Promoter Activity and Chromosomal Location of the Rana rugosa P450 Aromatase (CYP19) Gene

Homology in Sex Determination in Two Distant Spiny Frogs, Nanorana quadranus and Quasipaa yei

Sex determination is remarkably diverse, with frequent transitions between sex chromosomes, in amphibians. Under these transitions, some chromosomes are more likely to be recurrently co-opted as sex chromosomes, as they are often observed across deeply divergent taxa. However, little is known about the pattern of sex chromosome evolution among closely related groups. Here, we examined sex chromosome and sex determination in two spiny frogs, Nanorana quadranus and Quasipaa yei. We conducted an analysis of genotyping-by-sequencing (GBS) data from a total of 34 individuals to identify sex-specific makers, with the results verified by PCR. The results suggest that chromosome 1 is a homologous sex chromosome with an XY pattern in both species. This chromosome has been evolutionarily conserved across these closely related groups within a period of time. The DMRT1 gene is proposed to be implicated in homology across two distantly related spiny frog species as a putative candidate sex-determining gene. Harboring the DMRT1 gene, chromosome 1 would have been independently co-opted for sex determination in deeply divergent groups of anurans.

Heterogeneous Evolution of Sex Chromosomes in the Torrent Frog Genus Amolops

In sharp contrast to birds and mammals, in numerous cold-blooded vertebrates, sex chromosomes have been described as homomorphic. This sex chromosome homomorphy has been suggested to result from the high turnovers often observed across deeply diverged clades. However, little is known about the tempo and mode of sex chromosome evolution among the most closely related species. Here, we examined the evolution of sex chromosome among nine species of the torrent frog genus Amolops. We analyzed male and female GBS and RAD-seq from 182 individuals and performed PCR verification for 176 individuals. We identified signatures of sex chromosomes involving two pairs of chromosomes. We found that sex-chromosome homomorphy results from both turnover and X–Y recombination in the Amolops species, which simultaneously exhibits heterogeneous evolution on homologous and non-homologous sex chromosomes. A low turnover rate of non-homologous sex chromosomes exists in these torrent frogs. The ongoing X–Y recombination in homologous sex chromosomes will act as an indispensable force in preventing sex chromosomes from differentiating.

Analyzing the gonadal transcriptome of the frog Hoplobatrachus rugulosus to identify genes involved in sex development

BACKGROUND

The tiger frog (Hoplobatrachus rugulosus) is listed as a national Class II protected species in China. In the context of global warming, the sex ratio of amphibians will be affected, and the development of the population will be limited. Therefore, considering the potential for a decrease in the number of amphibians, studying sex evolution and molecular regulation of gonadal development in H. rugulosus, phenomenon that are currently unclear, is of great significance.

RESULTS

Here, H. rugulosus was used to explore the mechanisms regulating gonadal development in amphibians. Illumina HiSeq 3000 was used to sequence the gonadal transcriptome of male and female H. rugulosus at two growth stages to identify genes related to gonadal development and analyze expression differences in the gonads. This analysis indicated that cyp17α, hsd3β, hsd11β1, cyp19α, and hsd17β12 perform vital functions in sex development in amphibians. Specifically, the expression of cyp3α, cyp17α, hsd3β, hsd11β1, sox2, sox9, sox30, soat, cyp19α, hsd17β12, and hspα1s was correlated with gonadal development and differentiation in H. rugulosus, as determined using the quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction.

CONCLUSION

Significant differences were found in the gonadal gene expression levels in H. rugulosus of both sexes, and we identified a steroid hormone synthesis pathway in this species and analyzed related gene expression, but the changes during sex differentiation were still unclear. To our knowledge, this report presents the first analysis of the H. rugulosus gonadal transcriptome and lays the foundation for future research.

Identification of critical sex-biased genes in Andrias davidianus by de novo transcriptome

The Chinese giant salamander Andrias davidianus is a protected amphibian with high nutritional and economic value. Understanding its sex determination mechanism is important for improving culture techniques and sex control in breeding. However, little information on the characterization of critical genes involved in sex is available. Herein, sequencing of ovary and test produced 40,783,222 and 46,128,902 raw reads, respectively, which were jointly assembled into 80,497 unigenes. Of these, 36,609 unigenes were annotated, of which 8907 were female-biased and 10,385 were male-biased. Several sex-related pathways were observed, including the Wnt signaling pathway. After elevated temperature and estrogen exposure, neomale and neofemale specimens were identified by a female-specific marker for the first time. RT-qPCR analysis showed the expression profile of ten selected sex-biased genes to be exhibited consistently in male and neomale and in female and neofemale, with the exception of the Amh and TfIIIa genes. Results suggested that these genes may play important roles in A. davidianus sex determination and gonad development. This provides a basis for further investigation of the molecular mechanisms of sex determination in amphibians.

Sex Reversal in Amphibians

Amphibians have been widely used to study developmental biology due to the fact that embryo development takes place independently of the maternal organism and that observations and experimental approaches are easy. Some amphibians like Xenopus became model organisms in this field. In the first part of this article, the differentiation of the gonads in amphibians and the mechanisms governing this process are reviewed. In the second part, the state of the art about sex reversal, which can be induced by steroid hormones in general and by temperature in some species, is presented. Also information about pollutants found in the environment that could interfere with the development of the amphibian reproductive apparatus or with their reproductive physiology is given. Such compounds could play a part in the amphibian decline, since in the wild, many amphibians are endangered species.

Sexually Dimorphic Expression of Foxl2 and Ftz-F1 in Chinese Giant Salamander Andrias Davidianus

Foxl2 and FTZ-F1 play a crucial role in the regulation of gonad development in fish and mammals, but studies of their function in amphibians are scarce. We isolated the full length of Foxl2 (adFoxl2) and Ftz-F1 (adFtz-f1) cDNA from the Chinese giant salamander Andrias davidianus and quantified its expression in various tissues and developing gonads. The adFoxl2 gene encodes 301aa including a conserved forkhead box, and the adFtz-f1 gene encodes 467aa containing an Ftz-F1 box. The amino acid sequences showed high homology with other amphibians. adFoxl2 expression was high in ovary, whereas adFtz-f1 was higher in testis, moderate in pituitary, ovary, and kidney; and low in the remaining tested tissues. Expression of adFoxl2 gradually increased from 1Y to 5Y in ovary, whereas adFtz-f1 expression gradually decreased in testis. In addition, adFoxl2 and adFtz-f1 were detected in granulosa cell in ovary and in spermatocytes in testis. The adFoxl2 transcription was inhibited in brain and ovary after treatment with methyltestosterone and with letrozole, whereas adFtz-f1 expression was upregulated. High-temperature suppressed the expression of adFxl2 in ovary and enhanced the transcription of adFtz-f1. These results suggest that adFoxl2 functioned in ovary differentiation, whereas adFtz-f1 played a role in testis development, which lays a foundation for study of the sex differentiation mechanism in A. davidianus.

Mechanisms of crosstalk between endocrine systems: regulation of sex steroid hormone synthesis and action by thyroid hormones

Thyroid hormones (THs) are well-known regulators of development and metabolism in vertebrates. There is increasing evidence that THs are also involved in gonadal differentiation and reproductive function. Changes in TH status affect sex ratios in developing fish and frogs and reproduction (e.g., fertility), hormone levels, and gonad morphology in adults of species of different vertebrates. In this review, we have summarized and compared the evidence for cross-talk between the steroid hormone and thyroid axes and present a comparative model. We gave special attention to TH regulation of sex steroid synthesis and action in both the brain and gonad, since these are important for gonad development and brain sexual differentiation and have been studied in many species. We also reviewed research showing that there is a TH system, including receptors and enzymes, in the brains and gonads in developing and adult vertebrates. Our analysis shows that THs influences sex steroid hormone synthesis in vertebrates, ranging from fish to pigs. This concept of crosstalk and conserved hormone interaction has implications for our understanding of the role of THs in reproduction, and how these processes may be dysregulated by environmental endocrine disruptors.

Epigenetic control of gonadal aromatase (cyp19a1) in temperature-dependent sex determination of red-eared slider turtles

In the red-eared slider turtle (Trachemys scripta), a species with temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), the expression of the aromatase gene during gonad development is strictly limited to the female-producing temperature. The underlying mechanism remains unknown. In this study, we identified the upstream 5'-flanking region of the aromatase gene, gonad-specific promoter, and the temperature-dependent DNA methylation signatures during gonad development in the red-eared slider turtle. The 5'-flanking region of the slider aromatase exhibited sequence similarities to the aromatase genes of the American alligator, chicken, quail, and zebra finch. A putative TATA box was located 31 bp upstream of the gonad-specific transcription start site. DNA methylation at the CpG sites between the putative binding sites of the fork head domain factor (FOX) and vertebrate steroidogenic factor 1 (SF1) and adjacent TATA box in the promoter region were significantly lower in embryonic gonads at the female-producing temperature compared the male-producing temperature. A shift from male- to female-, but not from female- to male-, producing temperature changed the level of DNA methylation in gonads. Taken together these results indicate that the temperature, particularly female-producing temperature, allows demethylation at the specific CpG sites of the promoter region which leads the temperature-specific expression of aromatase during gonad development.

Isolation and characterization of the CYP17A1 gene and its processed pseudogene in Rana rugosa

CYP17A1 expression is up-regulated in the gonad in Rana (Glandirana) rugosa tadpoles treated with androgens to induce female-to-male sex-reversal. In this study, we isolated the CYP17A1 gene and its processed pseudogene from R. rugosa. The former was found to consist of 8 exons, and the latter a single-exon gene, designated CYP17A1P. The sequence of the promoter region of CYP17A1 differed from that of CYP17A1P. We found several consensus binding-sites for candidate transcription factors including androgen receptor (AR), Sox and FoxL2 in the CYP17A1 promoter region, but an AR-binding site was absent from CYP17A1P. When AR was over-expressed in Xenopus A6 cells, it did not increase CYP17A1 transcription in luciferase assays. CYP17A1 was strongly expressed in indifferent male gonads during sex determination and exclusively in testis, among eight adult tissues of R. rugosa. By contrast, CYP17A1P was expressed at very low, and similar levels in the adult tissues of both sexes. Fluorescent In-Situ Hybridization (FISH) analysis showed that CYP17A1P is localized to chromosome 4, while CYP17A1 is on chromosome 9. These results collectively suggest that CYP17A1, but not CYP17A1P is involved in male sex-determination in R. rugosa, and that androgens may not have a direct effect on the CYP17A1 transcription.

The mechanism of sex determination in vertebrates-are sex steroids the key-factor?

In many vertebrate species, sex is determined at fertilization of zygotes by sex chromosome composition, knows as genotypic sex determination (GSD). But in some species-fish, amphibians and reptiles-sex is determined by environmental factors; in particular by temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD). However, little is known about the mechanisms involved in TSD and GSD. How does TSD differ from GSD? As is well known, genes that activated downstream of sex-determining genes are conserved throughout all classes of vertebrates. What is the main factor that determines sex, then? Sex steroids can reverse sex of several species of vertebrate; estrogens induce the male-to-female sex-reversal, whereas androgens do the female-to-male sex-reversal. For such sex-reversal, a functioning sex-determining gene is not required. However, in R. rugosa CYP19 (P450 aromatase) is expressed at high levels in indifferent gonads before phenotypic sex determination, and the gene is also active in the bipotential gonad of females before sex determination. Thus, we may predict that an unknown factor, a common transcription factor locates on the X and/or W chromosome, intervenes directly or indirectly in the transcriptional up-regulation of the CYP19 gene for feminization in species of vertebrates with both TSD and GSD. Similarly, an unknown factor on the Z and/or Y chromosome probably intervenes directly or indirectly in the regulation of androgen biosynthesis for masculinization. In both cases, a sex-determining gene is not always necessary for sex determination. Taken together, sex steroids may be the key-factor for sex determination in some species of vertebrates.

Expression pattern, cellular localization and promoter activity analysis of ovarian aromatase (Cyp19a1a) in protogynous hermaphrodite red-spotted grouper

Aromatase plays a key role in sex differentiation of gonads. In this study, we cloned the full-length cDNA of ovarian aromatase from protogynous hermaphrodite red-spotted grouper (Epinephelus akaara), and prepared the corresponding anti-EaCyp19a1a antiserum. Western blot and immunofluorescence studies revealed ovary-specific expression pattern of EaCyp19a1a in adults and its dynamic expression change during artificial sex reversal. EaCyp19a1a was expressed by follicular cells of follicular layer around oocytes because strong EaCyp19a1a immunofluorescence was observed in the cells of ovaries. During artificial sex reversal, EaCyp19a1a expression dropped significantly from female to male, and almost no any positive EaCyp19a1a signal was observed in testicular tissues. Then, we cloned and sequenced a total of 1967 bp 5'-flanking sequence of EaCyp19a1a promoter, and showed a number of potential binding sites for some transcriptional factors, such as SOX5, GATA gene family, CREB, AP1, FOXL1, C/EBP, ARE and SF-1. Moreover, we prepared a series of 5' deletion promoter constructs and performed in vitro luciferase assays of EaCyp19a1a promoter activities. The data indicated that the CREB regulation region from -1010 to -898 might be a major cis-acting element to EaCyp19a1a promoter, whereas the elements GATA and SOX5 in the region from -1216 to -1010 might be suppression elements. Significantly, we found a common conserved sequence region in the fish ovary-type aromatase promoters with identities from 93% to 34%. And, the motifs of TATA box, SF-1, SOX5, and CREB existed in the region and were conserved among the most of fish species.

Sox3: a transcription factor for Cyp19 expression in the frog Rana rugosa

Cyp19 is expressed at a high level in the gonad of the female tadpole of the frog Rana rugosa during sex determination. To identify sequence elements important for expression of Cyp19, we isolated a genomic clone (approximately 40 kbp) carrying R. rugosa Cyp19 and analyzed the nucleotide sequence of the 5'-flanking region to search for potential transcription factor binding sites. Sox (SRY-related HMG box) protein and Sf1 binding sites were found in the ovary-specific promoter region of Cyp19. Because Sox3 is located on the sex chromosome in R. rugosa, we conducted the luciferase reporter assay in Xenopus A6 cells using the promoter region. Sox3 drove the reporter gene in the cells, but Sf1 did not. When sequential deletion of the 2.7 kbp Cyp19-promoter region was undertaken, a fragment spanning nucleotides -191 to +48 was sufficient to drive the transcription of the reporter gene. In site-directed mutagenesis, the binding site at -57 in the region was critical for Sox3 responsiveness. Sox3 lacking the HMG box had no ability to promote Cyp19 transcription. In addition, a chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) assay showed that DNA fragments were enriched 8-fold, as determined by real-time PCR, when chromatin was immunoprecipitated with the anti-His antibody against His-tagged Sox3. The results, taken together, suggest that Sox3 activates Cyp19 transcription by its direct binding to the binding site of the Cyp19 promoter region. Sox3 appears to be a factor that directs indifferent gonads to develop into an ovary in R. rugosa.

Molecular cloning and gene expression of Foxl2 in the frog Rana rugosa

Foxl2 is a transcription factor that plays a crucial role in the regulation of the early development of the female gonad in mammals and fish. However, little is known regarding its role in ovarian differentiation in amphibians. In this study, we isolated a Foxl2 cDNA from the ovary of the frog Rana rugosa and Xenopuslaevis and examined its expression during gonadal sex differentiation in R. rugosa. Alignment of known Foxl2 sequences from vertebrates showed high identity of the Foxl2 open reading frame and protein sequences, in particular the forkhead domain and C-terminal region, with other vertebrate sequences. Among different adult tissues, Foxl2 was expressed at its highest level in the ovary. Real-time RT-PCR analysis showed that Foxl2 expression was sexually dimorphic during gonadal sex differentiation in R. rugosa. In addition, Foxl2, which was detected immunochemically in somatic cells surrounding oocytes in the ovary, promoted R. rugosaCYP19 transcription in luciferase promoter assays conducted in A6 cells. We also found by FISH analysis that Foxl2 was an autosomal gene. Altogether, these results suggest that Foxl2 probably plays a very important role in ovarian differentiation of R. rugosa by possibly regulating CYP19 expression. The factor that up-regulates Foxl2 expression in female gonads still remains to be identified.

Immunohistochemical detection and biological activities of CYP17 (P450c17) in the indifferent gonad of the frog Rana rugosa

Sex steroids play a crucial role in the gonad differentiation in various species of vertebrates. However, little is known regarding the localization and biological activity of steroid-metabolizing enzymes during gonadal sex differentiation in amphibians. In the present study, we showed by real-time RT-PCR analysis that the expression of CYP17, one of the key steroidogenic enzymes, was higher in the indifferent gonad during sex differentiation in male than in female tadpoles of Rana rugosa but that there was no difference detected in the 3betaHSD mRNA level between the male and female gonads. We next examined the localization of CYP17, 3betaHSD and 17betaHSD in the indifferent and differentiating gonads by using three kinds of antibodies specific for CYP17, 3betaHSD and 17betaHSD, respectively. Positive signals for CYP17, 3betaHSD and 17betaHSD were observed in somatic cells of the indifferent gonad of males and in the interstitial cell of the testis. The enzymatic activity of CYP17 was also examined in the gonad during sex differentiation in this species. [(3)H]Progesterone (Prog) was converted to [(3)H]androstenedione (AE) in the indifferent gonad in males and females, but the rate of its conversion was higher in males than in females. Moreover, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis revealed that the CYP17 gene was located on the q arm of chromosome 9, indicating that CYP17 was autosomal in R. rugosa. Taken together, the results demonstrate that the CYP17 protein is synthesized in somatic cells of the indifferent gonad during gonadal sex differentiation in R. rugosa and that it is more active in converting Prog to AE in males than in females. The data suggest that CYP17 may be involved in testicular formation during sex differentiation in this species.

Sex determination in amphibians

The heterogametic sex is male in all mammals, whereas it is female in almost all birds. By contrast, there are two heterogametic types (XX/XY and ZZ/ZW) for genetic sex determination in amphibians. Though the original heterogametic sex was female in amphibians, the two heterogametic types were probably interchangeable, suggesting that sex chromosomes evolved several times in this lineage. Indeed, the frog Rana rugosa has the XX/XY and ZZ/ZW sex-determining systems within a single species, depending on the local population in Japan. The XY and ZW geographic forms with differentiated sex chromosomes probably have a common origin as undifferentiated sex chromosomes resulted from the hybridization between the primary populations of West Japan and Kanto forms. It is clear that the sex chromosomes are still undergoing evolution in this species group. Regardless of the presence of a sex-determining gene in amphibians, the gonadal sex of some species can be changed by sex steroids. Namely, sex steroids can induce the sex reversal, with estrogens inducing the male-to-female sex reversal, whereas androgens have the opposite effect. In R. rugosa, gonadal activity of CYP19 (P450 aromatase) is correlated with the feminization of gonads. Of particular interest is that high levels of CYP19 expression are observed in indifferent gonads at time before sex determination. Increases in the expression of CYP19 in female gonads and CYP17 (P450 17alpha-hydroxylase/C17-20 lyase) in male gonads suggest that the former plays an important role in phenotypic female determination, whereas the latter is needed for male determination. Thus, steroids could be the key factor for sex determination in R. rugosa. In addition to the role of sex steroids in gonadal sex determination in this species, Foxl2 and Sox3 are capable of promoting CYP19 expression. Since both the genes are autosomal, another factor up-regulating CYP19 expression must be recruited. The factor, which may be located on the X or W chromosome, intervenes directly or indirectly, in the transcriptional regulation of the CYP19 gene for feminization in amphibians. A factor up-regulating CYP17 expression remains to be identified.

Steroidogenic gene expression during sex determination in the frog Rana rugosa

Rana rugosa is unique among frog species in that it has two distinct types of sex chromosomes in two separate forms (XX/XY and ZZ/ZW). Treatment with sex steroids can reverse its gender from female to male or male to female. This phenomenon makes it a novel model for studying gonadal differentiation. The physiological role of sex steroids in sex differentiation in amphibians is yet unclear, however. To address this issue, we cloned the cDNAs of 17betaHSD types 8 (17betaHSD8) and 12 (17betaHSD12), 5alpha-reductase type 1 (5alphaRed1), and the steroidogenic acute regulatory protein known as StAR in the steroidogenic pathway. Then, we measured the mRNA levels of these genes during sex differentiation by real-time RT-PCR. The levels of CYP11A1, 3betaHSD, CYP17 and CYP19 mRNA were also measured by real-time RT-PCR. As a result, we detected transcripts of all such genes except for that of 17betaHSD8 in the indifferent gonad before the onset of sex determination. The expression of CYP17 occurred in indifferent gonads in both sexes; and its transcript levels were much higher in the male gonads. By contrast, the levels for CYP19 were much higher in the female gonads. CYP11A1, 3betaHSD, 17betaHSD12, 5alphaRed1 and StAR showed no sexually dimorphic expression during gonadal sex differentiation. Taken together, the results suggest that CYP17 has a major influence on testis development and that CYP19 plays a similar role in ovary development. However, the factors that up-regulate their expression remain to be identified.

Differential display analysis of gene expression in female-to-male sex-reversing gonads of the frog Rana rugosa

Sex steroids play pivotal roles in gonadal differentiation in many species of vertebrates. The sex can be reversed from female to male by testosterone in the Japanese wrinkled frog Rana rugosa, but it is still unclear what genes are up- or down-regulated during the XX sex-reversal in this species. To search the genes for the female-to-male sex-reversal, we employed differential display and 5'/3'-RACE. Consequently, we isolated from the gonads at day 8 after testosterone injection 24 different cDNA fragments showing a testosterone treatment-related change and then obtained three full-length cDNAs, which we termed Zfp64, Zfp112, and Rrp54. The former two cDNAs encoded different proteins with zinc-finger domains, whereas the latter cDNA encoded an unknown protein. Transcripts of the three genes were hardly detectable in the sex-reversing gonads at day 24 after the injection; at this time few growing oocytes were observed in the sex-reversing gonad. Besides, in situ hybridization analysis showed positive signals of the three genes in the cytoplasm of growing oocytes of an ovary when testosterone was injected into a tadpole. Thus, the decrease in expression of these three genes was probably due to the disappearance of growing oocytes and not to their direct involvement in the testis formation. To find the key-gene for testis formation, it will be necessary to analyze, by the differential display method, more genes showing a change in expression pattern during sex reversal.

Elevated expression of P450c17 (CYP17) during testicular formation in the frog

Sex steroids play decisive roles in gonadal differentiation in many species of vertebrates. The sex can be changed by sex steroids in some species of amphibians, but the mechanism of the sex-reversal is largely unknown. In this study, we cloned and characterized 3 cDNAs encoding sex steroid-synthesizing enzymes, i.e., CYP11A1, CYP17 and 3beta-HSD from the frog Rana rugosa. RT-PCR analysis showed that the CYP17 expression was much higher in male gonads than in female ones during sex determination in R. rugosa, whereas CYP11A1 and 3beta-HSD showed no sexually dimorphic expression. When testosterone was injected into tadpoles for female-to-male sex reversal, CYP17 expression appeared to be very strong in the gonad at days 16 and 24 after injection of testosterone. CYP11A1 was also transcribed higher at day 16, but its expression was weaker when compared with that of CYP17. The expression of 3beta-HSD did not change during the sex reversal. In addition, in situ hybridization analysis revealed that CYP17 was expressed in somatic cells of the indifferent male gonad and in those of the testis. Positive signals of CYP17 were also produced in somatic cells of a female-to-male sex-reversed gonad (testis) at days 16 and 24 post testosterone injection, but not in the ovary. Taken together, the results suggest that CYP17 is very involved in testicular differentiation of the gonad in R. rugosa.

The absence of a functional nuclear receptor element A (NREA) in the promoter II of the aromatase P450 gene in rabbit granulosa cells

Aromatase protein is synthesized in response to gonadotropins that activate expression of their target genes via the cAMP second messenger system. The -882/+103 bp region of the rabbit ovarian promoter (PII) was ligated to a luciferase vector and transfected into granulosa cells to elucidated the mechanism by which cAMP stimulates transcription. Deletions and mutational experiments indicate that (i) a cAMP-response element-like sequence (CLS) present at -208 to -200 bp is the main element required for the activation of the rabbit PII by cAMP and that (ii) both nuclear receptor element sites; NREA (-133/-126 bp) and NREB (-188/-181 bp) do not participate to the cAMP-dependent activity of the PII. The replacement of the specific rabbit NREA site by the human NREA site increases two-fold the cAMP response and indicates that trans-activating factors are present in rabbit granulosa cells. This study shows for the first time an efficient aromatase transcription occurs in granulosa cells in absence of a consensus NREA site. In addition a comparative study has been performed on the sheep aromatase promoter where sites deviate from rabbit. Mutagenesis experiments suggest that some of them are involved in the cAMP-induced response of the rabbit PII.