Laser-assisted nerve repair in primates

Transected sciatic nerve repair by diode laser protein soldering

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Despite advances in microsurgical techniques, repair of peripheral nerve injuries (PNI) is still a major challenge in regenerative medicine. The standard treatment for PNI includes suturing and anasthomosis of the transected nerve. The objective of this study was to compare neurorraphy (nerve repair) using standard suturingto diode laser protein soldering on the functional recovery of transected sciatic nerves.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty adult male Fischer-344 Wistar rats were randomly assigned to 3 groups: 1. The control group, no repair, 2. the standard of care suture group, and 3. The laser/protein solder group. For all three groups, the sciatic nerve was transected and the repair was done immediately. For the suture repair group, 10.0 prolene suture was used and for the laser/protein solder group a diode laser (500mW output power) in combination with bovine serum albumen and indocyanine green dye was used. Behavioral assessment by sciatic functional index was done on all rats biweekly. At 12weeks post-surgery, EMG recordings were done on all the rats and the rats were euthanized for histological evaluation of the sciatic nerves. The one-way ANOVA test was used for statistical analysis.

RESULTS

The average time required to perform the surgery was significantly shorter for the laser-assisted nerve repair group compared to the suture group. The EMG evaluation revealed no difference between the two groups. Based on the sciatic function index the laser group was significantly better than the suture group after 12weeks (p<0.05). Histopathologic evaluation indicated that the epineurium recovery was better in the laser group (p<0.05). There was no difference in the inflammation between the suture and laser groups.

CONCLUSION

Based on this evidence, laser/protein nerve soldering is a more efficient and efficacious method for repair of nerve injury compared to neurorraphy using standard suturing methods.

Sciatic nerve repair using adhesive bonding and a modified conduit

When repairing nerves with adhesives, most researchers place glue directly on the nerve stumps, but this method does not fix the nerve ends well and allows glue to easily invade the nerve ends. In this study, we established a rat model of completely transected sciatic nerve injury and repaired it using a modified 1 cm-length conduit with inner diameter of 1.5 mm. Each end of the cylindrical conduit contains a short linear channel, while the enclosed central tube protects the nerve ends well. Nerves were repaired with 2-octyl-cyanoacrylate and suture, which complement the function of the modified conduit. The results demonstrated that for the same conduit, the average operation time using the adhesive method was much shorter than with the suture method. No significant differences were found between the two groups in sciatic function index, motor evoked potential latency, motor evoked potential amplitude, muscular recovery rate, number of medullated nerve fibers, axon diameter, or medullary sheath thickness. Thus, the adhesive method for repairing nerves using a modified conduit is feasible and effective, and reduces the operation time while providing an equivalent repair effect.

Application of Novel CO2 Laser-Suction Device

Background Development of the flexible CO2 fiber has presented new opportunities for the use of precision laser cutting in cranial procedures. The efficacy of the CO2 scalpel is further enhanced by combining it with a fluid removal suction capability. Objectives We report our experience with a novel CO2 laser-suction device. Methods The novel laser-suction device was designed in conjunction with OmniGuide Inc. (Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA). We performed a case review of its use in firm tumors that were resistant to resection by bipolar, suction, and ultrasonic aspirator. Results The laser-suction device was applied in three tumors where resection with ultrasonic aspiration failed. Tumor resection using the laser-suction device was successful in all three cases. There were no complications related to the laser-suction device. There were no instances of intraoperative device malfunction. Discussion The CO2 laser combined with suction is a useful instrument for resection of firm tumors that prove to be resistant to ultrasonic aspiration. We also find it to be useful in settings where precise tissue incisions are desired with minimal manipulation. In our experience, the surgical efficiency of the CO2 laser is improved by the laser-suction device. This device allows the surgeon to utilize a suction device and laser in a single hand and enables concurrent use of bipolar electrocautery without repeated instrument changes.

Nerve glue for upper extremity reconstruction

Nerve glue is an attractive alternative to sutures to improve the results of nerve repair. Improved axon alignment, reduced scar and inflammation, greater and faster reinnervation, and better functional results have been reported with the use of nerve glue. The different types of nerve glue and the evidence to support or oppose their use are reviewed. Although the ideal nerve glue has yet to be developed, fibrin sealants can be used as nerve glue in select clinical situations. Technology to allow suture-free nerve repair is one development that can potentially improve functional nerve recovery and the outcomes of upper extremity reconstruction.

Carbon dioxide laser-assisted nerve repair: effect of solder and suture material on nerve regeneration in rat sciatic nerve

In order to further improve and explore the role of lasers for nerve reconstruction, this study was designed to investigate regeneration of sharply transected peripheral nerves repaired with a CO(2) milliwatt laser in combination with three different suture materials and a bovine albumin protein solder as an adjunct to the welding process. Unilateral sciatic nerve repair was performed in 44 rats. In the laser group, nerves were gently apposed, and two stay sutures (10-0 nylon, 10-0 polyglycolic acid, or 25 microm stainless steel) were placed epi/perineurially. Thereafter, the repair site was fused at 100 mW with pulses of 1.0 s. In the subgroup of laser-assisted nerve repair (LANR), albumen was used as a soldering agent to further reinforce the repair site. The control group consisted of nerves repaired by conventional microsurgical suture repair (CMSR), using 4-6 10-0 nylon sutures. Evaluation was performed at 1 and 6 weeks after surgery, and included qualitative and semiquantitative light microscopy. LANR performed with a protein solder results in a good early peripheral nerve regeneration, with an optimal alignment of nerve fibers and minimal connective tissue proliferation at the repair site. All three suture materials produced a foreign body reaction; the least severe was with polyglycolic acid sutures. CMSR resulted in more pronounced foreign-body granulomas at the repair site, with more connective-tissue proliferation and axonal misalignment. Furthermore, axonal regeneration in the distal nerve segment was better in the laser groups. Based on these results, CO(2) laser-assisted nerve repair with soldering in combination with absorbable sutures has the potential of allowing healing to occur with the least foreign-body reaction at the repair site. Further experiments using this combination are in progress.

Laser, fibrin glue, or suture repair of peripheral nerves: a comparative functional, histological, and morphometric study in the rat sciatic nerve

OBJECT

This study was undertaken to evaluate CO2 laser-assisted nerve repair and compare it with nerve repair performed with fibrin glue or absorbable sutures.

METHODS

In eight rats, the sciatic nerve was sharply transected and approximated using two 10-0 absorbable sutures and then fused by means of CO2 milliwatt laser welding (power 100 mW, exposure time 1 second per pulse, spot size 320 microm), with the addition of a protein solder (bovine albumin) to reinforce the repair site. The control groups consisted of eight rats in which the nerves were approximated with two 10-0 absorbable sutures and subsequently glued using a fibrin sealant (Tissucol), and eight rats in which the nerves were repaired using conventional microsurgical sutures (four to six 10-0 sutures in the perineurium or epineurium). Evaluation was performed 16 weeks postsurgery and included the toe-spreading test and light microscopy and morphometric assessment. The motor function of the nerves in all groups showed gradual improvement with time. At 16 weeks, the motor function was approximately 60% of the normal function, and there were no significant differences among the groups. On histological studies, all nerves revealed various degrees of axonal regeneration, with myelinated fibers in the distal nerve segments. There were slight differences in favor of the group treated with laser repair, in terms of wound healing at the repair site. In all groups, the number of axons distal to the repair site was higher compared with those proximal, but the axon diameter was significantly less than that in control nerves (p < 0.05). There were no significant differences in the number, density, or diameter of the axons in the proximal or distal nerve segments among the three nerve repair groups (p < 0.05), although there was a trend toward more and thicker myelinated axons in the distal segments of the laser-repaired nerves.

CONCLUSIONS

It was found that CO2 laser-assisted nerve repair with soldering is at least equal to fibrin glue and suture repair in effectiveness in a rodent model of sciatic nerve repair.

Morphometric and functional results after CO(2) laser welding of nerve coaptations

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Several reports describe nerve coaptations by laser welding in combination with stay sutures and bonding material. This study was undertaken to obtain functional and morphologic information by using a nerve coaptation technique by epineurial CO(2) laser welding only.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

The sciatic nerves of 24 rats were transected and epineurially coapted with the CO(2) laser at 60 mW or with microsutures as a control. Walking track analysis were carried out to evaluate the functional recovery, and the nerves were harvested for histology after 6 months of regeneration.

RESULTS

None of the 24 nerves showed dehiscence of the coaptations, and all showed good nerve fiber regeneration. Better results were obtained for the functional evaluation of the sciatic function index (P < 0.02) and the toe spread index (P < 0.04) from the laser nerve coaptations. Likewise, the morphologic evaluations of the fiber density (P < 0.04) and area fraction (P < 0.002) were better in the laser group.

CONCLUSION

CO(2) laser welded nerve coaptations are as successful as their sutured counterparts and may become a promising alternative in clinical practice.

Heat-induced tissue fusion for microvascular anastomosis

Laser tissue welding was compared with a crude method of bipolar coagulator-generated heat application for achieving the same heat-induced welding effect in rat microarterial anastomoses. Rat femoral arteries were anastomosed with three triangulated stay sutures and subsequent laser welding or bipolar coagulator application between each pair of stitches. Control (non-welded) vessels received nine stitches placed circumferentially. Laser-welded vessel patency at 1 or more days postoperatively was 90% (65/72) for vessels treated with 0.1-second laser pulses, not significantly different from controls (100%; 16/16) or coagulator-welded anastomoses (88%; 14/16). Pseudoaneurysm rates were higher in the welded vessels (9% and 14% for laser- and coagulator-treated vessels, respectively) than in controls (0%). Histologic and electron microscopic evaluation revealed good healing with no apparent differences between laser- and coagulator-welded repairs. These findings suggest that laser application for microvascular tissue welding is similar to poorly controlled welding with a bipolar coagulator.

Effects of endogenous absorption in human albumin solder for acute laser wound closure

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Human albumin is currently being used as a biological solder in laser tissue welding. Experiments were performed to characterize the effects of differing albumin concentrations on wound closure when a 1.32 microm Nd:YAG laser is used to repair skin incisions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In vivo comparison of acute tensile strength was made in full thickness porcine skin wounds using different solder concentrations. Histology of the repairs was also completed to evaluate the thermal denaturation of the tissue and solder. Transmission measurements were completed for nondenatured and denatured albumin solders. Finally, the real time denaturation pattern of different solder concentrations during laser irradiation was investigated.

RESULTS

A tissue solder consisting of 50% albumin provides the greatest tensile strength for acute in vivo skin closure. The transmission measurements verify that the primary absorber of 1.32-microm laser light was the solder solvent (water). A significant decrease in power transmission occurs when the 25% albumin solder was denatured. The real time denaturation profiles demonstrate that 1.32-microm laser light denatures 25% albumin solder from the outer surface, while in 50% albumin solder, denaturation occurs from within the solder bulk. Wound histology corroborates the pattern of denaturation seen in vitro.

CONCLUSION

The combination of 1.32-microm laser light and 50% human albumin solder can be used to create a deep tissue weld resulting in higher acute repair tensile strength. This permits a deep to superficial closure of wounds, which may result in an optimal method of acute closure for full-thickness wounds.

Laser nerve repair by solid protein band technique. II: assessment of long-term nerve regeneration

A total of 18 adult male Wistar rats had left tibial nerve repaired by either the laser-solder technique or a more conventional microsuture technique. The diode laser power was 90 mW and the radiation dose 16 J/mg. Three months postoperatively electrophysiology showed that the average compound muscle action potential (CMAP) of the laser repair group was not significantly different from the CMAP of the sutured nerves. Light microscopy confirmed regeneration of myelinated axons in both groups of animals. The laser-solder technique, when used with such parameters, proved to be a reliable method to achieve satisfactory peripheral nerve anastomosis and nerve regeneration.

Laser-activated solid protein bands for peripheral nerve repair: an vivo study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Severed tibial nerves in rats were repaired using a novel technique, utilizing a semiconductor diode-laser-activated protein solder applied longitudinally across the join. Welding was produced by selective laser denaturation of solid solder bands containing the dye indocyanine green.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

An in vivo study, using 48 adult male Wistar rats, compared conventional microsuture-repaired tibial nerves with laser solder-repaired nerves. Nerve repairs were characterised immediately after surgery and after 3 months.

RESULTS

Successful regeneration with average compound muscle action potentials of 2.5 +/- 0.5 mV and 2.7 +/- 0.3 mV (mean and standard deviation) was demonstrated for the laser-soldered nerves and the sutured nerves, respectively. Histopathology confirmed comparable regeneration of axons in laser- and suture-operated nerves.

CONCLUSION

The laser-based nerve repair technique was easier and faster than microsuture repair, minimising manipulation damage to the nerve.

Laser-assisted demucosalized gastrocystoplasty with autoaugmentation in a canine model

OBJECTIVES

Laser-assisted autoaugmentation gastrocystoplasty has been performed successfully. Experiments were performed to determine the optimal laser for tissue welding during demucosalized autoaugmentation gastrocystoplasty using both a 1.9-microm diode and a 1.32-microm neodymium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Nd:YAG) laser with and without thermal control.

METHODS

Autoaugmentation gastrocystoplasty was performed on 18 female mongrel dogs. Anastomoses were performed by either suture or laser welding with a 50% human albumin solution. A 1.9-microm diode laser was compared with a 1.32-microm Nd:YAG laser with and without thermal control. In vivo canine bladder capacity measurements were performed both before gastrocystoplasty and at euthanasia. The animals were studied on days 4 and 14. Samples of the anastomotic area from each group were taken to measure tensile strength. Histologic samples were assessed for tissue damage.

RESULTS

There was a significant increase in bladder volume in the 4-day group compared with pregastrocystoplasty values. Both the 1.9-microm diode laser and suture control dogs with the 14-day repairs had significantly more tensile strength than their 4-day counterparts. In contrast, no statistical difference was found between the 4 and 14-day 1.32-microm Nd:YAG groups. The suture control group had evidence of minor tissue devitalization at the anastomosis at both 4 and 14 days. The 1.9 and 1.32-microm laser groups both had evidence of tissue devitalization at 4 and 14 days. The 1.32-microm laser group had primarily severe tissue injury. The laser groups at 14 days demonstrated an inflammatory reaction that was localized to the albumin.

CONCLUSIONS

Demucosalized gastrocystoplasty with autoaugmentation can be safely and successfully performed with a 1.9-microm diode laser without significant differences in tensile strength when compared with suture controls. The 1.32-microm Nd:YAG laser can also be successfully used; however, the long-term results appear to be inferior to the 1.9-microm diode laser.

Effect of the CO2 milliwatt laser on neuroma formation in rats

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine whether the milliwatt laser can suppress neuroma formation at the end of a divided nerve.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

The peripheral nerves of eight rats were transected with microscissors and the cross-sectional area of their proximal ends was irradiated using the CO2 milliwatt laser. The power ranges used were similar to those applied to weld neural tissue.

RESULTS

None of the eight irradiated nerve ends formed a neuromatous bulb and only one of them regenerated into the surrounding tissues. Histologically, these nerve ends did not show the disorganized picture of classic neuromas. On morphometric measurements, they contained less connective tissue than the control nerve ends (P < 0.001) and their nerve fibers were larger in diameter (P < 0.001) and better myelinated (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

These findings in rats show that the CO2 milliwatt laser has the ability to suppress neuroma formation at the end of a divided nerve.

Laser(-assisted) nerve repair. A review

Over the last decade low power laser irradiation has been used to repair nerves by photothermal welding. Nineteen animal and clinical experimental studies of laser tissue welding of nerves are reviewed. Possible mechanisms of tissue welding are presented, together with the benefits, limitations, and possible future implications of several techniques used in laser nerve repair. The consensus of these studies is that nerve welding has some advantages over standard suture repair. These advantages include less neuroma- und scar formation and shorter repair time. The major disadvantage of laser nerve repair is the initial inferior tensile strength. In the future, use of dyes or proteins could enhance the welding process by reinforcing the union strength, thus may improve the results of this promising technique.

Laser tissue welding: a comprehensive review of current and future clinical applications

Laser techniques for joining tissue, in combination with other surgical technologies, will be a hallmark of surgery in the next century. At present, there are many clinical applications of tissue welding and soldering which are beginning to achieve wide spread acceptance. These exciting clinical developments are the result of many advances which have been made in the past few years in our understanding of the mechanism of laser tissue welding. Also contributing to this progress are many important technical refinements such as tissue solders and feedback control of the laser device. In this article, we describe in depth the history and development of laser tissue welding including key theoretical concepts as well as crucial experiments which have added to our insight into this phenomenon. We also review the evolving concepts of its clinical application and indicate clinical applications which are likely to become more important in the future.

CO2 laser repair of the facial nerve: an experimental study in the rat

The facial nerve is often injured by trauma, infection or during the course of tumour resection. Many techniques of nerve anastomosis have been described with the current standard nerve repair using the microscope and monofilament suture. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the CO2 surgical laser as a tool for facial nerve anastomosis. Following preliminary electrical measurements 36 nerves were anastomosed using either laser or conventional monofilament suture. Laser anastomosis had neither beneficial nor detrimental effects on nerve regeneration. This method of anastomosis may be advantageous when surgical access is limited. In addition this study found that the use of CO2 laser as a dissecting or vapourizing tool in proximity to intact facial nerves results in degenerative changes.

CO2 laser nerve welding: optimal laser parameters and the use of solders in vitro

To improve the welding strength, an in vitro study was performed to investigate the bonding strength of CO2 laser nerve welding (LNW), with and without the use of human albumin solution, dried albumin solution, egg white, fibrinogen solution, fibrin glue, and red blood cells as a solder. Fifteen different combinations of laser power (50, 100, and 150 mW) and pulse duration (0.1 to 3 s) were used with a spot size of 320 microns. The results have been compared to suture, fibrin glue, and laser-assisted nerve repair (LANR). The strongest welds (associated with whitening and caramelization of tissue) were produced at 100 mW with pulses of 1.0 s and at 50 mW with pulses of 3 s. The use of a dried albumin solution as a solder at 100 mW with pulses of 1 s increased the bonding strength 9-fold as compared to LNW (bonding strength 21.0 +/- 8.6 g and 2.4 +/- 0.9 g, respectively). However, positioning the nerves between cottons soaked in saline for 20 minutes resulted in a decrease of the bonding strength (9.8 +/- 4.5 g). The use of a 20% albumin solution and egg white, both at 50 mW with pulses of 3 s, resulted in a bonding strength of, respectively, 5.7 +/- 2.1 g and 7.7 +/- 2.4 g. Other solders did not increase the bonding strength in comparison to LNW. The substantial increase in bonding strength for some solders suggests that it is worthwhile to investigate the dehiscence rate and nerve regeneration of solder enhanced LNW in an in vivo study.

Lasers in neurosurgery

Lasers have been used in neurosurgery for the past 25 years, undergoing modifications to suit the specific needs of this medical discipline. The present report reviews the current use of lasers in neurosurgical practice and examines the pros and cons of lasers in specific neurosurgical applications. In spite of their advantages, laser use is still not widespread in neurosurgery. One reason is the continued lack of complete control over real-time laser interactions with neural tissue. A greater acceptance and use of lasers by neurosurgeons will depend upon automated control over defined specific parameters for laser applications based upon the type of tissue, the desired effect on tissue, and application to the clinical situation without loss of precision and a lot of expense. This will require the integration of newer lasers, computers, robotics, stereotaxy, and concepts of minimally invasive surgery into the routine management of neurosurgical problems.

Facial neurorrhaphy with autologous sural nerve graft using the CO2 laser in a primate model

Cranial nerves, being of fine caliber and having a poorly defined epineurium, pose problems in intracranial sutural anastomosis. The CO2 laser is a comparatively new prospect that is being evaluated for sutureless neural anastomosis. Because there are no reports on the laser anastomosis of a peripheral spinal nerve to a cranial nerve, we designed this study to explore the possibility of performing a laser anastomosis of the facial nerve, using an autologous sural nerve graft in a primate model. Six monkeys underwent resection of the right facial nerve in the parotid fossa. In five of them, the CO2 laser was used to anastomose sural nerve interposition grafts by the use of microsurgical techniques. In one control animal, the sural nerve graft was interposed between the cut ends of the facial nerve and no anastomosis was performed. Compound muscle action potentials were recorded preoperatively and 2, 4, and 6 weeks postoperatively. At the end of 6 weeks, the wound was again explored and the grafts were examined. The neurophysiological results showed that in the five laser-welded nerves, at 4 weeks and 6 weeks postoperatively, the proximal latencies showed an improving trend with each successive recording. It was concluded that the CO2 laser can be used for the anastomosis of interposition grafts to the facial nerve.

Preparation of human albumin solder for laser tissue welding

Previous studies have demonstrated that the addition of a protein solder to augment the laser tissue weld significantly improves postoperative results. Herein we describe a method for the preparation of human albumin for use as a laser tissue solder. We also review the brief history of laser tissue solders and discuss recent advances using this technology.

Is laser repair effective for secondary repair of a focal lesion in continuity?

It is possible to seal nerve ends together with the laser, and this can be effective for sharp injuries that are repaired relatively acutely or primarily. The possibility of utilizing the laser for secondary nerve repair after resection of a lesion in continuity was investigated in a rat sciatic nerve model. After baseline recording of nerve and muscle action potentials (MAP), a 3-mm-long crush injury of the sciatic nerve was performed bilaterally in 12 rats. Two weeks later, the crushed segment was resected, and the nerve on one side was repaired by end-to-end anastomosis using epineurial sutures and on the other side by sealing the nerve ends together with the CO2 laser. At reexploration 50 days postoperatively, all 12 suture repairs were anatomically in continuity and conducted a nerve action potential (NAP), while 10 of the 12 laser-repaired nerves had distracted. Laser repairs not distracted showed electrical and histologic evidence of regeneration. It is concluded that laser repair is not effective for delayed repair of lesions in continuity unless tension at the repair site can be lessened.

An investigation of the potential for laser nerve welding

Suture repair of a severed peripheral nerve is cumbersome, presents a focus for infection and neuroma formation, and does not always produce adequate stump alignment. An alternative form of repair is laser nerve welding, which is attractive because it does not introduce foreign material into the anastomotic site, it forms a circumferential seal, and it can be performed in difficult-to-reach areas. Laser repair has not been widely accepted both because the effect of laser irradiation on intact nerves is not well documented, and the anastomotic strength of the weld has been inferior to suture repair. In the first part of the present study, rat sciatic nerves were exposed and irradiated with increasing intensities from a Sharplan CO2 and KTP laser to document nerve damage as recorded by decreases in the peak compound action potential. A new technique of laser repair (S-Q weld) was then developed that involved harvesting subcutaneous tissue from the adjacent dermis, wrapping it around the two opposed nerve stumps, and lasering it to the epineurium to effect a weld. The strength of the S-Q weld (6.1 grams) was considerably greater than that produced by laser welding alone. The third phase of the study compared regeneration at 2 months in severed rat sciatic nerves repaired by either microsuture or S-Q weld. Analysis of the compound action potential values indicated that the number of regenerating fibers after laser repair was greater than that after suture repair, although a significant difference could not be demonstrated.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)