A Rare Adult Case with Diffuse Segmental Membranous Glomerulonephritis

Diagnostic and prognostic significance of extent of subepithelial electron dense deposits in membranous glomerulonephritis

There are limited data concerning the range and diagnostic significance of the extent of subepithelial electron dense deposits (SEEDD) in membranous glomerulonephritis (MGN). We described the range, and assessed the diagnostic and prognostic significance of extent of SEEDD, particularly in patients with sparse SEEDD, where diagnostic difficulty can arise. Adult renal biopsies with a confident or suspected histological diagnosis of MGN between 2013 and 2020 were included. Patients were classified based on extent of SEEDD as having either global MGN (GMGN, >75% SEEDD), segmental MGN (SMGN, 25%-75% SEEDD), or sparse-SEEDD (<25% SEEDD). Clinical and other features were compared. One hundred and eleven (74%) patients had GMGN; 23 (15%) had SMGN; and 16 (11%) had sparse-SEEDD. Patients with sparse-SEEDD had a significantly shorter duration of nephrotic syndrome prior to biopsy. 53% of patients with GMGN and 14% with SMGN had serum anti-phospholipase A2 receptor (PLA2r) antibodies. Patients with sparse-SEEDD did not have anti-PLA2r antibodies. Urine protein:creatinine ratio was significantly lower in sparse-SEEDD patients after 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. The proportion of sparse-SEEDD patients in complete remission from nephrotic range proteinuria at 6 and 12 months was significantly higher than that of GMGN patients. Analysis of a subgroup suggested sparse-SEEDD patients responded more rapidly to steroid containing immunosuppression than GMGN patients. There is a wide range of extent of SEEDD in patients with MGN. Sparse-SEEDD appears distinct from SMGN and GMGN and may be either an early form of MGN, or an epiphenomenon associated with another primary disease process, particularly minimal change disease.

Segmental membranous nephropathy

Most cases of membranous nephropathy (MGN) present with global and diffuse distribution of subepithelial deposits. However, segmental MGN, in which there is focal or diffuse segmental subepithelial deposits, are occasionally encountered. The clinical and pathologic significance of segmental MGN is not well understood and thought to be more likely due to either early or resolving phase of the global form of MGN. Several case reports and literature available suggest that it may be a manifestation of secondary causes based on pathologic features such as presence of C1q and mesangial deposits, extra-glomerular deposits involving tubular basement membranes, absence of PLA2R and THSD7A, IgG1 and IgG3 subclass dominance, and the presence of other co-existing renal disease. Other reports, however, suggest that some of these cases may be a variant of the primary form of MGN. In this review, we integrate what is known about segmental MGN in order to better direct interpretation of renal biopsies in which it is identified.

The clinicopathologic spectrum of segmental membranous glomerulopathy

Membranous glomerulopathy (MGN) is characterized by global subepithelial immune deposits that stain most intensely by immunofluorescence for IgG. Here we describe the clinical and pathologic findings in a cohort of patients with MGN in which, by definition, only segmental immune deposits are present. This rare variant, termed segmental MGN (sMGN), is poorly characterized. We retrospectively identified all patients with sMGN diagnosed at Columbia University from January 2010 to October 2018, excluding those with systemic lupus erythematosus. Data on presenting features, pathologic findings, and outcomes were collected. Fifty cases of sMGN were identified, representing 2.5% of MGN. In 21 of 50 biopsies, there was an alternative, predominant disease process. The remaining 29 patients with isolated sMGN had a median creatinine of 0.97 mg/dl, median 24-hour urine protein 3.1 g/day, and 32% had nephrotic syndrome. Staining for NELL-1 (a protein kinase C binding protein) was positive in five of 17 cases. Staining for PLA2R, THSD7A, and exostosin 1 (autoantigens in primary MGN) was negative in all biopsies evaluated. Ultrastructural evaluation revealed predominantly early stage sMGN (stage 1 or 1-2 in 14/29). Follow-up was available for 21 of the 29 patients with isolated sMGN (median 12 months), including seven who received immunosuppression (primarily glucocorticoids). During follow-up, 86% had stable/improved kidney function and 45% achieved complete while 15% achieved partial remission. Among the 15 patients with isolated sMGN without full nephrotic syndrome, only two received immunosuppression; nonetheless, 50% achieved complete while 21% achieved partial remission. Thus, sMGN is a rare PLA2R-negative variant of MGN with 29% NELL-1 positivity and favorable prognosis, even in the absence of immunosuppressive treatment.