Comparison of 2 types of milk flow meters for detecting bimodality in dairy cows

Evaluation of milking performance following 2 different teat-preparation routines

The aim of this study was to investigate whether the use of an iodine-based predip solution and paper towel (dip routine) reduces the incidence of delayed milk ejection and the recorded vacuum at the teat end, compared with a proprietary teat wipe (wipe routine), when forestripping is not part of the teat-preparation routine. Eight experimental milkings, 4 for each teat-preparation routine, were observed on a Holstein dairy herd milking 195 cows 3 times daily through a herringbone parlor. Allocation of routine at the first session was by coin toss, thereafter teat-preparation routine was alternated for each observed session. Parameters extracted from electronic on-farm milk meters included milk yield (kg), milking unit on time (MUOT; s), average milk flow rate (kg/min), maximum milk flow rate (kg/min), milk yield in the first 2 min (kg), percentage of total milk yield in the first 2 min (%), and occurrence of bimodal milking. Vacuum at the teat level was recorded using digital vacuum recorders and analyzed to determine the average mouthpiece chamber vacuum in front and back quarters during the main milking period. Cow characteristics including parity, DIM, calving date, and 305-d mature-equivalent milk production were obtained from dairy management software. Investigators used timestamps to calculate the duration the operator spent wiping teats and the lag time, which was defined as first application of the wipe or paper towel to cluster attachment. Data from 1,287 milkings (194 cows) were analyzed for milk flow outcomes, and data from 96 milkings (76 cows) were analyzed for vacuum outcomes. Multivariable mixed-effects models demonstrated that the odds of a bimodal milking pattern were higher when the wipe routine was used compared with the dip routine (odds ratio: 1.6). The dip routine was associated with 3.37% more milk produced in the first 2 min, 4.38 s less MUOT, and 2.69 kPa lower average vacuum in the back mouthpiece during main milking, with no significant difference in the front mouthpiece vacuum between the 2 preparation routines. These results indicate that dipping followed by wiping as part of the teat-preparation routine was associated with improved milk ejection and flow compared with using a disinfectant wipe alone.

Influence of delayed milk ejection on mammary gland health and milking performance in dairy cows: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Delayed milk ejection (DME) could compromise udder health and milking performance. The objectives of this systematic review and meta-analysis were to (i) explore the current evidence, assess the risk of bias, and identify the knowledge gaps in published studies that investigated the effect of DME on udder health and milking performance in dairy cows, and (ii) quantify the magnitude of the difference in milk yield per milking session (MY), milking duration (MD), and peak milk flow rate (PFR) between cows with and without DME. We performed the current systematic review and meta-analysis according to PRISMA 2020 statement. We tracked the pertinent peer-reviewed publications from PubMed using the following syntax (delayed milk ejection OR disturbed milk ejection OR bimodal milk flow OR bimodality) AND (bovine OR cattle OR cows), and additional relevant studies from the identified articles' reference lists. We calculated the pooled-mean difference in MY (kg), MD (seconds), and PFR (kg/min) between cows with and without DME using the random-effects models. The selection process identified 15 studies as the final number of studies qualified for review, including six interventional and nine observational studies published between 1980 and 2023 conducted in seven countries, including the USA, Germany, Italy, Switzerland, Netherlands, New Zealand, and Portugal. The results indicated that while the DME had a minimal influence on the udder health, it can reduce MY by 1.55 kg per milking session (95 % CI = -2.10, -1.00). The observed evidence here suggests that DME can negatively influence the milking profitability.

A randomized controlled trial to study the effect of supplemental premilking stimulation on milking performance, teat tissue condition, udder health, and well-being in dairy cows

The objectives of this study were to evaluate the effect of supplemental premilking stimulation, provided after manual stimulation, by means of high-frequency pulsation without reduction of the vacuum in the pulsation chamber on milking performance, teat tissue condition, udder health, and well-being in dairy cows. In a randomized controlled trial, Holstein cows (n = 491) from 1 commercial dairy farm with a thrice-daily milking schedule were assigned to treatment and control groups over a 64-d period. Treatments consisted of a maximum of 20 s of pulsation stimulation at a pulsation rate of 100 (SPS100) or 300 (SPS300) cycles per minute and a pulsation ratio of 25:75. The treatments were applied after completion of manual premilking stimulation upon milking unit attachment. Cows in the control group (CON) received only traditional premilking stimulation by manual forestripping and wiping for 6 s. Milking characteristics were measured with on-farm milk flow meters. Milking machine-induced short-term (swelling at teat base, firmness at teat end, and teat discoloration) and long-term (teat-end callosity) changes to the teat tissue were assessed manually and visually. Composite milk samples were analyzed for SCC. Cow hind-leg activity was assessed with 3-dimensional accelerometers. Fecal 11,17-dioxoandrostanes (11,17-DOA; a group of cortisol metabolites) were determined on wk 4 and 8 to assess the well-being of the cows. Generalized linear mixed models were used to study the effect of treatments on the outcome variables milk yield per milking and milking unit-on time. We observed no meaningful differences among groups for milk yield or milking unit-on time. Least squares means and their 95% CI for cows in the SPS100, SPS300, and CON groups were 13.9 (13.3-14.5), 14.0 (13.4-14.6), and 13.9 (13.3-14.6) kg for milk yield and 218 (212-224), 218 (211-224), and 218 (212-224) s for milking unit-on time, respectively. Compared with cows in the CON group, the odds (95% CI) of short-term changes were 1.30 (0.95-1.78) for the SPS100 group and 1.50 (1.10-2.05) for the SPS300 group. The odds of long-term changes were 0.94 (0.67-1.34) for cows in the SPS100 group and 0.71 (0.49-1.04) for cows in the SPS300 group. We observed no differences in SCC. In reference to the CON group, the hazard ratio (95% CI) in SPS100 and SPS300, respectively, were 0.35 (0.13-0.98) and 1.22 (0.57-2.64) for clinical mastitis, and 0.34 (0.12-0.95) and 1.28 (0.60-2.73) for culling. The LSM (95% CI) of hind-leg activity during milking were 8.3 (6.5-10.5), 10.6 (8.1-13.7), and 9.1 (7.2-11.6) movements per milking for the SPS100, SPS300, and CON groups, respectively. The LSM (95% CI) of fecal 11,17-DOA concentration (ng/g) at the first and second test days, respectively, were 31.1 (28.1-34.2) and 22.3 (19.2-25.4) for the SPS100 group, 26.4 (23.4-29.4) and 25.2 (22.0-28.4) for the SPS300 group, and 24.8 (21.8-27.9) and 25.0 (21.7-28.3) for the CON group. We conclude that applying supplemental stimulation after manual stimulation through the high-frequency pulsation system tested here did not impart additional benefits to the milk harvesting process, teat tissue condition, somatic cell count, or the well-being of the animals.

The effect of flow-responsive vacuum and pulsation with early attachment of milking unit on teat tissue condition and milking performance in Holstein dairy cows

The objectives of this study were to assess the effect of flow-responsive vacuum and pulsation, in conjunction with the early attachment of the milking unit (TRT), on teat tissue conditions and milking characteristics in dairy cows. In a switch-back trial, 5,235 Holstein cows milked 3 times daily in a rotary parlor were assigned to the TRT or control (CON) group. The trial lasted 84 d and was comprised of 4 alternating 3-week periods of TRT and CON. For both groups, premilking udder preparation consisted of teat brushing, forestripping and predipping, and wiping of teats, resulting in a stimulation time of 4 s. In the TRT group, the preparation lag time was 58 s, and in the CON group, it was 91 s for early- and mid-lactation cows and 105 s for late-lactation animals. Upon milking unit attachment, the TRT cows were milked at a lower vacuum (37.6 kPa) and pulsation (50 cycles/min, pulsation ratio of 30:70). The vacuum and pulsation settings were changed to milking mode when the milk flow reached 0.5 kg/min (pulsation switch-point) and 1.6 kg/min (vacuum switch-point). For milking mode, the vacuum setting was 47.7 kPa, and the pulsation rate was 60 cycles/min at a ratio of 65:35. The CON cows were milked with a flow-responsive vacuum, using the same vacuum settings as the TRT group. We assessed machine milking-induced short-term teat tissue changes and teat-end hyperkeratosis by palpation and visual inspection postmilking. Electronic on-farm milk meters were used to assess milking characteristics. Generalized linear mixed models were used to analyze the effect of treatment on the outcome variables. Compared with cows in group CON, the odds ratios (95% confidence interval; 95% CI) of short-term teat-tissue changes in early-, mid-, and late lactation cows in group TRT were 0.62 (0.52-0.76), 0.61 (0.48-0.77), and 0.93 (0.76-1.14), respectively. The least squares means [LSM, (95% CI)] for milking unit-on time in early-, mid-, and late lactation animals, respectively, were 251 (248-253), 236 (234-238), and 220 (218-222) s for group TRT and 247 (245-249), 232 (230-234), and 214 (213-216) s for the CON group. The LSM (95% CI) of peak milk flow rate in early-, mid-, and late lactation animals, respectively, were 5.75 (5.68-5.82), 5.77 (5.70-5.84), and 5.54 (5.48-5.59) kg/min for the TRT cows and 5.65 (5.58-5.72), 5.74 (5.68-5.81), and 5.45 (5.40-5.51) kg/min for the CON cows. The odds ratios (95% CI) of forced take-off in group TRT for early-, mid-, and late lactation cows, respectively, were 0.39 (0.37-0.41), 0.32 (0.30-0.34), and 0.47 (0.44-0.52) compared with their respective CON groups. In this study, cows that were milked using flow-responsive vacuum and pulsation with early attachment of the milking unit had lower odds of short-term teat tissue changes and forced take-off, as well as a higher peak milk flow rate. Our data suggest that the application of flow-responsive vacuum and pulsation facilitates early attachment of the milking unit, improves teat tissue condition, and has the potential to improve parlor efficiency.

Effects of flow-responsive pulsation on teat tissue condition and milking performance in Holstein dairy cows

The objectives of this study were to assess the effect of a reduced liner-open phase applied through flow-responsive pulsation (FRP), as a method to provide supplemental stimulation, on teat tissue conditions and milking characteristics in dairy cows. In 2 switch-back trials, 156 Holstein cows milked 3 times daily were assigned to the FRP or conventional (CON) group in alternating sequences. Trial 1 lasted for 35 d and was split into 5 alternating 1-wk periods of FRP and CON. The duration of trial 2 was 84 d, consisting of 4 alternating 3-wk periods of FRP and CON. Premilking udder preparation for both groups consisted of predipping, forestripping, and wiping the teats. Upon milking unit attachment, the FRP cows were milked at a pulsation rate of 50 cycles/min and a pulsation ratio of 30:70 until the preset milk flow threshold of 0.5 kg/min was reached. When the threshold value of 0.5 kg/min was reached, the pulsation was automatically switched to milking mode, which consisted of a pulsation rate of 60 cycles/min and a pulsation ratio of 70:30. Cows in the CON group were milked by milking mode (pulsation rate, 60 cycles/min; pulsation ratio, 70:30) immediately after attachment of the milking unit. We assessed machine milking-induced short-term changes to the teat tissue by palpation and visual inspection during trial 1, and we assessed teat-end hyperkeratosis in trial 2. Electronic on-farm milk meters were used to assess milking characteristics: milk yield (kg/milking session), milking unit-on time (s), 2-min milk yield (kg), peak milk flow rate (kg/min), and duration of low milk flow rate (s). Generalized linear mixed models were used to analyze the effects of treatment on the outcome variables. The odds of machine milking-induced short-term changes to the teat tissue were lower for cows in the FRP group than for those in the CON group: odds ratio (95% CI) = 0.41 (0.31-0.55). There were no meaningful differences in the odds of teat-end hyperkeratosis between the FRP and CON groups: odds ratio (95% CI) = 1.05 (0.38-2.89). The LSM (95% CI) of milking characteristics in the FRP and CON groups were 14.3 (13.8-14.7) and 14.3 kg (13.8-14.7) for milk yield, respectively; 272 (264-281) and 270 s (262-278) for milking unit-on time, respectively; and 5.0 (4.8-5.1) and 4.9 kg/min (4.7-5.1) for peak milk flow rate, respectively. The FRP group had lower odds of bimodality than the CON group: odds ratio (95% CI) = 0.67 (0.61-0.74). In reference to CON, the odds ratios (95% CI) in FRP were 1.05 (0.76-1.46) for kick-off and 1.02 (0.85-1.23) for milking unit reattachment. In this study, cows that were milked using FRP had lower odds of postmilking short-term changes to the teat tissue and lower odds of bimodal milk flow. We conclude that FRP may foster adequate teat stimulation in cows before the initiation of milk harvest and has the potential to improve teat tissue conditions.

The association between teat shape and bimodal milk ejection in Holstein dairy cows

Our objectives were to investigate the association of teat shape with (1) bimodality, (2) incremental milk flow rates (average flow rates during the first 15 s, 15-30 s, 30-60 s, and 60-120 s of milking), and (3) peak milk flow rate in Holstein dairy cows milked 3 times/d. In this prospective cohort study, we analyzed 220,928 milking observations that were collected from 2,520 cows from a single dairy herd over a period of 31 d. Teat shape was visually assessed and classified into 1 of 4 categories as follows: (1) triangular barrel and pointed teat end (TP), (2) square barrel and round teat end (SR), (3) square barrel, round teat end, and flat in the area of the teat orifice (SRF), and (4) square barrel and flat teat end (SF). Individual cow-level milk flow rates were obtained using electronic on-farm milk meters. We considered bimodality to be present if any of the incremental milk flow rates (flow rates during 15-30 s, 30-60 s, or 60-120 s) were lower than any of the previous rates (flow rates during the first 15 s, 15-30 s, or 30-60 s). The frequency distribution of cows with different teat shapes was as follows: TP, 96 (3.8%); SR, 1,751 (69.5%); SRF, 617 (24.5%); and SF, 56 (2.2%). A generalized linear mixed model revealed differences in the odds of bimodality among cows with different teat shapes. Compared with cows in category SR, the odds (95% CI) of bimodality of cows in other categories were as follows: TP, 0.68 (0.48-0.97); SF, 1.96 (1.21-3.19); and SRF, 1.46 (1.23-1.72). General linear mixed models indicated an association between teat shape and all incremental milk flow rates, with higher milk flow rates being present for cows with teat shapes in the SRF and SF categories. The general linear mixed model for the dependent variable peak milk flow rate indicated an association between teat shape and peak milk flow rate. Least squares means and 95% CI were 5.1 (4.9-5.3) kg/min for TP, 5.8 (5.5-6.1) kg/min for SF, 5.6 (5.5-5.7) for SRF, and 5.3 (5.3-5.4) for SR, respectively. We conclude that in this study cohort, bimodality is more likely to occur in cows with flat teat ends compared with those with a round teat ends. We attribute this relationship to the difference in milking speed across cows with different teat shapes. Teat shape may serve as a useful phenotype to identify cows that are more likely to exhibit bimodality. Because our study population was unique, future studies considering different circumstances such as breed, milking system, and milking routine are needed before results can be extrapolated.

The Association of Delayed Milk Ejection with Milking Performance in Holstein Cows in a Large Dairy Herd with Suboptimal Premilking Teat Stimulation

The primary objective was to investigate the association between delayed milk ejection (DME) and the average milk flow rate, milking unit-on time, and duration in a low milk flow rate in Holstein dairy cows in a large dairy herd with suboptimal premilking teat stimulation. Our second objective was to study the association between peak lactation milk yield and the occurrence of DME. This longitudinal field study was conducted at a 4300-cow dairy farm with a thrice-daily milking schedule over a 1-week period. We analyzed data from 61,677 cow milking observations from 2937 cows. Delayed milk ejection was defined as present if the 30-60 s milk flow rate was ≤3.1 kg/min. The mean average milk flow rate (MAMF, kg/min), mean milking unit-on time (MMUT, s), and mean duration of a low milk flow rate (MLMF, s) were calculated as the mean values from the 21 milking observations. General linear multivariable models revealed associations of DME with MAMF, MMUT, and MLMF. A multivariable ordinal logistic regression model revealed an association between peak lactation milk yield and DME. Cows with lower peak lactation milk yield had greater odds of exhibiting a higher frequency level of DME. The observed associations between DME and milking performance indices suggest that DME can negatively affect milking and parlor efficiency. Peak lactation milk yield may serve as a proxy to estimate cows' risk of recurrent DME. Future research is warranted to test if alleviating DME through, for example, a modified milking routine influences the milking performance indices described herein.

Study of the Milkability of the Mediterranean Italian Buffalo and the Tunisian Maghrebi Camel According to Parity and Lactation Stage

While considered as hard milkers, both buffaloes and camels are milked with equipment destined for dairy cows based on external morphological similarities with this species. This work aimed to study similarities and differences in milkability traits between Mediterranean buffaloes and Maghrebi she-camels and to evaluate the effect of parity and lactation stage. A total of 422 milk flow curves recorded with an electronic milkmeter (Lactocorder®) for both species were accessed. Milking characteristics including milk yield per milking, peak milk flow, average milk flow, duration of the main milking phase, duration of total milking, duration of various phases of milk flow, lag time and time to milk ejection, stripping yield, overmilking time and incidence of bimodal milk flow curves were evaluated for both species. Results showed that the values of milk yield per milking, duration of the main milking phase and duration of total milking were higher in buffaloes (3.98 ± 0.10 kg; 4.07 ± 0.11 min; 9.89 ± 0.21 min, respectively) compared to camels (3.51 ± 0.08 kg; 3.05 ± 0.09 min; 3.76 ± 0.09 min, respectively). However, camels had significantly higher peak and average milk flow (2.45 ± 0.07 kg/min and 1.16 ± 0.03 kg/min, respectively). Camels took significantly less time for milk ejection to occur. Only 15.49% of recorded curves were bimodal in buffaloes while 34.93% of bimodal curves were recorded for camels. Overmilking was significantly higher in buffaloes (3.64 ± 0.21 min vs. 0.29 ± 0.02 min). Parity and lactation stage had a significant effect on most studied milking traits suggesting the need for some particular practices with primiparous animals and animals at different levels of lactation for both species.

The effect of 2 different premilking stimulation regimens, with and without a latency period, on teat tissue condition and milking performance in Holstein dairy cows

The objectives of this study were to assess the effect of 2 different premilking stimulation regimens, with and without a latency period between tactile stimulation and the attachment of the milking unit, on the teat tissue condition and milking performance of dairy cows. In a randomized controlled crossover study, 145 Holstein cows milked 3 times daily were assigned to treatment (TRT) or control (CON) groups. Premilking udder preparation for the TRT group consisted of the application of a latency period resulting in a preparation lag time of 90 s. The only difference in the premilking udder preparation of the CON group was the absence of latency period; the milking unit was attached immediately after completion of the tactile stimulation. The average duration of total tactile stimulation in TRT and CON group was 8 ± 2 and 9 ± 2 s, respectively. The study lasted for 14 d and was split into 2 periods, each consisting of a 2-d adjustment period followed by 5 d of data collection. We assessed machine milking-induced short-term changes to the teat tissue by palpation and visual inspection postmilking. Electronic on-farm milk meters were used to assess milking characteristics (milk yield [kg/milking session], machine-on time [s], 2-min milk yield [kg], and duration of low milk flow rate [s]). Generalized linear mixed models were used to analyze the effect of treatment on the outcome variables. The odds of machine milking-induced short-term changes to the teat tissue were lower for cows that received a 90-s preparation lag time (TRT cows) compared with cows in the CON group (odds ratio [95% confidence interval; 95% CI] = 0.13 [0.08-0.20]). The least squares means (95% CI) values of cows in the TRT and CON groups were 15.4 (14.9-15.9) and 15.3 (14.8-15.8) kg, respectively, for milk yield, and 246 (239-253) and 253 (247-260) s for machine-on time. The 2-min milk yield was higher for the TRT compared with CON group cows at all the parity levels. The 2-min milk yields of animals in lactation 1, 2, and ≥3 were 5.7, 5.7, and 6.5 kg, respectively, in the TRT group and 4.6, 5.0, and 5.9 kg in the CON group. The TRT cows spent less time in low milk flow rate compared with CON cows at all parity levels. The durations of low milk flow rate of cows in lactation 1, 2, and ≥3 in the TRT group were 19, 17 and 13 s, respectively, and those in the CON group were 31, 22, and 15 s. In this study, cows that received a latency period, and thus were subjected to a 90-s preparation lag time had lower odds of exhibiting short-term changes to the teat tissue after machine milking, shorter machine-on time, higher 2-min milk yields, and lower durations of low milk flow rates. We conclude that consideration of latency period leading to a 90-s preparation lag time in the premilking stimulation regimen facilitated cows' milk-ejection reflex. This latency period can alleviate the adverse effects of vacuum-induced forces on teat tissue during machine milking, improve udder health, and promote animal well-being.