Time-dependent effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation on changes in spinal excitability are dependent on stimulation frequency: A preliminary study in healthy adults

A comparative study of changes in Hmax/Mmax under spinning permanent magnet stimulation, repetitive peripheral magnetic stimulation, and transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in healthy individuals

Kiso A, Maeda H, Otaka Y, Mori H, Kagaya H. A comparative study of changes in Hmax/Mmax under spinning permanent magnet stimulation, repetitive peripheral magnetic stimulation, and transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in healthy individuals. Jpn J Compr Rehabil Sci 2024; 15: 58-62.

Objective

We have developed a compact device using a spinning permanent magnet (SPM) that induces an electrical field by changing the magnetic flux. We hypothesized that SPM stimulation also reduced spasticity, comparable with repetitive peripheral magnetic stimulation (rPMS) and transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS). This study evaluated the effect of a single session of SPM stimulation and compared it with those of rPMS and TENS in healthy individuals.

Methods

Eleven healthy adult men participated in this study. The active electrode was placed on the soleus muscle, and the reference electrode was placed at 5 cm distal from the active electrode on the medial side of the Achilles tendon. The stimulating electrodes were fixed on the popliteal fossa to stimulate the tibial nerve. The maximum H-reflex (Hmax) and the maximum motor response (Mmax) were measured, and Hmax/Mmax was calculated under the following conditions: a) 15 min SPM stimulation, b) 30 min SPM stimulation, c) 10,000 pulses rPMS, d) 15 min TENS, and e) 15 min rest (control). The devices for SPM, rPMS, and TENS were applied to the belly of the soleus muscle in the prone position.

Results

Compared with the control, Hmax/Mmax significantly decreased under SPM stimulation for 15 and 30 min, as well as under rPMS and TENS (p < 0.005). The changes in Hmax/Mmax under 15 min SPM stimulation were significantly smaller than those under 30 min SPM stimulation and rPMS (p < 0.005).

Conclusion

SPM stimulation reduced Hmax/Mmax in healthy individuals and is a potential new treatment for spasticity.

Acute Effects of Combination Therapy by Triceps Surae Stretching and Electrical Stimulation to the Tibialis Anterior on Medial Forefoot Plantar Pressure During Gait in Patients With Diabetes Mellitus

High plantar flexor moment and limited ankle mobility are known to cause high plantar pressure under the forefoot. Stretching is an effective physical therapy for the limited ankle range of motion (ROM), and electrical stimulation is used to regulate the activity of antagonistic muscle via the action of reciprocal inhibition. Additionally, stretching paired with electrical stimulation has been reported to improve the limited ROM significantly. This study aims to investigate the influences of stretching on triceps surae (STR), electrical stimulation to tibialis anterior (ES), and the combination (ES+STR) on the ROM, kinematic parameters, and plantar pressure distribution during gait in patients with diabetes mellitus. Planter pressure and other parameters were measured before and after the intervention of ES, STR, ES+STR, or the rest sitting on the bed (CON) for 10 min. Pressure time integral under the medial forefoot decreased in the ES+STR compared to CON (P< .05). Interestingly, ES+STR increased passive and dynamic ROM on ankle dorsiflexion during gait and increased the lateral center of pressure excursion (P < .05). Furthermore, these changes were followed by decreased contact duration under the medial forefoot (P < .05). The combined therapy improves ankle mobility during gait and reduces the contact duration and the plantar pressure under the medial forefoot in patients with diabetes mellitus.

Short-term effect of a close-fitting type of walking assistive device on spinal cord reciprocal inhibition

One of the major problems with walking encountered by patients with spastic hemiplegia is diminished toe clearance due to spasticity of their leg muscles. To improve their walking, a specialized robot assist for ankle movements (RE-Gait) has been utilized. The present study examined the neurophysiological effects whether spinal cord reciprocal Ia inhibition (RI) in the leg was altered by using RE-Gait. Sixteen patients with a clinical diagnosis of stroke were divided into the two groups, RE-Gait walking group (Group R) and normal (controlled) walking group (Group C). In each group, they walked on a flat floor for 15 min with or without RE-Gait. The depression of soleus (Sol) H-reflexes conditioned by common peroneal nerve stimuli with the conditioning-test (C-T) intervals of 1, 2, 3, and 4 ms were assessed before and immediately after each walking session. After the intervention, the LSM (SE) of Sol H-reflex amplitude with 1, 2 and 3 ms C-T interval conditions were significantly decreased in group R (1 ms: 88.15 (4.60), 2 ms: 86.37 (4.60), 3 ms: 89.68 (4.62)) compared to group C (1 ms: 105.57 (4.56), 2 ms: 100.89 (4.58), 3 ms: 107.72 (4.58)) [1 ms: p = 0.012, 2 ms: p = 0.035, 3 ms: p = 0.011]. Walking assistive robot that targets ankle movements might be a new rehabilitation tool for regulating spinal cord excitability.

Modulation of plantar pressure and gastrocnemius activity during gait using electrical stimulation of the tibialis anterior in healthy adults

High plantar flexor moment during the stance phase is known to cause high plantar pressure under the forefoot; however, the effects on plantar pressure due to a change of gastrocnemius medialis (GM) activity during gait, have not been investigated to date. Reciprocal inhibition is one of the effects of electrical stimulation (ES), and is the automatic antagonist alpha motor neuron inhibition which is evoked by excitation of the agonist muscle. The aim of this study was to investigate the influences of ES of the tibialis anterior (TA) on plantar pressure and the GM activity during gait in healthy adults. ES was applied to the TAs of twenty healthy male adults for 30 minutes at the level of intensity that causes a full range of dorsiflexion in the ankle (frequency; 50 Hz, on-time; 10 sec, off-time; 10 sec). Subjects walked 10 meters before and after ES, and we measured the peak plantar pressure (PP), pressure time integral (PTI), and gait parameters by using an F-scan system. The percentage of integrated electromyogram (%IEMG), active time, onset time, peak time, and cessation time of TA and GM were calculated. PP and PTI under the forefoot, rear foot, and total plantar surface significantly decreased after the application of ES. Meanwhile, changes of gait parameters were not observed. %IEMG and the active time of both muscles did not change; however, onset time and peak time of GM became significantly delayed. ES application to the TA delayed the timing of onset and peak in the GM, and caused the decrease of plantar pressure during gait. The present results suggest that ES to the TA could become a new method for the control of plantar pressure via modulation of GM activity during gait.

Modulation of spinal inhibitory reflexes depends on the frequency of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation in spastic stroke survivors

Neurophysiological studies in healthy subjects suggest that increased spinal inhibitory reflexes from the tibialis anterior (TA) muscle to the soleus (SOL) muscle might contribute to decreased spasticity. While 50 Hz is an effective frequency for transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) in healthy subjects, in stroke survivors, the effects of TENS on spinal reflex circuits and its appropriate frequency are not well known. We examined the effects of different frequencies of TENS on spinal inhibitory reflexes from the TA to SOL muscle in stroke survivors. Twenty chronic stroke survivors with ankle plantar flexor spasticity received 50-, 100-, or 200-Hz TENS over the deep peroneal nerve (DPN) of the affected lower limb for 30 min. Before and immediately after TENS, reciprocal Ia inhibition (RI) and presynaptic inhibition of the SOL alpha motor neuron (D1 inhibition) were assessed by adjusting the unconditioned H-reflex amplitude. Furthermore, during TENS, the time courses of spinal excitability and spinal inhibitory reflexes were assessed via the H-reflex, RI, and D1 inhibition. None of the TENS protocols affected mean RI, whereas D1 inhibition improved significantly following 200-Hz TENS. In a time-series comparison during TENS, repeated stimulation did not produce significant changes in the H-reflex, RI, or D1 inhibition regardless of frequency. These results suggest that the frequency-dependent effect of TENS on spinal reflexes only becomes apparent when RI and D1 inhibition are measured by adjusting the amplitude of the unconditioned H-reflex. However, 200-Hz TENS led to plasticity of synaptic transmission from the antagonist to spastic muscles in stroke survivors.