Genomic evaluation of feed efficiency in US Holstein heifers

Invited review: Phenotyping strategies and genetic background of dairy cattle behavior in intensive production systems-From trait definition to genomic selection

Understanding and assessing dairy cattle behavior is critical for developing sustainable breeding programs and management practices. The behavior of individual animals can provide valuable information on their health and welfare status, improve reproductive management, and predict efficiency traits such as feed efficiency and milking efficiency. Routine genetic evaluations of animal behavior traits can contribute to optimizing breeding and management strategies for dairy cattle but require the identification of traits that capture the most important biological processes involved in behavioral responses. These traits should be heritable, repeatable, and measured in noninvasive and cost-effective ways in many individuals from the breeding populations or related reference populations. Although behavior traits are heritable in dairy cattle populations, they are highly polygenic, with no known major genes influencing their phenotypic expression. Genetically selecting dairy cattle based on their behavior can be advantageous because of their relationship with other key traits such as animal health, welfare, and productive efficiency, as well as animal and handler safety. Trait definition and longitudinal data collection are still key challenges for breeding for behavioral responses in dairy cattle. However, the more recent developments and adoption of precision technologies in dairy farms provide avenues for more objective phenotyping and genetic selection of behavior traits. Furthermore, there is still a need to standardize phenotyping protocols for existing traits and develop guidelines for recording novel behavioral traits and integrating multiple data sources. This review gives an overview of the most common indicators of dairy cattle behavior, summarizes the main methods used for analyzing animal behavior in commercial settings, describes the genetic and genomic background of previously defined behavioral traits, and discusses strategies for breeding and improving behavior traits coupled with future opportunities for genetic selection for improved behavioral responses.

Genomic evaluation of residual feed intake in US Holstein cows: insights into lifetime feed efficiency

Residual feed intake (RFI) is an important trait of feed efficiency that has been increasingly considered in the breeding objectives for dairy cattle. The objectives of this study were to estimate the genetic parameters of RFI and its component traits, namely, dry-matter intake (DMI), body weight (BW), and energy-corrected milk (ECM), in lactating Holstein cows; we thus developed a system for genomic evaluation of RFI in lactating Holstein cows and explored the associations of the RFI of heifers and cows. The RFI values were calculated from 2,538 first (n = 2,118) and second (n = 420) lactation Holsteins cows between 2020 and 2024 as part of the STgenetics EcoFeed® program. Of the animals, 1,516 were heifers from the same research station with previously established RFI values . After quality control, 61,283 single-nucleotide polymorphisms were used for the analyses. Univariate analyses were performed to estimate the heritabilities of RFI and its components in lactating cows; bivariate analyses were then performed to estimate the genetic correlations between the RFI of heifers and lactating cows using the genomic best unbiased linear prediction method. Animals with phenotypes and genotypes were used as the training population, and animals with only genotypes were considered the prediction population. The reliability of breeding values was obtained by approximation based on partitioning a function of the accuracy of the training population's genomic estimated breeding values (GEBVs) and magnitudes of genomic relationships between the individuals in the training and prediction populations. The heritability estimates (mean ± SE) of the RFI, DMI, ECM, and BW were 0.43 ± 0.07, 0.44 ± 0.04, 0.40 ± 0.05, and 0.46 ± 0.04, respectively. The average reliability of the GEBVs for RFI from the training and prediction populations were 44% and 30%, respectively. The genetic correlations for the RFI were 0.42 ± 0.08 between heifers and first lactation cows and 0.34 ± 0.06 between heifers and first and second lactation cows. Our results show that the genetic components of RFI are not fully carried over from heifers to cows and that there is re-ranking of the individuals at different life stages. Selection of animals for feed efficiency on a lifetime basis thus requires accounting for the efficiencies during animal growth and milk production as a lactating cow.

Advancing Dairy and Beef Genetics Through Genomic Technologies

The US beef and dairy industries have made remarkable advances in sustainability and productivity through technological advancements, including selective breeding. Yet, challenges persist due to the complex nature of quantitative traits. While the beef industry has progressed in adopting genomic technologies, the availability of phenotypic data remains an obstacle. To meet the need for sustainable production systems, novel traits are being targeted for selection. Additionally, emerging approaches such as genome editing and high-throughput phenotyping hold promise for further genetic progress. Future research should address the challenges of translating functional genomic findings into practical applications, while simultaneously harnessing analytical methods.

Selection indices for residual feed intake derived from milk spectra

Improving production efficiency and minimizing the environmental impact of dairy farming are 2 important goals of the dairy industry. Achieving these objectives requires improving the feed-to-milk conversion efficiency. One way to achieve this goal is through genetic selection. However, measuring feed efficiency in commercial herds is currently not feasible. As such, we conducted a study to evaluate the genetic accuracy of various selection indices derived from Fourier transform mid-infrared (FTIR)-spectra or milk composition. We use 7,793 weekly records on 537 genotyped cows (78,964 SNPs), with information on residual feed intake (RFI), and FTIR-spectra. We fitted various types of selection indexes using the complete FTIR-spectra of milk samples. The estimated heritability of RFI was 0.12 ± 0.02. The accuracy of indirect selection using the FTIR-spectra was maximized using a principal components selection index (0.16 ± 0.07), followed by a Lasso-type penalized selection index (0.14 ± 0.06). We determined that an index based on milk spectral data recorded on ~25 daughters produced a progeny average with an accuracy comparable to direct phenotypic selection for RFI. We conclude that indirect selection for RFI using FTIR-spectra data can be effective for sires with progeny; however, future studies with a larger sample size are needed to validate these results.

Association of genomically enhanced residual feed intake with performance, feed efficiency, feeding behavior, gas flux, and nutrient digestibility in growing Holstein heifers

Residual feed intake (RFI), a metric of feed efficiency, is moderately heritable and independent of body size and productivity, making it an ideal trait for investigation as a selection criterion to improve the feed efficiency of growing cattle. The objective of this study was to examine the differences in performance, feed efficiency, feeding behavior, gas flux, and nutrient digestibility in Holstein heifers with divergent genomically enhanced breeding values for RFI (RFIg). Holstein heifers (n = 55; BW = 352 ± 64 kg) with low (n = 29) or high (n = 26) RFIg were selected from a contemporary group of 453 commercial Holstein heifers. Heifers were rotated between 1 of 2 pens, each equipped with 4 electronic feed bunks and 1 pen with a GreenFeed emissions monitoring (GEM) system. Individual dry matter intake (DMI) and feeding behavior data were collected for 84-d. Body weight (BW) was measured weekly and spot fecal samples were collected at weighing. Phenotypic RFI (RFIp) was calculated as the residual from the regression of DMI on average daily gain (ADG) and mid-test metabolic BW (BW0.75). A mixed model including the fixed effect of RFIg classification and the random effect of group was used to evaluate the effect of RFIg classification on response variables. There were no differences (P > 0.05) in BW and ADG for heifers with divergent RFIg; however, low RFIg heifers consumed 7.5% less (P < 0.05) feed per day. Consequently, low RFIg heifers exhibited a more favorable (P < 0.05) RFIp compared to high RFIg heifers (-0.196 vs 0.222 kg/d, respectively). Low RFIg heifers had 8.7% fewer (P < 0.05) bunk visit events per day and tended to have an 11.2% slower (P < 0.10) eating rate. Low RFIg heifers had 7.7% lower (P < 0.05) methane (CH4) emissions (g/d), 6.1% lower (P ≤ 0.05) carbon dioxide (CO2) production (g/d), and 5.6% lower (P ≤ 0.05) heat production (Mcal/d) than high RFIg heifers. However, CH4 yield and CO2 yield (g/kg DMI), and heat production per unit DMI (Mcal/kg DMI) did not differ (P > 0.05) between heifers with divergent RFIg. Dry matter (DM) and nutrient digestibility did not differ (P > 0.05) between heifers with divergent RFIg. Results suggest that selection based on RFIg provides opportunities to select cattle with favorable feed efficiency phenotypes to increase the economic and environmental sustainability of the cattle industry.

Unraveling the Genetic Basis of Feed Efficiency in Cattle through Integrated DNA Methylation and CattleGTEx Analysis

Feed costs can amount to 75 percent of the total overhead cost of raising cows for milk production. Meanwhile, the livestock industry is considered a significant contributor to global climate change due to the production of greenhouse gas emissions, such as methane. Indeed, the genetic basis of feed efficiency (FE) is of great interest to the animal research community. Here, we explore the epigenetic basis of FE to provide base knowledge for the development of genomic tools to improve FE in cattle. The methylation level of 37,554 CpG sites was quantified using a mammalian methylation array (HorvathMammalMethylChip40) for 48 Holstein cows with extreme residual feed intake (RFI). We identified 421 CpG sites related to 287 genes that were associated with RFI, several of which were previously associated with feeding or digestion issues. Activator of transcription and developmental regulation (AUTS2) is associated with digestive disorders in humans, while glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase 2 (GPD2) encodes a protein on the inner mitochondrial membrane, which can regulate glucose utilization and fatty acid and triglyceride synthesis. The extensive expression and co-expression of these genes across diverse tissues indicate the complex regulation of FE in cattle. Our study provides insight into the epigenetic basis of RFI and gene targets to improve FE in dairy cattle.