Magnetic resonance imaging and morphometric quantitation of cartilage histology after chronic infusion of interleukin 1 in rabbit knees

Cartilage, bone and synovial histomorphometry in animal models of osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

This review focuses on histomorphometry for assessing the pathological changes in various compartments of the joint including cartilage, bone and synovium in animal models of osteoarthritis (OA).

METHODS

Different methodological approaches are presented concerning sampling, embedding, sectioning, staining, mounting of stained sections and measurement of histomorphometric parameters using automated and semi-automated methods. Notes are provided describing some methods in greater detail.

RESULTS

Histomorphometry allows a significant gain of objectivity, accuracy and reproducibility in the quantification of the main histological parameters which best characterize OA in the affected joint (cartilage thickness (CT), chondrocyte size and density, cartilage fissure, proteoglycan (PG) content, subchondral bone plate thickness (SBPT), thickness of synovial living cell layer) in animal models.

CONCLUSION

Use of histomorphometry could contribute to a better quantification of histological differences between control and OA animals. Contributing also to the introduction of normative data, it is a major advantage for therapeutic assessments in experimental OA and particularly for the analytical comparison of the efficacy of disease modifying OA drugs (DMOAD).

Reliability of diffraction enhanced imaging for assessment of cartilage lesions, ex vivo

OBJECTIVE

The assessment of articular cartilage integrity is of value for the detection of early degenerative joint disease in both the clinical and the research settings. It was the purpose of this study to determine the accuracy and reliability of identifying articular cartilage defects through Diffraction Enhanced Imaging (DEI), a high contrast radiographic imaging technique. DEI provides two new sources of image contrast to radiography: refraction and scatter rejection, besides the absorption of conventional radiography.

DESIGN

Cadaveric tali were DEI imaged in the anterior-posterior position at the National Synchrotron Light Source. Two independent observers provided gross score evaluations (on a five point scale) of the trochlear surfaces. The DEI image of each trochlear surface was then graded (on a five point scale) by two additional independent observers who were blinded with regard to the gross evaluation of the articular surfaces. Inter-observer agreement for DEI grades was assessed with the weighted kappa statistic. Correlation of diffraction enhanced image score to the gross score was assessed with Spearman correlation coefficient.

RESULTS

The defects of articular cartilage of talar trochleae could be visualized through DEI. The Spearman correlation of gross grades with DEI grades on the 165 talar regions for observers 1 and 2 were 0.91 and 0.91, respectively. The overall weighted kappa value for inter-observer agreement was 0.93, thus considered high agreement.

CONCLUSIONS

DEI is accurate and reliable for detection of articular cartilage defects ex vivo. Even early stages of degeneration of cartilage can be visualized with this high contrast technique. Future studies will focus on the application of DEI to the identification of such lesions in vivo.

Magnetic resonance imaging evaluation of the effects of juvenile rheumatoid arthritis on distal femoral weight-bearing cartilage

OBJECTIVE

To examine magnetic resonance imaging-derived T2 relaxation times in the weight-bearing cartilage of the distal femur in healthy children and in children with juvenile rheumatoid arthritis (JRA).

METHODS

T2 relaxation time maps were created for 39 girls (ages 4.9-10.9 years), 21 of whom were considered healthy and 18 of whom had JRA. The spatial distribution of T2 relaxation times for the distal femoral weight-bearing cartilage (including epiphyseal and articular cartilage) was mapped for each group as a whole. Average data sets for each group were then compared using paired t-tests to detect differences between the 2 populations.

RESULTS

The spatial distribution of T2 relaxation time values was nearly identical in the 2 groups, with a concave curve that was highest near the subchondral bone and articular surfaces. The average T2 relaxation times were significantly higher in the girls with JRA than in the group of healthy girls (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The finding of an increased average T2 relaxation time in the children with JRA suggests that T2 relaxation time maps may reflect cartilage microstructure differences that occur in JRA. T2 relaxation time mapping may allow for early detection of cartilage changes and provide an objective, quantitative method of monitoring disease progression, with the long-term potential to guide therapy.

In vivo contrast-enhanced micro MR-imaging of experimental osteoarthritis in the rabbit knee joint at 7.1T1

OBJECTIVE

In this longitudinal MR study the early stages of joint pathology in two surgically-induced rabbit models of osteoarthritis (OA) were monitored by in vivo contrast-enhanced MRI at 7.1T. Qualitative and quantitative MR data were compared with macroscopic and microscopic findings.

METHOD

Scanning of mature, male New Zealand White rabbits (N=12) was performed before surgery, and at 2, 4, and 8 weeks after unilateral transection of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACLT), medial meniscectomy (ME), or sham operation. MR-images were simultaneously obtained of both knee joints after intravenous injection of Magnevist. We implemented a 2D T1-weighted (T1w) coronal, fat-saturated gradientecho protocol (68 x 138 microm2, slice thickness 1 mm). Additionally, consecutive 3D gradientecho images were obtained from two sham-operated and two rabbits of the ME group (234 x 273 x 234 microm(3)). ACLT animals were sacrificed at 2 weeks (N=1), and 8 weeks (N=3), ME animals were sacrificed at 4 weeks (N=2), and 8 weeks (N=4), and sham-operated animals were sacrificed at 2 weeks (N=1) and 8 weeks (N=1), respectively.

RESULTS

Both OA models reflected important characteristics of the clinical picture of OA. With MR we were able to monitor time dependently the decline of synovial effusion and the formation of osteophytes. Morphologic MR examination showed a moderate to high accuracy for detecting synovial effusion (75%), meniscus (86%) and cruciate ligament (91%) lesions, and osteophytes (88%) as assessed by macroscopic examination. False-negative MR findings for gross macroscopic changes were due to the relative high slice thickness in 2D scans and the fact that the slices only covered the main weightbearing area of the femorotibial joint. Contour abnormalities of articular cartilage were not reliably detected. Quantitative analysis revealed a statistically significant increase of cartilage signal intensity in medial tibial cartilage (48+/-9% ACLT, and 29+/-9% ME in 2D datasets) as compared to contralateral control knees in two-week scans. Signal enhancement persisted or increased at later dates.

CONCLUSION

With high-resolution contrast-enhanced MRI at 7.1T the time course of gross pathologic changes in rabbit knees with surgically induced OA can be monitored. Still insufficient spatial resolution and image contrast of the applied 2D protocols limit the sensitivity and prohibit detection of articular cartilage contour abnormalities. However, signal alterations in the cartilage layer indicate alterations of tissue composition at a very early stage of OA development. When used with 3D protocols, contrast-enhanced MRI offers a promising tool for qualitative and quantitative in vivo monitoring of OA in rabbit models.

Automated techniques for visualization and mapping of articular cartilage in MR images of the osteoarthritic knee: a base technique for the assessment of microdamage and submicro damage

The purpose of this paper is to describe automated techniques for the visualization and mapping of articular cartilage in magnetic resonance (MR) images of the osteoarthritic knee. The MR sequences and analysis software which will be described allow the assessment of cartilage damage using a range of standard scanners. With high field strength systems it would be possible, using these techniques, to assess micro-damage. The specific aim of the paper is to develop and validate software for automated segmentation and thickness mapping of articular cartilage from three-dimensional (3-D) gradient-echo MR images of the knee. The method can also be used for MR-based assessment of tissue engineered grafts. Typical values of cartilage thickness over seven defined regions can be obtained in patients with osteoarthritis (OA) and control subjects without OA. Three groups of patients were studied. The first group comprised patients with moderate OA in the age range 45-73 years. The second group comprised asymptomatic volunteers of 50-65 years; the third group, younger volunteers selected by clinical interview, history and X-ray. In this paper, sagittal 3-D spoiled-gradient steady-state acquisition images were obtained using a 1.5-T GE whole-body scanner with a specialist knee coil. For validation bovine and porcine cadaveric knees were given artificial cartilage lesions and then imaged. The animal validations showed close agreement between direct lesion measurements and those obtained from the MR images. The feasibility of semi-automated segmentation is demonstrated. Regional cartilage thickness values are seen as having practical application for fully automated detection of OA lesions even down to the submicrometer level.

23Na MRI accurately measures fixed charge density in articular cartilage

One of the initiating steps of osteoarthritis is the loss of proteoglycan (PG) molecules from the cartilage matrix. One method for assessing cartilage integrity, therefore, is to measure the PG content or fixed charge density (FCD) of cartilage. This report shows the feasibility of calculating FCD by (23)Na MRI and introduces MRI protocols for human studies, in vivo. (23)Na MRI was used to measure the sodium concentration inside bovine patellar cartilage. The sodium concentration was then converted to FCD (mM) by considering ideal Donnan equilibrium. These FCD measurements were compared to FCD measurements obtained through standard dimethylmethylene blue PG assays. There was a high correlation (slope = 0.89, r(2) = 0.81) between the FCD measurements obtained by (23)Na MRI and those obtained by the PG assays. These methods were then employed in quantifying the FCD of articular cartilage of human volunteers in vivo. Two imaging protocols were compared: one using a birdcage coil, the other using a transmit/receive surface coil. Both methodologies gave similar results, with the average sodium concentration of normal human patellar cartilage ranging from approximately 240 to 260 mM. This corresponds to FCDs of -158 mM to -182 mM.

MRI techniques in early stages of cartilage disease

Cartilage degenerative diseases affect millions of people. Our understanding of these diseases and our ability to establish efficacious treatment strategies have been confounded by the difficulty of nondestructively evaluating the state of cartilage. Imaging strategies that allow visualization of cartilage integrity would revolutionize the field by allowing us to visualize early stages of degeneration and thus to evaluate predisposing factors for cartilage disease and changes resulting from interventions (eg, therapies) in culture studies, tissue-engineered systems, animal models, and in vivo in humans. Here we briefly review current state-of-the-art MRI strategies relevant to understanding and following treatment in early cartilage degeneration. We review MRI as applied to the assessment of the whole joint, of cartilage as a whole (as an organ), of cartilage tissue, and of cartilage molecular composition and structure. Each of these levels is amenable to assessment by MRI and offers different information that, in the long run, will serve as an important element of cartilage imaging.

In vivo magnetic resonance methods in pharmaceutical research: current status and perspectives

In the last decade, in vivo MR methods have become established tools in the drug discovery and development process. In this review, several successful and potential applications of MRI and MRS in stroke, rheumatoid and osteo-arthritis, oncology and cardiovascular disorders are dealt with in detail. The versatility of the MR approach, allowing the study of various pathophysiological aspects in these disorders, is emphasized. New indication areas, for the characterization of which MR methods have hardly been used up to now, such as respiratory, gastro-intestinal and skin diseases, are outlined in a subsequent section. A strength of MRI, being a non-invasive imaging modality, is the ability to provide functional, i.e. physiological, readouts. Functional MRI examples discussed are the analysis of heart wall motion, perfusion MRI, tracer uptake and clearance studies, and neuronal activation studies. Functional information may also be derived from experiments using target-specific contrast agents, which will become important tools in future MRI applications. Finally the role of MRI and MRS for characterization of transgenic and knock-out animals, which have become a key technology in modern pharmaceutical research, is discussed. The advantages of MRI and MRS are versatility, allowing a comprehensive characterization of a diseased state and of the drug intervention, and non-invasiveness, which is of relevance from a statistical, economical and animal welfare point of view. Successful applications in drug discovery exploit one or several of these aspects. In addition, the link between preclinical and clinical studies makes in vivo MR methods highly attractive methods for pharmaceutical research.

Measurement of localized cartilage volume and thickness of human knee joints by computer analysis of three-dimensional magnetic resonance images

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

This work demonstrates a new method for computerized measurement of the dimensions (thickness and volume) of articular cartilage for any specified region of the human knee joint. Three-dimensional magnetic resonance (MR) images optimized for cartilage contrast have been analyzed using computerized edge-detection techniques, and the reproducibility of articular cartilage thickness and volume measurements is assessed.

METHODS

A fat-suppressed, three-dimensional SPoiled GRass MR sequence (45/7.5/30 degrees) with total scan time of approximately 12 minutes was used to acquire volume images of human knee joints at spatial resolution of 0.6 x 1.2 x 1.2 mm. Measurements were made using six repeated scans for three healthy volunteers over a period of 2 months. The subsequent semi-automated image processing to establish total cartilage volume and cartilage thickness maps for the femur required approximately 60 minutes of operator time.

RESULTS

The mean coefficient of variation for total cartilage volume for the six repeated scans for the three volunteers was 3.8%, and the average coefficient of variation for the user-selected cartilage plugs was 2.0%. The cartilage thickness maps from the repeated scans of the same knee were similar.

CONCLUSIONS

Standard resolution MR images with fat-suppressed contrast lead to an objective and reproducible measurement of spatial dimensions of articular cartilage when analyzed semi-automatically using computerized edge-detection methods.

MRI contrast enhanced study of cartilage proteoglycan degradation in the rabbit knee

Early degeneration of cartilage is accompanied by a loss of proteoglycans and consequent changes in the content of water. Conventional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) cannot reliably detect this change, since the relaxation properties of the cartilage are dominated by its collagen content. The applicability of a positively charged nitroxide as an MRI contrast agent in detection of the content of the negatively charged proteoglycans within the cartilage was investigated. The results from both MRI and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy indicate that the accumulation of the contrast agent reflects the amount of proteoglycans within the cartilage, presumably due to the electrostatic interactions between the negatively charged proteoglycans and the positively charged nitroxide. Such a contrast agent could be useful in the detection and study of early stages of the degeneration of joints.

Comparison of low-field (0.2 Tesla) and high-field (1.5 Tesla) magnetic resonance imaging of the knee joint

In order to evaluate the reliability of low-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), we examined 22 patients using a 0.2-Tesla magnet unit in comparison with a 1.5-Tesla system. The MRI findings were compared with the intraoperative findings. Concerning the diagnosis of meniscal tears, the gradings of both systems differed only in three cases. The specificity was 97% (both systems), the sensitivity 83% (1.5 T) versus 75% (0.2 T). The sensitivity and specificity for detection of tears of the anterior cruciate ligament were 100% and 75%, respectively, for both systems. The gradings differed only in two cases. In our series we found 6 full-thickness cartilage defects that were all detected with the high-field imaging system. They were missed by the low-field imaging system in 5 cases. The results suggest that both systems are reliable in diagnosing meniscal tears and ruptures of the anterior cruciate ligament.