Influence of object size on beam hardening in dual energy images: A study using different dual-energy CT systems

INTRODUCTION

Dual-energy CT (DECT) enables material decomposition and artifact reduction. However, beam hardening effects, which vary by DECT system and object size, can impact measurement accuracy. This study investigates the influence of beam hardening across various DECT systems and object sizes.

METHODS

A polyethylene Mercury phantom with five diameters (16, 21, 26, 31, and 36 cm) was scanned using three DECT systems: fast kilovolt-switching CT (FKSCT), dual-source CT (DSCT), and dual-layer CT (DLCT). Measurements included CT numbers and standard deviations (SD) of virtual monochromatic images (VMI) at 70 keV for iodine inserts, iodine concentrations, and artifact indices (AI) to assess beam hardening artifacts.

RESULTS

CT numbers and iodine concentrations decreased with increasing phantom size for FKSCT and DLCT, with DLCT showing a larger decrease. DSCT exhibited relatively stable CT numbers and iodine concentrations across all sizes. Noise levels (SD) increased significantly with phantom size for DSCT and DLCT, while FKSCT showed a smaller increase. Beam hardening artifacts, as assessed by AI, were the lowest for FKSCT, while DSCT and DLCT exhibited greater artifacts compared to FKSCT, particularly at larger phantom sizes.

CONCLUSION

The effect of beam hardening varies among DECT systems. FKSCT demonstrated the most stable performance across object sizes, while DSCT and DLCT were more sensitive to object size, affecting measurement accuracy and stability. These findings emphasize the importance of understanding system-specific characteristics to ensure optimal DECT use.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

In clinical practice, when using DECT to measure CT numbers and iodine concentration, it is important to understand that the size of the object may be affected by beam hardening, depending on the DECT system.

Development and Validation of a CT-Radiomics Nomogram for the Diagnosis of Small Prevascular Mediastinal Nodules: Reducing Nontherapeutic Surgeries

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The preoperative diagnosis of small prevascular mediastinal nodules (SPMNs) presents a challenge, often leading to unnecessary surgical interventions. Our objective was to develop a nomogram based on preoperative CT-radiomics features, serving as a non-invasive diagnostic tool for SPMNs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Patients with surgically resected SPMNs from two medical centers between January 2018 and December 2022 were retrospectively reviewed. Radiomics features were extracted and screened from preoperative CT images. Logistic regression was employed to establish clinical, radiomics, and hybrid models for differentiating thymic epithelial tumors (TETs) from cysts. The performance of these models was validated in both internal and external test sets by area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC), while also comparing their diagnostic capability with human experts.

RESULTS

The study enrolled a total of 363 patients (median age, 53 years [IQR:45-59 years]; 175 [48.2%] males) for model development and validation, including 136 TETs and 227 cysts. Lesions' enhancement status, shape, calcification, and rad-score were identified as independent factors for distinction. The hybrid model demonstrated superior diagnostic performance compared to other models and human experts, with an AUC of 0.95 (95% CI:0.92-0.98), 0.94 (95% CI:0.89-0.99), and 0.93 (95% CI:0.83-1.00) in the training set, internal test set, and external test set respectively. The calibration curve of the model demonstrated excellent fit, while decision curve analysis underscored its clinical value.

CONCLUSION

The radiomics-based nomogram effectively discriminates between the most prevalent types of SPMNs, namely TETs and cysts, thus presenting a promising tool for treatment guidance.

Prediction of proton stopping power ratios using dual-energy CT basis material decomposition

BACKGROUND

Proton radiotherapy treatment plans are currently restricted by the range uncertainties originating from the stopping power ratio (SPR) prediction based on single-energy computed tomography (SECT). Various studies have shown that multi-energy CT (MECT) can reduce the range uncertainties due to medical implant materials and age-related variations in tissue composition. None of these has directly applied the basis material density (MD) images produced by projection-based MECT systems for SPR prediction.

PURPOSE

To present and evaluate a novel proton SPR prediction method based on MD images from dual-energy CT (DECT), which could reduce the range uncertainties currently associated with proton radiotherapy.

METHODS

A theoretical basis material decomposition into water and iodine material densities was performed for various pediatric and adult human reference tissues, as well as other non-tissue materials, by minimizing the root-mean-square relative attenuation error in the energy interval from 40 to 140 keV. A model (here called MD-SPR) mapping predicted MDs to theoretically calculated reference SPRs was created with locally weighted scatterplot smoothing (LOWESS) data-fitting. The goodness of fit of the MD-SPR model was evaluated for the included reference tissues. MD images of two electron density phantoms, combined to form a head- and an abdomen-sized phantom setup, were acquired with a clinical projection-based fast-kV switching DECT scanner. The MD images were compared to the theoretically predicted MDs of the tissue surrogates and other non-tissue materials in the phantoms, as well as used for input to the MD-SPR model for generation of SPR images. The SPR images were subsequently compared to theoretical reference SPRs of the materials in the phantoms, as well as to SPR images from a commercial algorithm (DirectSPR, Siemens Healthineers, Forchheim, Germany) using image-based consecutive scan DECT for the same phantom setups.

RESULTS

The predicted SPRs of the tissue surrogates were similar for MD-SPR and DirectSPR, where the adipose and bone tissue surrogates were within 1% difference to the reference SPRs, while other non-adipose soft tissue surrogates (breast, brain, liver, muscle) were all underestimated by between -0.7% and -1.8%. The SPRs of the non-tissue materials (polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), polyether ether ketone (PEEK), graphite and Teflon) were within 2.8% for MD-SPR images, compared to 6.8% for DirectSPR.

CONCLUSIONS

The MD-SPR model performed similar compared to other published methods for the human reference tissues. The SPR prediction for tissue surrogates was similar to DirectSPR and showed potential to improve SPR prediction for non-tissue materials.

Advances for Pulmonary Functional Imaging: Dual-Energy Computed Tomography for Pulmonary Functional Imaging

Dual-energy computed tomography (DECT) can improve the differentiation of material by using two different X-ray energy spectra, and may provide new imaging techniques to diagnostic radiology to overcome the limitations of conventional CT in characterizing tissue. Some techniques have used dual-energy imaging, which mainly includes dual-sourced, rapid kVp switching, dual-layer detectors, and split-filter imaging. In iodine images, images of the lung's perfused blood volume (PBV) based on DECT have been applied in patients with pulmonary embolism to obtain both images of the PE occluding the pulmonary artery and the consequent perfusion defects in the lung's parenchyma. PBV images of the lung also have the potential to indicate the severity of PE, including chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension. Virtual monochromatic imaging can improve the accuracy of diagnosing pulmonary vascular diseases by optimizing kiloelectronvolt settings for various purposes. Iodine images also could provide a new approach in the area of thoracic oncology, for example, for the characterization of pulmonary nodules and mediastinal lymph nodes. DECT-based lung ventilation imaging is also available with noble gases with high atomic numbers, such as xenon, which is similar to iodine. A ventilation map of the lung can be used to image various pulmonary diseases such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.

Technical note: Evaluation of Artificial 120-kilovolt computed tomography images for radiation therapy applications

PURPOSE

The purpose of this work is to evaluate the scaled CT number accuracy of an artificial 120 kV reconstruction technique based on phantom experiments in the context of radiation therapy planning.

METHODS

An abdomen-shaped electron density phantom was scanned on a clinical CT scanner capable of artificial 120 kV reconstruction using different tube potentials from 70 kV to 150 kV. A series of tissue equivalent phantom inserts (lung, adipose, breast, solid water, liver, inner bone, 30%/50% CaCO3, cortical bone) were placed inside the phantom. Images were reconstructed using a conventional quantitative reconstruction kernel as well as the artificial 120 kV reconstruction kernel. Scaled CT numbers of inserts were measured from images acquired at different kVs and compared with those acquired at 120 kV, which were deemed as the ground truth. The relative error was quantified as the percentage deviation of scaled CT numbers acquired at different tube potentials from their ground truth values acquired at 120 kV.

RESULTS

Scaled CT numbers measured from images reconstructed using the conventional reconstruction demonstrated a strong kV-dependence. The relative error in scaled CT number ranged from 0.6% (liver insert) to 31.1% (cortical bone insert). The artificial 120 kV reconstruction reduced the kV-dependence, especially for bone tissues. The relative error in scaled CT number was reduced to 0.4% (liver insert) and 2.6% (30% CaCO₃ insert) using this technique. When tube potential selection was limited to the range of 90 kV to 150 kV, the relative error was further restrained to <1.2% for all tissue types.

CONCLUSION

Phantom results demonstrated that using the artificial 120 kV technique, it was feasible to acquire raw projection data at a desired tube potential and then reconstruct images with scaled CT numbers comparable to those obtained directly at 120 kV. In radiotherapy applications, this technique may allow optimization of tube potential without complicating clinical workflow by eliminating the necessity of maintaining multiple sets of CT calibration curves. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Dual-energy CT: minimal essentials for radiologists

Dual-energy CT, the object is scanned at two different energies, makes it possible to identify the characteristics of materials that cannot be evaluated on conventional single-energy CT images. This imaging method can be used to perform material decomposition based on differences in the material-attenuation coefficients at different energies. Dual-energy analyses can be classified as image data-based- and raw data-based analysis. The beam-hardening effect is lower with raw data-based analysis, resulting in more accurate dual-energy analysis. On virtual monochromatic images, the iodine contrast increases as the energy level decreases; this improves visualization of contrast-enhanced lesions. Also, the application of material decomposition, such as iodine- and edema images, increases the detectability of lesions due to diseases encountered in daily clinical practice. In this review, the minimal essentials of dual-energy CT scanning are presented and its usefulness in daily clinical practice is discussed.

Influence of beam hardening in dual-energy CT imaging: phantom study for iodine mapping, virtual monoenergetic imaging, and virtual non-contrast imaging

In this study, we investigated the influence of beam hardening on the dual-energy computed tomography (DECT) values of iodine maps, virtual monoenergetic (VME) images, and virtual non-contrast (VNC) images. 320-row DECT imaging was performed by changing the x-ray tube energy for the first and second rotations. DECT values of 5 mg/mL iodine of the multi-energy CT phantom were compared with and without a 2-mm-thick attenuation rubber layer (~700 HU) wound around the phantom. It was found that the CT density values UH, with/without the rubber layer had statistical differences in the iodine map (184 ± 0.7 versus 186 ± 1.8), VME images (125 ± 0.3 versus 110 ± 0.4), and VNC images (−58 ± 0.7 versus −76 ± 1.7) (p < 0.010 for all). This suggests that iodine mapping may be underestimated by DECT and overestimated by VME imaging because of x-ray beam hardening. The use of VNC images instead of plain CT images requires further investigation because of underestimation.

Dual-Energy CT Images: Pearls and Pitfalls

Dual-energy CT (DECT) is a tremendous innovation in CT technology that allows creation of numerous imaging datasets by enabling discrete acquisitions at more than one energy level. The wide range of images generated from a single DECT acquisition provides several benefits such as improved lesion detection and characterization, superior determination of material composition, reduction in the dose of iodine, and more robust quantification. Technological advances and the proliferation of various processing methods have led to the availability of diverse vendor-based DECT approaches, each with a different acquisition and image reconstruction process. The images generated from various DECT scanners differ from those from conventional single-energy CT because of differences in their acquisition techniques, material decomposition methods, image reconstruction algorithms, and postprocessing methods. DECT images such as virtual monochromatic images, material density images, and virtual unenhanced images have different imaging appearances, texture features, and quantitative capabilities. This heterogeneity creates challenges in their routine interpretation and has certain associated pitfalls. Some artifacts such as residual iodine on virtual unenhanced images and an appearance of pseudopneumatosis in a gas-distended bowel loop on material-density iodine images are specific to DECT, while others such as pseudoenhancement seen on virtual monochromatic images are also observed at single-energy CT. Recognizing the potential pitfalls associated with DECT is necessary for appropriate and accurate interpretation of the results of this increasingly important imaging tool. Online supplemental material is available for this article. ©RSNA, 2021.

New Fast kVp Switching Dual-Energy CT: Reduced Severity of Beam Hardening Artifacts and Improved Image Quality in Reduced-Iodine Virtual Monochromatic Imaging

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

To compare degradation of the image quality due to beam hardening artifacts in reduced-iodine-dose virtual monochromatic imaging (VMI) between a new fast kVp switching dual-energy computed tomography (CT) scanner (Revolution CT) and the conventional dual-energy scanner (Discovery CT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

First, a phantom study was performed to quantitatively evaluate beam hardening artifacts in images obtained by VMI reconstruction at different energy levels. In the second study, we performed a retrospective evaluation of the images of 28 patients who had undergone reduced-iodine (300 mg/kg) dual-energy scanning in both Revolution CT and Discovery CT. We evaluated each image quantitatively by measuring the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) and qualitatively by scoring the artifacts and image quality. We also calculated the modulation transfer function (MTF) and noise power spectrum (NPS) of the two scanners.

RESULTS

In the phantom study, VMI reconstruction of the CT images at 40-70 keV was associated with a significantly greater reduction in the severity of the artifacts in the Revolution CT images as compared to the Discovery CT images. In the retrospective study, there were no significant differences in the CT value of the aorta, noise, or CNR between the two scanners, but the scores for image quality were significantly higher in the Revolution CT images as compared to the Discovery CT images. The MTF of Revolution CT was higher than that of Discovery CT, reflecting the better spatial resolution.

CONCLUSION

In Revolution CT, beam hardening artifacts were reduced in reduced-iodine VMI at lower energy levels compared to Discovery CT, contributing to better image quality.

Multi-energy computed tomography and material quantification: Current barriers and opportunities for advancement

Computed tomography (CT) technology has rapidly evolved since its introduction in the 1970s. It is a highly important diagnostic tool for clinicians as demonstrated by the significant increase in utilization over several decades. However, much of the effort to develop and advance CT applications has been focused on improving visual sensitivity and reducing radiation dose. In comparison to these areas, improvements in quantitative CT have lagged behind. While this could be a consequence of the technological limitations of conventional CT, advanced dual-energy CT (DECT) and photon-counting detector CT (PCD-CT) offer new opportunities for quantitation. Routine use of DECT is becoming more widely available and PCD-CT is rapidly developing. This review covers efforts to address an unmet need for improved quantitative imaging to better characterize disease, identify biomarkers, and evaluate therapeutic response, with an emphasis on multi-energy CT applications. The review will primarily discuss applications that have utilized quantitative metrics using both conventional and DECT, such as bone mineral density measurement, evaluation of renal lesions, and diagnosis of fatty liver disease. Other topics that will be discussed include efforts to improve quantitative CT volumetry and radiomics. Finally, we will address the use of quantitative CT to enhance image-guided techniques for surgery, radiotherapy and interventions and provide unique opportunities for development of new contrast agents.

Optimal Kiloelectron Volt for Noise-Optimized Virtual Monoenergetic Images of Dual-Energy Pediatric Abdominopelvic Computed Tomography: Preliminary Results

Objective

To compare quantitative and qualitative image quality parameters in pediatric abdominopelvic dual-energy CT (DECT) using noise-optimized virtual monoenergetic image (VMI) and conventional VMI at different kiloelectron volt (keV) levels.

Materials and Methods

Thirty-six consecutive abdominopelvic DECT scans were retrospectively included. Noise-optimized VMI and conventional VMI were reconstructed at seven energy levels, from 40 keV to 100 keV at 10 keV intervals. The contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the liver, pancreas, and aorta were objectively measured and compared. Image quality was evaluated subjectively regarding image noise, image blurring of solid organ, bowel image quality and severity of beam-hardening artifacts. Optimal monoenergetic levels in keV for both algorithms were determined based on overall image quality score.

Results

The maximal CNR and SNR values for all investigated organs were observed at 40 keV in noise-optimized VMI (CNR and SNR of liver, pancreas, aorta in order [CNR; 20.93, 17.34, 46.75: SNR; 37.39, 33.80, 63.21]), at 60–70 keV and at 70 keV in conventional VMI (CNR; 8.12, 5.67, 15.97: SNR; 19.57, 16.66, 26.65). In qualitative image analysis, noise-optimized VMI and conventional VMI showed the best overall image quality scores at 60 keV and at 70 keV, respectively. Noise-optimized VMI at 60 keV showed superior CNRs, SNRs, and overall image quality scores compared to conventional VMI at 70 keV (p < 0.001).

Conclusion

Optimal energy levels for noise-optimized VMI and conventional VMI were 60 keV and at 70 keV, respectively. Noise-optimized VMI shows superior CNRs, SNRs and subjective image quality over conventional VMI, at the optimal energy level.

Detection of Lumbar Spine Osseous Metastases Using Dual-Energy CT: Phantom Results and Preliminary Clinical Validation

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the sensitivity, tumor conspicuity, and image quality of different material decomposition images of phantoms and patients with nearly isodense bone metastases using rapid-kilovoltage-switching dual-energy CT (DECT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty-one semianthropomorphic lumbar spine phantoms embedded with 75 simulated tumors were scanned without and with outer torso-attenuating encasement under the same scan settings. Two radiologists independently reviewed the 70-keV virtual monochromatic and material decomposition images (hydroxyapatite-water, water-hydroxyapatite, cortical bone-water, water-cortical bone). The sensitivity of tumor detection, tumor conspicuity (on a 3-point scale), and image quality (on a 3-point scale) were recorded by two independent readers. McNemar and Wilcoxon signed rank tests were used to compare results between the image reconstructions. Six clinical abdominopelvic DECT scans (three men, three women; mean age, 52 years) with nine nearly isodense lumbar spine tumors missed in the clinical report but confirmed on other scans were also evaluated.

RESULTS

The hydroxyapatite-water material decomposition algorithm showed improved sensitivity for isodense lesion detection (without torso phantom encasement, 94% vs 82%, p = 0.031; with torso phantom encasement, 38% vs 18%, p = 0.013), and higher tumor conspicuity scores (p < 0.0001) compared with 70-keV virtual monoenergetic images. Artifacts were more prevalent with all material decomposition images than with 70-keV virtual monoenergetic images. Similar results were seen in the patient study.

CONCLUSION

Dual-energy CT with hydroxyapatite-water material decomposition may improve the detection of bone marrow metastases, especially for subtle isodense tumors. Further study in prospective clinical scans is warranted.

Imaging of pulmonary perfusion using subtraction CT angiography is feasible in clinical practice

Abstract

Subtraction computed tomography (SCT) is a technique that uses software-based motion correction between an unenhanced and an enhanced CT scan for obtaining the iodine distribution in the pulmonary parenchyma. This technique has been implemented in clinical practice for the evaluation of lung perfusion in CT pulmonary angiography (CTPA) in patients with suspicion of acute and chronic pulmonary embolism, with acceptable radiation dose. This paper discusses the technical principles, clinical interpretation, benefits and limitations of arterial subtraction CTPA.

Key Points

• SCT uses motion correction and image subtraction between an unenhanced and an enhanced CT scan to obtain iodine distribution in the pulmonary parenchyma.

• SCT could have an added value in detection of pulmonary embolism.

• SCT requires only software implementation, making it potentially more widely available for patient care than dual-energy CT.

Dual layer computed tomography: Reduction of metal artefacts from posterior spinal fusion using virtual monoenergetic imaging

INTRODUCTION

To evaluate the clinical potential of dual layer computed tomography (DLCT) for posterior fusions of the thoracic and lumbar spine and determine the optimal keV-settings for an improved overall image quality and effective reduction of metal artefacts affecting the implant inheriting vertebral body, the spinal canal, the paravertebral muscle and aorta.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Twenty patients with posterior thoracic and lumbar spinal fusion, who underwent a 120kVp- DLCT scan were included in this study. Two independent readers evaluated axial 0.9 mm slides with soft tissue and bone window settings. Image quality of the conventional scan was compared to virtual monoenergetic images (VMI) at 40, 60, 80, 100,120, 140, 160, 180 and 200 keV. Diagnostic image quality was assessed on a four point Likert-scale overall, as well as specifically for the implant inheriting bone, paravertebral muscle, spinal canal or aorta. The Hounsfield Units (HU) of the area with the most pronounced streak artefact as well as HU of a reference area containing fat and muscle were documented for each keV-setting and compared to the conventional image. SNR and CNR were calculated for each of the four anatomic areas. Statistical analysis was conducted for the total collective and separately for the thoracic and lumbar spine level.

RESULTS

Starting from 80 keV qualitative analysis revealed significant improvement of overall image quality and benefit for each tissue separately compared to the conventional images (CI) (p-values in the range from <0.001 to 0.005). 180 keV was considered the optimal monoenergetic setting regarding the overall image quality. For the assessment of the implant inheriting bone, the spinal canal, paravertebral muscle and aorta 200, 180, 160 and 180 keV were rated to be the most sufficient. Our results reveal high inter-reader agreement for qualitative evaluations (intra-class correlation coefficients >0.927; p < 0.05). HU values within the most pronounced streak artefact increased significantly with higher keV (p < 0.001), while there was no significant alteration of HU within the reference area. A decrease in SNR and CNR for higher VMI was revealed by our results.

CONCLUSION

VMIs of higher energies provide significant reduction of metallic artefacts from posterior spinal fusions. Dedicated keV settings to evaluate either the implant inheriting bone, the spinal canal,adjacent muscle or aorta - structures, which are frequently of particular interest after posterior spinal fusion - are recommended. In addition, an optimal keV for an improved overall image quality is proposed.