Effects of organ dose modulation applied to a part of the scan range on radiation dose in computed tomography of the body

In computed tomography (CT), organ dose modulation (ODM) reduces radiation exposure from the anterior side to reduce radiation dose received by the radiosensitive organs located anteriorly. We investigated the effects of ODM applied to a part of the scan range on radiation dose in body CT. The thorax and thoraco-abdominopelvic region of an anthropomorphic whole-body phantom were imaged with and without ODM. ODM was applied to various regions, and the tube current modulation curves were compared. Additionally, the dose indices were compared with and without ODM in thoracic and thoraco-abdominopelvic CTs in 800 patients. ODM was applied to the thyroid in male patients and to the thyroid and breast in female patients. In phantom imaging of the thorax, the application of ODM below the scan range decreased the tube current, and that to the breast showed a further decrease. Decreased tube current was also observed in phantom imaging of the thoraco-abdominopelvic regions with ODM below the scan range, and the application of ODM to the whole scan range, thyroid, breast, and both thyroid and breast further reduced the tube current in the region to which ODM was applied. In patient imaging, the dose indices were significantly lower with ODM than without ODM, regardless of the scan range or sex. The absolute reduction in dose-length product was larger for thoraco-abdominopelvic CT (male, 43.2 mGy cm; female, 59.7 mGy cm) than for thoracic CT (male, 30.8 mGy cm; female, 37.6 mGy cm) in both sexes, indicating dose reduction in the abdominopelvic region to which ODM was not applied. In conclusion, The application of ODM in body CT reduces radiation dose not only in the region to which ODM is applied but also outside the region. In radiation dose management, it should be considered that even ODM applied to a limited region affects the dose indices.

Multicentric characterization of organ-based tube current modulation in head computed tomography: A dosimetric and image quality study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the efficiency of organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) in head Computed Tomography (CT) for different radiology departments and manufacturers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five CT scanners from four radiology departments were evaluated in this study. All scans were performed using a standard and a routine head protocol. A scintillating fiber optic detector was placed directly on the gantry to measure the tube exit kerma. Image quality was quantified on a 16-cm HEAD phantom by measuring the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and the standard deviation of the Hounsfield units (HU) of circular regions of interest placed in the phantom. The Noise Power Spectrum (NPS) was also studied. Measured values were compared on images with and without OBTCM.

RESULTS

The reduction rates in tube exit kerma, on the anterior part, vary between 11 % and 74 % depending on the CT scanner and the protocol used. The tube exit kerma on the posterior part remains unchanged in GE and Canon CT scanners. On the contrary, the tube exit kerma to the posterior part increases by up to 39 % in Siemens CT scanner. Image noise and SNR increase by up to 10 % in the five CT scanners. Nonetheless, the differences in noise and SNR are statistically significant (p-value < 0.05).The analysis of the NPS indicates that the noise texture remains unchanged.

CONCLUSION

OBTCM reduces the tube exit kerma to the anterior part of the gantry without reducing substantially image quality for head protocols.

Organ-based tube current modulation versus spectral shaping via tin prefiltration: What does bismuth breast shielding add in low-dose lung CT?

PURPOSE

Since organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) and tin prefiltration are limited on their own in lowering the dose of lung CT examinations, this experimental study was designed to investigate whether combinations with anterior patient shielding can increase the dose reduction potential.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Three pairs of scan protocols without/with breast shield (P1/P2: standard 120kVp, P3/P4: OBTCM at 100 kVp, P5/P6: Sn 100 kVp) were employed for radiation exposure and image quality comparisons on an anthropomorphic Alderson-Rando phantom. Equivalent doses were measured in eleven sites via thermoluminescent dosimetry and the effective dose was obtained by summation of the weighted organ doses. Dose-weighted contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRD) were calculated and four radiologists independently assessed the quality of images generated with each protocol.

RESULTS

While no significant difference was determined between standard and OBTCM protocols regardless of breast shield (p ≥ 0.068), equivalent doses with spectral shaping were substantially lower (p ≤ 0.003). The highest effective dose was ascertained for standard scans (P1/P2: 7.3/6.8 mSv) with a dose reduction of 8.0 % via breast shielding. The use of a bismuth shield was more beneficial in OBTCM (P3/P4: 6.6/5.3 mSv) and spectral shaping (P5/P6: 0.7/0.6 mSv), reducing the effective dose by 19.8 % and 13.9 %, respectively. Subjective assessment favoured standard protocol P1 over tin prefiltration low-dose scans (p ≤ 0.032), however, no scan protocol entailed diagnostically insufficient image quality.

CONCLUSIONS

Whereas breast shielding is particularly beneficial in combination with OBTCM, spectral shaping via tin prefiltration facilitates the most pronounced dose reduction in lung CT imaging with acceptable image quality.

Assessment of the effectiveness of Saba shielding with the composition of Cu-Bi in neck CT imaging: a phantom and patient study

The use of computed tomography (CT) is a very well-established medical diagnostic imaging modality, however, the high radiation dose due to this imaging method is a major concern. Therefore, dose reduction methods are necessary, especially for superficial radiosensitive organs like the thyroid. The aim of this study is to construct and assess a CT shield with composition of 90% Cu and 10% Bi (Saba shield) with regard to dose reduction and image quality. The efficiency of the constructed shields for dose reduction was assessed by measuring entrance skin dose (ESD), using thermoluminescence dosimeters placed on an anthropomorphic phantom. Image quality was assessed quantitatively based on image noise and CT number accuracy by drawing regions of interest on CT images of the anthropomorphic phantom. Image quality was further investigated qualitatively in a patient study. Application of the Saba shield and 100% Bi shield with the thickness of one thickness (1T) reduced ESD by 50.2% and 51.7%, respectively, and using a three-fold thickness reduced ESD by 64.6% and 65.1%, respectively. Saba shield with thickness of 1T had no significant change in image noise in the anterior part, and image noise and mean CT number in the posterior part (P> 0.05). The statistical analysis performed did not find any meaningful difference between the study and control groups in image quality assessment of the patient study (P> 0.05). The 1T Saba shield reduced thyroid dose efficiently during neck CT imaging without causing unwanted effects on image quality.

THE EFFECT OF OUT-OF-PLANE PATIENT SHIELDING ON CT RADIATION EXPOSURE AND TUBE CURRENT MODULATIONS: A PHANTOM STUDY ACROSS THREE VENDORS

The aim of this study was to evaluate how out-of-plane patient shielding affects radiation exposure parameters and tube current modulation on different vendors' computed tomography (CT) scanners. Helical CT scans were performed using two homogenous phantoms to mimic patient attenuation. Four CT scanners from three vendors were investigated by varying the distance of the patient shield from the border of the imaging volume. Scans were performed with a shield placed before and after the localizer. Changes in volume computed tomography dose index (CTDIvol), dose-length product (DLP) and tube current-time products were studied. Out-of-field lead shield increased the CTDIvol and DLP values for each scanner at least for one scan setting when the shield was present in the localizer. The most notable changes were recorded with >1.3 pitch values when the shield was closest to the scanned volume (2.5 cm), and the scan direction was towards the shield. The usage of patient shields in the localizer CT scans can disturb TCM even when placed 7.5 cm away from the edge of the scan.

Systematic literature review on the benefit of patient protection shielding during medical X-ray imaging: Towards a discontinuation of the current practice

PURPOSE

Patient shielding during medical X-ray imaging has been increasingly criticized in the last years due to growing evidence that it often provides minimal benefit and may even compromise image quality. In Europe, and as also shown in a short assessment in Switzerland, the use of patient shielding is inhomogeneous. The aim of this study was to systematically review recent literature in order to assess benefits and appraise disadvantages related to the routine use of patient shielding.

METHODS

To evaluate benefits and disadvantages related to the application of patient shielding in radiological procedures, a systematic literature review was performed for CT, radiography, mammography and fluoroscopy-guided medical X-ray imaging. In addition, reports from medical physics societies and authorities of different countries were considered in the evaluation.

RESULTS

The literature review revealed 479 papers and reports on the topic, from which 87 qualified for closer analysis. The review considered in- and out-of-plane patient shielding as well as shielding for pregnant and pediatric patients. Dose savings and other dose and non-dose related effects of patient shielding were considered in the evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

Although patient shielding has been used in radiological practice for many years, its use is no longer undisputed. The evaluation of the systematic literature review of recent studies and reports shows that dose savings are rather minimal while significant dose- and non-dose-related detrimental effects are present. Consequently, the routine usage of patient protection shielding in medical X-ray imaging can be safely discontinued for all modalities and patient groups.

REDUCING ABSORBED DOSE TO THYROID IN NECK CT EXAMINATIONS: THE EFFECTS OF SABA SHIELDING

Bi shielding has been used for the protection of radiosensitive organs during computed tomography (CT) for 20 years. In 2017, American Association of Physicists in Medicine recommended against Bi shielding due to its degrading effects on image quality. Saba shielding introduced recently protecting organs as Bi shielding without degrading image quality. In this study, the Saba shield was modified and primary radiation attenuation values of the shields and entrance skin dose (ESD) on the thyroid were measured with and without shielding. Furthermore, the quality of images obtained using Saba shielding was investigated quantitatively and qualitatively. Saba and Bi shielding reduced the ESD on the thyroid by about 50%. Saba shielding had about 5-7 HU less noise and about 51-65 HU less CT numbers shift in comparison with Bi shielding at a distance of 1 cm from the shields. Saba shielding had no degrading effects on image quality in the patient study.

Organ-based tube current modulation in chest CT. A comparison of three vendors

INTRODUCTION

Organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) is designed for anterior dose reduction in Computed Tomography (CT). The purpose was to assess dose reduction capability in chest CT using three organ dose modulation systems at different kVp settings. Furthermore, noise, diagnostic image quality and tumour detection was assessed.

METHODS

A Lungman phantom was scanned with and without OBTCM at 80-135/140 kVp using three CT scanners; Canon Aquillion Prime, GE Revolution CT and Siemens Somatom Flash. Thermo-luminescent dosimeters were attached to the phantom surface and all scans were repeated five times. Image noise was measured in three ROIs at the level of the carina. Three observers visually scored the images using a fivestep scale. A Wilcoxon Signed-Rank test was used for statistical analysis of differences.

RESULTS

Using the GE revolution CT scanner, dose reductions between 1.10 mSv (12%) and 1.56 mSv (24%) (p < 0.01) were found in the anterior segment and no differences posteriorly and laterally. Total dose reductions between 0.64 (8%) and 0.91 mSv (13%) were found across kVp levels (p < 0.00001). Maximum noise increase with OBTCM was 0.8 HU. With the Canon system, anterior dose reductions of 6-10% and total dose reduction of 0.74-0.76 mSv across kVp levels (p < 0.001) were found with a maximum noise increase of 1.1 HU. For the Siemens system, dose increased by 22-51% anteriorly; except at 100 kVp where no dose difference was found. Noise decreased by 1 to 1.5 HU.

CONCLUSION

Organ based tube current modulation is capable of anterior and total dose reduction with minimal loss of image quality in vendors that do not increase posterior dose.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

This research highlights the importance of being familiar with dose reduction technologies.

A new brain CT reference line: the lower eyelid to the inner occipital base line closely parallels the Talairach-Tournoux line

Background

There is no standardized brain computed tomography (CT) reference line that can be determined on both scout and reformatted sagittal CT images. Here, a tangential line from the anterior edge of the lower eyelid to the inner table of the occipital base (LEL/O line) appears nearly parallel to the Talairach–Tournoux (T/T) line, which shows a consistent intracranial anatomical relationship among subjects, and acts as a standard reference line for magnetic resonance (MR) imaging.

Purpose

To quantitatively validate the LEL/O line as a new standard brain CT reference line.

Material and Methods

We measured: angle 1 = the LEL/O line on scout images from the LEL/O line on parasagittal CT images (n=93); and angle 2 = the LEL/O line on scout images from the T/T line on high resolution midsagittal MR images (n=97). Angles in a clockwise direction were defined as positive and were expressed as mean±SD with the 95% confidence interval (CI) of the SD. Angle 2 was measured independently by two observers and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated.

Results

Angle 1 was –0.4°±1.2° (95% CI of SD 1.1°–1.5°); angle 2 was –0.4°±2.0° (95% CI of SD, 1.8°–2.4°). The ICC in the angle 2 measurement was 0.780 (P<0.001), which indicated high inter-observer reliability.

Conclusion

The LEL/O lines on scout and parasagittal CT images show practically the same gradient, and these LEL/O lines are almost parallel to the T/T line. Use of the LEL/O line either for direct scanning or reformation can minimize intra- and inter-subject variations on CT images and mismatch between CT and MR images.

COMPARISON OF ORGAN-BASED TUBE CURRENT MODULATION AND BISMUTH SHIELDING IN CHEST CT: EFFECT ON THE IMAGE QUALITY AND THE PATIENT DOSE

The aim of the study was to compare the absorbed doses and image quality of organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) and bismuth shielding of breasts and thyroid against regular tube current modulation in chest CT scan. An anthropomorphic phantom and MOSFET dosemeters were used to evaluate absorbed doses. Image quality was assessed from HU and noise. Relative to the reference scan, the average absorbed dose reduction with OBTCM was 5.2% and with bismuth shields 24.2%. Difference in HU values compared to the reference varied between -4.1 and 4.2 HU in OBTCM scan and between -22.2 and 118.6 HU with bismuth shields. Image noise levels varied between 10.0 to 26.3 HU in the reference scan, from 9.6 to 27.7 HU for the OBTCM scan and from 11.9 to 43.9 HU in the bismuth scan. The use of bismuth shields provided greatest dose reduction compared to the investigated OBTCM.

Targeted radiation energy modulation using Saba shielding reduces breast dose without degrading image quality during thoracic CT examinations

OBJECTIVE

Breasts dose during thoracic computed tomography examinations is a serious challenge and practical dose reduction strategies is needed. The bismuth shielding is an available method for dose reduction; however, its use is on debate due to degrading effects on image quality. The aim of this study is to explore and evaluate the efficiency of a new composition of the X-ray absorbing material to achieve a shield with a lower impact on image quality.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Different shields were manufactured with combinations of various weight percentage of copper and bismuth. Dose reduction ratio and image quality were evaluated in phantom studies. A controlled trial with 20 female participants was conducted for image quality assessment. The shield with a lower impact on image quality, named Saba shielding, was used in the clinical trial.

RESULTS

Shielding by one (1 T) and three thickness (3 T) of the constructed shields reduced the mean entrance skin dose of breasts about 52% and 73%, respectively. The shield with a composition of 90% Cu and 10% Bi (Saba shielding) had the lowest while the shield with 100% bismuth had the highest degrading effect on image quality. The Saba shielding could provide 21% higher dose reduction than the Bi shielding at the equivalent image quality. The 1 T Saba shielding did not cause artifacts in the reconstructed images.

CONCLUSION

The Saba shielding is flexible, cheap and user-friendly for shielding breasts in thoracic CT examinations while do not have the degrading effect of the Bi shielding on image quality.

Use of bismuth shield for protection of superficial radiosensitive organs in patients undergoing computed tomography: a literature review and meta-analysis

The study aimed to assess the effect of bismuth (Bi) shielding on dose reduction and image quality in computed tomography (CT) through a literature review. A search was conducted in the following databases: Web of Science, PubMed, Google Scholar, and Scopus. Studies that reported estimated dose reduction with bismuth shielding during imaging of the eye, thyroid, and breast were included, and a meta-regression analysis was used to examine the influence of the CT scanner type on the dose reduction. The studies included a total of 237 patients and 34 pediatric and adult anthropomorphic phantoms for whom the radiation dose was reported. Bismuth shielding was recommended in 88.89% of the studies based on the maintenance of appropriate image quality under shielding. Noise associated with Bi shielding was 7.5%, 263%, and 23.5% for the eye, thyroid, and breast, respectively. The fixed-effects pooled estimate of dose reduction was 34% (95% CI: 13-55; p < 0.001) for the eye, 37% (95% CI 14-61; p < 0.001) for the thyroid, and 36% (95% CI 36-55; p < 0.001) for the breast. The image quality, usage of foams, CT scanner type, beam energies, and backscatter radiation were important factors that directly affected the efficacy of Bi shielding to reduce the radiation dose at the superficial radiosensitive organs.

Application of Different methods for Reducing Radiation Dose to Breast during MDCT

The increased use of computed tomography (CT) and its high radiation dose have led to great concerns about its potential for radiation induced cancer risks. Breast is a radiosensitive tissue based on tissue weighting factors assigned by the International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP). Moreover, the dose is maximal on the surface of the patient. Therefore, strategies should be taken to reduce radiation dose to the breast. The aim of this review is to introduce methods used for reducing radiation dose to breast in thoracic CT and review related performed studies. The literature indicates that bismuth shielding increases image noise and CT numbers as well as introducing streak artifacts. Tube current modulation (TCM) technique and iterative reconstruction algorithms can provide some levels of dose reduction to radiosensitive organs and superior image quality without the disadvantages of bismuth shielding. However, they are not available on all CT scanners, especially in low-income countries. Such centers may have to continue using bismuth shields to reduce the dose until these superior techniques become available at lower costs in all CT scanners. Furthermore, design and manufacture of new shields with the lower impact on image quality are desirable.