Avaliação da implantação da iniciativa hospital amigo da criança no Rio de Janeiro, Brasil

External evaluation and self-monitoring of the Baby-friendly Hospital Initiative's maternity hospitals in Brazil

Background

In Brazil, the Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative (BFHI) proposes following the criteria, the “Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding”, International Code of Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes and Good birth and delivery practices. Brazilian Baby-Friendly Hospitals are reassessed triennially by external evaluators and annually by self-monitoring. This study aimed to verify if the self-monitoring system fulfills its role of enabling accredited hospitals to assess and improve their compliance with the BFHI criteria. In this sense, we will analyze the self-monitoring evaluation results and compare them with those of the external reassessment.

Methods

This descriptive evaluation study of the compliance with the BFHI criteria by the Brazilian Baby-Friendly Hospitals by self-monitoring evaluators from 2010 to 2015 and by external evaluators in 2015.

Results

Self-monitoring was performed in all years from 2010 to 2015 by 143 BFHI accredited hospitals. The trend of the levels of compliance with BFHI’s criteria according to self-monitoring evaluations was stable over the assessed period. Most criteria presented compliance above 70%, except Step 4 (skin-to-skin contact and breastfeeding in the first hour of life), with mean compliance of 67%. Steps 1 (written policy), 7 (rooming-in) and 9 (give no artificial teats) showed mean compliance above 90%. Regarding the external evaluation carried out in 2015, the criteria with lowest compliance were Step 4 and Woman-Friendly care, both below 50%. Steps 9 and 10 (refer mothers to breastfeeding support groups) reached levels of compliance above 90%. For 2015, self-monitoring provided significant higher compliance levels than those from external evaluations in most criteria, except Step 3 (prenatal information on breastfeeding) and Step 10. There was a difference of more than 30% points between evaluations of Steps 1 (written policy), 2 (training), 5 (show mothers how to breastfeed), Woman-Friendly Care and father or mother stay with their newborn.

Conclusions

The self-monitoring system fulfilled partially its role of allowing accredited hospitals to self-assess and improve rates of compliance with BFHI criteria. Future trainings of hospital managers need to address difficulties and identify solutions to improve implementation of Steps 4 and 6.

The Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative: increasing breastfeeding and decreasing infant mortality in Brazil

Abstract Objectives: to estimate the population attributable fraction of preventable infant mortality rates due to changes in breastfeeding (BF) indicators attributable to the Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative (BFHI). Methods: an estimate on the impact of BFHI in reducing infant mortality with an inferential level of plausibility, using secondary data from the II Breastfeeding Prevalence Survey of 2008. Initially, the effect of BFHI on breastfeeding in the first hour of life, exclusive breastfeeding, and any breastfeeding based on the prevalence of the outcomes among infants born in BFHI or non-BFHI was calculated. Second, the population attributable fraction of nonbreastfeeding was estimated for late neonatal mortality, mortality by all causes and infant mortality by infections, for BFHI and non-BFHI, and the number of potentially avoidable deaths if all children were born in BFH. Results: reduction of 4.2% of late neonatal deaths due to the increase in BF prevalence in the first hour, as provided by BFHI. BFHI potentially contributed with 3.5% of all-cause deaths and 4.2% of deaths from infection by BF promotion in infants below 6 months. Conclusions: the reduction of mortality in children between 7 and 180 days in 2008 potentially attributable to BFHI through the promotion of BF indicators reinforces the importance of strengthening and expanding this initiative in Brazil to ultimately enhance child survival.

Factors associated with submission to HIV rapid test in childbirth care

Rapid HIV tests are used in maternity hospitals to prevent mother-to-child transmission. This study aimed to analyze factors associated with submission to the rapid HIV test (outcome). This is a cross-sectional study conducted in 2009 in 15 hospitals from the Rio de Janeiro's Unified Health System (SUS) by interviewing a representative sample of 835 pregnant women hospitalized for birth and by verifying medical records. Adjusted prevalence ratios were obtained by Poisson regression according to a hierarchical model, and variables associated with the outcome (p ≤ 0.05) remained in the final model. According to medical records (MR), 79.6% of mothers were submitted to rapid HIV test and, according to interviews (INT), 55.7%. At the distal level, the lack of a partner (MR), having ≥ 6 residents at home (MR) and non-white skin color (INT) were associated with a higher prevalence of the outcome. At the intermediate level, not having a negative HIV serology from prenatal care (MR and INT) was associated with a higher prevalence of the outcome, as well as PHC prenatal care (MR) and lack of prenatal care (INT). At the proximal level, delivery in a hospital not certified as Baby-Friendly was associated with a higher prevalence of outcome (MR and INT).

[Training of health professionals in breastfeeding and its association with knowledge, skills and practices]

A cross-sectional study was conducted in the 15 hospitals with over 1000 deliveries/year in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, to verify the association between training of health professionals in breastfeeding and professional knowledge, skills and practices. Interviews were staged with 215 health professionals, 48.4% working in Baby-Friendly Hospitals, by means of a questionnaire adapted from the revalidation instrument of the initiative. The three dichotomized outcomes were subjected to bivariate and multivariate analysis. Adjusted prevalence ratios were obtained by the Poisson regression model: 48.1% of the professionals had adequate knowledge, 58.9% adequate skills and 74.9% reported adequate practice. Theoretical and practical training ≥ 18 hours considered adequate (by 65.6% of the professionals) showed a significant association with professional knowledge (aPR = 1.575), skills (aPR = 1.530) and practices (aPR = 1.312). Less working experience was associated with less knowledge (aPR = 0.723), but with better practices (aPR = 1.183). Nursing staff reported better practices than physicians (aPR = 0.808) and other categories (aPR = 0.658). The study concludes that training contributes to improved breastfeeding knowledge, skills and practices that are essential for maternal and child care.

Impact of health professional training in breastfeeding on their knowledge, skills, and hospital practices: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To identify the impact of training in breastfeeding on knowledge, skills, and professional and hospital practices.

DATA SOURCE

The systematic review search was carried out through the MEDLINE, Scopus, and LILACS databases. Reviews, studies with qualitative methodology, those without control group, those conducted in primary care, with specific populations, studies that had a belief and/or professional attitude as outcome, or those with focus on the post-discharge period were excluded. There was no limitation of period or language. The quality of the studies was assessed by the adapted criteria of Downs and Black.

SUMMARY OF DATA

The literature search identified 276 articles, of which 37 were selected for reading, 26 were excluded, and six were included through reference search. In total, 17 intervention articles were included, three of them with good internal validity. The studies were performed between 1992 and 2010 in countries from five continents; four of them were conducted in Brazil. The training target populations were nursing practitioners, doctors, midwives, and home visitors. Many kinds of training courses were applied. Five interventions employed the theoretical and practical training of the Baby-Friendly Hospital Initiative. All kinds of training courses showed at least one positive result on knowledge, skills, and/or professional/hospital practices, most of them with statistical significance.

CONCLUSIONS

Training of hospital health professionals has been effective in improving knowledge, skills, and practices.

Avaliação da testagem anti-HIV no pré-natal e na assistência ao parto no Rio de Janeiro, Brasil

Resumo Objetivos: avaliar a testagem anti-HIV durante a assistência pré-natal e ao parto no Sistema Único de Saúde. Métodos: estudo transversal conduzido em 2009 em 15 maternidades no Rio de Janeiro, sendo entrevistada amostra representativa de 835 parturientes e observados prontuários. Para avaliação da adequação da testagem anti-HIV foi elaborado um modelo lógico. Resultados: segundo informação das parturientes, 86,7% dispunham de sorologia não reagente do pré-natal e 55,7% foram submetidas ao teste rápido anti-HIV no hospital; em 49,9% dos casos o procedimento relativo ao teste rápido anti-HIV no hospital foi considerado adequado: mães com status ignorado de HIV do pré-natal submetidas ao teste rápido e mães com status conhecido não submetidas ao mesmo. Segundo dados do prontuário, 68,0% dispunham de sorologia não reagente e 79,6% foram submetidas ao teste rápido anti-HIV; em 50,9% dos casos o procedimento relativo ao teste rápido anti- HIV no hospital foi adequado. Conclusões: o protocolo de exames anti-HIV no pré-natal e na maternidade, vigentes em 2009, não foram cumpridos a contento, tanto por gerar procedimentos desnecessários quanto falhas na testagem da população alvo, ameaçando a instituição oportuna de medidas profiláticas de controle da transmissão vertical.

Fatores associados ao início tardio da amamentação em hospitais do Sistema Único de Saúde no Município do Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, 2009

Resumo O objetivo do trabalho foi analisar os fatores associados com o início tardio da amamentação (não amamentar na primeira hora de vida). Estudo transversal conduzido em 2009 com 673 puérperas internadas em hospitais do Sistema Único de Saúde (SUS) do Município do Rio de Janeiro, Brasil. Um modelo de regressão logística multinível com dois níveis (individual e hospitalar) foi utilizado nas análises estatísticas. A prevalência de início tardio da amamentação foi de 49,2%. O parto em Hospital Amigo da Criança (HAC) teve um efeito protetor contra o atraso no início da amamentação (OR = 0,17; IC95%: 0,05-0,55), enquanto a cesariana (OR = 5,95; IC95%: 3,88-9,12) e o desconhecimento do resultado do exame anti-HIV até o parto (OR = 2,16; IC95%: 1,04-4,50) aumentaram a chance de atraso. Redução das taxas de cesariana, adesão aos protocolos de atenção pré-natal e ampliação do credenciamento dos hospitais como HAC são estratégias importantes para promover o aleitamento materno na primeira hora de vida.

Caesarean section and neonatal outcomes in private hospitals in Brazil: comparative study of two different perinatal models of care

This study aims at comparing caesarean section rates and neonatal outcomes of two perinatal models of care provided in private hospitals in Brazil. Birth in Brazil data, a national hospital-based cohort conducted in the years 2011/2012 was used. We analysed 1,664 postpartum women and their offspring attended at 13 hospitals located in the South-east region of Brazil, divided into a "typical"--standard care model and "atypical"--Baby-Friendly hospital with collaborative practices between nurse-midwives and obstetricians on duty to attend deliveries in an alternative labour ward. The Robson's classification system was used to compare caesarean sections, which was lower in the atypical hospital (47.8% vs. 90.8%, p<0.001). Full term birth, early skin-to-skin contact, breastfeeding in the first hour, rooming-in care, and discharge in exclusive breastfeeding were more frequent in the atypical hospital. Neonatal adverse outcome did not differ significantly between hospitals. The atypical hospital's intervention should be further evaluated since it might reduce caesarean section prevalence and increase good practices in neonatal care.

Associação entre as orientações pré-natais em aleitamento materno e a satisfação com o apoio para amamentar

OBJETIVOS: analisar a associação entre orientações pré-natais em aleitamento materno e a satisfação das gestantes com o apoio recebido para amamentar. MÉTODOS: estudo transversal realizado no município do Rio de Janeiro, Brasil, com amostra representativa de 461 gestantes acompanhadas nos 15 hospitais com mais de 1000 partos/ano do Sistema Único de Saúde. Sete desses hospitais eram credenciados na Iniciativa Hospital Amigo da Criança e oito não. As razões de prevalência (RP) da satisfação foram obtidas por modelo de regressão de Poisson com variância robusta, segundo modelo hierarquizado. RESULTADOS: ficaram satisfeitas com o apoio recebido para amamentar 62,0% das gestantes. As variáveis associadas ao desfecho na análise múltipla foram ter recebido orientação sobre como amamentar (RP=1,77; IC95%: 1,38-2,28), ter recebido orientação sobre livre demanda (RP=1,52; IC95%: 1,22-1,88), ter recebido orientação sobre não uso de mamadeira e outros leites (RP=1,35; IC95%: 1,15-1,58) e a qualidade do acompanhamento pré-natal segundo a percepção da gestante (RP=1,22; IC95%: 1,08-1,38). CONCLUSÕES: a satisfação da gestante com o apoio recebido para amamentar não variou segundo as características sociodemográficas da mulher, porém se associou a orientações pré-natais sobre aleitamento materno, ressaltando a importância da qualidade da assistência.