Alveolar bone loss in thymectomized golden hamsters

Immunosuppressive properties of Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans leukotoxin

Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans produces a leukotoxin that kills human polymorphonuclear cells (PMNs) and monocytes but not lymphocytes. In this study, we examined A. actinomycetemcomitans leukotoxin for its ability to alter human peripheral blood lymphocyte (HPBL) responsiveness. After a 90-min exposure to the leukotoxin, all monocytes were killed and HPBL responsiveness to mitogens and antigens was significantly inhibited. The ability of the leukotoxin to inhibit HPBL responses was not surprising, since monocytes and macrophages are required for many lymphocyte functions. However, we were unable to totally restore HPBL responsiveness when adherent autologous monocytes were added back to cultures of leukotoxin-treated lymphocytes. These studies demonstrate that A. actinomycetemcomitans leukotoxin may also exert nonlethal effects directly on lymphocytes. Furthermore, impaired lymphocyte function did not appear to be the result of indirect effects of products released by dying monocytes. Although it is not clear how A. actinomycetemcomitans acts to cause disease, several investigators have proposed that impaired host defenses may play a pivotal role. Several studies have demonstrated defects in PMN, monocyte, and lymphocyte function in patients with periodontal disease. These findings, along with the data presented in this paper, support the hypothesis that patients who harbor A. actinomycetemcomitans could suffer from local or systemic immune suppression. The effects of this suppression may be to enhance the pathogenicity of A. actinomycetemcomitans itself or that of some other opportunistic organism.

Immunologic dysfunction in the pathogenesis of periodontal diseases

Despite significant progress in our understanding of the pathogenesis and etiology of periodontal diseases, the nature and contribution of the immune system to this disorder remains unclear. Several studies provide evidence for either a protective or destructive rôle. These conflicting findings are difficult to reconcile, since most interpretations tend to argue for a static contributory rôle (i.e., either protective or destructive) of the immune system. Current theories on the rôle of the immune response do not address these conflicting findings as well as the contradictory observation of a detectable immune response in the face of persistent infection in these patients. In this article, we present a model, based on available data, for the contribution of the immune system to the pathogenesis of periodontal disease. This model ascribes a dynamic rôle for the immune response. As documented in other infectious diseases, it is entirely possible, for example, that a state of immunologic dysfunction may occur in the earliest stages of periodontal disease progression; this may then be followed by a period of active immune reactivity (humoral and/or cellular) that would represent either a delayed or depressed response. This model is discussed in conjunction with recent findings that several suspected periodontal pathogens are capable of producing immunosuppressive agents. Many of the apparently contradictory clinical observations concerning the host immune response to oral pathogens and its correlation (or lack of) with both the progression and severity of periodontal disease may be accounted for in this model.

Advances in understanding cell interactions in tissue resorption. Relevance to the pathogenesis of periodontal diseases and a new hypothesis

Much of the connective tissue degradation that takes place in periodontal diseases is mediated by proteolytic enzymes. Previous studies have focused on the action of proteinases released by invading polymorphonuclear neutrophils and macrophages, and bacterial enzymes. In view of recent work establishing that resident connective tissue cells can be induced by cytokines to bring about the destruction of their own matrix, we propose a new hypothesis. In this we envisage that a critical step is the interaction of bacterial antigens with inflammatory cells, resulting in the production of a cytokine, interleukin-1. Our interpretation of in vitro evidence is that the loss of connective tissue attachment and bone matrix resorption in periodontal diseases is mediated by metalloproteinases such as collagenase and stromelysin released by cells of the periodontium. Such proteolytic destruction can be induced by interleukin-1, whose production may not be dependent on a specific microbial flora but may be triggered by a number of organisms. It is now clear that interleukin-1 has multiple actions on both immune and non-immune cells; these include the induction of lymphocyte differentiation and proliferation and the stimulation of bone and cartilage resorption, and prostaglandin and metalloproteinase synthesis by connective tissues. It seems likely that further knowledge about the production and function of this cytokine will have an increasing impact in many diseases that involve resorption, particularly since interleukin-1-like molecules can be produced by cell types other than monocytes/macrophages, including keratinocytes and fibroblasts.

Periodontal bone loss and immune characteristics of congenitally athymic and thymus cell-reconstituted athymic rats

We investigated the ability to reconstitute the T-cell deficiency in congenitally athymic (nude; rnu/rnu) Rowett rats by intravenous injection of 10(7) heterozygous normal (rnu/+) rat thymus cells. The thymus cell-reconstituted animals showed essentially normal lymphocyte proliferation to phytohemagglutinin P and concanavalin A, normal spleen and lymph node T-lymphocyte distribution, and normal serum immunoglobulin G levels. These rats were used to study the effect of T-cell deficiency on periodontal disease. Animals with minimal oral flora were divided into three groups: nude, thymus cell-reconstituted nude, and normal rats. Immune response, gingival inflammation, and periodontal bone loss were examined in these animals. Less than 40% of the T cells recovered from the normal rat gingiva could be recovered from the nude rat gingiva. In contrast to the situation in normal or thymus cell-reconstituted rat gingiva, B cells were vastly predominant in the nude rat gingiva, with approximately four B cells for each T cell. There was increased periodontal bone loss in the nude rats compared with that in the normal rats. Thymus cell reconstitution of the nude rats was associated with decreased bone destruction. It is suggested that T cells have a regulatory function in relation to the potentially excessive B-cell response to abundant antigen and polyclonal activators in the oral cavity.

Host response in experimental periodontal disease

Experiments were performed to determine the role of the immune response in rat periodontal disease. Germ-free rats were fed defined antigen-free liquid diets or a diet containing ovalbumin(OVA) as a prototype antigen. The OVA-fed rats demonstrated increased gingival lymphocytes (mainly T at early times), OVA-sensitized spleen cells, and increased periodontal bone loss. In further studies, rats pre-sensitized with OVA, and receiving OVA in the diet, showed elevated IgG antibody, sensitized spleen cells, and elevated periodontal bone loss scores. The concept that bone loss was due to mixed hypersensitivity reaction is consistent with the periodontal pathology. The effects of pre-immunization with A. actinomycetemcomitans (Aa) on periodontal bone loss in Actinobacillus (Aa) - infected rats was examined. Delayed hypersensitivity (DTH) was present in immunized rats throughout the experimental period. Sham-immunized rats showed DTH after 30 days of infection. In addition, immunized rats showed elevated bone loss scores. These experiments support the contention that a combination of hypersensitivity reactions (i.e., mixed hypersensitivity to Aa) could give rise to the periodontal pathology observed. Congenitally athymic rats (nude) were shown to have more periodontal bone loss than did normal littermates. However, bone loss in thymus-cell reconstituted nude rats was not different from that in control rats. Normal rats receiving Aa-sensitized T lymphocytes prior to infection with Aa demonstrated increased DTH and periodontal bone loss. These studies support the concept that T-cell functions and thymic regulation of immune responses can exert protective and/or destructive effects in periodontal disease. In order to modify disease, it will be necessary to enhance the protective aspects of the immune response and to minimize the detrimental aspects.

A longitudinal study of periodontal disease in patients with reduced immunocapacity

The periodontal status of renal transplant patients on immunosuppressant drug therapy was compared with that of an age matched normal group over a period of 2 to 4 1/2 years. Gingival Index, Plaque Index, and Periodontal Destruction Index were used as measures of comparison. Over this period of time the Gingival Index of the immunosuppressed patients increased significantly when compared to the normals. There was a significant increase in the mean Plaque Index for both groups during the study period. The increase was greater in the immunosuppressed group. However, the difference in the Plaque Index for the two groups was not significant. There was little change in the Periodontal Destruction Index in both groups over time. The results of this study indicate that there is little difference in the rate of periodontal destruction between patients taking immunosuppressant drugs and normal patients. These findings, taken in conjunction with other recent reports, would seem to indicate that T cells play a minor role in the etiology of periodontal disease.