Facial nerve preservation in patients with large acoustic neuromas treated by a combined middle fossa transtentorial translabyrinthine approach

Clinical Studies and Pre-clinical Animal Models on Facial Nerve Preservation, Reconstruction, and Regeneration Following Cerebellopontine Angle Tumor Surgery-A Systematic Review and Future Perspectives

Background and purpose: Tumorous lesions developing in the cerebellopontine angle (CPA) get into close contact with the 1st (cisternal) and 2nd (meatal) intra-arachnoidal portion of the facial nerve (FN). When surgical damage occurs, commonly known reconstruction strategies are often associated with poor functional recovery. This article aims to provide a systematic overview for translational research by establishing the current evidence on available clinical studies and experimental models reporting on intracranial FN injury.

Methods: A systematic literature search of several databases (PubMed, EMBASE, Medline) was performed prior to July 2020. Suitable articles were selected based on predefined eligibility criteria following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Included clinical studies were reviewed and categorized according to the pathology and surgical resection strategy, and experimental studies according to the animal. For anatomical study purposes, perfusion-fixed adult New Zealand white rabbits were used for radiological high-resolution imaging and anatomical dissection of the CPA and periotic skull base.

Results: One hundred forty four out of 166 included publications were clinical studies reporting on FN outcomes after CPA-tumor surgery in 19,136 patients. During CPA-tumor surgery, the specific vulnerability of the intracranial FN to stretching and compression more likely leads to neurapraxia or axonotmesis than neurotmesis. Severe FN palsy was reported in 7 to 15 % after vestibular schwannoma surgery, and 6% following the resection of CPA-meningioma. Twenty-two papers reported on experimental studies, out of which only 6 specifically used intracranial FN injury in a rodent (n = 4) or non-rodent model (n = 2). Rats and rabbits offer a feasible model for manipulation of the FN in the CPA, the latter was further confirmed in our study covering the radiological and anatomical analysis of perfusion fixed periotic bones.

Conclusion: The particular anatomical and physiological features of the intracranial FN warrant a distinguishment of experimental models for intracranial FN injuries. New Zealand White rabbits might be a very cost-effective and valuable option to test new experimental approaches for intracranial FN regeneration. Flexible and bioactive biomaterials, commonly used in skull base surgery, endowed with trophic and topographical functions, should address the specific needs of intracranial FN injuries.

Evolving Role of Non-Total Resection in Management of Acoustic Neuroma in the Gamma Knife Era

OBJECTIVE

To examine patients with residual tumor after vestibular schwannoma (VS) resection with focus on need for further therapy, including stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) and revision surgery.

STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING

Retrospective review at two tertiary otology referral centers.

PATIENTS AND INTERVENTION

Patients undergoing primary surgery for VS from 2007 to 2017.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Degree of resection and need for further treatment.

RESULTS

Of 289 patients undergoing surgery, 38 (13.1%) underwent subtotal resections (<95% of tumor resected) and 77 (26.6%) underwent near-total resections (≥95% but <100%). Patients with any residual tumor had larger tumors preoperatively (mean estimated volume 6.3 cm versus 2.1 cm, p < 0.0005) but were otherwise clinically and demographically similar to the population as a whole. Further treatment (surgery or SRS) was needed in 4.6, 14.3, and 50.0% of patients after gross total, near-total, and subtotal resections, respectively (p < 0.0005). Patients undergoing additional therapy had larger residual tumors (median post- to preoperative estimated volume ratio 0.09 versus 0.01, p < 0.0005). Patients undergoing subtotal and near-total resections had poorer facial function at ultimate follow up than those undergoing gross total resections (p = 0.001), likely due to larger tumors and more difficult resections. Literature review revealed higher rates of gross total resection as well as facial palsy in the pre-SRS era.

CONCLUSION

Residual tumor following VS resection is more common today than in the pre-SRS era. Availability of SRS may encourage leaving residual tumor intraoperatively to preserve neural structures. Current surgical strategies decrease surgical morbidity but necessitate further treatment in over 10% of cases.

Facial nerve preservation and tumor control after gamma knife radiosurgery of unilateral acoustic tumors

To assess the long-term risk of facial nerve dysfunction after unilateral acoustic tumor stereotactic radiosurgery, we retrospectively analyzed our initial experience in 98 unilateral acoustic tumor patients who were evaluated at least 2 years after treatment. This observation interval permits an analysis of both the risk of onset and the potential for recovery of facial nerve function. The overall risk of developing any degree of delayed transient or permanent postoperative facial neuropathy was 21.4% (21 of 98 patients). Only one patient undergoing radiosurgery alone had poor residual facial nerve dysfunction worse than House-Brackmann grade III. Normal facial nerve function (House-Brackmann grade 1) was preserved in 95% of patients with small tumors (10 mm or less petrous-pons dimension) and in 90% of patients who had useful hearing and normal facial function preoperatively. Normal facial function was preserved in all patients with intracanalicular acoustic tumors. The risk of delayed facial neuropathy was reduced by performing radiosurgery when tumors were small (1000 mm(3) or less), by enclosing the tumor within the 50% isodose volume, by using multiple small radiation isocenters, and by detailed identification of the tumor volume using stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging.

Prediction of facial nerve function after surgery for cerebellopontine angle tumors: use of a facial nerve stimulator and monitor

A series of 18 patients undergoing surgery for cerebellopontine angle tumors is reported. Patients were grouped according to size of tumor (0 to 2.5 cm, 11 cases; more than 2.5 cm, 7 cases). In all, the facial nerve was identified and conductance assessed by monitoring the facial electromyographic response to facial nerve stimulation. Postoperative facial nerve function was graded clinically after 3 months according to the House scale. Tumor removal was complete in all cases. In patients with tumors up to 2.5 cm the facial nerve was intact to visual inspection at the end of the procedure in all but one, where partial division was evident. In this group intraoperative facial nerve stimulation indicated electrical integrity in 8 of the 11 cases, all of which regained good facial nerve function postoperatively (House grades I and II). Nerve conduction was lost during the operation in the remaining three patients with small tumors; two subsequently developed a moderately severe (grade IV) dysfunction and the third, a total paralysis (grade VI). In the large (more than 2.5 cm) tumor group the facial nerve was anatomically intact in five of the seven cases, partially divided in one, and completely sectioned in the remaining case. Facial nerve stimulation indicated functional integrity in three patients, two of whom developed moderate (grade III) and the third a severe (grade V) dysfunction. In the other four cases nerve function could not be detected at operation; three of these developed a moderate facial nerve dysfunction (grade III/IV) and the final case a complete paralysis (grade VI). Intraoperative facial nerve monitoring appeared to predict eventual facial function accurately in the small tumor group, but did not predict facial nerve recovery reliably following surgery for larger tumors.

Preservation of facial nerve function after resection of vestibular schwannoma

OBJECTIVE

Most data regarding facial nerve function in patients undergoing microsurgical resection of vestibular schwannomas predominantly include series performed at a single institution. In an effort to minimise individual surgeon or institutional bias, we performed an analysis of the published literature on facial nerve outcomes following microsurgical resection of vestibular schwannomas. The objective of this study was to provide a comprehensive assessment of reported outcomes for facial nerve preservation after VS surgery.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We identified a total of 296 studies involving over 25,000 patients that included outcome data for facial nerve function of vestibular schwannoma patients treated surgically. Data regarding surgical approach, tumour size, patient age, and use of intra-operative monitoring were extracted and correlated with facial nerve function after surgery. Patients with preoperative facial nerve dysfunction (House-Brackmann score 3 or higher) were excluded and 'facial nerve preservation' was defined as grade I or II House-Brackmann function at last follow-up visit.

RESULTS

A total of 79 articles reporting on 11,873 patients met our inclusion criteria contributing to our analysis. Patients treated with the middle cranial fossa approach had a trend towards higher overall facial nerve preservation rate (85%), compared to the translabyrinthine approach (81%, p = 0.07) , and did statistically better than the retrosigmoid approach (78%, p < 0.0001). Patients with an average tumour size <20 mm had significantly improved facial nerve preservation rates, compared to larger tumours (90% vs. 67%, p < 0.0001). Patients under 65 years of age had a lower facial nerve preservation rate (71% vs. 84%, p < 0.001). Finally, the use of intra-operative monitoring improved the facial nerve preservation rate (76% vs. 71%, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Factors that appear to be associated with facial nerve preservation after microsurgical resection of a vestibular schwannoma include tumour size <20 mm, use of the middle fossa approach and use of neuromonitoring during surgery. These data provide a summary assessment of the published literature regarding facial nerve preservation after microsurgical resection of vestibular schwannoma.

Report of 190 consecutive cases of large acoustic tumors (vestibular schwannoma) removed via the translabyrinthine approach

OBJECT

The choice of approach for surgical removal of large acoustic neuromas is still controversial. The authors reviewed the results in a series of patients who underwent removal of large tumors via the translabyrinthine approach.

METHODS

The authors conducted a database analysis of 190 patients (89 men and 101 women) with acoustic neuromas 3 cm or greater in size. The mean age of these patients was 46.1+/-15.6 years. One hundred seventy-eight patients underwent primary translabyrinthine surgical removal and 12 underwent surgery for residual tumor. Total tumor removal was accomplished in 183 cases (96.3%). The tumor was adherent to the facial nerve to some degree in 64% of the cases, but the facial nerve was preserved anatomically in 178 (93.7%) of the patients. Divided nerves were repaired by primary attachment or cable graft. Facial nerve function was assessed immediately after surgery, at the time of discharge, and at 3 to 4 weeks and 1 year after discharge. Excellent function (House-Brackmann facial nerve Grade I or II) was present in 55%, 33.9%, 38.8%, and 52.6% of the patients for each time interval, respectively, with acceptable function (Grades I-IV) in 81% at 1 year. Cerebrospinal fluid leakage that required surgical repair occurred in only 1.1% of the patients and meningitis in 3.7%. There were no deaths.

CONCLUSIONS

Use of the translabyrinthine approach for removal of large tumors resulted in good anatomical and functional preservation of the facial nerve, with minimum incidence of morbidity and no incidence of mortality. The authors continue to recommend use of this approach for acoustic tumors larger than 3 cm and for smaller tumors when hearing preservation is not an issue.

Report of 190 consecutive cases of large acoustic tumors (vestibular schwannoma) removed via the translabyrinthine approach

Object

The choice of approach for surgical removal of large acoustic neuromas is still controversial. The authors reviewed the results in a series of patients who underwent removal of large tumors via the translabyrinthine approach.

Methods

The authors conducted a database analysis of 190 patients (89 men and 101 women) with acoustic neuromas 3 cm or greater in size. The mean age of these patients was 46.1 ± 15.6 years. One hundred seventy-eight patients underwent primary translabyrinthine surgical removal and 12 underwent surgery for residual tumor. Total tumor removal was accomplished in 183 cases (96.3%). The tumor was adherent to the facial nerve to some degree in 64% of the cases, but the facial nerve was preserved anatomically in 178 (93.7%) of the patients. Divided nerves were repaired by primary attachment or cable graft. Facial nerve function was assessed immediately after surgery, at the time of discharge, and at 3 to 4 weeks and 1 year after discharge. Excellent function (House-Brackmann facial nerve Grade I or II) was present in 55%, 33.9%, 38.8%, and 52.6% of the patients for each time interval, respectively, with acceptable function (Grades I–IV) in 81% at 1 year. Cerebrospinal fluid leakage that required surgical repair occurred in only 1.1% of the patients and meningitis occurred in 3.7%. There were no deaths.

Conclusions

Use of the translabyrinthine approach for removal of large tumors resulted in good anatomical and functional preservation of the facial nerve, with minimum incidence of morbidity and no incidence of mortality. The authors continue to recommend use of this approach for acoustic tumors larger than 3 cm and for smaller tumors when hearing preservation is not an issue.

Lateral approaches to the petroclival region

The microsurgical anatomy that provides the basis for dealing with lesions arising in the petroclival region was reviewed in 15 adult cadaver heads and 25 dry skulls. The eight surgical approaches studied were the retrosigmoid, extreme lateral transcondylar, translabyrinthine, transcochlear, combined supra and infratentorial presigmoid, subtemporal anterior transpetrosal, subtemporal preauricular infratemporal, and the postauricular transtemporal approach. Considerations important in the selection of these approaches are discussed. Special attention was directed to the course of the facial nerve and internal carotid artery in the temporal bone and the major venous pathways draining the region.

Acoustic tumour volume and the prediction of facial nerve functional outcome from intraoperative monitoring

The long-term facial function in 26 patients undergoing surgery to remove an acoustic neuroma has been related to the tumour volume (ml) estimated by computerized tomogram (CT) reconstruction techniques. Analysis of data allowed accurate categorization into 'small' (= < 5 ml) and 'large' (> 5 ml) tumours, which gave the maximum prognostic distinction between two groups for facial recovery. Thus, of the 14 patients with small volume tumours, 11 achieved a good (House grade I or II) facial outcome compared with 1 out of 12 patients with large tumours. Combined with the information derived from the assessment of intraoperative facial nerve electrical integrity using a combined nerve stimulator and EMG monitor, long-term facial function was predictable for all small tumours defined by volume. This represented a 15% improvement in prediction of facial recovery when defining tumour size by maximum linear dimension (small = < 2.5 cm, large > 2.5 cm). The calculations of volume obtained using a simplified ellipsoidal model compared well with CT reconstructed values (r2 = 0.85), and gave identical prediction and outcome comparisons.

Intra-operative monitoring of the facial nerve with an air inflated balloon. Technical note

A simple, reliable and cheap device for intra-operative monitoring of the facial nerve during surgery for cerebellopontine angle tumours is presented. It consists of a single use tracheostomy tube with a low pressure air inflatable cuff placed in the mouth of the patient on the side of the tumour, connected by a pressure transducer to a monitoring unit. It records any pressure changes in the patient's mouth induced by muscular contractions as a result of excitation of the inferior parts of the facial nerve.

Comparisons of the clinical and radiological features and surgical management of posterior fossa meningiomas and acoustic neuromas

Next to acoustic neuromas, meningiomas are the most common benign tumour of the posterior fossa. This paper reviews the personal experience of one of the authors with the management of 26 posterior fossa meningiomas and 212 acoustic neuromas. The aim was to compare the clinical and radiological features of these two types of posterior fossa tumours to determine whether they can be differentiated preoperatively. The study also aimed at analysing the surgical treatment of posterior fossa meningiomas. The results showed that posterior fossa meningiomas can usually be differentiated from acoustic neuromas on the basis of clinical and radiological features. Preoperative differentiation aids surgical management, especially for selection of surgical approach. In most instances, posterior fossa meningiomas can be totally resected with minimal morbidity and mortality.

A modified extended middle cranial fossa approach for acoustic nerve tumors. Results of 125 operations

During the past 10 years, 125 operations for acoustic nerve tumors were performed on 114 patients at the authors' institution using a modified extended middle cranial fossa approach. This approach is based on a combination of King and Morrison's translabyrinthine-transtentorial approach and on the extended approach through the middle cranial fossa described by Bochenek and Kukwa. There were two hospital deaths (operative mortality 1.6%). In 102 operations on the initial tumor, total removal was performed in 89 cases (87%), and in 71 (80%) of these the facial nerve was anatomically preserved. Intracranial end-to-end anastomosis was performed on five of the 18 sacrificed facial nerves; a facial-hypoglossal anastomosis was carried out in the remaining 13 patients and in five (7%) of the 71 patients whose anatomically preserved facial nerve functioned poorly. In seven (39%) of the 18 patients in whom an attempt to preserve hearing was made, postoperative hearing was saved. In 23 operations on 17 patients for recurrent tumors, most of which had previously been removed subtotally via the suboccipital approach, total removal was accomplished in 13 (57% of the 23 reoperations and 76% of the 17 patients). At reoperation, the facial nerve was preserved in six (55%) of the 11 patients in whom the facial nerve had not been sacrificed. Postoperative leakage of cerebrospinal fluid occurred in 11 cases (8.8%), with rhinorrhea in 10 cases and otorrhea in one. Five of the fistulas were corrected by surgery and the rest healed spontaneously. Other complications were not significant.

Electrophysiological monitoring during acoustic neuroma and other posterior fossa surgery

Techniques used to monitor the function of the seventh and eighth cranial nerves during acoustic neuroma and other posterior fossa surgery are reviewed. The auditory brainstem response (ABR), electrocochleogram (ECochG) and direct recording from the auditory nerve (CNAP) were compared. The best technique is the ECochG, although in many cases, the CNAP should be used as a back-up technique. The CNAP is especially useful for the identification of the auditory nerve. Both can provide real-time feedback on the physiological integrity of the auditory nerve. The ABR may be helpful in monitoring brainstem function. For some procedures, optimal monitoring requires the combined recording of all three techniques. Monopolar constant-voltage intracranial stimulation of the facial nerve is helpful for the identification and preservation of the facial nerve. Audio monitoring of spontaneous electromyographic activity provides real-time feedback on the effect of surgical manipulation of the nerve. Monitoring of ephaptic transmission in the facial nerve during microvascular decompression for hemifacial spasm aids in the identification of the offending vessel.

Surgical approaches to acoustic nerve tumours

A critical account is given of the orthodox neurosurgical approach to acoustic nerve tumours and alternatives through the petrous bone or tentorium.

An extended middle fossa approach combined with a suboccipital craniectomy to the base of the skull in the posterior fossa

A new approach to the base of the skull in the posterior fossa is described. This approach involves removing the petrous bone without any injury to the labyrinth, and dividing the superior petrosal sinus and tentorium cerebelli. A combined suboccipital craniectomy is used for excision of the portion of tumors that extended inferiorly. Total or subtotal removal of tumors was performed in 11 patients and partial removal in 3 patients, without any operative mortality. The facial nerve was preserved in all patients and hearing was retained in 9 of 12 patients. This approach is useful for large tumors located around the clivus.

Acoustic neuromas: management of 204 cases

This paper reviews the author's personal experience with the management of 204 patients with the clinical diagnosis of acoustic neuroma. Craniotomy was performed in 181 of these cases, all of whom were proven to have acoustic neuromas. The remaining 23 cases with the clinical diagnosis of acoustic neuroma did not have tumour surgery, mainly because of advanced age or concurrent disease, although some required shunts for hydrocephalus. The management of acoustic neuromas including the selection of surgical approach depends upon the patient's age and general health, the size and growth direction of the tumour, previous surgical attempts at removal, and the presence of hydrocephalus, a contralateral tumour, and serviceable hearing. Twenty-nine other cases with the clinical diagnosis of acoustic neuroma underwent craniotomy: 20 had petrous or tentorial meningiomas encroaching on the porus acousticus or growing in the internal auditory canal, six had neuromas of the seventh cranial nerve and three had arachnoiditis occluding the internal auditory canal.

Preservation of hearing in patients undergoing excision of acoustic neuromas and other cerebellopontine angle tumors

Microsurgical techniques have made it possible to identify and preserve the cochlear nerve from its origin at the brain stem and along its course through the internal auditory canal in patients undergoing removal of small or medium-sized acoustic neuromas or other cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumors. In a consecutive series of 100 patients with such tumors operated on between 1975 and 1981, an attempt was made to preserve the cochlear nerve in 23. The decision to attempt to preserve hearing was based on tumor size and the degree of associated hearing loss. In cases of unilateral acoustic neuroma, the criteria for attempted preservation of hearing were tumor size (2.5 cm or less), speech reception threshold (50 dB or less), and speech discrimination score (60% or greater). In patients with bilateral acoustic neuromas or tumors of other types, the size and hearing criteria were significantly broadened. All patients were operated on through a suboccipital approach. Hearing was preserved postoperatively in six (31.6%) of the 19 patients with unilateral acoustic neuromas, although the cochlear nerve was preserved in 16. Of the six patients with postoperative hearing, three retained excellent hearing, and the other three had only sound awareness and poor discrimination. Hearing was preserved in three cases with other CPA tumors, including an epidermoid cyst and small petrous meningiomas in the internal auditory canal. Of the two cases with bilateral tumors, hearing was preserved in one. Of the 23 patients in whom hearing preservation was attempted, nine (39.1%) had some postoperative hearing, which in six was equal to or better than the preoperative level. Thus, it is worthwhile to attempt hearing preservation in selected patients with CPA tumors.

Facial nerve function after suboccipital removal of acoustic neurinoma

The recovery of facial nerve function after suboccipital removal of 91 acoustic neurinomas is presented. The results after anatomical preservation of the nerve (60 cases), direct anastomosis of the nerve (7 cases), nerve grafting (16 cases), and facial hypoglossal anastomosis (8 cases) are presented after a follow-up period of 31.2 months. A simplified classification was used to describe motor function. The results are compared to those in the literature.