe v. Wade in 2022. For the search criteria using Boolean operators, keywords included the terms "fetal anomaly," "abortion ban," and "implications." Inclusion criteria incorporated studies published between 1980 and 2021, and controlled experimental research studies aimed to evaluate interventions were excluded. This resulted in 469 records initially found. Duplicate records were removed, and two separate tier reviews were conducted. Eleven reviewers independently screened abstracts and titles of 332 records to ascertain eligibility. Eligibility included pregnant women diagnosed with fetal anomalies, women denied access to safe abortions, and the maternal and fetal medical impacts of this. Three reviewers in the second screening independently read 36 full articles to further assess eligibility, resulting in 14 articles in the final review. Findings from this study showed that abortion bans in countries around the world have led to health complications in women seeking illegal abortion services, a decline in maternal mental health, including stress and depression, various medical complications such as obstructed labor, and an increase in high-risk fetuses born with severe deficits. The findings of this review portend similar negative consequences to be experienced by women who are subject to stricter abortion laws in the U.S.

Imperfect twinning: a clinical and ethical dilemma

OBJECTIVE To review the history, epidemiology, etiology, gestational aspects, diagnosis and prognosis of imperfect twinning. DATA SOURCES Scientific articles were searched in PubMed, SciELO and Lilacs databases, using the descriptors "conjoined twins", "multiple pregnancy", "ultrasound", "magnetic resonance imaging" and "prognosis". The research was not delimited to a specific period of time and was supplemented with bibliographic data from books.

DATA SYNTHESIS

The description of conjoined twins is legendary. The estimated frequency is 1/45,000-200,000 births. These twins are monozygotic, monochorionic and usually monoamniotic. They can be classified by the most prominent fusion site, by the symmetry between the conjoined twins or by the sharing structure. The diagnosis can be performed in the prenatal period or after birth by different techniques, such as ultrasound, magnetic resonance imaging and echocardiography. These tests are of paramount importance for understanding the anatomy of both fetuses/children, as well as for prognosis and surgical plan determination. CONCLUSIONS Although imperfect twinning is a rare condition, the prenatal diagnosis is very important in order to evaluate the fusion site and its complexity. Hence, the evaluation of these children should be multidisciplinary, involving mainly obstetricians, pediatricians and pediatric surgeons. However, some decisions may constitute real ethical dilemmas, in which different points should be discussed and analyzed with the health team and the family.

Twenty-five years of fetal echocardiography in conjoined twins: lessons learned

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to determine the accuracy of prenatal echocardiography in the diagnosis of intracardiac malformations and the degree of cardiac fusion in conjoined twins presenting to a single center over a 25-year period.

METHODS

The study group included 53 sets of conjoined twins from 1987 to 2012, including 38 thoracopagus, six parapagus, six omphalo-ischiopagus, two omphalopagus, and one cephalopagus. Twins were classified according to the degree of cardiac fusion: separate hearts and pericardium (group A, n = 10), separated hearts and common pericardium (group B, n = 2), fused atria and separated ventricles (group C, n = 2), and fused atria and ventricles (group D, n = 39). Postmortem examination was possible in 68 individual cases (98 deaths [69.3%]).

RESULTS

Cardiac defects were diagnosed in 47 sets of twins (88.6%). In 10 (18.8%), only one fetus was affected, and in 37 (69.8%), both fetuses were affected (n = 84/106 [79.2%]). There was a high predominance of right-sided lesions (63.0% [53 fetuses in 84 affected]) including pulmonary atresia or stenosis (35.7%), tricuspid atresia (11.9%), and hypoplastic or small right ventricle (21.4%). Autopsy findings added information to fetal echocardiographic findings in nine sets of twins (25.7%). Three pairs classified antenatally in groups A, B, and D were confirmed by autopsy in groups B, C, and C, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that specialized fetal echocardiography is not a perfect diagnostic tool but is sensitive enough to establish prognosis in the counseling process. Because of complexity, such evaluations should be performed only at tertiary centers by specialists who are familiar with the peculiarities of this rare malformation. The predominance of right-sided lesions is not only an interesting finding, but this information has essential importance in terms of shortening examination times, allowing a more focused analysis of the fetal heart.