Outcome after Surgical Management of Acetabular Fractures: A 7-Year Experience

Developing a core outcome set for acetabular fractures: a systematic review (part I)

BACKGROUND

There are indications that clinical studies investigating the surgical treatment of acetabular fractures assess different outcomes. This heterogeneity reduces the comparability of study results and, thus, limits the knowledge generated from research. Core outcome sets (COS) contain a minimum set of outcomes that should be measured in studies investigating a specific disease or injury. A COS for surgically treated acetabular fractures does not yet exist. Therefore, the aim of this study is to identify the reported outcomes in studies investigating the surgical treatment of acetabular fractures.

METHODS

Studies including skeletally mature individuals (≥ 16 years) with isolated acetabular fractures treated surgically were included. Studies with polytrauma patients, pathological fractures, additional pelvic fractures, exclusively non-surgical treatment, or juvenile individuals were excluded. Three databases and two clinical trial registries were searched on 15 November 2022. The identified outcomes were grouped and subsequently categorized according to the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials Guidelines.

RESULTS

A total of 193 studies were included, which reported a cumulative total of 2581 outcomes. After grouping, 266 unique outcomes were identified. No outcome was examined in all studies. Pain, ability to walk independently, range of motion, quality of reduction, and heterotopic ossification were the most reported unique outcomes and assessed in at least 60% of included studies. A total of 105 outcomes were only assessed in one of the included studies. Outcomes of all five core areas and 25 outcome domains of the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials taxonomy were examined. Furthermore, outcomes were named and defined differently, measured at different time points, and assessed using a variety of measurement instruments.

CONCLUSION

Overall, this systematic review shows that a wide range of outcomes are measured in studies examining surgical treatment of acetabular fractures. The results of this systematic review will be used in a subsequent study to develop the COS for surgically treated acetabular fractures by using the Delphi method.

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION

PROSPERO: CRD42022357644; COMET: 2123.

Acetabular fracture in India: An epidemiological study

Introduction

Acetabular fractures, resulting from high-energy trauma, present significant orthopaedic challenges. Despite their rarity, the incidence of these fractures is rising, necessitating a comprehensive understanding of their epidemiological characteristics, especially in diverse populations like India.

Methods

This retrospective study analyzed data from 3643 patients across four level-1 trauma centers in India (North 1, North 2, West, and South) from January 2001 to December 2019. Prior ethical approval was obtained from the respective institutions. Data were collected using the computerized patient record system (CPRS) and included patients with complete clinical and radiological records. Only patients with full radiological data were included, comprising standard anteroposterior radiograph, Judet views on radiographs, and computed tomography scan of the pelvis. The study evaluated the demographic characteristics, fracture patterns and surgical approaches.

Results

The majority of patients were males (84.05 %) and the fractures were mostly seen in young individuals between 19 and 40 years' age group (44.9 %), followed by 41-60 years (42.3 %). Associated bony or other system injuries were seen in 53.42 % of patients, with pelvic injuries being the most common (9.8 %). Posterior wall fractures were the most frequent (20.7 %), while anterior wall fractures were the least common (0.8 %). Operative management was employed in 82 % of cases, with the Kocher-Langenbeck approach being the most commonly employed (42.5 %).

Conclusion

High-velocity trauma remains the commonest cause of acetabular trauma in India, primarily affecting young male individuals. Pelvic fractures are the most commonly associated injuries. Posterior wall fractures are the commonest type of acetabular fracture, and the Kocher-Langenbeck approach is the commonly adopted surgical approach.

Modified one third tubular plate (spring plate) augmented with reconstruction plates for treatment of comminuted posterior wall acetabular fractures, Short to midterm outcomes of 24 patients

The most common form of acetabular fracture is believed to be the posterior wall; its incidence ranges from 25% to 47%. Managing such fractures has been difficult in the past and until recently. To obtain a favorable functional outcome, an accurate diagnosis and a well-executed treatment strategy are essential.

Objective

To evaluate the clinical and functional outcomes of employing a spring plate augmented by a traditional 3.5 mm reconstruction plate for the treatment of comminuted posterior wall acetabular fractures.

Patients and Methods

A prospective case series was performed on 24 patients with comminuted fractures of the posterior wall. After an average of 6 days, the patients underwent surgery. Eighteen patients were fixed with one spring plate, six patients were fixed with two spring plates, and all were reinforced with a 3.5-mm reconstruction plate. Each case was followed once every three months until the fracture healed and then regularly every six months thereafter.

Results

There were 21 men and 3 women. The average follow-up period was 14 months, and the median age was 34.5 years. The main reason for injuries was motor vehicle collisions. The mean operation time was 107.5 min. The clinical results were evaluated by the MAP and m HHS, and the means were 10.2 (5-12) and 86 (64-96), respectively. Only two patients developed avascular necrosis and were treated by total hip replacement, another three (12.5%) had mild arthritis.

Conclusion

Comminuted acetabulum posterior wall fractures can be stabilized with spring plates. It could be used in conjunction with the primary reconstruction plate as a viable alternative for stable and anatomical reduction. High patient satisfaction and good functional results make this approach effective.

Incidence and risk factors associated with surgical site infection in acetabular fracture patients: An experience from north India

Introduction

Nearly 5-7% of patients undergoing surgical management of acetabular fractures develop surgical site infection (SSI) which is one of the most important factors affecting the hospital stay, success of procedure and overall patient satisfaction. Systematic studies to identify the risk factors and their control could help to reduce the surgical site infection rate considerably. The present study assessed the incidence and risk factors related with SSI in patients undergoing surgical management of acetabular fractures at our center.

Methods and materials

This retrospective record review included a total of 228 adult acetabular fracture patients (≥18 years) who were managed surgically. Demographic and clinical profile of the patients was noted and cases developing SSI. Univariate and multivariate association of different demographic and clinical factors was done to identify factors significantly associated with SSI. Univariate analysis was done using chi-square test. Multivariate assessment was done using binary logistic regression.

Results

Mean age of patients was 36.40 ± 14.18 years. Majority of patients were males (83.8 %). Incidence of SSI was 6.1 %. On univariate analysis, age ≥40 years, occupation service/business, fall from height, BMI >25 kg/m2, presence of associated injury, ≥48 h gap between injury and surgery, smoking and use of Kocher-Langenbeck approach for surgery were found to be significantly associated with an increased risk of SSI. However, on multivariate analysis only age >40 years (OR = 3.72; 95 % CI = 1.00-3.75; p = 0.049) and BMI>25.0 kg/m2 (OR = 0.20; 95 % CI = 0.05-0.85; p = 0.029) were the significant predictors of SSI.

Conclusions

This study identified that surgical site infection rates show a secular stagnating trend. There were almost no modifiable risk factors that could reduce this incidence, however, a strict post-operative care in patients with age >40 years and BMI>25 kg/m2 could help to change the direction of these trends.

The Association between Acetabulum Fractures and Subsequent Coxarthrosis in a Cohort of 77 Patients-A Retrospective Analysis of Predictors for Secondary Hip Osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

the aim of this study was to document the occurrence of THA after acetabulum surgery and examine the factors that predict its occurrence.

METHODS

This study included 77 consecutive patients who were admitted for acetabulum fracture surgery between 2012 and 2019. The inclusion criteria were acetabular fractures and indications for operative management. The exclusion criteria were acetabular fractures treated non-operatively, fractures requiring primary THA, and periprosthetic acetabular fractures. Data concerning demographics, date of injury, date of surgery, surgical approach, stabilization, and further reconstructive surgery were collected retrospectively. The number of patients who underwent THA and their risk factors were recorded. The minimum follow-up for each patient was 2 years of observation. A total of 77 patients with a mean age of 53 years were included.

RESULTS

At a mean follow-up of 2 years, THA was performed in 16 (20.8%) patients due to post-traumatic arthritis. An analysis of the surgical approaches showed that the Kocher-Langenbeck approach increased the risk of THA nearly 12 times compared with the ilioinguinal approach (p = 0.016). Furthermore, the duration of the waiting period for surgery significantly impacted the occurrence of THA, with each additional day leading to an 89% increase in the risk of prosthesis usage (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that acetabular fractures may lead to post-traumatic hip osteoarthritis. The surgical approach and the waiting time for surgery are potential factors that may predict secondary hip osteoarthritis and the need for subsequent THA. However, further investigations should be performed to establish predictors for secondary hip osteoarthritis, and especially to determine the impact of the surgical approach.

Quality of life from return to work and sports activities to sexual dysfunction after surgical treatment of acetabular fractures

INTRODUCTION

To evaluate the outcomes of patients treated for acetabular fractures in terms of Quality of Life (QoL), return to work, functional outcome, sports activities, and post-operative sexual dysfunction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The database of a level 1 trauma center was used to investigate the results of patients treated for acetabular fractures from 2010 to 2020. The minimum patient follow-up was 12 months. QoL was evaluated with the SF-12 questionnaire, return to work with the Workplace Activity Limitation Survey (WALS), functional outcomes and sports activities with Harris Hip Score (HHS) and Tegner activity scores, respectively, and the sexual function damage with a 0-10 NRS.

RESULTS

Sixty-five patients (44 men, 21 women) were enrolled, mean age at surgery of 53.4 years (20-85 years). The HHS and Tegner scores were 79.0 ± 19.4 and 2.6 ± 1.5, respectively, and 18.5% of patients underwent THA after 21.3 ± 28.6 months. QoL evaluated with the SF-12 showed the worst results in terms of Bodily Pain and Role Physical; 35.4% of the patients who were working before the trauma lost their job, and one third was affected at sex functional level. Sex was found to influence significantly both Harris Hip Score (p < 0.05) and Tegner activity score (p < 0.05), with men reporting better scores. On the other hand, men presented a higher impact in terms of job loss and sexual dysfunction.

CONCLUSION

Acetabular fractures affect patients' life as a whole, beyond the mere functional outcomes, often leading to a high rate of job loss and a significant probability of sexual functional worsening, especially for men. A significant number of patients also underwent THA at an early follow-up. Further efforts should aim at optimizing the surgical management, to improve functionality and the entire QoL sphere of patients affected by acetabular fractures.

[Osteosynthesis of geriatric acetabular fractures]

The aim of the treatment of acetabular fractures is principally an anatomical reconstruction of the joint surface to avoid posttraumatic arthritis. The increasing number of geriatric patients with acetabular fractures of the anterior column type resulting from simple falls on the side and substantial patient-related inherited comorbidities, represent particular challenges for the surgical approach and osteosynthesis due to the osteoporotic bone quality. Due to the establishment of minimally invasive lateral pelvic accesses to the acetabulum and the adaptation of the osteosynthesis technique and material to these approaches, it appears that even in very old patients with acetabular fractures mobility can be better and more rapidly restored and sequelae caused by immobility can be prevented.

Outcome of acetabulum fractures treated with open reduction and internal fixation through Kocher-Langenbeck Approach: A retrospective study

BACKGROUND

Complex anatomy of acetabular fracture is quite challenging for the orthopedic surgeons. Many Acetabular fracture fixation approaches have been used for a long time to treat different fracture patterns of acetabulum. Kocher-Langenbeck Approach (K-L approach) of acetabulum fracture is usually used by most of orthopedic surgeons. In this retrospective study, we evaluated the clinical and functional outcome of subtypes of acetabulum fractures treated with K-L approach. Assessment of Intra and postoperative complications of subtypes of acetabulum fractures was also done.

METHOD

Eighty patients (48 men and 32 women) were included in this retrospective study with a mean follow-up period of 2.6 years. Fractures were classified according to Letournal and Judet classification. K-L approach was performed in all these patients. Post operative reduction, Radiological outcome was quantified using Matta's criteria while the functional outcome was assessed according to Merle d'Aubigné and Postel scoring system. Postoperative complications were evaluated.

RESULTS

The mean age of a total of 80 cases was 43.64 ± 13.24 year. The type of fracture was found to be significantly associated with concentric/non-concentric reduction (p = 0.003) and with post op reduction (p = 0.005). The post operative reduction was found to be significantly associated with radiological (p < 0.001) and functional outcome (p < 0.001) at one year post op. The type of fracture was found to be significantly associated with radiological outcome (p < 0.001) while non-significantly found to be associated with functional outcome at 1 year (p = 0.050). The type of fracture was found to be significantly associated with post op complications (p = 0.003) and with arthritis (p = 0.001).

CONCLUSION

K-L approach is a multifaceted and convenient approach for treating acetabulum fractures. Type of fracture and post-operative reduction are key factors for a satisfactory outcome. Transverse with posterior wall fracture has the worst prognosis.

Evoked potential as an adjuvant predictive tool for neurological deficit in acetabular and pelvic ring injuries: A meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To identify the value of the evoked potential as an adjuvant predictive tool in pelvic ring and acetabulum fractures focusing on the neurological deficit.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Adhering to PRISMA guidelines, we performed a systematic review with a priori design to identify randomized controlled trials, retrospective and prospective cohort studies, and case-control studies of interventions in acetabular and pelvic ring injuries. The search strategy included the use of Title/Abstract related to: ("somatosensory" or "evoked potential" or "electrophysiology") and ("randomized controlled trials" or "clinical studies" or "controlled clinical trial" or "systematic literature review" or "meta-analysis" or "review" or "overview") and ("complications"). From 01/1985 to 12/2019, we searched MEDLINE, PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane, Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, reference lists and journals. The PRISMA checklist was adopted to evaluate reporting quality. Two reviewers independently selected studies and extracted data. Statistical analysis was conducted to assess the probability of evoked potential tests performed on random samples, with the assumption of normal distribution of the populations from which they were derived and knowledge of the parametric variance.

RESULTS

Five articles fulfilled eligibility criteria.

CONCLUSION

Evoked potential tests can quickly and accurately detect imminent neurological impairment during surgery of acetabular and pelvic ring injuries. This results in significantly better surgical outcomes, although in some cases the irreversible nature of the injury cannot be prevented.

[Research progress of different surgical approaches in treatment of acetabular both-column fractures]

Objective

To review the research progress of different surgical approaches in the treatment of acetabular both-column fractures.

Methods

The domestic and foreign related research literature on surgical approaches for acetabular both-column fractures was extensively consulted. The anatomical characteristics, exposure ranges, advantages, disadvantages, and indications of various common surgical approaches for both-column fractures were mainly summarized.

Results

The ilioinguinal approach is more suitable for both-column fractures if the anterior column fracture is complicated or combined with the anterior wall fracture while the posterior column fracture is simple and stable. The modified Stoppa approach or the lateral (para) rectus abdominal approach is the preferred choice when both-column fractures are combined with a quadrilateral fracture or femoral head dislocation. What's more, the Kocher-Langenbeck approach is required when the posterior column fractures are complicated or combined with posterior wall fractures. In addition, the simultaneous ilioinguinal and Kocher-Langenbeck approaches are the first choices when the both-column fractures possessing extremely severe and obvious displacement.

Conclusion

The reasonable choice of surgical approach is extremely important for acetabular both-column fractures. Each surgical approach has its advantages and limitations. It is necessary to take the precise reposition of the acetabular joint surface as the principle, and comprehensively judge the fracture types and severity of anterior column, posterior column, and square area, and then select the optimal surgical approach for surgical treatment.

Factors affecting the functional outcome of surgically managed displaced acetabular fractures

PURPOSE OF STUDY

To evaluate the impact of various factors on functional outcome of surgically managed displaced acetabular fractures.

METHODS

In this prospective study 50 cases of surgically managed displaced acetabular fractures were followed up to a mean of 28.6±4 months (18-48 months). The effect of age, associated injuries, fracture pattern (elementary/associated type), time to surgery (<2 weeks/>2 weeks), accuracy of reduction (anatomical/imperfect/poor), gender and associated hip dislocation on the clinical outcome was evaluated using Harris hip score and modified Postel Merle d'Aubigné score.

RESULTS

The mean age was 36.6±11.9 years (range 19-67 years). There were 76% (n=38) males and 24% (n=12) females. 82% (n=41) patients sustained fracture due to motor vehicle accident. 60% of the cases had associated injuries. The mean Harris hip score at final follow-up was 80.96±8.9 and mean modified Merle d'Aubigné and Postel score was 15.1±2.4. The Harris Hip score and modified Postel Merle d'Aubigné score was significantly affected by presence of associated injuries (P=0.0025 and 0.0037 respectively), time to surgery (P=0.0087 and 0.0093 respectively), fracture pattern (P=0.015 and 0.023 respectively), associated hip dislocation (P=0.011 and 0.008 respectively), accuracy of reduction (P<0.05) and age (P<0.05), but gender (P=0.78 and 0.93 respectively) didn't have any significant effect on the clinical outcome.

CONCLUSION

The presence of associated injuries, concomitant hip dislocation, associated type of fracture patterns, elderly age (more than 60 years), sub optimal fracture reduction and delay in surgery beyond 2 weeks are factors that lead to statistically significant suboptimal functional scores.

Return to work after surgically treated acetabular fractures in an Asian population

BACKGROUND

Acetabular fractures are rare but are severe injuries that occur in younger patients with a significant economic impact. There is limited evidence describing the return to work rates in this group of patients. The aim of our study was to examine the rate and time to return to work (RTW) after surgical fixation of acetabular fractures.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective study on all patients with surgically treated acetabular fractures at a single institution between 1 July 2010 and 31 December 2018. Medical records were reviewed to analyze demographics such as age, gender, occupation and RTW characteristics.

RESULTS

There were 30 patients, with a mean age of 43.3 ± 12.7 years. There were 26 patients who were employed prior to injury. The most common mechanism of injury was from a road traffic accident (73.3%). The average ISS was 8.9 ± 5.2. The mean follow-up duration was 21.5 months ± 15.7. The rate of RTW was 80.8%. Eighteen patients (85.7%) returned to the same job and duties, while two (9.5%) returned with same job but lighter duties and one (4.8%) had to change job. Three patients (11.5%) retired. The average time to return to work was 8.3 months (range 2-57.5). RTW rates were 15.4%, 61.5%, 69.2% at 3, 6 and 12 months, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Acetabular fractures can lead to loss of economic productivity, with 80.8% of patients returning to work. Work reintegration programs after acetabular fractures are important.

Total Hip Arthroplasty After Prior Acetabular Fracture: Infection Is a Real Concern

BACKGROUND

Acetabular fractures often require surgical intervention for fracture fixation and can result in premature osteoarthritis of the hip joint. This study hypothesized that total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients with a prior acetabular fracture who had undergone open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) is associated with a higher rate of subsequent periprosthetic joint infection (PJI).

METHODS

About 72 patients with a history of acetabular fracture that required ORIF, undergoing conversion THA between 2000 and 2017 at our institution, were matched based on age, gender, body mass index, Charlson comorbidity index, and date of surgery in a 1:3 ratio with 215 patients receiving primary THA. The mean follow-up for the conversion THA cohort was 2.9 years (range, 1-12.15) and 3.06 years (range, 1-12.96) for the primary THA.

RESULTS

Patients with a previous acetabular fracture, compared with the primary THA patients, had longer operative times, greater operative blood loss, and an increased need for allogeneic blood transfusion (26.4% vs 4.7%). Most notably, PJI rate was significantly higher in acetabular fracture group at 6.9% compared with 0.5% in the control group. Complications, such as aseptic revision, venous thromboembolism, and mortality, were similar between both groups.

CONCLUSION

The present study demonstrates that conversion THA in patients with prior ORIF of acetabular fractures is associated with higher complication rate, in particular PJI, and less optimal outcome compared with patients undergoing primary THA. The latter findings compel us to seek and implement specific strategies that aim to reduce the risk of subsequent PJI in these patients.

Epidemiological assessment of acetabular fractures in a level one trauma centre: A 7-Year observational study

PURPOSE

The present study was conducted to evaluate the epidemiological characteristics of the Acetabular fractures treated in a level one trauma centre of India. This study is one of the largest to provide first-hand information regarding the demography, fracture patterns, other associated injuries, and the hospital stay of acetabular fractures in India.

METHOD

Patients admitted with the diagnosis of acetabular fractures between January 2013 and November 2019 were retrospectively analyzed in terms of demographic data such as age and sex, mechanism of injury, other associated injuries, and the duration of hospital stay.

RESULTS

A total of 305 patients with 313 fractures of the acetabulum were included in the study. Among the 305 patients, 268 (87.8%) were male and 37 (12.1%) were female, with a declining male to female ratio over the years. The mean age was 37.1 ± 13.2 years (range 14-84 years). During the seven years, the mean age of presentation progressively increased. Linear regression showed an increase from 33 to 40 years from 2013 to 2019 (R2 = 0.027). Road traffic injuries were the most common mechanism of injury, contributing to about 77.4% of all cases. Associated injuries were seen in 62% of total cases with multiple system involvement in 26.6% of patients. The most frequent pattern in this epidemiological study was an isolated posterior wall fracture (21.4%) while the isolated anterior wall was the least frequent (0.95%).

CONCLUSION

Acetabular fractures are increasing in numbers and with increasing knowledge so is their surgical management in our country. It shall be prudent to establish an integrated electronic national trauma registry to maintain complete documentation in all institutions dealing with trauma management to ascertain the changing trends of acetabular fracture patterns in the country over time.

[Comparison of effectiveness between two combined anterior and posterior approaches for complicated acetabular fractures]

Objective

To compare the effectiveness between modified ilioinguinal approach combined with Kocher-Langenbeck (K-L) approach and Stoppa approach combined with K-L approach for the treatment of complicated acetabular fractures.

Methods

Between May 2011 and May 2016, Sixty-two patients with complicated acetabular fractures were treated with operation via combined anterior and posterior approaches. Thirty-four cases (group A) were treated with modified ilioinguinal approach combined with K-L approach, and 28 cases (group B) were treated with Stoppa approach combined with K-L approach. There was no significant difference in gender, age, injury causes, the type of fracture, time from injury to operation, and associated injury between 2 groups ( P>0.05). The operation time, intraoperative blood loss, and hospitalization time were recorded. X-ray film was performed to evaluate the fracture reduction according to the Matta reduction criteria and observe the fracture healing, osteoarthritis, and heterotopic ossification. Clinical results were evaluated according to the grading system of modified d'Aubigne and Postel.

Results

There was no significant difference in operation time, intraoperative blood loss, and hospitalization time between 2 groups ( P>0.05). Postoperative incision fat liquefaction occurred in 2 cases in group A and group B respectively, and deep vein thrombosis of lower extremity occurred in 1 case in group A. No iatrogenic injury was found in 2 groups. Fifty-six patients were followed up after operation. Thirty patients in group A were followed up 12-48 months (mean, 31.8 months). Twenty-six patients in group B were followed up 12-46 months (mean, 30.2 months). At 12 months after operation, according to the grading system of modified d'Aubigne and Postel, the hip function was rated as excellent in 9 cases, good in 16 cases, fair in 3 cases, and poor in 2 cases, with the excellent and good rate of 83.3% in group A; the hip function was rated as excellent in 7 cases, good in 14 cases, fair in 2 cases, and poor in 3 cases, with the excellent and good rate of 80.8% in group B. There was no significant difference in the hip function between 2 groups ( Z=0.353, P=0.724). The X-ray films showed that there were 23 cases of anatomical reduction, 6 cases of satisfactory reduction, and 1 case of unsatisfactory reduction in group A, and 20 cases, 5 cases, and 1 case in group B, respectively. There was no significant difference in the results of fracture reduction between 2 groups ( Z=0.011, P=0.991). Fracture healing was observed in both groups. There was no significant difference in fracture healing time between 2 groups ( t=0.775, P=0.106). During follow-up, 5 cases of osteoarthritis changes, 2 cases of heterotopic ossification, and 2 cases of avascular necrosis of femoral head occurred in group A, and 4 cases, 2 cases, and 1 case in group B, respectively. The difference between 2 groups was not significant ( P>0.05).

Conclusion

According to the location and type of fracture, making a choice between the modified anterior approach and Stoppa approach, and then combined with K-L approach for treatment of complicated acetabular fracture, can obtain satisfactory effectiveness.