Subtraction CTA: An Alternative Imaging Option for the Follow-Up of Flow-Diverter-Treated Aneurysms?

Ultra-high resolution CT angiography for the assessment of intracranial stents and flow diverters using photon counting detector CT

BACKGROUND

The patency of intracranial stents may not be reliably assessed with either CT angiography or MR angiography due to imaging artifacts. We investigated the potential of ultra-high resolution CT angiography using a photon counting detector (PCD) CT to address this limitation by optimizing scanning and reconstruction parameters.

METHODS

A phantom with different flow diverters was used to optimize PCD-CT reconstruction parameters, followed by imaging of 14 patients with intracranial stents using PCD-CT. Images were reconstructed using three kernels based on the phantom results (Hv56, Hv64, and Hv72; Hv=head vascular) and one kernel to virtually match the resolution of standard CT angiography (Hv40). Signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) measurements were calculated. Subjective image quality and diagnostic confidence (DC) were assessed using a five point visual grading scale (5=best, 1=worst) and a three point grading scale (1=best, 3=worst), respectively, by two independent neuroradiologists.

RESULTS

Phantom images demonstrated the highest image quality across dose levels for 0.2 mm reconstructions with Hv56 (4.5), Hv64 (5), and Hv72 (5). In patient images, SNR and CNR decreased significantly with increasing kernel sharpness compared with control parameters. All reconstructions showed significantly higher image quality and DC compared with the control reconstruction with Hv40 kernel (P<0.001), with both image quality and DC being highest with Hv64 (0.2 mm) and Hv72 (0.2 mm) reconstructions.

CONCLUSION

Ultra-high resolution PDC-CT angiography provides excellent visualization of intracranial stents, with optimal reconstructions using the Hv64 and the Hv72 kernels at 0.2 mm.

REGISTRATION

BASEC 2021-00343.

Enhanced vessel wall magnetic resonance imaging in the follow-up of intracranial aneurysms treated with flow diversion

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to compare the efficacy of enhanced 3D T1-weighted black-blood fast-spin-echo vessel wall magnetic resonance imaging (eVW-MRI) and time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography (TOF MRA) for follow-up evaluation of aneurysms treated with flow diversion (FD).

METHODS

Our study enrolled 77 patients harboring 84 aneurysms treated with FD. Follow-up was by MRI (eVW-MRI and TOF MRA) and digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Two radiologists, blinded to DSA examination results, independently evaluated the images of aneurysm occlusion and parent artery patency using the Kamran-Byrne Scale. Interobserver diagnostic agreement and intermodality diagnostic agreement were acquired. Pretreatment and follow-up aneurysm wall enhancement (AWE) patterns were collected.

RESULTS

Based on the Kamran-Byrne Scale, the intermodality agreement between eVW-MRI and DSA was better than TOF MRA versus DSA for aneurysm remnant detection (weighted ĸ = 0.891 v. 0.553) and parent artery patency (ĸ = 0.950 v. 0.221). Even with the coil artifact, the consistency of eVW-MRI with DSA for aneurysm remnant detection was better than that of TOF MRA (weighted ĸ = 0.891 v. 0.511). The artifact of adjunctive coils might be more likely to affect the accuracy in evaluating parent artery patency with TOF MRA than with eVW-MRI (ĸ = 0.077 v. 0.788). The follow-up AWE patterns were not significantly associated with pretreatment AWE patterns and aneurysm occlusion.

CONCLUSIONS

The eVW-MRI outperforms TOF MRA as a reliable noninvasive and nonionizing radioactive imaging method for evaluating aneurysm remnants and parent artery patency after FD. The significance of enhancement patterns on eVW-MRI sequences needs more exploration.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT

The application of enhanced vessel wall magnetic resonance imaging has proven to be a promising tool to depict aneurysm remnant and parent artery stenosis in order to tailor the antiplatelet therapy strategy in patients after flow diversion.

KEY POINTS

• Enhanced vessel wall magnetic resonance imaging has an emerging role in depicting aneurysm remnant and parent artery patency after flow diversion. • With or without the artifact from adjunctive coils, enhanced vessel wall magnetic resonance imaging was better than TOF MRA in detecting aneurysm residual and parent artery stenosis by using DSA imaging as the standard. • Enhanced vessel wall magnetic resonance imaging holds potential to be used as an alternative to DSA for routine aneurysm follow-up after flow diversion.

Utility of follow-up ultra-high-resolution CT angiography with model-based iterative reconstruction after flow diverter treatment for cerebral aneurysms

PURPOSE

Follow-up examinations after flow diverter (FD) treatment for cerebral aneurysms typically involve magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) or digital subtraction angiography (DSA). However, MRI is prone to vascular defects due to metal artifacts from FD, and DSA carries a risk of ischemic complications. In the context of computed tomography angiography (CTA), this study compares the efficacy of ultra-high-resolution CT (UHRCT) and novel reconstruction techniques, such as model-based iterative reconstruction (MBIR), against conventional methods such as filtered back projection (FBP) and hybrid iterative reconstruction (IR), to determine if they are a viable alternative to DSA in clinical settings.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A phantom study was conducted with the full-width half-maximum considered as the FD thickness. This study compared three reconstruction methods: MBIR, FBP, and hybrid IR. A clinical study was also conducted with 21 patients who underwent follow-up CTA after FD treatment. The FD's visibility was assessed using a 4-point scale in FBP, hybrid IR, and MBIR compared to cone-beam CT (CBCT) with angiographic systems.

RESULTS

In the phantom study, FBP, hybrid IR, and MBIR visualized thinner FD thicknesses and improved detail rendering in that order. MBIR proved to be significantly superior in both the phantom and clinical study.

CONCLUSION

UHRCT with MBIR is highly effective for follow-up evaluations after FD treatment and may become the first-choice modality in the future.

Evaluation of Intra-Aneurysmal Residual Blood Flow with the iMSDE T1-Black Blood Imaging after Flow Diverter Treatment

Objective

We aimed to evaluate the efficacy of the "improved motion-sensitized driven-equilibrium (iMSDE)"-prepared T1-weighted black blood (T1-BB) MRI for monitoring treatment effect with a flow diverter (FD) for cerebral aneurysms.

Methods

Following the exclusion of concomitant coiling and retreatment cases from 60 consecutive cases of cerebral aneurysms treated with FDs at our institution, 32 with imaging data were included in the analysis. Detectability of residual blood flow within the aneurysms was validated as follows: 1) comparison of MRI sequences (iMSDE-prepared T1-BB images, T1-weighted images [ T1WI], and time-of-flight [ TOF]-MRA) in cases of incompletely occluded aneurysms and 2) comparison of angiography and MRI sequences in the same period.

Results

1) The probability of diagnosing intra-aneurysmal blood flow was significantly higher with iMSDE-prepared T1-BB (iMSDE-prepared T1-BB vs. T1WI, p <0.001; iMSDE-prepared T1-BB vs. TOF-MRA, p <0.001). 2) The diagnostic accuracy of residual aneurysmal blood flow was significantly higher with iMSDE-prepared T1-BB than that with T1WI (p = 0.032). Furthermore, in cases of incomplete occlusion, the probability of detecting intra-aneurysmal blood flow was significantly higher with iMSDE-prepared T1-BB (iMSDE-prepared T1-BB vs. T1WI, p <0.001; iMSDE-prepared T1-BB vs. TOF-MRA, p = 0.023).

Conclusion

Our results demonstrated that iMSDE-prepared T1-BB could help distinguish between blood flow and thrombus within the aneurysms after FD treatment, especially in the early stages of FD treatment.

Magnetic particle imaging for artifact-free imaging of intracranial flow diverter stents: A phantom study

PURPOSE

Magnetic Particle Imaging (MPI) is a new, background- and radiation-free tomographic imaging method that enables near real-time imaging of superparamagnetic iron-oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) with high temporal and spatial resolution. This phantom study aims to investigate the potential of MPI for visualization of the stent lumen in intracranial flow diverters (FD).

METHODS

Nitinol FD of different dimensions (outer diameter: 3.5 mm, 4.0 mm, 5.5 mm; total length: 22-40 mm) were scanned in vascular phantoms in a custom-built MPI scanner (in-plane resolution: ~ 2 mm, field of view: 65 mm length, 29 mm diameter). Phantoms were filled with diluted (1:50) SPION tracer agent Ferucarbotran (10 µmol (Fe)/ml; NaCL). Each phantom was measured in 32 different projections (overall acquisition time per image: 3200 ms, 5averages). After image reconstruction from raw data, two radiologists assessed image quality using a 5-point Likert scale. The signal intensity profile was measured using a semi-automatic evaluation tool.

RESULTS

MPI visualized the lumen of all FD without relevant differences between the stented vessel phantom and the reference phantom. At 3.5 mm image quality was slightly inferior to the larger diameters. The FD themselves neither generated an MPI signal nor did they lead to relevant imaging artifacts. Ratings of both radiologists showed no significant difference, interrater reliability was good (ICC 0.84). A quantitative evaluation of the signal intensity profile did not reveal any significant differences (p > 0.05) either.

CONCLUSION

MPI visualizes the lumen of nitinol FD stents in vessel phantoms without relevant stent-induced artifacts.

Imaging for Treated Aneurysms (Including Clipping, Coiling, Stents, Flow Diverters)

Intracranial aneurysms are common in the adult population and carry a risk of rupture leading to catastrophic subarachnoid hemorrhage. Treatment of aneurysms has evolved significantly, with the introduction of new techniques and devices for minimally invasive and endovascular approaches. Follow-up imaging after aneurysm treatment is standard of care to monitor for recurrence or other complications, and the preferred imaging modality and schedule for follow-up are areas of active research. The modality and follow-up schedule should be tailored to treatment technique, aneurysm characteristics, and patient factors.

Postinterventional Assessment after Stent and Flow-Diverter Implantation Using CT: Influence of Spectral Image Reconstructions and Different Device Types

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

CTA provides a noninvasive alternative technique to DSA in the follow-up after endovascular aneurysm treatment to evaluate aneurysm occlusion and exclude intraluminal narrowing after stent or flow-diverter implantation; however, assessability may be impeded by stent material artifacts. The objective of this in vitro study was to compare the visual assessability of different conventional stents and flow diverters as well as different reconstructions of dual-layer CT images.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Four conventional intracranial stents and 4 flow diverters were implanted in identical aneurysm phantoms. Conventional and monoenergetic images (40, 50, 60, 90, 120, 180 keV) were acquired to evaluate attenuation alteration, visible lumen diameter, and SNR. Image quality was rated subjectively by 2 independent radiologists using a 4-point Likert scale.

RESULTS

Low kiloelectron volt (40-60 keV) monoenergetic reconstructions showed an improved SNR and an improved lumen density ratio compared with high kiloelectron volt reconstructions (90-180 keV) and conventional reconstructions, however without reaching significance compared with the latter. Assessment of the adjacent aneurysm and subjective evaluation was not affected by the imaging technique and stent type. Artifact susceptibility varied with the device used and increased among flow diverters.

CONCLUSIONS

Low kiloelectron volt reconstructions improved the assessment of the stent lumen in comparison with high kiloelectron volt reconstructions. No significant improvement in image quality could be shown compared with conventional images. For some devices, iodine-specific reconstructions led to severe artifacts and are therefore not recommended. There was no relevant improvement in the assessability of the adjacent aneurysm.

Ultra-high-resolution subtraction CT angiography in the follow-up of treated intracranial aneurysms

In subtraction CT angiography (CTA), a non-contrast CT acquisition is subtracted from a contrast-enhanced CTA acquisition. Subtraction CTA can be applied in the detection, classification, and follow-up of intracranial aneurysms and is advantageous over conventional angiography because of its non-invasive nature, shorter examination time, and lower costs. Recently, an ultra-high-resolution CT scanner has been introduced in clinical practice offering an in-plane spatial resolution of up to 0.234 mm, approaching the resolution as seen during conventional invasive digital subtraction angiography (DSA). The twofold increase in spatial resolution as compared to a conventional CT scanner could improve the evaluation of small vascular structures and, coupled with dedicated post-processing techniques, further reduce metal artifacts. Technical considerations using a state-of-the-art high-resolution subtraction CTA protocol are discussed for application in the follow-up of surgical and endovascular treated intracranial aneurysms.