Surgical treatment of complex traumatic frontobasal lesions: personal experience in 74 patients

Cerebrospinal fluid leak management in anterior basal skull fractures secondary to head trauma

OBJECTIVE

To summarize the presentation, diagnosis, and management of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leaks in the setting of traumatic anterior skull base fracture.

METHODS

Wide literature research has been performed as well as the authors' own clinical experience has been summarized.

RESULTS

Articles from the most recent 30 years have been reviewed and a typical case of our own has been presented. Based on the most updated evidence, a treatment algorithm for CSF leaks has been proposed.

CONCLUSION

Anterior skull base fracture accounts for about 4% of all head injuries and CSF leaks is a complication that commonly presents with clear fluid emanating from the nasal passage. A positive beta-2-transferrin study is highly specific for diagnosis, while thin-slice CT scanning and MRI cisternography are also useful tools. The majority of the CSF leaks tend to be resolved spontaneously, and conservative management is attempted first with or without the augmentation of a lumbar drain. Surgical management mainly includes open surgery and endoscopic surgery, which have their own pros and cons.

Management of CSF leak in base of skull fractures in adults

AIMS

CSF leaks are not uncommon after a base of skull fracture. Currently there is no standardised algorithm for the investigation and management of post-traumatic CSF leaks. In this paper we aim to provide an evidence-based framework for managing post-traumatic CSF leaks.

METHODS

We searched the English literature over the past 45 years using CINAHL, EMBASE and MEDLINE for the terms (1) post-traumatic CSF leaks or fistulas, and (2) basilar or base of skull fractures, but excluded papers on post-operative and non-traumatic CSF leaks, and papers on paediatric post- traumatic CSF leaks.

RESULTS

The diagnosis of a base of skull fracture and any resultant CSF leak can be challenging. Therefore a combination of biochemical and radiological studies are needed to optimise the diagnosis of this condition. Post-traumatic CSF leaks are generally treated conservatively, and a majority of them resolve without further surgical management. However for patients who are refractory to such treatments, surgical closure of the CSF fistula is necessary. Surgical obliteration of CSF leaks can be challenging and requires the involvement of multiple surgical specialties such as neurosurgery, otolaryngology, and maxillofacial surgery.

CONCLUSION

Although we have formulated a simple algorithm to aid the investigation and management of post-traumatic CSF leaks, there are still many important unresolved questions requiring further well powered studies to answer.

Single Operation to Repair Multifocal Cerebrospinal Fluid Fistulae Following Gunshot Wound: A Case Report

Introduction Traumatic cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) fistulae can be a challenging neurosurgical disease, often requiring complicated surgical intervention. Case Presentation A 54-year-old man presented with a gunshot wound to the head with complex injury to the skull base and significant CSF leakage from multiple sites. A single surgery was performed using a combined Neurosurgery, Neurotology, and Rhinology team, which was successful in repairing the multiple skull base defects and preventing further CSF leak. Discussion Trauma to the skull base is a common inciting factor for the development of CSF fistulae. Endoscopic approaches are often preferred for repairing these defects, but craniotomy remains a viable option that may be required in more complex cases. A combined approach has not been described previously, but was successful for this severe multifocal defect. Conclusion A multidisciplinary approach allowed for a combined intervention that addressed both the anterior and middle fossae fistulae simultaneously. This limited the potential infectious complications of continued CSF leak and allowed for early rehabilitation.

[Trauma of the anterior floor of the base of the skull: about a series of 136 cases]

Les traumatismes de l’étage antérieur de la base du crâne représentent 15 à 20% des traumatismes crâniens en général. Ils menacent les structures neuro-encéphaliques sus jacentes et sont très souvent responsables de brèches ostéo-méningées exposant au risque infectieux. Notre travail a concerné 136 dossiers exploitables de traumatisme de l’étage antérieur de la base du crâne colligés sur une période de 10 ans entre janvier 2003 et décembre 2012. Le diagnostic a été suspecté devant les signes cliniques évocateurs (ecchymose péri-orbitaire, rhinorrhée…) et a été confirmé dans la plupart des cas par la TDM. Le traitement idéal est la fermeture chirurgicale de la brèche en association aux moyens médicaux (vaccination, anti-épileptiques, mesures de réanimation…) Le moment idéal de la réparation est au-delà de la 72^ème heure après la diminution de l'oedème cérébral en cas d'absence d'une lésion intracrânienne nécessitant une intervention en urgence. Notre équipe ne pratiquant pas la voie endoscopique, l'abord frontal est souvent indiqué. Le pronostic dépend des lésions cérébrales associées et surtout de la présence d'une brèche dont le diagnostic et la réparation doivent être les plus rapides et les plus précis possibles. Ainsi toute rhinorrhée post-traumatique nécessite une exploration systématique, le timing idéal: c'est la disparition de l'oedème cérébral pour faciliter l'exploration, ceci est en général possible à partir de la 72^ème heure sauf dans les cas associés à une autre lésion intra crânienne nécessitant une exploration en urgence.

Complications of frontal sinus fractures

Frontal sinus fracture represents 5 to 12% of all maxillofacial fractures. Because of the anatomic position of the frontal sinus and the enormous amount of force required to create a fracture in this area, these injuries are often devastating and associated with other trauma. Associated injuries include skull base, intracranial, ophthalmologic, and maxillofacial. Complications should be categorized to address these four areas as well as the skin-soft tissue envelope, muscle, and bone. Other variables that should be examined are age of the patient, gender, mechanism of injury, fracture pattern, method of repair, and associated injuries. Management of frontal sinus fractures is so controversial that the indications, timing, method of repair, and surveillance remain disputable among several surgical specialties. The one universal truth that is agreed upon is that all patients undergoing reconstructive surgery of the frontal sinus have a lifelong risk for delayed complications. It is hoped that when patients do experience the first symptoms of a complication, they seek immediate medical attention and avoid potentially life-threatening situations and the need for crippling or disfiguring surgery. The best way to facilitate this is through long-term follow-up and routine surveillance.

CSF rhinorrhea-feasibility of conservative management in children

PURPOSE

To study the role of conservative management in CSF rhinorrhea in pediatric population.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective study in a tertiary care center.

METHODS

Cases with a diagnosis of CSF rhinorrhea discharged after conservative management but required skull base repair for recurrence of CSF rhinorrhea or meningitis were included in the study between periods 2000 and July 2010.

RESULTS

12 cases of CSF rhinorrhea managed were treated conservatively, 7 patients again required rehospitalisation for recurrence of CSF rhinorrhea or meningitis. Male:female ratio was 4:1. The age ranged from 3 years to 14 years. Duration of recurrence of the CSF leak or meningitis varied from 6 to 121 months. Presenting symptoms included headache, rhinorrhea, or recurrent meningitis. The time from the initial injury to surgical exploration ranged from 163 to 3650 days. All patients were under regular follow-up and doing well except one had recurrence of the leak 2 months after surgery requiring revision surgery following which the patient had no recurrence.

DISCUSSION

The management of CSF fistulae is still a matter of debate and there will be a risk of recurrent meningitis on conservative management. Most comprehensive study to date indicates there is a 9.8% annual risk of developing meningitis. Duration of recurrence of the CSF leak or meningitis varied from 6 months to 121 months. The overall incidence of meningitis as a result of skull base defect and CSF leak ranges from 9% to 50% with a reported cumulative risk of 85% in 10 years if no repair is performed. As seen in our series CSF repair can resolve with conservative management but there is a risk of intermittent CSF leak or meningitis due to an incompletely healed or tenuous mucosal regeneration which should be addressed surgically. The patients with traumatic CSF leak who were treated with conservative management alone had a 25-29% risk of subsequent meningitis.

CONCLUSION

Conservative treatment of CSF leaks may lead to recurrent meningitis or leaks, therefore surgical closure of defects at the skull base should be considered treatment of choice to prevent ascending meningitis.

Multidisciplinary surgical approach for cerebrospinal fluid leak in children with complex head trauma

INTRODUCTION

Post-traumatic cerebrospinal fluid leak from the anterior cranial fossa in children may be isolated or combined with severe facial and calvarial injury. Untreated leak may result with meningitis, hydrocephalus, and abnormal neurocognitive development.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We present nine children, ages 4-16 years, with complicated craniofacial injury treated by a combined subcranial and intracranial approach. A continuous lumbar drainage was kept for several days, and prophylactic antibiotics and anti-convulsive medications were routinely given. A multidisciplinary approach including discussion before surgery about other surgical options (endoscopic extracranial and intracranial alone) were performed.

RESULTS

None of the operated children had episodes of meningitis/leak after the combined approach, suggesting that appropriate sealing of the base of the skull has been achieved. There was no mortality, and the long-term follow-up showed good developmental and cosmetic results. Most of the children had significant brain contusions prior to surgery; however, these did not progress as minimal retraction was enabled by the extensive subcranial and intracranial approach.

CONCLUSIONS

Child's age, anatomy of the bone, extent of cranial injury, and clinical parameters should be seriously considered when choosing the technical methods as for sealing base of skull and reconstruction of facial/cranial bones. Young age does not seem to be a contraindication to the combined approach, thus, we recommend considering it in extensive base of skull fractures when concomitant cranial, maxillofacial, and orbital fractures coexist, as alternative options may not suffice in these cases.

Epidemiology, etiology, pathogenesis, and diagnosis of recurrent bacterial meningitis

Recurrent bacterial meningitis is a rare phenomenon and generally poses a considerable diagnostic challenge to the clinician. Ultimately, a structured approach and early diagnosis of any underlying pathology are crucial to prevent further episodes and improve the overall outcome for the affected individual. In this article, we are reviewing the existing literature on this topic over the last two decades, encompassing 363 cases of recurrent bacterial meningitis described in 144 publications. Of these cases, 214 (59%) were related to anatomical problems, 132 (36%) were related to immunodeficiencies, and 17 (5%) were related to parameningeal infections. The review includes a detailed discussion of the underlying pathologies and microbiological aspects as well as recommendations for appropriate diagnostic pathways for investigating this unusual entity.

SURGICAL MANAGEMENT OF ANTERIOR CRANIAL BASE FRACTURES WITH CEREBROSPINAL FLUID FISTULAE

OBJECTIVE

The management of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) fistulae after anterior cranial base fracture remains a surgical challenge. We reviewed our results in the repair of CSF fistulae complicating multiple anterior cranial base fractures via a combined intracranial extradural and intradural approach and describe a treatment algorithm derived from this experience.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the files of 209 patients with an anterior cranial base fracture complicated by a CSF fistula who were admitted between 1980 and 2003 to Liège State University Hospital. Among those patients, 109 had a persistent CSF leak or radiological signs of an unhealed dural tear. All underwent the same surgical procedure, with combined extradural and intradural closure of the dural tear.

RESULTS

Of the 109 patients, 98 patients (90%) were cured after the first operation. Persistent postoperative CSF rhinorrhea occurred in 11 patients (10%), necessitating an early complementary surgery via a transsphenoidal approach (7 patients) or a second-look intracranial approach (4 patients). No postoperative neurological deterioration attributable to increasing frontocerebral edema occurred. During the mean follow-up period of 36 months, recurrence of CSF fistula was observed in five patients and required an additional surgical repair procedure.

CONCLUSION

The closure of CSF fistulae after an anterior cranial base fracture via a combined intracranial extradural and intradural approach, which allows the visualization and repair of the entire anterior base, is safe and effective. It is essentially indicated for patients with extensive bone defects in the cranial base, multiple fractures of the ethmoid bone and the posterior wall of the frontal sinus, cranial nerve involvement, associated lesions necessitating surgery such as intracranial hematomas, and post-traumatic intracranial infection. Rhinorrhea caused by a precisely located small tear may be treated with endoscopy.