Dendritic cell immunotherapy for HIV infection: from theory to reality

Programming T cell Killers for an HIV Cure: Teach the New Dogs New Tricks and Let the Sleeping Dogs Lie

Despite the success of combination antiretroviral therapy (cART), a latent viral reservoir persists in HIV-1-infected persons. Unfortunately, endogenous cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are unable to control viral rebound when patients are removed from cART. A "kick and kill" strategy has been proposed to eradicate this reservoir, whereby infected T cells are induced to express viral proteins via latency-inducing drugs followed by their elimination by CTLs. It has yet to be determined if stimulation of existing HIV-1-specific CTL will be sufficient, or if new CTLs should be primed from naïve T cells. In this review, we propose that dendritic cells (DCs), the most potent antigen presenting cells, act as dog trainers and can induce T cells (the dogs) to do magnificent tricks. We propose the hypothesis that an HIV-1 cure will require targeting of naïve T cells and will necessitate "teaching new dogs new tricks" while avoiding activation of potentially dysfunctional endogenous memory CTLs (letting the sleeping dogs lie).

HIV-1 capture and antigen presentation by dendritic cells: enhanced viral capture does not correlate with better T cell activation

During HIV-1 infection, dendritic cells (DC) facilitate dissemination of HIV-1 while trying to trigger adaptive antiviral immune responses. We examined whether increased HIV-1 capture in DC matured with LPS results in more efficient Ag presentation to HIV-1-specific CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. To block the DC-mediated trans-infection of HIV-1 and maximize Ag loading, we also evaluated a noninfectious integrase-deficient HIV-1 isolate, HIV(NL4-3ΔIN). We showed that higher viral capture of DC did not guarantee better Ag presentation or T cell activation. Greater HIV(NL4-3) uptake by fully LPS-matured DC resulted in higher viral transmission to target cells but poorer stimulation of HIV-1-specific CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells. Conversely, maturation of DC with LPS during, but not before, viral loading enhanced both HLA-I and HLA-II HIV-1-derived Ag presentation. In contrast, DC maturation with the clinical-grade mixture consisting of IL-1β, TNF-α, IL-6, and PGE(2) during viral uptake only stimulated HIV-1-specific CD8(+) T cells. Hence, DC maturation state, activation stimulus, and time lag between DC maturation and Ag loading impact HIV-1 capture and virus Ag presentation. Our results demonstrate a dissociation between the capacity to capture HIV-1 and to present viral Ags. Integrase-deficient HIV(NL4-3ΔIN) was also efficiently captured and presented by DC through the HLA-I and HLA-II pathways but in the absence of viral dissemination. HIV(NL4-3ΔIN) seems to be an attractive candidate to be explored. These results provide new insights into DC biology and have implications in the optimization of DC-based immunotherapy against HIV-1 infection.

An old enzyme for current needs: adenosine deaminase and a dendritic cell vaccine for HIV

After nearly three decades of searching for a vaccine against HIV, a cure for this pandemic disease still remains elusive. The low immunogenicity of the surface proteins and the huge variability of the virus, together with the immunocompromised status of the host, have made developing an HIV vaccine an uphill battle. Over the past few years, both immunogen design and immunization strategies have improved, providing hope for future, although the anti-HIV responses achieved still remain modest. As developing a prophylactic vaccine seems unlikely nowadays, efforts have focused on alternative therapeutic immunization approaches, although these still need to be further optimized. Using an immunomodulator capable of restoring immune function in the context of infection, thereby boosting cell-mediated and humoral responses, could be critical in effectively improving current therapeutic approaches. Adenosine deaminase, a protein with a pivotal role in T-cell co-stimulation, has been shown to robustly enhance specific T-cell responses against HIV in vitro. Although its role in humoral responses has not yet been assessed, genetic defects in this enzyme are associated with impaired cellular and humoral responses. Importantly, this molecule is already commercially available pharmaceutically and, therefore, it fulfils all the requirements to be assayed as an anti-HIV vaccine adjuvant.

Challenges in dendritic cells-based therapeutic vaccination in HIV-1 infection Workshop in dendritic cell-based vaccine clinical trials in HIV-1

Therapeutic immunization has been proposed as an approach that might help limit the need for lifelong combined antiretroviral therapy (cART). One approach for therapeutic vaccination which has been explored during the last few years is the administration of autologous monocyte-derived DCs (MD-DCs) loaded ex vivo with a variety of antigens. It has been shown in experimental murine models as well as in cancer patients and in patients with chronic infections that this approach can induce and potentiate antigen-specific T-cell response (and to induce a potent protective immunity). Contrary to the wide experience with this strategy in cancer, in HIV-1 infection the experience is limited and the design of the clinical trials varies greatly between groups. This variability affects all the steps of the process, from preparation of immunogen and DCs to clinical trial design and immune monitoring. Although both the study designs and the DC preparation (the maturation stimuli and the identity and source of HIV-1 antigens used to pulse DCs) varied in most of the studies that were published so far, overall the results indicate that DC immunotherapy elicits some degree of immunological response. To address this situation and to allow comparison between trials a panel of experts working in DC-based clinical trials in HIV-1 infection met in Barcelona at the end of 2010. During this meeting, the participants shared the data of their current research activities in this field in order to unify criteria for the future. This report summarizes the present situation of the field and the discussions and conclusions of this meeting.