The two-stage excision of huge acoustic neurinomas

Two-Stage Surgical Management for Acutely Presented Large Vestibular Schwannomas: Report of Two Cases

The surgical management of vestibular schwannomas should be based on their presentation, neuro-imaging findings, surgeons' expertise, and logistics. Multi-stage surgery can be beneficial for large-sized lesions with acute presentations. Herein, we highlighted the indications for two cases managed initially through the retrosigmoid and, subsequently, translabyrinthine approaches. The first case presented with acute balance and gait issues and a long history of hearing loss and blurred vision. Neuroimaging findings revealed a cerebellopontine angle lesion, resembling a vestibular schwannoma, with significant brainstem compression and hydrocephalus. Due to the rapidly deteriorating clinical status and large-sized tumor, we first proceeded with urgent decompression via a retrosigmoid approach, followed by gross total resection via a translabyrinthine approach two weeks later. The second case presented with gradually worsening dizziness and hemifacial numbness accompanied by acute onset severe headaches and hearing loss. Neuroimaging findings showed a large cerebellopontine angle lesion suggestive of a vestibular schwannoma with acute intratumoral hemorrhage. Given the acute clinical deterioration and large size of the tumor, we performed urgent decompression with a retrosigmoid approach followed by gross total resection through a translabyrinthine approach a week later. Post-surgery, both patients showed excellent recovery. When managing acutely presented large-sized vestibular schwannomas, immediate surgical decompression is vital to avoid permanent neurological deficits.

Large Vestibular Schwannoma: A Two-Stage Surgery

Treatment of large vestibular schwannoma (VS) has historically centered on total resection of the lesion. Staged surgery has been used for VS that is highly vascularized, unexpected events during surgery, and thinned and stretched facial nerve with serious adherence causing difficult dissection. We present a case of a patient with a large VS resected through a two-stage surgery through the same retrosigmoid craniotomy.

Radiosurgery treatment is associated with improved facial nerve preservation versus repeat resection in recurrent vestibular schwannomas

BACKGROUND

Vestibular schwannomas (VSs) are benign neoplasms of the Schwann cells of cranial nerve VIII, and treatment of VS typically involves surgical resection. However, tumor recurrence may necessitate reintervention, and secondary treatment modalities include repeat surgical resection or adjuvant radiosurgery. The purpose of this study is to examine the scientific literature in order to determine whether surgical resection or radiosurgery for recurrent VS results in better tumor control, hearing preservation, and preservation of facial nerve function.

METHODS

The PubMed, Scopus, Embase, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases were searched for studies reporting on patients undergoing either radiosurgery or repeat surgical resection after primary surgical resection for recurrent VS. Statistical analyses were performed on the compiled data, primarily outcome data involving tumor control, hearing preservation, and preservation of facial nerve function.

RESULTS

We analyzed the data of 15 individual studies involving 359 total patients, and our results reveal that tumor control rates are comparable between adjuvant radiosurgery (91%, CI: 88-94%) and secondary resection (92%, CI 75-98%). However, adjuvant radiosurgery was shown to preserve good facial nerve function better (94%, CI 84-98%) compared to secondary surgical resection (56%, CI 41-69%).

CONCLUSION

With comparable tumor control rates and better preservation of good facial nerve function, this study suggests that secondary radiosurgery for recurrent VS is associated with both optimal tumor control and preservation of good facial nerve function.

Staged resection of large acoustic neuromas

OBJECTIVE

Surgical removal of large (>3 cm) acoustic neuromas is associated with poor long-term facial nerve function results and higher complication rates. This study analyzes whether long term facial nerve function and the incidence of neurological and vascular complications is improved by resection of large acoustic neuromas in 2 or 3 stages.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Among 660 patients who underwent surgical resection of acoustic neuromas between 1989 and 2002 by the senior author (J.M.K.), 34 (5%) patients underwent a staged resection of their large-sized tumors: stage I via a retrosigmoid craniotomy and stage II via a translabyrinthine approach. A retrospective chart review was performed. Tumor size, completeness of tumor removal, tumor recurrence, facial nerve function, and any complications were noted.

RESULTS:

The average tumor size was 4.4 cm with a mean postoperative length of follow-up of 6 years after the last surgery. Thirty-one patients underwent a 2-staged resection and 3 patients underwent a 3-staged resection. After their last surgery, 32 (94%) patients had excellent long-term facial function grades of House-Brackmann (H-B) I, one was H-B III, and one was H-B VI. All patients had a total or near-total (>98%) resection. There were no tumor recurrences on follow-up MRI scans. From these 71 operations, no patients required reoperation for a CSF leak. There were no deaths, strokes, hydrocephalus, or meningitis.

CONCLUSION:

In conjunction with the reported technical refinements, staged resection of large tumors significantly reduces morbidity and improves long-term facial nerve function. EBM rating: C.

Staged resection for vestibular schwannoma

CONCLUSION

Surgery remains the preferred option for large vestibular schwannoma (VS). The presence of unpredictable intraoperative difficulties may convince the operator to suspend the surgery to avoid risks to patient life. Additional surgeries may be mandatory and are better performed using a transcochlear approach. High rates of complications, poor facial nerve results, and a percentage of incomplete removals should be expected in such unfavorable cases.

OBJECTIVES

To review the results for nine cases of huge VS treated by staged resection.

METHOD

A retrospective case review was performed for all nine patients who underwent staged resection of VS at the Gruppo Otologico between 1984-2012. The decision to perform staged surgery was always made intra-operatively after encountering unpredicted difficulties.

RESULTS

The nine patients represented 0.3% of all patients who underwent VS surgery during the same period. Mean tumor size was 4.7 cm (range = 3.0-6.6 cm). Two cases required three surgeries, resulting in a total of 20 operations. In addition, two cases required pre-operative ventriculoperitoneal shunt and one required temporary tracheotomy. After the final stage of surgery, complete removal had been achieved in six of the nine patients. The facial nerve was never preserved anatomically.

Improved facial nerve outcomes using an evolving treatment method for large acoustic neuromas

OBJECTIVE

To describe a successful paradigm for the treatment of large acoustic neuromas (vestibular schwannomas).

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case review.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

The charts of 2,875 acoustic neuroma patients at Michigan Ear Institute were reviewed to identify 153 patients who underwent surgical resection for large acoustic neuromas (>=3 cm) between 2000 and 2009.

INTERVENTION(S)

Staged surgical resection or single stage surgery with or without adjuvant stereotactic radiosurgery.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Postoperative facial nerve outcomes are reported using the House-Brackmann (HB) facial nerve grading scale and compared with historical controls from a literature review. Rates of adverse outcomes are also reported.

RESULTS

Seventy-five patients underwent staged surgical resection of their tumors, whereas 78 patients underwent either single stage surgery or surgery with subsequent stereotactic radiosurgery. Eighty-one percent of patients in the staged surgical resection group had a postoperative HB Grade I or II facial nerve function compared with 75% in the single stage surgical group. Overall, 78% of patients in the current study had HB Grade I or II after treatment compared with a mean of 53% in the literature for similar sized tumors. Our methods including the decision to use staged surgery when necessary, dissection of tumor with stimulating dissector-directed intraoperative monitoring, and use of adjuvant stereotactic radiosurgery are described.

CONCLUSION

Using the described paradigm, large acoustic neuromas can be successfully treated with either staged or single-stage surgical resection with or without adjuvant radiosurgery to obtain more favorable facial nerve outcomes than historically reported controls while minimizing morbidity for the patient.

Technical nuances of resection of giant (> 5 cm) vestibular schwannomas: pearls for success

Removal of vestibular schwannomas (VSs, or acoustic neuromas) remains one of the most challenging operations in neurosurgery. Giant or huge tumors (> 5 cm) heighten these challenges, and technical nuances play a special role in maximizing tumor resection while minimizing complications. In this article, the senior author describes his technical experience with microsurgical excision of giant VSs. The accompanying video further illustrates these details.

Facial nerve preservation and tumor control after gamma knife radiosurgery of unilateral acoustic tumors

To assess the long-term risk of facial nerve dysfunction after unilateral acoustic tumor stereotactic radiosurgery, we retrospectively analyzed our initial experience in 98 unilateral acoustic tumor patients who were evaluated at least 2 years after treatment. This observation interval permits an analysis of both the risk of onset and the potential for recovery of facial nerve function. The overall risk of developing any degree of delayed transient or permanent postoperative facial neuropathy was 21.4% (21 of 98 patients). Only one patient undergoing radiosurgery alone had poor residual facial nerve dysfunction worse than House-Brackmann grade III. Normal facial nerve function (House-Brackmann grade 1) was preserved in 95% of patients with small tumors (10 mm or less petrous-pons dimension) and in 90% of patients who had useful hearing and normal facial function preoperatively. Normal facial function was preserved in all patients with intracanalicular acoustic tumors. The risk of delayed facial neuropathy was reduced by performing radiosurgery when tumors were small (1000 mm(3) or less), by enclosing the tumor within the 50% isodose volume, by using multiple small radiation isocenters, and by detailed identification of the tumor volume using stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging.

Staged resection of large hypervascular vestibular schwannomas in young adults

Two young adults underwent resection of large hypervascular vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas) via two-stage surgery. The first patient, a 27-year-old woman with hydrocephalus, had a large hypervascular vestibular tumor in the left cerebellopontine angle (CPA) supplied by the left anterior inferior cerebellar artery (AICA) and posterior inferior cerebellar artery (PICA). The second patient, a 34-year-old woman, had a large AICA-supplied hypervascular vestibular tumor in the left CPA that displaced the brain stem significantly. At the initial stage, only the lateral aspect of the tumor was debulked due to excessive bleeding from the tumor bed. Angiography 1 or 2 months after the initial operation showed that the tumor was hypovascular. At the second stage, the remnant medial aspect of the tumor was relatively avascular and nonadherent to the brain stem. Without blood transfusion during the second stage, the tumor was removed totally in the first patient and subtotally in the second patient. Pathological examination revealed that dilatated blood vessels were prominently increased at the first surgery; however, at the second surgery, the number of blood vessels had decreased, showing necrosis and degeneration. Although there are no absolute indications for the staged resection of vestibular schwannomas, this procedure may represent one of the safest options for these difficult lesions in young adults.

Beyond audiofacial morbidity after vestibular schwannoma surgery

Object

Outcomes following vestibular schwannoma (VS) surgery have been extensively described; however, complication rates reported in the literature vary markedly. In addition, the majority of reports have focused on outcomes related to cranial nerves (CNs) VII and VIII. The objective of this study was to analyze reported morbidity unrelated to CNs VII and VIII following the resection of VS.

Methods

The authors performed a comprehensive search of the English language literature, identifying and aggregating morbidity and death data from patients who had undergone microsurgical removal of VSs. A subgroup analysis based on surgical approach and tumor size was performed to compare rates of CSF leakage, vascular injury, neurological deficit, and postoperative infection.

Results

One hundred articles met the inclusion criteria, providing data for 32,870 patients. The overall mortality rate was 0.2% (95% CI 0.1–0.3%). Twenty-two percent of patients (95% CI 21–23%) experienced at least 1 surgically attributable complication unrelated to CNs VII or VIII. Cerebrospinal fluid leakage occurred in 8.5% of patients (95% CI 6.9–10.0%). This rate was markedly increased with the translabyrinthine approach but was not affected by tumor size. Vascular complications, such as ischemic injury or hemorrhage, occurred in 1% of patients (95% CI 0.75–1.2%). Neurological complications occurred in 8.6% of cases (95% CI 7.9–9.3%) and were less likely with the resection of smaller tumors (p < 0.0001) and the use of the translabyrinthine approach (p < 0.0001). Infections occurred in 3.8% of cases (95% CI 3.4–4.3%), and 78% of these infections were meningitis.

Conclusions

This study provides statistically powerful data for practitioners to advise patients about the published risks of surgery for VS unrelated to compromised CNs VII and VIII.

Staging in vestibular schwannoma surgery: a modified technique

The authors herein propose the staged excision as a novel strategy to preserve facial nerve and minimize complication during microsurgery of large vestibular schwannoma (VS). At the first stage, for reducing mass effect on the brain stem and cerebellum, subtotal tumor resection was performed via a retrosigmoid craniotomy without intervention of meatal portion of tumor. With total resection of the remaining tumor, the facial nerve was decompressed and delineated during the second stage translabyrinthine approach at a later date. A 38-year-old female who underwent the staging operation for resection of her huge VS is illustrated.

Hypervascular vestibular schwannomas

BACKGROUND

Vestibular schwannoma (VS) is usually hypovascular and can be resected totally without major morbidity. Resection of the more uncommon hypervascular VS is complicated by excessive tumor bleeding. We have attempted to clarify the clinical characteristics and management of hypervascular VS.

METHODS

Surgical reports and videos of 78 patients with unilateral VS (5 hypervascular, 73 nonhypervascular) were retrospectively reviewed and clinical characteristics, radiological findings, and case management were compared.

RESULTS

Hypervascular VS presented at a younger age than nonhypervascular VS (29 +/- 12 vs. 52 +/- 16 years old) (p < 0.01). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed that hypervascular VS was solid, without tumor cyst, and significantly larger than nonhypervascular VS (p < 0.05). The surface of hypervascular VS consistently showed multiple flow voids representing large draining veins. The characteristic angiographical findings of hypervascular VS were extensive tumor vessels, tumor stains, and early filling of draining veins; vertebrobasilar arteries supplied hypervascular VS. A multi-stage surgical approach was used since torrential tumor bleeding in the first surgery interfered with resection, resulting in partial tumor removal. Angiography before the second surgery showed much reduced tumor vascularity, bleeding was much reduced, and tumor was resected with less difficulty. In this approach, all 5 hypervascular VS were resected totally (1 case) or near-totally (4 cases) without major morbidity.

CONCLUSIONS

Hypervascular VS, a solid and large tumor, presents at an earlier age. Although angiography provides characteristic findings, MRI can confirm the diagnosis of a hypervascular VS by showing multiple flow-voids on the tumor surface. Since partial tumor removal (first surgery) extensively reduces tumor vascularity and intraoperative tumor bleeding considerably, hypervascular VS should be managed by a multi-staged surgical approach.

Staged removal of acoustic tumors: techniques and lessons learned from a series of 83 patients

The removal of large acoustic tumors is associated with increased mortality and cranial nerve injury. One method for treating these difficult lesions is staged resection. Between 1972 and 1992, more than 600 acoustic tumors were resected at our institution. Of these, 83 were removed in stages. This represents the largest series of staged acoustic tumor resections reported to date. A review of available films and patient records was performed for all acoustic tumors resected in stages between 1972 and early 1993 to analyze demographic information, tumor size, operative technique, outcome, and complications. The information was collected on standardized data sheets and entered into a computer database. Virtually all tumors were large, with the average size being 4 cm in greatest diameter. The average patient age was 41 years, and there was a slight preponderance of female patients. Ten patients had neurofibromatosis Type 2. The suboccipital approach was used in most patients. Anatomic preservation of the VIIth cranial nerve was achieved in > 72% of patients, with an average House-Brackmann score of Grade 3 at the longest follow-up (mean, 43 mo). Facial reanimation was performed in 19 of 23 patients with transected VIIth cranial nerves. Complications included cerebrospinal fluid fistulas in 11 patients, with 8 of 11 fistulas resolving after lumbar drainage. Six patients had meningitis (bacterial in three and aseptic in three). Two patients developed wound infections, and 10 patients developed exposure keratitis. There were two documented recurrences. There were no operative deaths. In most series, the incidence of cranial nerve deficits as well as morbidity and mortality is directly related to tumor size. Our operative strategy involved debulking the lateral aspect of large tumors during Stage I. Second stage removal is performed after the remaining tumor is shown to decompress out of the pons on computed tomographic or magnetic resonance images. During the second procedure, the residual tumor is less vascular and no longer densely adherent to the brain stem. Although staged removal is not without risk, there seems to be no apparent increase in morbidity when these results are compared with the results of series from the literature. Although there remain no absolute indications for staged resection of acoustic tumors, we think that it may represent the safest option for these difficult lesions.

Electrophysiological characterization of pre- and postoperative facial nerve function in patients with acoustic neuroma using electrical and magnetic stimulation techniques

Facial nerve function was examined in patients who underwent posterior fossa surgery for unilateral acoustic neuroma. Examinations took place prior to surgery (n = 47 patients), early after surgery (0-12 days, n = 16 of 47 patients), and late after surgery (187-1505 days, n = 29 of 47 patients). Clinical signs of facial palsy were present to a variable extent in 13 of 47 patients before, in 12 of 16 patients early, and in 18 of 29 patients later after surgery. Electrophysiologically, the facial nerve was stimulated electrically at the stylomastoid fossa and magnetically at its proximal intracanalicular segment. In addition, the face-associated motor cortex was stimulated magnetically. In patients with facial palsy, any of these stimulation methods resulted in a decreased amplitude of the response in the nasalis muscle. The decrease showed a linear relationship to the clinical grade of palsy, pre- and postoperatively. Corticomuscular latencies remained unchanged. We conclude that: (i) the electrophysiological characteristics of facial nerve lesions due to compression by acoustic neuromas or due to a complication of neuroma removal are those of a purely axonal neuropathy; (ii) the three stimulation techniques have a similar diagnostic yield, thus making the use of all three of them redundant; and (iii) the electrophysiological techniques allowed no prediction of the final facial nerve function.

The impact of continuous electrophysiological monitoring on preservation of the facial nerve during acoustic tumour surgery

Continuous electromyographic (EMG) activity and responses to electrical stimulation of the facial nerve were monitored intraoperatively in 35 patients undergoing primary removal of acoustic neuroma. The rate of anatomical and immediate functional preservation of the facial nerve of these patients was compared with a matched population where a facial nerve stimulator and monitoring of facial muscle contraction by the anaesthetist only was employed. Overall, 94% (n = 33) of facial nerves were preserved anatomically in patients with continuous EMG monitoring, compared with 64% (n = 89) of patients (n = 139) without continuous monitoring. Amongst the 33 cases with anatomical facial nerve preservation, 64% (n = 21) had immediate functional preservation. Immediate functional preservation was only achieved in 39% (n = 35) of anatomically preserved facial nerves (n = 89) where conventional monitoring was used.

An extended middle fossa approach combined with a suboccipital craniectomy to the base of the skull in the posterior fossa

A new approach to the base of the skull in the posterior fossa is described. This approach involves removing the petrous bone without any injury to the labyrinth, and dividing the superior petrosal sinus and tentorium cerebelli. A combined suboccipital craniectomy is used for excision of the portion of tumors that extended inferiorly. Total or subtotal removal of tumors was performed in 11 patients and partial removal in 3 patients, without any operative mortality. The facial nerve was preserved in all patients and hearing was retained in 9 of 12 patients. This approach is useful for large tumors located around the clivus.

Acoustic nerve tumor surgery before and since the laser: comparison of results

A random computer selection of 21 patients who underwent 28 operations for acoustic neurinoma between 1974 and 1980 using conventional methods, including the operating microscope and microtechnique, was compared with a cohort of 22 patients who underwent 25 operations between 1980 and 1984 utilizing a carbon dioxide laser. Completeness of tumor removal, anatomical and functional preservation of the facial nerve, preservation of hearing, morbidity and mortality, average hospital stay, and eventual outcome were used as markers and were compared. Utilizing P values, the study demonstrated a significantly superior outcome, and as a result a better life quality, in patients who were operated on utilizing a CO2 laser in addition to conventional microsurgical technique.

Does intravascular coagulation contribute to the operative mortality for large acoustic neuromas?

Three cases of abnormal bleeding during suboccipital excision of large acoustic neuroma are reported. The possible role of limited operative intravascular coagulation is discussed.

[Results of 110 microsurgical acoustic neuroma operations]

We report our experiences in 110 cases of microsurgical removal of acoustic neurinomas. The historic development, the chances of preservation of the facial nerve and hearing function and the mortality risks are described in detail, hereby stressing the advantages of the lateral suboccipital approach in microneurosurgery.

Contralateral pontine hemorrhage as a complication of acoustic neurinoma surgery

The authors report the occurrence of a contralateral pontine hemorrhage after an operation for an acoustic neurinoma. A 55-year-old woman was found to have a small pontine hemorrhage opposite to the side of the tumor immediately after the operation. The cause of the hemorrhage is discussed.

Technical and instrumental improvements in the surgical treatment of acoustic neurinomas

Microsurgical removal of large acoustic neurinomas, more than 3 cm in diameter, has been performed by the lateral suboccipital transmeatal approach with the patient in the lateral position in 68 cases in the past 5 years. sixty-two patients (92%) returned to their former occupations and two died: one in the immediate postoperative period and the other 16 months later. The postoperative follow-up examination showed satisfactory facial nerve function in 70% of the patients. Hearing was preserved in six of 14 patients who had preoperatively retained their auditory function. The authors emphasize the usefulness of bipolar forceps for intraoperative stimulation of the facial nerve and for facial muscle monitoring. The value of the four-pronged hook and the multipurpose head-frame in this procedure is also discussed.

Brain tumors and the geriatric patient

The prognosis, site of occurrence, and histologic type of primary brain tumors are age-dependent phenomena. In general, the incidence of meningiomas, acoustic Schwannomas, and glioblastomas increases with advancing age until the end of the eighth decade. Of 99 patients consecutively admitted to an aggressive multimodality treatment program for glioblastoma multiforme, 18 per cent were in the 61-70 age group and 4 per cent in the 71-80 group; the oldest was 85. The operative mortality was only 4 per cent. In 16 patients over 65, the 6- and 12-month calculated survival probabilities were 0.65 and 0.31, respectively. The Kaplan-Meier survival curve for these patients was significantly different from that for 26 patients under the age of 40. Grade 4 astrocytomas were present in 62 per cent of patients under 40 but in 83 per cent of patients over 61. In all glioblastoma populations, age is the most significant prognostic variable. The incidence of metastic brain tumors also increases with age, and all of the usual primary sites are represented. The prognosis for elderly patients with metastatic brain tumor is uniformly worse than that for younger patients, even though modern diagnostic and operative techniques carry virtually the same morbidity and mortality rates in older patients as in younger ones. It is vitally important, therefore, that the clinical effects of treatable intracranial tumors in the elderly are not ascribed to dementia, the aging process, the systemic effects of cancer, or the side effects of cancer therapy, without suitable diagnostic investigation.

Facial nerve preservation in patients with large acoustic neuromas treated by a combined middle fossa transtentorial translabyrinthine approach

With large acoustic neuromas, the primary goal of surgery is safe total removal of the tumors, and the secondary goal is preservation of nearby neural structures, including the facial nerve. In a series of 15 consecutive patients with large cerebellopontine angle tumors, all of which were more than 2.5 cm in diameter, tumor excision was performed by a one-stage combined middle fossa-translabyrinthine approach. There were 13 acoustic neuromas, 10 of which were more than 4 cm in diameter, one petrous apex meningioma 4 cm in diameter, and one facial neuroma 3 cm in diameter. The tumors were totally removed in all 15 patients. The facial nerve was preserved in 12 of 13 evaluable patients. In the 14th patient the nerve had been transected in a previous suboccipital procedure with incomplete removal, and in the 15th patient the nerve was sutured following excision of a facial neuroma. Thus, the nerve was lost at surgery in only one patient. This combined approach provided very clear visualization of the cerebellopontine angle, including the brain stem and the lower cranial nerves. It enabled identification of both the origin of the facial nerve at the brain stem and the lateral segment of the nerve in the internal auditory canal. Anterior extensions of tumor growing through the tentorial hiatus were easily removed. The results in these 15 patients show that this approach is excellent for total removal of large acoustic neuromas with preservation of the facial nerve. It is especially suitable for large tumors with anterior extensions.

Preservation of facial and acoustic nerves in the total removal of large and small acoustic tumors. Report of two cases

Two cases are presented in which an acoustic tumor was totally removed without the aid of an operating microscope. In one of them, a large lesion was excised, with restoration of the patient's hearing postoperatively. The anatomical problems are analyzed, and the relevant literature is reviewed briefly.