The C2 Pedicle Width, Pars Length, and Laminar Thickness in Concurrent Ipsilateral Ponticulus Posticus and High-Riding Vertebral Artery: A Radiological Computed Tomography Scan-Based Study

Influence of variations of craniovertebral junction anatomy on safe C1 lateral mass and C2 pedicle screw insertion: a cadaveric and radiologic study

PURPOSE

The aim of the present study is to analyze the feasibility of a new optimized C1 lateral mass and C2 pedicle screw method that has a suitable trajectory for a range of anatomical variations to decrease the risk of vertebral artery injury.

METHODS

The craniovertebral junction of 17 cadavers (34 sides) were dissected after performing thin-cut computed tomography. The screw entry points, targets, angles, and lengths of the trajectories were performed for C1 lateral mass and C2 pedicle. We particularly focused on the morphometric features and the safety of trajectories in cadavers with vascular and bony variations.

RESULTS

For the C1 lateral mass, the ideal medial and cranial angles were 13.4° ± 1.0° and 14.7° ± 1.1°, respectively. For the C2 pedicle screw, the cranial and medial angles were 27.7° ± 1.4° and 20.4° ± 1.5°, respectively. High-riding vertebral arteries (HRVA) were observed in 35.3% of all cadavers. The incidence of an arcuate foramen was 47% among all sides and its coexistence with an HRVA among all cadavers was 23.5%.

CONCLUSION

Preoperative pedicle-oriented radiological evaluation is crucial before C1 lateral mass and C2 pedicle screw placement because of the high incidence of bony and vascular variations. Using our safe C2 pedicle trajectory, a longer and safer screw course that preserves the vertebral artery can be achieved with a more feasible cranial angle, even with HRVAs, with the exception of narrow pedicle anatomy.

Types of high-riding vertebral artery: a classification system for preoperative planning of C2 instrumentation based on 908 potential screw insertion sites

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Our recent studies indicated that a high-riding vertebral artery (HRVA) is a common variant posing a risk of injuring the vessel during C2 instrumentation. However, several different types fit in the current definition of HRVA, which may require a different strategy for C2 screw placement.

PURPOSE

To classify HRVA and provide a clinical aid for preoperative planning of C2 instrumentation. A secondary goal was to estimate coexistence of each HRVA type with the ipsilateral narrow C2 pedicle (NP).

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective observational study involving radiologic measurements of the estimated number of anonymized cervical computed tomography (CT) scans. STROBE checklist was applied.

PATIENT SAMPLE

A total of 908 potential screw insertion sites (PSIS) of 454 consecutive cervical CT scans were analyzed. The sample size was estimated using ScalaR SP function in RStudio.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Three types of HRVA based on a series of C2 vertebral morphological parameters including the C2 isthmus height (C2IsH) and C2 internal height (C2InH). Also, the prevalences of each HRVA type and coexisting NP based on the C2 pedicle width (C2PW).

METHODS

HRVA was defined as C2IsH of ≤5 mm and/or C2InH of ≤2 mm measured 3 mm lateral to the lateral border of the spinal canal. A narrow pedicle was defined as C2PW of ≤4 mm. Measurements were done using Syn.govia software. Interobserver, intraobserver, and inter-software agreement coefficients for C2IsH, C2InH, and C2PW parameters were adopted from our previous study. K-means cluster analysis was applied.

RESULTS

Prevalence of at least 1 HRVA was 24.9% (n=113 subjects) and 16.2% of PSIS (n=147 sites). Based on the measurements and K-means clustering, the following 3 types of HRVA have been distinguished: type 1-isthmic with only C2IsH being reduced and normal C2InH; type 2-internal with only C2InH being reduced and C2IsH within normal limits; type 3-isthmo-internal with both C2IsH and C2InH being reduced. Kruskal-Wallis test followed by unadjusted and Bonferroni-adjusted posthoc multiple comparison analysis detected significant differences across the types. The prevalences of the newly identified types were as follows: 78.2%, 8.8%, and 12.9% for type 1, type 2, and type 3, respectively. 73.9% of type 1 HRVA, 53.8% of type 2 HRVA, and 100% of type 3 HRVA had a concomitant ipsilateral NP. Prediction of the HRVA types by the K-means clustering has been evaluated. Screw placement techniques for each type are proposed and discussed.

CONCLUSIONS

We present the first classification system for the high-riding vertebral artery distinguishing 3 types based on the large homogenous cohort, which may serve as an adjunct to preoperative planning of C2 instrumentation. External validation of this classification scheme shall determine its further clinical utility.

The association between unilateral high-riding vertebral artery and atlantoaxial joint morphology: a multi-slice spiral computed tomography study of 396 patients and a finite element analysis

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

A high-riding vertebral artery (HRVA) can deviate too medially, too posteriorly, or too superiorly to allow the safe insertion of screws. However, it is unknown whether the presence of a HRVA is associated with morphological changes of the atlantoaxial joint.

PURPOSE

To investigate the association between HRVA and atlantoaxial joint morphology in patients with and without HRVA.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective case-control study and finite element (FE) analysis.

PATIENT SAMPLE

A total of 396 patients with cervical spondylosis underwent multi-slice spiral computed tomography (MSCT) of cervical spine at our institutions from 2020 to 2022.

OUTCOME MEASURES

A series of atlantoaxial joint morphological parameters, including C2 lateral mass settlement (C2 LMS), C1-2 sagittal joint inclination (C1-2 SI), C1-2 coronal joint inclination (C1-2 CI), atlanto-dental interval (ADI), lateral atlanto-dental interval (LADI), and C1-2 relative rotation angle (C1-2 RRA) were measured, and lateral atlantoaxial joints osteoarthritis (LAJs-OA) was recorded. The stress distribution on the C2 facet surface under different torques of flexion-extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation was analyzed by FE models. A 2-Nm moment was applied to all models to determine the range of motion (ROM).

METHODS

A total of 132 consecutive cervical spondylosis patients with unilateral HRVA were enrolled in the HRVA group, and 264 patients without HRVA matched for age and sex were enrolled in the normal (NL) group. Atlantoaxial joint morphological parameters were compared between two sides of C2 lateral mass within HRVA or NL group, and between HRVA and NL groups. A 48-year-old woman with cervical spondylosis without HRVA was selected for cervical MSCT. A three-dimensional (3D) FE intact model of the normal upper cervical spine (C0-C2) was created. We established the HRVA model by simulating atlantoaxial morphological changes of unilateral HRVA with FE method.

RESULTS

The C2 LMS was significantly smaller on the HRVA side than that on the non-HRVA side in the HRVA group, but C1-2 SI, C1-2 CI, and LADI on HRVA side were significantly larger than those on non-HRVA side. There was no significant difference between left and right sides in the NL group. The difference in C2 LMS (d-C2 LMS) between HRVA side and non-HRVA side in the HRVA group was larger than that in the NL group (P < 0.05). Meanwhile, the differences in C1-2 SI (d-C1/2 SI), C1-2 CI (d-C1/2 CI), and LADI (d-LADI) in the HRVA group were significantly larger than those in the NL group. The C1-2 RRA in the HRVA group was significantly larger than that in the NL group. Pearson correlations showed that d-C1/2 SI, d-C1/2 CI, and d-LADI were positively associated with d-C2 LMS (r=0.428, 0.649, 0.498, respectively, p<.05 for all). The incidence of LAJs-OA in the HRVA group (27.3%) was significantly larger than that in the NL group (11.7%). Compared with the normal model, the ROM of C1-2 segment declined in all postures of the HRVA FE model. We found a larger distribution of stress on the C2 lateral mass surface of the HRVA side under different moment conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that HRVA affects the integrity of the C2 lateral mass. This change in patients with unilateral HRVA is associated with the nonuniform settlement of the lateral mass and an increase in the lateral mass inclination, which may further affect the degeneration of the atlantoaxial joint because of the stress concentration on the C2 lateral mass surface.

[The effect of axis pedicle and intra-axial vertebral artery on C 2 pedicle screw placement]

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the influence of axis pedicle and intra-axial vertebral artery (IAVA) alignment on C 2 pedicle screw placement by measuring the data of head and neck CT angiography.

METHODS

The axis pedicle diameter (D), isthmus height (H), isthmus thickness (T), and IAVA alignment types were measured in 116 patients (232 sides) who underwent head and neck CT angiography examinations between January 2020 and June 2020. Defined the IAVA offset direction by referencing the vertical line through the center of C 3 transverse foramen on the coronal scan, it was divided into lateral (L), neutral (N), and medial (M). Defined the IAVA high-riding degree by referencing the horizontal line through the outlet of the C 2 transverse foramen, it was divided into below (B), within (W), and above (A). The rate of pedicle stenosis, high-riding vertebral artery, and different IAVA types were calculated, and their relationships were analysed. Simulative C 2 pedicle screws were implanted by Mimics 19.0 software, and the interrelation among the rates of pedicle stenosis, high-riding vertebral artery, IAVA types, and vertebral artery injury were analyzed.

RESULTS

The rate of C 2 pedicle stenosis was 33.6% (78/232), and the rate of high-riding vertebral artery was 35.3% (82/232). According to the offset direction and the degree of riding, IAVA was divided into 9 types, among which the N-W type (29.3%) was the most, followed by the L-W type (19.0%) and the L-B type (12.9%), accounting for 60.9%. The vertebral artery injury rate of simulative implanted C 2 pedicle screws was 35.3% (82/232). The vertebral artery injury rate in patients with pedicle stenosis and high-riding vertebral artery was significantly higher than that who were not ( P<0.001). The rate of pedicle stenosis, high-riding vertebral artery, and vertebral artery injury were significantly different among IAVA types ( P<0.001), and M-A type was the most common.

CONCLUSION

Vertebral artery injury is more common in pedicle stenosis and/or high-riding vertebral artery and/or IAVA M-A type. Preoperative head and neck CT angiography examination has clinical guiding significance.

Asymmetry of the C2 pars interarticularis: a clinical anatomical study with relevance to screw placement

PURPOSE

Potential asymmetries of the C2 posterior elements pose a problem for the spine surgeon seeking to make the best choice for spinal stabilization while reducing morbidity.

METHODS

A digital caliper was used to measure the pars interarticularis height and length on left and right sides of 25 adult C2 vertebrae. The pars interarticularis was defined as the bone between the posterior most aspect of the superior articular process and the anterior most aspect of the inferior articular process of C2. Also, the C2 vertebrae from 49 patients were scanned by CT. Parasagittal images were reviewed and using the same definitions as were used for the skeletal specimens, the length and the height of the C2 pars interarticularis from both the left and right sides were measured using CT. The image slices were acquired at 3 mm intervals. The pars interarticularis height was determined on sagittal CT reconstruction, while the pars interarticularis length was calculated on the basis of the axial images.

RESULTS

The lengths and the heights of the left and right pars interarticularis were compared using CTs of patients and skeletal specimens. No significant differences were found in the length and height measurements of the CT images on both sides. However, in the skeletal specimens, the left and right pars interarticularis did not differ significantly in length but differed significantly in height (p = 0.003). The mean height of the left pars interarticularis was approximately two times larger than the right in the skeletal specimens. Absolute differences were calculated between the side with the greater length and height and the side with the lesser length and height irrespective of their left-right orientations. For CT measurements, most differences in length and height between the greater pars interarticularis and lesser pars interarticularis occurred between 0 and 1 mm with each successive disparity interval yielding lower numbers. Skeletal measurements revealed a similar length disparity distribution to the CT measurements. However, height measurements in the skeletal specimens varied widely. Eight pars interarticularis specimens demonstrated a height difference between 0 and 1 mm. No dry bone pars interarticularis specimens demonstrated a height difference between 1 and 2 mm. The pars interarticularis of nine specimens demonstrated a height difference between 2 and 3 mm. Two demonstrated a height difference between 3 and 4 mm. Four demonstrated a height difference between 4 and 5 mm and two demonstrated a height difference greater than 5 mm. The greater pars interarticularis lengths and heights were combined and compared to their lesser counterparts on CT and skeletal measurements. In all measurements of this type, significant differences were found in the pars interarticularis length and height, whether measured through CT or via digital calipers.

CONCLUSION

Asymmetry between the left and right C2 pars interarticularis as shown in the present study can alter surgical planning. Therefore, knowledge of this anatomical finding might be useful to spine surgeons.

Assessments of Prevalence of Ponticulus Posticus, Atlas Posterior Arch Deficiency, Sella Turcica Bridging, Maxillary Canine Impaction, and Associations Among Them in 500 CBCTs of Italian Orthodontic Patients

Background: The ponticulus posticus (PP) is an important anomaly of the atlas (C1 vertebra) with a complete or partial bone bridge that transforms the groove of the vertebral artery (VA) into a canal (arcuate foramen). The aim was to retrospectively determine prevalence of PP evaluating morphological features and the possible association with other dentoskeletal anomalies in the midface and neck area such as maxillary canine impaction (MCI), atlas posterior arch deficiency (APAD), and sella turcica bridging (SB).

Methods: This study was conducted in the Department of Medical, Oral and Biotechnological Sciences of the University “G. D'Annunzio” in Chieti. The detection of PP was performed on 500 patients with cone beam CT (CBCT) images (6 to 87 years).

Results: Analysis revealed the presence of uni- and bi-lateral PP in 110 patients (22%): 24 (4.8%) patients with bilateral complete PP, 12 (2.4%) patients with complete PP on the left, 6 (1.2%) patients with complete PP on the right, 8 (1.6%) patients with complete PP on the right and partial PP on the left, 6 (1.2%) patients with complete PP on the left and partial PP on the right, 26 (5.2%) patients with partial bilateral PP, 18 (3.6%) patients with partial left PP, and 10 (2%) patients with partial PP on the right. The Chi-squared statistic confirmed that there are significant associations between MCI and PP (p = 0.020) and between SB and MCI (p &lt;0.00001). No correlation between chronological age and presence of the PP (p = 0.982), between chronological age and morphotypes of the PP (p = 0.779), between APAD and the PP (p = 0.0757), between SB and the PP (p = 0.111), and between APAD and MCI (p = 0.222) were found.

Conclusion: This observational study showed how bilateral partial variant and bilateral complete variant are the most represented morphotypes in all the age groups. The prevalence of MCI is positively associated with PP and with SB.

Surgical Outcomes for C2 Tear Drop Fractures: Clinical Relevance to Hangman's Fracture and C2-3 Discoligamentous Injury

Objective

To analyze characteristics of surgically managed tear drop (TD) fractures of the C₂ axis associated with other injuries such as hangman's fracture and C_2‐3 discoligamentous injury as well as treatment outcomes.

Methods

A total of 14 patients (eight men and six women) with TD fractures of the C₂, who were surgically treated at four national trauma centers of tertiary university hospitals from January 2000 to December 2017, were included in this retrospective study. The mean age of the patients was 45.5 years (ranging from 19 to 74 years). The characteristics, surgical treatment methods (anterior fusion vs posterior fusion), and results of 14 TD fractures of the C₂ were analyzed retrospectively. And the clinical relevance between C₂ TD fracture and hangman's fracture and C_2‐3 discoligamentous injury was investigated through the co‐occurrence between injuries. The mean follow‐up time after surgery was 22.6 months (ranging from 12 to 60 months).

Results

Among 14 patients with TD fracture of the C₂, four patients (28.6%) had anterior TD fracture and 10 patients (71.4%) had posterior TD fracture. All 10 posterior TD fracture patients had anterior C_2‐3 displacement. While two of four anterior TD fracture patients had posterior C_2‐3 displacement, the remaining two did not. All 14 patients of TD fracture had at least two or more other associated C₂ injuries as well as C_2‐3 discoligamentous injuries. About 92.9% (13/14) of the patients had typical or atypical hangman's fracture; 100% (10/10) of the posterior TD fracture patients had hangman's fracture, but 75% (3/4) of the anterior TD fracture had hangman's fracture. At admission, 13 patients were neurologically intact. However, the remaining patient had spinal cord injury with American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) impairment scale B with C_2‐3 bilateral facet dislocation. All four anterior TD fracture patients underwent posterior C_2‐3 fusion. While four of 10 posterior TD fracture patients underwent C_2‐3 anterior fusion, the remaining six underwent posterior fusion. At last follow‐up, 100% (14/14) of the patients achieved solid fusion, and visual analog scale for neck pain was significantly improved (5.9 vs 2.2, P < 0.001). One patient with ASIA impairment scale B had significantly improved to scale D. No major complications occurred.

Conclusion

Our study showed that surgically managed TD fractures of the C₂ showed a high incidence of other associated spine injuries including hangman's fracture and C_2‐3 discoligamentous injury. Therefore, special attention and careful radiologic evaluation are needed to investigate the presence of other associated spine injuries including hangman's fracture and C_2‐3 discoligamentous injury, which are likely to require surgery.

Prevalence of Vertebral artery anomaly in upper cervical and its surgical implications: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

The presence vertebral artery (VA) abnormalities in the upper cervical may be a potential cause of catastrophic complication in the posterior approach of the upper cervical spine surgery. The aim of this study was to demonstrate the real incidence of the V3 segment anomaly in patients who need upper cervical surgery, and tried to find out the risk factors of V3 segment anomaly to evaluate the necessary of computed tomographic angiography (CTA) for upper cervical surgery.

METHOD

This systematic review was conducted following the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-Analyses (PRISMA). Retrospective studies and reports of case series involving human subjects with data on anomalies of vertebral artery in upper cervical spine were included. Data on the prevalence of persistent first intersegmental artery (PIA), fenestration of the VA (FA), posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA) were extracted.

RESULTS

A total of 16 articles involving 5927 subjects met the inclusion criteria. The total incidence of V3 segment anomaly in the patients with bony abnormalities was 25.9% (74/286): PIA was 17.5%, FA was 6.6% and PICA was 1.8%. The total incidence of V3 segment anomaly in the patients without bony abnormalities was 2.7% (152/5671): PIA was 1.76%, FA was 0.4% and PICA was 0.5%. The total incidence of V3 segment anomaly in Asian population without bony abnormalities was 5.8%, while in European and American population was 0.8 and 0.6%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Patients with bone abnormalities are high risk factor for VA abnormalities, CTA is of paramount importance to evaluate the variant VA anatomy. However, regarding to the low incidence of V3 variation in normal population, we do not recommend preoperative CT angiography as mandatory part of preoperative.

Proposal of Treatment Strategy for Pedicle Fractures of the C2: An Analysis of 49 Cases

Spine surgeons often confuse C2 pedicle fractures (PFs) with pars interarticularis fractures. In addition, little information is available about the characteristics and treatment strategies for C2 PFs. We sought to investigate the characteristics of C2 PFs and to propose an appropriate treatment strategy. A total of forty-nine patients with C2 PFs were included in this study. We divided these patients into unilateral and bilateral C2 PF groups. The incidence rates and characteristics of other associated C2 and C2-3 injuries, and other cervical injuries, were evaluated. In addition, treatment methods and outcomes were analyzed. Twenty-two patients had unilateral C2 PFs and twenty-seven patients had bilateral C2 PFs. Among the cases of unilateral C2 PFs, all patients had one or more other C2 fractures, and twenty patients (90.9%) had one or two C2 body fractures. Meanwhile, among the cases of bilateral C2 PF, all patients had two or more other C2 fractures and one or two C2 body fractures. In unilateral C2 PFs, three patients with C2-3 anterior slip or adjacent cervical spine (C1-3) injury underwent surgery and nineteen patients (86.4%) were treated with conservative methods. In bilateral C2 PFs, three patients with C2-3 anterior slip or SCI at C2-3 underwent surgery and twenty-four patients (88.9%) were treated with conservative methods. Our results showed that C2 PFs do not occur alone and are always accompanied by other associated C2 injuries. C2 PFs should, generally, be thought of as a more complex fracture type than hangman's fracture or dens fracture. Despite the complex fracture characteristics, most C2 PFs can be managed with conservative treatment. However, surgical treatments should be considered if the C2 PFs are accompanied by the C2-3 anterior slip and adjacent cervical spine injury.

Prevalence of High-Riding Vertebral Artery: A Meta-Analysis of the Anatomical Variant Affecting Choice of Craniocervical Fusion Method and Its Outcome

OBJECTIVE

A high-riding vertebral artery (HRVA) has been defined as a C2 isthmus height of ≤5 mm and/or internal height of ≤2 mm measured 3 mm lateral to the border of the spinal canal. Its reported prevalence has varied widely. If overlooked during the approach for craniocervical fusion, injury to the vertebral arteries can occur, affecting the outcome. The present meta-analysis aimed to provide the pooled prevalence of HRVAs.

METHODS

A comprehensive database search was conducted by 3 of us. Peer-reviewed studies that had followed the strict definition for HRVAs and had reported its prevalence were included. The risk of bias was assessed using the anatomical quality assessment tool. The PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines were followed. The pooled prevalence was calculated using a random effects model.

RESULTS

The data from 20 studies with 3126 subjects (7496 sides) were analyzed. The overall pooled prevalence of ≥1 HRVA was 25.3% (95% confidence interval [CI], 19.6%-31.5%). The prevalence in those without the most important confounding factor, rheumatoid arthritis (RA), was 20.9% (95% CI, 16.5%-25.8%). Patients with RA had a prevalence of 42.9% (95% CI, 23.8%-63.1%). The difference between the non-RA and RA groups was statistically significant (P < 0.001, test of homogeneity, χ²). No geographical differences were noted (P = 0.20, test of homogeneity, χ²). Among those with HRVA, unilateral HRVA was present in 70.3% (95% CI, 65.2%-75.2%) and bilateral in 29.7% (95% CI, 24.8%-34.8%). No left or right side predilection was found (left, 50.8%; 95% CI, 33.8%-67.6%; right, 49.2%; 95% CI, 32.4%-66.2%).

CONCLUSIONS

Craniocervical fusion should be preceded by examination of the vertebral arteries at the level of C2 because the presence of HRVAs is common and might preclude the safe insertion of transarticular or transpedicular screws.

[Short-term effectiveness of axis laminar screws for reducible atlantoaxial dislocation]

OBJECTIVE

To investigate reliability and short-term effectiveness of axis laminar screws for reducible atlantoaxial dislocation (RAAD).

METHODS

A clinical data of 41 patients with RAAD who were admitted between February 2013 and February 2018 and met the inclusion criteria was retrospectively analyzed. The atlases in all patients were fixated by lateral mass screws, and the axes were fixed by laminar screws in 13 cases (LS group) and by pedicle screws in 28 cases (PS group). There was no significant difference in gender, age, and preoperative Japanese Orthopedic Association (JOA) score between the two groups ( P>0.05). The effectiveness was estimated by post-operative JOA score; and the accuracy of the axis screw, atlantoaxial bone graft fusion, and the fixation stability were examined by X-ray film and CT.

RESULTS

All incisions healed by first intention. All patients were followed up 12-17 months (mean, 13.8 months) in LS group and 12-20 months (mean 14.1 months) in PS group, and the difference in follow-up time was not significant ( Z=-0.704, P=0.482). At last follow-up, JOA scores were 13.9±1.6 in LS group and 14.3±1.8 in PS group, which significantly improved when compared with the pre-operative scores in the two groups ( t=-9.033, P=0.000; t=-15.835, P=0.000); while no significant difference was found between the two groups ( t=-0.630, P=0.532). Twenty-five screws of 26 screws in LS group and 54 screws of 56 screws in PS group were implanted accurately, with no significant difference in the accuracy of the axis screw between the two groups ( Z=-0.061, P=0.951). All patients obtained atlantoaxial bone graft fusion, except 1 case in PS group. There was no significant difference in the atlantoaxial bone graft fusion between the two groups ( Z=-0.681, P=0.496).

CONCLUSION

For RAAD, Axis laminar screws can maintain the atlantoaxial primary stability and had a good short-term effectiveness. So, it could be an alternative and reliable technique for axis screw.