Long-term abolition of parkinsonian tremor following attempted ventriculography

Pretargeting For The Implantation Of Stimulation Electrodes Into The Subthalamic Nucleus:A Comparative Study Of Magnetic Resonance Imaging And Ventriculography

OBJECTIVE:

The optimal imaging modality for preoperative targeting of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) for high-frequency stimulation is controversially discussed. Commonly used methods were stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), stereotactic ventriculography, and fusion between MRI and stereotactic computer tomography. All of these techniques not only have their own advantages but also specific limitations and drawbacks. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of the preoperative MRI targeting as compared with ventriculography in terms of both the STN target as well as the internal landmarks.

METHODS:

Thirty patients with Parkinson's disease who underwent bilateral surgery for STN-high-frequency stimulation received both stereotactic ventriculography and stereotactic MRI. The theoretical target was determined by each of these two imaging modalities. The final electrode placement was performed after extensive electrophysiological evaluation using microrecording and microstimulation. The real target was assumed to be given by the electrode contact with the best clinical result assessed by the United Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale in the postoperative follow-up. In addition, the coordinates of the two landmarks, anterior commissure and posterior commissure, were determined using both imaging methods.

RESULTS:

The mean targeting error was 4.1 ± 1.7 mm (mean ± standard deviation) for MRI and 2.4 ± 1.1 mm for ventriculography (P < 0.0001). The mean target mismatch between the two imaging methods was 2.9 ± 1.2 mm. The length of the anterior commissure-posterior commissure distance differed significantly (P < 0.0001) between MRI (27.6 ± 1.6 mm) and ventriculography (25.0 ± 1.3 mm). The mismatch was mainly induced by an anterior diplacement of the anterior commissure by 1.9 ± 2.2 mm (P < 0.0001) in MRI determination, as compared with ventriculography.

CONCLUSION:

Our findings show that the indirect targeting of the STN using coordinates based on radiological landmarks is more accurate than the direct targeting using anatomic visualization of the target structure. Regardless of the imaging procedure, electrophysiological mapping is required for optimal electrode placement, although in 20% of cases, the target determined by MRI falls out of the radius explored by electrophysiology.

Deep brain stimulation for Parkinson’s disease

Deep brain stimulation at high frequency was first used in 1997 to replace thalamotomy in treating the characteristic tremor of Parkinson's disease, and has subsequently been applied to the pallidum and the subthalamic nucleus. The subthalamic nucleus is a key node in the functional control of motor activity in the basal ganglia. Its inhibition suppresses symptoms in animal models of Parkinson's disease, and high frequency chronic stimulation does the same in human patients. Acute and long-term results after deep brain stimulation show a dramatic and stable improvement of a patient's clinical condition, which mimics the effects of levodopa treatment. The mechanism of action may involve a functional disruption of the abnormal neural messages associated with the disease. Long-term changes, neural plasticity and neural protection might be induced in the network. Similar effects of stimulation and lesioning have led to the extension of this technique for other targets and diseases.

Imaging of subthalamic nucleus and ventralis intermedius of the thalamus

The techniques of targeting the subthalamic nucleus (STN) and the ventralis intermedius nucleus (Vim) are similar, only the coordinates are different. Targeting ideally consists of gathering all data about a target and positioning the electrode correctly within that target. The electrode should be positioned within a statistical range of coordinates, where the neuronal firing fits a given pattern and responds to external stimuli, particularly to proprioceptive inputs, in a somatotopically organized manner. Moreover, final placement should provide the best clinical improvement of symptoms under the stimulation parameters expected to be used in the long term. This latter criterion is by far the most important, because intraoperative findings indicate the functional benefit for the patient, which is the ultimate purpose of this surgery. A variety of radiological modalities are available to provide data for electrode placement, but each type has its drawbacks. Ventriculography, although safe when performed accordingly to strict technical procedure, is the most precise method but provides more indirect targeting and is more invasive than magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). MRI is the best method for visualizing the STN and, to some extent, for discerning the Vim, but it is plagued with unpredictable and nonreproducible deformations that induce a systematic distortion. These shortcomings no doubt will be corrected in the near future, and the technologies will better assist us in the proper placement of electrodes, which will provide the patient with the highest possible benefit.

Comparison of MRI-guided and ventriculography-based stereotactic surgery for Parkinson's disease

Stereotactic surgery for Parkinson's disease can be performed using different neuroimaging methods. Ventriculography has been used to locate the coordinates of the structures close to the third ventricle. Although it has several potential disadvantages related to the intraventricular injection of iodine contrast, it is considered a precise method. Computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging have been used in some centers. In order to compare their efficacy, 50 stereotactic thalamotomies for Parkinson's disease were performed using either ventriculography (VE) (25) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (25). In 14 out of 25 VE procedures, computed tomography (CT-scan) was also used and showed a significant mean difference of coordinate Y and Z. The clinical results employing either VE or MRI were similar, with 80% abolition of tremor in the VE group, and 84% in the MRI group, after a follow up period of at least 3 months. Another 12% of VE and 16% of MRI group showed significant improvement of tremor. Complication rate was 4% in both groups. MRI-guided stereotactic thalamotomy in Parkinson's disease has shown good clinical results, comparable to VE-guided stereotaxis.

Chronic electrical stimulation of the ventralis intermedius nucleus of the thalamus as a treatment of movement disorders

Tremor was suppressed by test stimulation of the thalamic ventralis intermedius (VIM) nucleus at high frequency (130 Hz) during stereotaxy in nonanesthetized patients suffering from Parkinson's disease or essential tremor. Ventralis intermedius stimulation has since been used by the authors over the last 8 years as a treatment in 117 patients with movement disorders (80 cases of Parkinson's disease, 20 cases of essential tremor, and 17 cases of various dyskinesias and dystonias including four multiple sclerosis). Chronic electrodes were stereotactically implanted in the VIM and connected to a programmable stimulator. Results depend on the indication. In Parkinson's disease patients, tremor, but not bradykinesia and rigidity, was selectively suppressed for as long as 8 years. Administration of L-Dopa was decreased by more than 30% in 40 Parkinson's disease patients. In essential tremor patients, results were satisfactory but deteriorated with time in 18.5% of cases, mainly for patients who presented an action component of their but deteriorated with time in 18.5% of cases, mainly for patients who presented an action component of their tremor. In other types of dyskinesias (except multiple sclerosis), results were much less favorable. Fifty-nine patients underwent bilateral implantation and 14 other patients received implantation contralateral to a previous thalamotomy. Thirty-seven patients (31.6%) experienced minor side effects, which were always well tolerated and immediately reversible. Three secondary scalp infections led to temporary removal of the implanted material. There was no permanent morbidity. This tremor suppression effect could be due to the inhibition or jamming of a retroactive loop. Chronic VIM stimulation, which is reversible, adaptable, and well tolerated even by patients undergoing bilateral surgery (74 of 117 patients) and by elderly patients, should replace thalamotomy in the regular surgical treatment of parkinsonian and essential tremors.

An experimental study to evaluate the accuracy of diencephalic and pallidal target localization using the Brown-Roberts-Wells stereotactic system and unreformatted axial GE8800 CT scanning

An experimental study was undertaken to evaluate the accuracy with which the intercommissural line (IL) length and anterior-posterior commissural (AC-PC) plane could be selected using unreformatted axial CT8800 imaging. Using these reference points, the Schaltenbrandt and Bailey stereotactic atlas and the Brown-Roberts-Wells (BRW) stereotactic system 1.82 mm ball bearings were deposited at selected diencephalic and pallidal targets in cadaver brains. There were errors in both IL length (median 1.5 mm) and AC-PC plane (median forward angulation of 9 degrees) estimation. Ball bearing deposition into large nuclei such as the pulvinar and globus pallidus and those in proximity to the mid IL such as the nuclei ventro oralis anterior (Voa), ventro oralis posterior (Vop) and ventro intermedius (Vim) was generally good; however, localization of the relatively small intralaminar nucleus was poor. This study suggests that when the AC and PC are not well imaged on sagittal reformations of axial diencephalic CT scans estimation of the AC-PC plane and IL from axial CT scans may be accurate enough for anatomical localization of certain functional stereotactic targets. The implications of this experimental study to operative functional stereotaxy are discussed.

Clinical evaluation of computed tomography-guided versus ventriculography-guided thalamotomy for movement disorders

38 patients with Parkinsonian or essential tremor who underwent thalamotomy based on ventriculographic coordinates were compared to 23 patients whose thalamotomy was performed on the basis of computed tomography (CT)-derived target coordinates. The comparison between the two groups concerned the age, sex, duration of disease, target side, intra-operative target correction, duration of postoperative stay in hospital, transient side-effects, permanent complication, and tremor alleviation. The study showed that the surgical results in terms of tremor control were the same in the two groups. However, the percentage of post-operative transient side-effects was higher and the duration of stay in hospital was longer for the ventriculographic patients than for the CT patients.