A novel electroneurography method in facial palsy

Prognostic value of electroneurography using the midline method for predicting the development of synkinesis after peripheral facial palsy

OBJECTIVE

The prognostic value of electroneurography (ENoG) for predicting the incidence of synkinesis is reportedly about 40 % using the formal standard method (ENoG-SM). However, the prognostic value of ENoG using the newly developed midline method (ENoG-MM) has not been determined. The aim of this study was to demonstrate the optimal prognostic value and advantages of ENoG-MM for predicting the incidence of synkinesis.

METHODS

Participants were 573 patients treated for peripheral facial palsy including Bell's palsy or Ramsay Hunt syndrome. We investigated the clinical presence of any oral-ocular or ocular-oral synkinesis from the medical records. ENoG-MM and ENoG-SM were performed 10-14 days after symptom onset. In ENoG-MM, compound muscle action potentials were recorded by placing the anode on the mental protuberance and the cathode on the philtrum. In ENoG-SM, electrodes were placed on the nasolabial fold. Synkinesis was clinically assessed at the end of follow-up or at >1 year after onset. The sensitivity and specificity of ENoG values for predicting the incidence of synkinesis were compared between ENoG-MM and ENoG-SM at every 5 % around 40 % (range, 30-50 %).

RESULTS

At every 5 % of ENoG values around 40 %, ENoG-MM provided higher sensitivity and lower specificity for predicting the incidence of synkinesis compared with ENoG-SM. In particular, when the cut-off value was set at 45 %, sensitivity was 100 % and 95.3 % with ENoG-MM and ENoG-SM, respectively.

CONCLUSION

In peripheral facial palsy, ENoG-MM offered higher sensitivity than ENoG-SM for predicting synkinesis. ENoG-MM is useful for screening patients at risk of developing synkinesis. In clinical practice, an ENoG-MM cut-off value of 45 % must be the optimal prognostic value because of the 100 % sensitivity.

An electrophysiological prognostic diagnosis for facial palsy

Two electrophysiological tests for facial palsy-electroneurography (ENoG) and nerve excitability test (NET)-were reviewed. ENoG has advantages over NET in that it reflects the percentage of degenerated facial nerve fibers and can provide an accurate prognosis. However, as disadvantages, ENoG requires large, expensive equipment, and such supramaximal electrical stimulation can be quite painful for patients. NET is less painful due to weak stimulation with just enough current to meet the threshold, and the required equipment is compact and inexpensive to procure. However, it is impossible to calculate the percentage of degenerated nerve fibers, and NET is inferior to ENoG in terms of accurate prognostic prediction for facial palsy. The appropriate timing for both ENoG and NET is 7 to 10 days after the onset. While ENoG has proven more popular than NET because of its accuracy for prognostic prediction, we should not predict the prognosis of facial palsy based solely on the results of electrophyisiolgical examinations; a comprehensive evaluation including the facial muscle grading system is essential.

Optimal current intensity for supramaximal stimulation during electroneurography for facial palsy

OBJECTIVE

To determine the optimal current intensity for supramaximal stimulation during electroneurography (ENoG) for facial palsy.

METHODS

Forty patients with unilateral facial palsy (32 Bell's palsy, 7 Ramsay Hunt syndrome, and 1 temporal bone fracture) were enrolled. All patients were initially treated with intravenous steroid injections and examined using ENoG. Compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) of the orbicularis oris muscle were measured on the paralyzed and healthy sides. Stimulation current intensity was varied every 5 mA from 20 mA to 50 mA using two recording methods (the midline and standard methods). The CMAPs of both sides were monitored to see whether they would saturate under the high current intensity stimulation or not.

RESULTS

No obvious saturation of CMAPs was observed in either side with the midline or standard methods. Statistically, a current of 35 mA and above in the healthy side, and 30 mA and above in the paralytic side, resulted in no difference to each side when using the midline recording method. On the other hand, a current of 35 mA and above in the healthy side, and 25 mA and above in the paralytic side, resulted in no difference to each side when using the standard recording method.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that a current intensity of at least 35 mA is required to achieve supramaximal stimulation on the healthy side in a patient with unilateral facial nerve palsy. Clinically, for simplicity or standardization purposes, if the same current intensity is introduced bilaterally for ENoG measurements, adopting 40 mA (35 mA plus 10-20%) stimulation would be appropriate for supramaximal stimulation, while being cognizant of the potential effects of artifacts from other muscles.

Electrodiagnostic testing in acute facial palsy: Outcomes and comparison of methods

OBJECTIVE

To study the relationship between various electrodiagnostic modalities in acute facial palsy.

SETTING

Academic tertiary care center.

PATIENTS

One-hundred and six patients who presented with traumatic or non-traumatic acute facial paralysis (House-Brackmann, HB, grade 6/6) between 2008 and 2017 and underwent acute electrodiagnostic testing.

INTERVENTION

Electroneurography (ENoG) using nasolabial fold (NLF) or nasalis muscle (NM) methods, and volitional electromyography (EMG) in all patients.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Percent degeneration of ipsilateral facial nerve compound muscle action potentials (CMAP) on NLF- and NM-ENoG, presence or absence of muscle unit potentials (MUPs) on EMG.

RESULTS

Extent of facial nerve degeneration measured by NLF- and NM-ENoG were highly correlated (r = 0.85, P < .01) on each test and on serial testing. NLF- and NM-ENoG concordantly diagnosed ≥90% degeneration in 44 patients (80%), of whom 32 patients were diagnosed to have 100% degeneration by both methodologies. Absence of MUPs on EMG was 63% sensitive and 92% specific for ≥90% degeneration on ENoG, with a positive predictive value of 90%. For patients with Bell's palsy, percent degeneration on ENoG was also correlated to HB score at 1 year. Surgical decompression resulted in mean HB scores of 2.2 and 3.0 for patients with Bell's palsy and trauma, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

NM-ENoG may be a valid and comparable method to NLF-ENoG for predicting the recovery of facial nerve function in acute paralysis. Absence of MUPs on EMG is a specific measure of severe degeneration and highly predictive of candidacy for surgical decompression.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 3.

Electroneurography value as an indicator of high risk for the development of moderate-to-severe synkinesis after Bell's palsy and Ramsay Hunt syndrome

Background: The degree of distress caused by the sequelae of peripheral facial nerve palsy usually depends on the severity of synkinesis. Objective: To clarify whether electroneurography (ENoG) can predict the severity of synkinesis after peripheral facial nerve palsy. Materials and methods: One-hundred and fourteen patients treated for facial nerve palsy at our hospital from April 2014-September 2016 were retrospectively reviewed. ENoG was performed 10-16 days after symptom onset. Patients were classified into Groups A (ENoG value 10%-20%, n = 9) and B (ENoG value <10%, n = 21). Eight months after symptom onset, electrophysiological and symptomatic outcomes were evaluated as the aberrant regeneration ratio of the blink reflex and the total synkinesis score of the Sunnybrook facial grading system, respectively. The outcomes of the groups were compared. Results: Group B had a significantly higher median aberrant regeneration ratio (0% versus 87%, p=.015), median total synkinesis score (1 versus 3, p < .001), and incidence of moderate-to-severe synkinesis (0% versus 57.2%, p=.003) than did Group A. Conclusions and significance: Patients with an ENoG value of <10% have higher risks of aberrant regeneration and moderate-to-severe synkinesis than those with an ENoG value of 10%-20%. Patients with ENoG values of <10% may require rehabilitation to prevent synkinesis.

A new electroneurography as a prognostic tool for marginal mandibular nerve paralysis after parotid gland surgery: A preliminary evaluation

OBJECTIVE

Marginal mandibular nerve paralysis is the most frequent complication of benign parotid tumor surgery and results in cosmetic deformity. The purpose of this study was to develop a new electroneurography method for marginal mandibular nerve paralysis using electroneurography (ENoG) and judge its usefulness for clinical practice.

METHODS

Twenty-seven patients who underwent surgery for benign parotid tumor were enrolled. We proposed and use the mandibular angle method, in which the recording electrode was placed on the skin above the depressor anguli oris muscle while the reference electrode was placed on the skin of the parietal region, and percutaneous electrical stimulation was applied to enclose the mandibular angle that could measure the function of the marginal mandibular nerve solely. Preoperative and postoperative ENoG values were compared in paralytic and non-paralytic patients.

RESULTS

The mean postoperative ENoG value (35.0%) was lower than the preoperative value (90.5%) in paralytic patients, whereas no difference was observed between preoperative (79.3%) and postoperative (69.5%) ENoG values in non-paralytic patients.

CONCLUSION

A new ENoG method (mandibular angle method) was thought to reflect marginal mandibular nerve injury and might be useful for determining the likelihood of paralysis.

The midline electroneurography method for facial palsy reflects total nerve degeneration

CONCLUSION

The midline electroneurography (ENoG) method might reflect total facial nerve degeneration.

OBJECTIVE

We compared ENoG values in patients with facial palsy using two different methods, the midline method and five electroneurogram recordings, to reveal whether the ENoG value obtained with the midline method reflects total facial nerve degeneration.

METHODS

Forty patients with facial palsy were enrolled. Compound muscle action potentials (CMAPs) were recorded using the midline method, in which the anode was placed on the mental protuberance and the cathode was placed on the philtrum. Additionally, five electroneurogram recordings were obtained by placing the anode on the skin of the parietal region and five cathodes on the skin over five facial muscles (frontalis, orbicularis oculi, nasalis, orbicularis oris, and depressor anguli oris muscles). ENoG values recorded using the two methods were compared.

RESULTS

The ENoG values of the five facial muscles did not differ from those obtained using the midline method. The total ENoG value calculated by summing five CMAPs from five facial muscles, which is considered to reflect total facial nerve degeneration, was not significantly different from that using midline methods; moreover, a strong positive correlation coefficient (r = 0.87) was found between them.