Bilateral sweat tests with two different methods as a part of cystic fibrosis newborn screening (CF NBS) protocol and additional quality control

Diagnosing Cystic Fibrosis in the 21st Century-A Complex and Challenging Task

Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a chronic and potentially life-threatening condition, wherein timely diagnosis assumes paramount significance for the prompt initiation of therapeutic interventions, thereby ameliorating pulmonary function, addressing nutritional deficits, averting complications, mitigating morbidity, and ultimately enhancing the quality of life and extending longevity. This review aims to amalgamate existing knowledge to provide a comprehensive appraisal of contemporary diagnostic modalities pertinent to CF in the 21st century. Deliberations encompass discrete delineations of each diagnostic modality and the elucidation of potential diagnostic quandaries encountered in select instances, as well as the delineation of genotype-phenotype correlations germane to genetic counseling endeavors. The synthesis underscores that, notwithstanding the availability and strides in diagnostic methodologies, including genetic assays, the sweat test (ST) retains its position as the preeminent diagnostic standard for CF, serving as a robust surrogate for CFTR functionality. Prospective clinical investigations in the realm of CF should be orchestrated with the objective of discerning novel diagnostic modalities endowed with heightened specificity and sensitivity.

Clinical characteristics of rare CFTR mutations causing cystic fibrosis in Polish population

INTRODUCTION

More than 2000 mutations have been identified since the discovery of the CFTR gene in 1989. However, only 346 mutations have been classified as cystic fibrosis (CF)-causing mutations. Due to the increasing number of mutations and poor correlation between the genotype and phenotype, there is an urgent need to determine the mutations that are pathogenic, nonpathogenic, or lead to variable symptoms.

AIM

The aim of the study was to present the clinical characteristics of Polish patients with rare and novel CFTR mutations, with an attempt to determine the pathogenicity status of those variants.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The group included 13 patients born between September 2006 and May 2019, who underwent CF newborn screening and in whom two CFTR mutations, including at least one rare or a novel mutation, were identified.

RESULTS

We identified 13 patients with mutations in both alleles of the CFTR gene, one of which was at least rare in Polish population (R289NfsX17, I618RfsX2, T682KfsX40, S1347PfsX13, W356X, E33X, dup.16,17A) or was a mutation of unknown clinical consequences (H199R, L468P, A1217E, Q359R, T1036I, W1282R). None of them were described in the CFTR2 database. In all examined patients, sweat tests were elevated. The diagnosed patients presented with a wide spectrum of clinical symptoms. Broad clinical characteristics and test results are presented.

CONCLUSION

Pathogenic mutations are H199R, L468P, A1217E, Q359R, T1036I, W1282R, R289NfsX17, I618RfsX2, T682KfsX40, S1347PfsX13, W356X, E33X, dup.16,17A. Every patient with a mutation of unknown clinical consequences in one CFTR allele requires attentive follow-up.

Newborn Screening for Cystic Fibrosis in Russia: A Catalyst for Improved Care

In order to assess the effectiveness of the detection of cystic fibrosis (CF) patients by screening compared with diagnoses based on clinical manifestations, the data of the National CF Patient Registry (NCFPR) from the year 2012 (group I: children aged 6-9 years, diagnosed prior to the start of screening) were compared with the data in the NCFPR from the year 2015 (group II: children 6-9 years after the start of screening) for CF patients from the Moscow region. Homozygotes for c.1521_1523delCTT (F508del) were separately compared in both groups. The average diagnosis age, genotype, body mass index, spirometry data, pulmonary infection, medications, and presence of complications were analyzed. This study demonstrated that in the c.1521_1523delCTT (F508del) homozygote group, the patients diagnosed by screening had significant advantages over the patients born before the start of newborn screening in the diagnosis age, the number of patients with chronic Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection, the pulmonary function, and the growth in the percentiles. Newborn screening (NBS) detects nearly twice as many CF patients as the diagnostics based on clinical symptoms during the same time period. Importantly, patients will benefit from the early diagnosis of the disease and the early start of therapy.

Processing Newborn Bloodspot Screening Results for CF

Every newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) result for cystic fibrosis (CF) consists of two parts: a screening part in the laboratory and a clinical part in a CF centre. When introducing an NBS programme, more attention is usually paid to the laboratory part, especially which algorithm is most suitable for the region or the country. However, the clinical part, how a positive screening result is processed, is often underestimated and can have great consequences for the affected child and their parents. A clear algorithm for the diagnostic part in CF centres is also important and influences the performance of a CF NBS programme. The processing of a positive screening result includes the initial information given to the parents, the invitation to the sweat test, what to do if a sweat test fails, information about the results of the sweat test, the inconclusive diagnosis and the carrier status, which is handled differently from country to country. The time until the definitive diagnosis and adequate information is given, is considered by the parents and the CF team as the most important factor. The communication of a positive NBS result is crucial. It is not a singular event but rather a process that includes ensuring the appropriate clinicians are aware of the result and that families are informed in the most efficient and effective manner to facilitate consistent and timely follow-up.

Comparison of two sweat test systems for the diagnosis of cystic fibrosis in newborns

OBJECTIVES

In the national newborn screening programme for CF in Switzerland, we compared the performance of two sweat test methods, by investigating the feasibility and diagnostic performance of the Macroduct^® collection method (with chloride mesurement) and Nanoduct^® test (measuring conductivity) for diagnosing CF.

STUDY-DESIGN

We included all newborns with a positive screening result between 2011 and 2015 who were referred to a CF-centre for sweat testing. In the CF-centre, a Macroduct and Nanoduct sweat test were performed simultaneously. If sweat test results were positive or borderline, a DNA analysis was performed. Final diagnosis was based on genetic mutations.

RESULTS

Over 5 years, 445 children were screened positive and in 413 (114 with CF) at least one sweat test was performed (median age at first test, 22 days); both tests were performed in 371 children. A sweat test result was more often available with the Nanoduct compared to the Macroduct (79 vs 60%, P < 0.001). The Nanoduct was equally sensitive as the Macroduct in identifying newborns with CF (sensitivity 98 vs 99%) but less specific (specificity 79 vs 93%; P-value comparing ROC curves = 0.033).

CONCLUSIONS

This national multicentre study revealed high failure rates for Macroduct and Nanoduct in newborns in real life practice. While this needs to be addressed, our results suggested that performing the Nanoduct in addition to the Macroduct might speed up the diagnostic process because it more often yields valid results with comparable diagnostic performance. The addition of the Nanoduct sweat test can therefore help to reduce the stressful time of uncertainty for parents and to start appropriate treatment earlier.

Clinical evaluation of the Nanoduct sweat test system in the diagnosis of cystic fibrosis after newborn screening

After a positive newborn screening test for cystic fibrosis (CF), a sweat test is performed to confirm the diagnosis. The success rate of the generally acknowledged methods (Macroduct/Gibson and Cooke) in newborns varies between 73 and 99%. The Nanoduct sweat test system is easier to perform and less sweat is needed. The main aim of this study was to measure the success rate of the Nanoduct compared to current approved sweat test methods in a newborn population. After informed consent of the parents, newborns with a positive screening test for CF were included. The Macroduct or Gibson and Cooke and Nanoduct were performed in all infants, during the same appointment. The chloride concentration was determined by standard coulorimetry; conductivity was measured directly and converted to a NaCl molarity. One hundred eight newborns were included: 17 with CF, 7 with cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR)-related metabolic syndrome (CRMS), and 84 healthy children. The success rate of the Nanoduct was 93% and for the Macroduct/Gibson and Cooke 79% (McNemar, p = 0.002). The Nanoduct detected the same CF patients as the Macroduct/Gibson and Cooke; one CF patient had an equivocal result for both tests, and no patients were missed. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for detection of CF with the Nanoduct was 0.999, with ideal cutoff levels of 91 and 66 mmol/l, comparable to former studies.

CONCLUSION

The success rate of the Nanoduct to collect sufficient sweat in infants was higher compared to the Macroduct and Gibson and Cooke.

Nanoduct sweat conductivity measurements in 2664 patients: relationship to age, arterial blood gas, serum electrolyte profiles and clinical diagnosis

Background

The Nanoduct^® device has acceptable diagnostic accuracy, but there is not enough systematic data supporting its usage in the diagnosis of cystic fibrosis (CF).

Methods

A retrospective review of patients with an indication for the sweat test was conducted. The conductivity test was repeated in patients who had values higher than 60 mmol/L, and they were referred for sweat chloride measurements. Associations between sweat conductivity measurements and age, gender, (pH, HCO₃, pCO₂, Na, K, Cl), family history, consanguinity, indications for the test and number of hospitalization were studied.

Results

Among 2,664 patients, 16 children had sweat conductivity values higher than 80. The median age of patients diagnosed with CF was 4 months old. Age, pH, HCO₃, Na, Cl, K and the sweat conductivity test were statistically related (P < 0.001). The ROC curve showed very high agreement between the 2nd conductivity test and the sweat test.

Conclusions

Patients suspected to have CF can be screened using the Nanoduct^® conductivity device in non-qualified centers.

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis: Polish 4 years' experience with CFTR sequencing strategy

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis (NBS CF) in Poland was started in September 2006. Summary from 4 years' experience is presented in this study. The immunoreactive trypsin/DNA sequencing strategy was implemented. The group of 1,212,487 newborns were screened for cystic fibrosis during the programme. We identified a total of 221 CF cases during this period, including, 4 CF cases were reported to be omitted by NBS CF. Disease incidence in Poland based on the programme results was estimated as 1/4394 and carrier frequency as 1/33. The frequency of the F508del was similar (62%) to population data previously reported. This strategy allowed us to identify 29 affected infants with rare genotypes. The frequency of some mutations (eg, 2184insA, K710X) was assessed in Poland for the first time. Thus, sequencing assay seems to be accurate method for screening programme using blood spots in the Polish population.

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Newborn screening for cystic fibrosis (CF) is now universal in the US and many other countries. The rapid expansion of screening has resulted in numerous publications identifying new challenges for healthcare providers. This review provides an overview of these publications and includes ideas on managing these challenges.

RECENT FINDINGS

Most CF newborn screening algorithms involve DNA mutation analysis. As screening has expanded, new challenges have been identified related to carrier detection and inconclusive diagnoses. Early descriptions of infants with CF-related metabolic syndrome (CRMS) indicate that the natural history of this condition cannot be predicted. Early identification has also provided an opportunity to better understand the pathophysiology of CF. However, few studies have been conducted in infants with CF to determine optimal therapy and recommendations are largely anecdotal.

SUMMARY

Newborn screening provides an opportunity to identify and begin treatment early in individuals with CF. Whereas a single, optimal approach to screening does not exist, all programs can benefit from new findings regarding sweat testing, carrier detection, early pathophysiology, and clinical outcomes.