Titanium aneurysm clips: mechanical characteristics and clinical trial

[Completeness of brain aneurysm exclusion according to CT angiography]

OBJECTIVE

To develop a classification of the completeness of brain aneurysm exclusion according to CT angiography for determining further diagnostic and curative strategy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The study included 138 patients who had 164 brain aneurysms. Clipping was carried out at the Burdenko Neurosurgery Center in 2013-2017. Titanium clips were used in 111 cases, cobalt clips - in 53 patients.

RESULTS

Completeness of brain aneurysm exclusion was assessed in 149 cases using CT angiography. In 15 cases, artifacts from cobalt clips impaired assessment. Total exclusion was achieved in 136 (91.3%) cases, subtotal (a remainder of residual neck) - in 10 (6.7%) cases, complete exclusion of the body and bottom (patent neck) - 2 (1.3%) patients, partial exclusion (partially patent bottom) - 1 patient (0.7%). In this series, a clip prevented complete contrast enhancement of brain aneurysm bottom in all cases.

CONCLUSION

CTA is a reliable method for assessing the quality of exclusion of brain aneurysm in patients with implanted titanium clips. In case of cobalt clips, stratification depending on severity of CT artifacts should be performed for data interpretation. In some cases, artifacts impair visualization of the vessels adjacent to the clips. In these patients, direct cerebral angiography or dual-energy computed tomography scanners with metal artifact suppression programs should be recommended.

Follow-up is recommended for patients with remnants of residual cervix. Redo surgery is indicated for completely patent neck, as well as partial or complete contrast enhancement of aneurysm bottom.

An Investigation Into the Challenges of Using Metal Additive Manufacturing for the Production of Patient-Specific Aneurysm Clips

Cerebral aneurysm clips are biomedical implants applied by neurosurgeons to re-approximate arterial vessel walls and prevent catastrophic aneurysmal hemorrhages in patients. Current methods of aneurysm clip production are labor intensive and time-consuming, leading to high costs per implant and limited variability in clip morphology. Metal additive manufacturing is investigated as an alternative to traditional manufacturing methods that may enable production of patient-specific aneurysm clips to account for variations in individual vascular anatomy and possibly reduce surgical complication risks. Relevant challenges to metal additive manufacturing are investigated for biomedical implants, including material choice, design limitations, postprocessing, printed material properties, and combined production methods. Initial experiments with additive manufacturing of 316 L stainless steel aneurysm clips are carried out on a selective laser melting (SLM) system. The dimensions of the printed clips were found to be within 0.5% of the dimensions of the designed clips. Hardness and density of the printed clips (213 ± 7 HV1 and 7.9 g/cc, respectively) were very close to reported values for 316 L stainless steel, as expected. No ferrite and minimal porosity is observed in a cross section of a printed clip, with some anisotropy in the grain orientation. A clamping force of approximately 1 N is measured with a clip separation of 1.5 mm. Metal additive manufacturing shows promise for use in the creation of custom aneurysm clips, but some of the challenges discussed will need to be addressed before clinical use is possible.

Vascular assessment after clipping surgery using four-dimensional CT angiography

Recent advances in computed tomography angiography (CTA) enable repeated imaging follow up for post-clipping surgery. The purpose of this study was to clarify the critical volume and configuration of the aneurysmal clip in the postoperative evaluation using volume rendering (VR) imaging, and present four-dimensional (4D)-CTA for these larger metal artifacts. A total of 44 patients with cerebral aneurysm, treated using clipping surgery, were included in this study. The metal artifact volume was assessed using CTA and the association between the type of clips and its metal artifact volume was analyzed. A VR image and a 4D-CTA were then produced, and the diagnostic accuracy of arteries around the clip or residual aneurysm on these images was evaluated. In the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis, the cutoff value for metal artifacts was 2.32 mm³ as determined through a VR image. Patients were divided into two groups. Group 1 included patients with a simple and small clip, and group 2 included patients with multiple, large or fenestrated clips. The metal artifact volume was significantly larger in group 2, and the group incorporated the cutoff value. Post-clipping status on the VR image was significantly superior in group 1 compared with group 2. In group 2, the imaging quality of post-clipping status on 4D-CTA was superior in 92.9% of patients. The metal artifact volume was dependent on the number, size, or configuration of the clip used. In group 2, evaluation using a 4D-CTA eliminated the effect of the metal artifacts.

Quantitative Analysis of Factors Affecting Cobalt Alloy Clip Artifacts in Computed Tomography

Objective

Clip artifacts limit the visualization of intracranial structures in CT scans from patients after aneurysmal clipping with cobalt alloy clips. This study is to analyze the parameters influencing the degree of clip artifacts.

Methods

Postoperative CT scans of 60 patients with straight cobalt alloy-clipped aneurysms were analyzed for the maximal diameter of white artifacts and the angle and number of streak artifacts in axial images, and the maximal diameter of artifacts in three-dimensional (3-D) volume-rendered images. The correlation coefficient (CC) was determined between each clip artifact type and the clip blade length and clip orientation to the CT scan (angle a, lateral clip inclination in axial images; angle b, clip gradient to scan plane in lateral scout images).

Results

Angle b correlated negatively with white artifacts (r=-0.589, p<0.001) and positively with the angle (r=0.636, p<0.001) and number (r=0.505, p<0.001) of streak artifacts. Artifacts in 3-D images correlated with clip blade length (r=0.454, p=0.004). Multiple linear regression analysis revealed that angle b was the major parameter influencing white artifacts and the angle and number of streak artifacts in axial images (p<0.001), whereas clip blade length was a major factor in 3-D images (p=0.034).

Conclusion

Use of a clip orientation perpendicular to the scan gantry angle decreased the amount of white artifacts and allowed better visualization of the clip site.

Mechanical evaluation of long titanium alloy clip--comparison of cobalt alloy clip

Long titanium aneurysm clips have recently been released. In the present study, comparative study of long titanium and cobalt alloy clips was performed. Two kinds of Sugita long clips (straight clips of 25- and 35-mm blade length) made of titanium and cobalt alloys were tested by measuring the closing force, the anti-scissoring torque, and the maximum opening width. There were some differences between the two materials. In the 25-mm blade length clip, closing force and maximum opening width of titanium alloy clip were greater than those of cobalt alloy clip. By contrast, the anti-scissoring torque of 35-mm blade length titanium clip was stronger than that of the cobalt. The long titanium clips would have equivalent endurance to long cobalt clip and are safe for clinical use.

Benchtop testing and comparisons among three types of through-the-scope endoscopic clipping devices

BACKGROUND

Through-the-scope (TTS) endoscopic clipping devices are widely used. No benchtop testing or direct comparisons of these endoclips have been performed to show their rotational ability and inherent mechanical strengths during closure and after deployment. This study aimed to provide benchtop data that can be used to guide clinical applications and to promote future device research and development.

METHODS

Benchtop testing and comparisons were performed for three groups of TTS clips: QuickClip2 long, resolution, and instinct clips. The main outcome measurements were device-in-endoscope retroflection angles (DIERA), opening strength, "snapping" force of acute clip closure, and neoprene pulling strength.

RESULTS

The achievable gastroscope DIERA was 10° for QuickClip2, 3° for the resolution clip, and 10° for the instinct clip. The QuickClip and the Instinct clip rotated almost equally well under all endoscope configurations, including endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP). With or without a sheath, the resolution clip lacked the ability to rotate. During clip opening force testing (the amount of force required to force open the jaws of a deployed clip by 3.2 mm; 3.2 mm was chosen due to the standard dimension of the gauge used for the measurement), the Instinct clips were the strongest. For the Instinct clips, an opening force of 404 ± 124 g was needed to open the closed clip, and an additional 386 ± 133 g was required to open the clip jaws to 3.2 mm. In terms of snapping force during acute closure and neoprene pulling strength, the instinct and resolution clips performed almost equally. The limitations of the study were the benchtop testing and the finite sample size for closing and pulling strength comparisons.

CONCLUSIONS

The QuickClip2 and the Instinct clip rotate equally well under different endoscope configurations. The resolution clips lack rotational ability. The instinct clips are stronger mechanically than the other two TTS clips. Stronger clips are perhaps associated with higher therapeutic efficacy and retention rates.

The new aneurysm clip system for particularly complex aneurysm surgery: technical note

BACKGROUND

Currently, there is an ongoing debate regarding the best treatment option for ruptured aneurysms. The International Subarachnoid Aneurysm Trial study suggests that an endovascular procedure is the best treatment. In some complex cases, or in patients with an additional large intracerebral hemorrhage, aneurysms require further microsurgical clipping.

OBJECTIVE

We introduce a new clip system to improve clipping procedures in especially complex aneurysms.

METHODS

The inverted opening mechanism of the clip in combination with the special clip applier provides the surgeon with a good overview in the operating field. The new design also enables a wider opening of the clip jaws in contrast to all other well-known titanium aneurysm clips. This should provide a better and safer application and decrease the danger of premature rupture.

RESULTS

From January 2006 to July 2008, 55 aneurysms were clipped in 45 patients. The most common aneurysm location was the anterior communicating artery (20 patients) followed by the M1 segment of the middle cerebral artery (16 patients). Four patients had 2, one had 3, and one had 5 aneurysms. Two clipping procedures were performed for an arteriovenous malformation-associated aneurysm. All aneurysms were clipped without any technical complication.

CONCLUSION

The use of the new clip system, especially in complex aneurysm surgery, has potential benefits because of the better surgical vision during clip application and the wider opening of the clip jaws. It is easy to handle and compatible with magnetic resonance imaging.

Computed tomographic angiography in the evaluation of clip placement for intracranial aneurysm

BACKGROUND

Computed tomographic angiography (CTA) has been shown to reliably detect aneurysms pre-operatively. The aim of this study was to compare the ability of post-operative CTA to detect aneurysmal remnants in connection with clip placement compared with digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Furthermore, special attention was paid to identifying factors influencing the image quality of CTA.

METHOD

Between January 2005 and January 2006 a total of 76 patients with intracranial aneurysms were treated in our department. Thirty-two patients with a total of 33 clipped aneurysm were included in this study. All patients underwent CTA and DSA after surgery. Two investigators, each blinded to the classifications of the other, assessed image quality and clip placement.

FINDINGS

In three patients aneurysmal remnants could be detected with CTA and DSA. One 2-mm aneurysmal remnant was not clearly identified on CTA; two small (<2-mm) aneurysmal remnants were definitely not seen on CTA. A single titanium clip was used for aneurysmal clipping in 26 patients, two clips were needed in six patients and one aneurysm required three clips being used. Overall, use of one titanium clip tended to result in better image quality. In addition, clip-gantry angles between 30 degrees and 60 degrees tended to yield better image quality.

CONCLUSION

Post-operatively, CTA can be recommended as a reliable non-invasive diagnostic tool only with optimal image quality and with this criterion up to 66% of the aneurysms can be evaluated. Titanium artefacts, especially in the important zone (<2 mm) around the clip in which small aneurysmal remnants can occur, can render adequate evaluation impossible. CTA image quality depends on the number of titanium clips used, but clip-gantry-angle does not significantly influence the image quality.

Limitations of three-dimensional reconstructed computerized tomography angiography after clip placement for intracranial aneurysms

Object. The authors compared the usefulness of three-dimensional (3D) reconstructed computerized tomography (CT) angiography with 3D digital subtraction (DS) angiography in assessing intracranial aneurysms after clip placement. A retrospective review of clinical cases was performed.

Methods. Between May 2001 and May 2003, 17 patients with a total of 20 intracranial aneurysms underwent 3D CT and 3D DS angiography following clip placement. The authors assessed the presence or absence of residual aneurysm necks and stenoocclusive changes in the parent artery and the neighboring artery. The efficacy of CT angiographic visualization was also evaluated.

In 12 of the 20 aneurysms, both 3D modalities similarly demonstrated the residual aneurysm neck and stenoocclusive changes in the parent artery and neighboring artery. Three-dimensional CT angiography failed to demonstrate three of the aneurysms, and the studies were not considered suitable for evaluation because of the presence of metallic artifacts. In the remaining five studies, the 3D CT angiograms did not effectively demonstrate the neighboring and parent arteries. The detectability of residual aneurysm necks was correlated with the clip material and with the number of clips applied.

Conclusions. Three-dimensional DS angiography is still necessary in cases involving multiple clips or with cobalt alloy clips because the clips appear as metal artifacts on 3D CT angiography.

Endurance of aneurysm clips: mechanical endurance of Yaşargil and Spetzler titanium aneurysm clips

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether repeated use weakens titanium aneurysm clips, making them unsafe for clinical use.

METHODS

Nine Yaşargil (titanium alloy) and five Spetzler (pure titanium) clips were subjected to clinically relevant maneuvers, and the effects on the closing force were assessed. Clips were considered unsafe if 1) the blades crossed, 2) the clips failed to close completely, or 3) the blood pressure could open them.

RESULTS

Yaşargil and Spetzler clips significantly (P < 0.01 for both) weakened, by 18.9% and 26.1%, respectively, after 10 minutes of sustained maximal opening. After 100 open-close cycles, Spetzler clips showed no change in closing force, but the closing force of Yaşargil clips decreased significantly (P < 0.01), by a further 12.0%.

CONCLUSION

Repeated use weakens Spetzler and Yaşargil clips. All Spetzler and all but one Yaşargil clips were deemed safe for clinical use at the end of the experiments.