Experimental studies of thermotolerance in vivo. I. The baby rat tail model

Potential femoral head osteonecrosis model induced by high-intensity focused ultrasound

Osteonecrosis of the femoral head is a common disease that can result in complex hip replacement. To evaluate potential treatments, a model that consistently creates osteonecrosis is needed. We studied and demonstrated the possibility of developing an osteonecrosis model using high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) on canine femora in vitro. To achieve these goals, the temperature in the medullary cavity of the femoral head was measured. A phenomenological model was developed to fit the measured temperature variations with the HIFU parameters for similar HIFU experiments on femoral heads. The average temperature discrepancy between model and measured values was less than 0.83°C. Histology confirmed that the temperature in the medullary cavity can be elevated to a level at which an acute thermal injury is created. HIFU has the potential to be used in a non-invasive model of osteonecrosis.

Thermal tolerance reduces hyperthermia-induced disruption of working memory: a role for endogenous opiates?

Previous reports indicate that microwave-induced hyperthermia can impair learning and memory. Here, we report that preexposure to a single 20-min period of hyperthermia can produce thermal tolerance and, thereby, attenuate future physiological and behavioral reactions to heating. Because endogenous opioids have been implicated in thermoregulation and reactions to microwave exposure, we also determined how opioid receptor antagonism might modulate these effects. In an initial experiment, rats were exposed daily, over 5 successive days, to 600-MHz microwaves (at a whole-body specific absorption rate of 9.3 W/kg) or sham exposed. In animals exposed to microwaves, thermal tolerance was evidenced by declining rectal temperatures over time. Temperature reductions following microwave exposure were prominent after a single previous exposure. Therefore, in a second study, a single hyperthermic episode was used to induce thermal tolerance. On Day 1, rats were either exposed, over a 20-min period, to 600-MHz microwaves (at a whole-body specific absorption rate of 9.3 W/kg) or sham exposed. Just prior to radiation/sham-radiation treatment, rats received either saline or naltrexone (0.1 or 10 mg/kg, intraperitoneally (i.p.)). The following day (Day 2), rats were either microwave or sham exposed and tested on a task which measures the relative time subjects explore a familiar versus a novel stimulus object. Normothermic rats spend significantly more time in contact with new environmental components and less time with familiar objects. Brain (dura) and rectal temperatures were recorded on both days of the study. Microwave exposure produced a reliable hyperthermia which was significantly lower (on Day 2) in rats receiving repeated treatments (tolerant group). On the behavioral test, rats exposed only once to microwave-induced hyperthermia (nontolerant group) exhibited significantly different patterns of object discrimination than did tolerant or sham-exposed animals. Sham-exposed and tolerant animals showed a distinct preference for the new object whereas the nontolerant animals did not. Naltrexone (10 mg/kg) antagonized the hyperthermia-induced disruption of the object discrimination task (in nontolerant rats) and produced patterns of object exploration that were similar to those of sham-irradiated and thermal-tolerant rats, suggesting that endogenous opioids play a role in the organism's response to heating. Taken together, these data are consistent with the conclusions that 1) microwave-induced hyperthermia can cause a dose-dependent disruption of the normal discrimination between new and familiar objects, 2) physiological reactions to a single hyperthermic episode can produce a thermotolerance that expresses itself in both reduced levels of hyperthermia and attenuated behavioral disruptions following microwave exposure, and 3) opioid antagonism can partially reverse some of the behavioral effects of microwave-induced hyperthermia.

The development and magnitude of thermotolerance during chronic hyperthermia in murine bone marrow granulocyte-macrophage progenitors: I

Murine bone marrow granulocyte-macrophage progenitors (CFU-GM) are capable of developing thermotolerance during exposure to temperatures < 42.5 degrees C. Bone marrow from the tibia and femora was heated to 40-42 degrees C (i.e. chronic hyperthermia), and challenged immediately with 15 min at 44 degrees C at regular intervals during treatment (step-up heating). CFU-GM were heated and cultured in McCoy's 5A medium + 15% FBS (fetal bovine serum) and lung-conditioned medium (source of colony stimulating factor) in semisolid agar. The kinetics of thermotolerance development and decay, and the magnitude of the thermotolerance during chronic heating with temperatures of 40-41.5 degrees C were similar. Survival increased rapidly to a maxima by approximately 120 min of hyperthermia (temperatures of 40-41.5 degrees C) and thereafter decreased with a slope similar to the controls. Normalization for cell killing by chronic hyperthermia that occurred during "step-up' heating permitted analysis of thermotolerance in the surviving cells. The surviving fraction after 15 min at 44 degrees C, during incubation at 40, 41 and 41.5 degrees C increased from 0.13 to maxima of 0.56 +/- 0.04, 0.71 +/- 0.03 and 0.82 +/- 0.03 respectively, by 150 min and did not decrease for up to 480 min during chronic hyperthermia. The surviving fraction after 15 min at 44 degrees C during incubation at 42 degrees C increased more slowly than during incubations at 40-41.5 degrees C. The survival of thermotolerant cells after exposure to 15 min at 44 degrees C during 42 degrees C chronic hyperthermia was maximal at 0.87 +/- 0.08 by 120 min and then decreased after approximately 150 min of exposure to 42 degrees C. The thermotolerance ratios (TTR's) were 4.0, 5.4, 6.7 and 6.9 for temperatures of 40, 41, 41.5 and 42 degrees C respectively. The results suggest that chronic hyperthermia temperatures (i.e. 40-42 degrees C) induce rapid thermotolerance development in CFU-GM during the thermal exposure and protect this normal marrow progenitor during whole body hyperthermia or ex vivo purging of leukaemic cells.

Hyperthermia in cancer growth regulation

With present techniques, hyperthermia used alone can cause complete clinical regression in 10-15% of tumours but the duration of response is very short. The greatest advantage for hyperthermia at the present time appears to be in combination with radiation in the local control of cancer growth. Currently, large randomised phase III studies are in progress to determine whether the addition of local hyperthermia to radiation or chemotherapy yields significant advantage. Phase III studies of wholebody hyperthermia in combination with chemotherapy are planned for the future and will include tumours with a high growth fraction such as small cell lung cancer and high grade non Hodgkins lymphoma.

Thermotolerance in the mouse foot estimated at various levels of normal tissue damage

The effect of fractionated 43.7 degrees C water bath heating on the skin of CDF1 mice was investigated. The normal tissue damage was scored at five levels (from slight redness and oedema to loss of a toe or greater damage) according to an arbitrary score system. The heating time to induce a given level of damage in half of the treated animals (RD50) was used as an end point. The feet were exposed either to a single treatment at 43.7 degrees C for different time periods or to a priming treatment of 30 min. at 43.7 degrees C followed at different intervals by a second graded heat treatment at 43.7 degrees C. In all treatment schedules, the score level increased proportionally with heating time, and the score system offered a good description of the acute skin damage following hyperthermia. The priming heat treatment induced thermotolerance with a time course independent of the score level chosen to estimate the heat response. The thermotolerance developed rapidly, reached a maximum within a 24 hr. interval, and then decayed slowly. The degree of thermotolerance was calculated by means of two previously described formulas for the thermotolerance ratio (TTR). The kinetics of thermotolerance in the skin of mice was independent of the TTR formula, whereas the degree of thermotolerance depended on both the score level and the TTR formula used.

Studies relevant to a means of quantifying the effects of hyperthermia

There is as yet no fully satisfactory method of defining 'thermal dose'. However, in order to relate different hyperthermal treatments it has been suggested that the relationship between heating time and temperature be used to derive an isoeffect parameter which might be useful in this context. The equation t2/t1 = RT1-T2, where t is the treatment time, T the temperature, R = 2 for T greater than 42.5 degrees C and R = approximately 6 for T less than 42.5 degrees C, has been shown to fit the isoeffect data from many studies both in vivo and in vitro. Whether or not this relationship is applicable when the temperature is varying has been tested using an animal model system, i.e. the response of the baby rat tail. It has shown that the relationship between time and temperature is indeed characterized by the above equation, and the phenomena of thermotolerance and step-down sensitization were clearly demonstrated. Tails were then alternated between waterbaths at different temperatures in order to simulate varying temperature. The measured effects were, in general, in good agreement with those derived from the formula. The maximum difference between the observed and predicted effect, obtained under rather extreme conditions unlikely to be experienced clinically, amounted to an under-estimate of the effective temperature by approximately 0.3 degrees C, i.e. a net small effect of thermotolerance. It is therefore suggested that the above formula for 'heat dose' provides a reasonable interim method for comparing clinical hyperthermic treatments. The formula does not, however, account for differing absolute sensitivities between tissues nor for effects of fractionating heat treatments.

1985 Douglas Lea memorial lecture. Hyperthermia in the treatment of cancer

There are sound biological reasons for using hyperthermia in the treatment of malignant disease. This review includes a discussion of this rationale and describes effects of hyperthermia either given alone or in combination with ionising radiation to cells in vitro, tumours or normal tissues. Topics discussed include thermotolerance, step-down sensitisation, fractionation, re-treatment of previously irradiated sites, thermal enhancement ratio and thermal dose. Problems of heat delivery and temperature measurement are considered and the current status of clinical studies is stated briefly.

Influence of prior heat treatment on the effects of heat alone or combined with X-rays on mouse stromal tissue

The tumour bed effect assay was used to study the sensitivity of mouse stromal tissue to heat applied alone or combined with irradiation. Prior heat treatment, 30 min at 43 degrees C, of the tumour bed led to thermotolerance. After priming, thermotolerance developed fully within 24 h and it had disappeared completely after about 10 days. The kinetics of development and decay of thermotolerance in this slowly dividing tissue is similar to that which we had observed previously in skin. When decay rates of several normal tissues with different proliferation characteristics are compared, it is obvious that there is not a clear relationship between proliferation rate of the presumed target cells in the tissue and thermotolerance decay rate.