Current perspectives on laparoscopic robot-assisted pancreas and pancreas-kidney transplantation

Modern indications for referral for kidney and pancreas transplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Pancreas transplantation (PTx) is currently the only therapy that can predictably achieve sustained euglycemia independent of exogenous insulin administration in patients with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. This procedure involves a complex abdominal operation and lifetime dependence on immunosuppressive medications. Therefore, PTx is most frequently performed in combination with other organs, usually a kidney transplant for end stage diabetic nephropathy. Less frequently, solitary PTx may be indicated in patients with potentially life-threatening complications of diabetes mellitus. There remains confusion and misperceptions regarding indications and timing of patient referral for PTx.

RECENT FINDINGS

In this review, the referral, evaluation, and listing process for PTx is described, including a detailed discussion of candidate assessment, indications, contraindications, and outcomes.

SUMMARY

Because the progression of diabetic kidney disease may be less predictable than other forms of kidney failure, early referral for planning of renal and/or pancreas transplantation is paramount to optimize patient care and allow for possible preemptive transplantation.

Pancreas Transplantation in Minorities including Patients with a Type 2 Diabetes Phenotype

Background: Prior to year 2000, the majority of pancreas transplants (PTx) were performed as simultaneous pancreas-kidney transplants (SPKTs) in Caucasian adults with end stage renal failure secondary to type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) who were middle-aged. In the new millennium, improving outcomes have led to expanded recipient selection that includes patients with a type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) phenotype, which excessively affects minority populations. Methods: Using PubMed® to identify appropriate citations, we performed a literature review of PTx in minorities and in patients with a T2DM phenotype. Results: Mid-term outcomes with SPKT in patients with uremia and circulating C-peptide levels (T2DMphenotype) are comparable to those patients with T1DM although there may exist a selection bias in the former group. Excellent outcomes with SPKT suggests that the pathophysiology of T2DM is heterogeneous with elements consisting of both insulin deficiency and resistance related to beta-cell failure. As a result, increasing endogenous insulin (Cp) production following PTx may lead to freedom checking blood sugars or taking insulin, better metabolic counter-regulation, and improvements in quality of life and life expectancy compared to other available treatment options. Experience with solitary PTx for T2DM or in minorities is limited but largely mirrors the trends reported in SPKT. Conclusions: PTx is a viable treatment option in patients with pancreas endocrine failure who are selected appropriately regardless of diabetes type or recipient race. This review will summarize data that unconventional patient populations with insulin-requiring diabetes may gain value from PTx with an emphasis on contemporary experiences and appropriate selection in minorities in the new millennium.

A controllable double-cycle cryogenic device inducing hypothermia for laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplantation in swine

Background

It is necessity to maintain donor kidneys at a low temperature for laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplantation (LOKT). We recently designed a controllable double-cycle cryogenic device (DCD) with a safer and more effective cooling setting. This study aimed to evaluate the safety and efficacy of this device in a swine model.

Methods

A total of 20 pigs were procured for this study. We performed LOKT on 8 pigs using the controllable DCD for hypothermia, on another 8 pigs using the silicon tube cage (STC) for hypothermia, and on 4 pigs as the control group with no hypothermia measures (NH). The LOKTs were performed in autotransplantation mode in which the right kidney vein and artery were end-to-end anastomosed to the left kidney vein and artery in all three groups. The perioperative data, graft temperatures, and surgical complications were recorded, and histological examinations of kidney specimens were performed.

Results

The average surface temperature in the DCD group (5±3.5 °C) was significantly lower than that in the STC (10±5.5 °C) and NH (28±3.0 °C) groups. In the DCD and STC groups, the temperature between the cooling setting and the adjacent peritoneum was 30±3.0 and 12±5.0 °C, respectively. All pigs survived for 7 days in the DCD group. In the STC group, 2 pigs died from liver lesions and other causes. A single pig had diabetes insipidus. No pigs survived for 7 days in the NH group. The specimens from pigs immediately after revascularization and from the surviving pigs on day 7 following transplantation showed that the morphology of the glomerular and renal tubules was largely normal in the DCD and STC groups. However, in the NH group, there was minimal interstitial and tubular oedema, and endothelial cell swelling occurred in some specimens immediately after revascularization. Pathological examination of the harvested graft specimens showed severe acute tubular necrosis in the NH group.

Conclusions

The newly designed controllable DCD can achieve the goal of cooling the kidney and warming the patient and may be a reliable, effective, inexpensive, and practical hypothermic maintenance system for LOKT in swine.

Extraperitoneal Laparoscopic Kidney Transplantation: Preliminary Clinical Experiences from China

OBJECTIVE

To report on the pioneering clinical experiences of six cases of extraperitoneal laparoscopic kidney transplantation in China.

METHODS

For the first time in clinical practice, a customised, controllable double-circulation cooling device was used to protect the transplanted kidney. Of the six patients, two underwent an allograft renal transplantation because they had been diagnosed with uraemia and were on maintenance haemodialysis. The other four patients underwent kidney autotransplantation because of a central renal tumour.

RESULTS

The extraperitoneal laparoscopic kidney transplantations were successfully completed between 2017 and 2018. The operative time for the two patients undergoing the allograft transplantation was 3-3.5 h. The time for venous anastomosis was approximately 53-65 min, and the time for arterial anastomosis was approximately 25-30 min. The creatinine level was 90-80 μmol/L after surgery. The operative time of the four patients who underwent autotransplantation was 9.4-17.5 h. The times of venous and arterial anastomosis were 58-90 min and 35-48 min, respectively. The follow-up B-mode ultrasound after surgery showed good blood supply in the spared nephron. A renal graft was removed from one patient 6 months after surgery because of renal atrophy and dysfunction caused by poor blood supply. Five patients (two undergoing allografting and three undergoing autografting) completed the 12-month follow-up, and their renal graft function was good.

CONCLUSIONS

Extraperitoneal laparoscopic kidney transplantation, either allograft or autologous transplantation, is a safe and feasible procedure with a good chance of survival for the transplanted kidney. A customised cooling device is effective and practical during laparoscopic kidney transplantation.

Robot-Assisted Transplant Surgery - Vision or Reality? A Comprehensive Review

Minimally invasive surgery is standard procedure for many operations. Further refinements include the introduction of robotic surgery which is still an emerging field especially in laparoscopic surgery. Since the successful introduction of the da Vinci Robotic Surgical System, the robotic approach in organ transplantation has become of great interest in both the live donor organ retrieval and the recipient operation. Robotic surgery for kidney, liver, and pancreas transplantation is feasible. Over 700 donor nephrectomies and 100 kidney transplantations have been performed already, and robotic surgery is standard in a small number of pioneer centers; however, larger series and most importantly randomized controlled trials for the highest evidence are needed. Longer warm ischemia time and higher costs limit these procedures at the moment.

Surgery of pancreas transplantation

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The surgical techniques of pancreas transplantation have been evolving and significantly improved over time. This article discusses different current techniques and their modifications.

RECENT FINDING

At this time, the most commonly used technique is systemic venous drainage (for venous outflow) and enteric drainage (for management of exocrine pancreatic secretions). However, new modifications of established techniques such as gastric or duodenal exocrine drainage and venous drainage to the inferior vena cava continue to be introduced.

SUMMARY

This article provides a state-of the-art review of the most prevalent up-to-date surgical techniques as well as a synopsis of their specific risks and benefits. The article also provides the most current registry data regarding utilization of different surgical techniques in the United State and worldwide.

The use of robotic surgery in abdominal organ transplantation: A literature review

Minimally invasive surgical approaches in transplantation are gaining increasing interest, and many centers are reporting their, mainly laparoscopic, experiences. Robotic surgery (RS) has some hypothetical advantages over traditional laparoscopy and has been successfully applied, although infrequently to organ transplantation. Our goal was to review and critique the publications reporting RS use in organ transplantation. Most of the RS experience has been with living renal donor organ procurement and, to a lesser extent, with RS procedures in the transplant recipient. The available literature suggests that RS appears to be a safe surgical alternative to standard open procedures. RS in living liver donor surgery remains limited, and more experience is required before commenting on RS-related outcomes RS in pancreatic transplantation is exceedingly rare. The enhanced precision and ergonomics of RS may expand its applicability to liver living donation and pancreas transplantation at some point in the future.

Robot-assisted renal surgery: current status and future directions

This paper examines the current role of robot-assisted renal surgery as complex and partial nephrectomies, including vena cava thrombus, combined nephroureterectomies, living donor nephrectomy, autotransplantation, and difficult anatomy as in patients with obesity or adhesions. Indications for robot-assisted renal surgery are comparable to those of conventional laparoscopic approaches. A reduction in the learning curve leads to a stabilization of the procedure and further increases the number of minimally invasive procedures performed. A Medline literature search for publications on the field of robotic kidney surgery has been performed using the MeSH terms: robotic surgical procedures and kidney. Future directions include progress in robotic technology and instrumentation with further miniaturization of robotic procedures as laparoendoscopic single-site interventions and progress in image-guided robotic surgery.

Robotic general surgery: current practice, evidence, and perspective

BACKGROUND

Robotic technology commenced to be adopted for the field of general surgery in the 1990s. Since then, the da Vinci surgical system (Intuitive Surgical Inc, Sunnyvale, CA, USA) has remained by far the most commonly used system in this domain. The da Vinci surgical system is a master-slave machine that offers three-dimensional vision, articulated instruments with seven degrees of freedom, and additional software features such as motion scaling and tremor filtration. The specific design allows hand-eye alignment with intuitive control of the minimally invasive instruments. As such, robotic surgery appears technologically superior when compared with laparoscopy by overcoming some of the technical limitations that are imposed on the surgeon by the conventional approach.

PURPOSE

This article reviews the current literature and the perspective of robotic general surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

While robotics has been applied to a wide range of general surgery procedures, its precise role in this field remains a subject of further research. Until now, only limited clinical evidence that could establish the use of robotics as the gold standard for procedures of general surgery has been created. While surgical robotics is still in its infancy with multiple novel systems currently under development and clinical trials in progress, the opportunities for this technology appear endless, and robotics should have a lasting impact to the field of general surgery.

Transplantation of the pancreas

Pancreas transplantation consistently induces insulin-independence in beta-cell-penic diabetic patients, but at the cost of major surgery and life-long immunosuppression. One year after grafting, patient survival rate now exceeds 95 % across recipient categories, while insulin independence is maintained in some 85 % of simultaneous pancreas and kidney recipients and in nearly 80 % of solitary pancreas transplant recipients. The half-life of the pancreas graft currently averages 16.7 years, being the longest among extrarenal grafts, and substantially matching the one of renal grafts from deceased donors. The difference between expected (100 %) and actual insulin-independence rate is mostly explained by technical failure in the postoperative phase, and rejection in the long-term period. Death with a functioning graft remains a further major issue, especially in uremic patients who have undergone prolonged periods of dialysis. Refinements in graft preservation, surgical techniques, immunosuppression, and prophylactic treatments are expected to further improve the results of pancreas transplantation.

Comparison of 2 devices in pigs to induce hypothermia in laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplant

OBJECTIVES

To laparoscopically compare the effectiveness of 2 cooling devices for renal hypothermia and investigate the feasibility of laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplant using a pig model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eight pigs were divided into 2 groups of 4 animals each. Laparoscopic nephrectomy and autotransplant were performed first on only the right kidney. One week later, these procedures were performed on the left kidney, while the first transplanted autograft was removed. After 1 more week, the left autograft was removed for observation. In 1 group, the silicon tube cage was used to induce hypothermia during laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplant (silicon tube cage group), and in the other group, the plastic bag jacket was used to induce hypothermia during laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplant (plastic bag jacket group).

RESULTS

Two pigs in the silicon tube cage group survived for 7 days after the second autotransplant with serum creatinine levels of 210 μmol/L and 1010 μmol/L. One pig in the plastic bag jacket group survived for 5 days. The mean surface temperature of the grafts was maintained at 9°C ± 3°C and 12°C ± 3°C in the silicon tube cage and plastic bag jacket groups (P = .166). Three of 6 plastic bag jacket devices were ruptured by stitches or instruments. The mean venous and arterial anastomotic times in the silicon tube cage group were significantly shorter than were those in the plastic bag jacket group.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study shows that the silicon tube cage may be a reliable renal cooling device for use in laparoscopic kidney transplant and indicates the feasibility of laparoscopic orthotopic kidney transplant in pigs.