Video-head impulse test results in patients with Menière's disease related to duration and stage of disease

Video Head Impulse Test Coherence Predicts Vertigo Recovery in Sudden Sensorineural Hearing Loss With Vertigo

OBJECTIVES

Labyrinthitis significantly reduces quality of life due to prolonged vestibular symptoms in patients experiencing sudden sensorineural hearing loss with vertigo (SSNHLV). This study employed a novel coherence analysis in the video head impulse test (vHIT) to explore vertigo outcomes in SSNHLV patients.

METHODS

A retrospective review was conducted on 48 SSNHLV patients who completed high-dose steroid treatment between December 2016 and April 2023. Additionally, 38 healthy volunteers were prospectively enrolled from November 2022 to April 2023 at our academic tertiary referral center. The magnitude-squared wavelet coherence between eye and head velocities during the vHIT was measured to assess correlations across frequency bands. Recovery from vertigo, determined by a visual analog scale (VAS) score of 0 at both 2 weeks and 2 months, was analyzed using multivariable Cox regression.

RESULTS

The mean VAS for patients with SSNHLV was 5.73±2.45. Higher coherent frequencies in the horizontal semicircular canal (SCC), posterior SCC, and the mean and minimal coherent frequencies of all three SCCs combined were significantly associated with early complete remission of vertigo 2 weeks posttreatment. In the multivariate analysis, the minimal coherent frequency among the three SCCs emerged as an independent factor (hazard ratio, 2.040; 95% CI, 1.776-2.304). Two months posttreatment, in addition to the previously significant parameters, abnormalities in the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) in the posterior SCC, gains in the horizontal and posterior SCCs, total and overt saccades in the horizontal SCC, coherent frequency in the anterior SCC, and mean VOR gain of all three SCCs combined were also statistically significantly related to total relief from vertigo.

CONCLUSION

The highest minimal coherent frequency among the three SCCs significantly contributed to earlier vertigo relief in patients with SSNHLV. Coherence analysis in vHIT may offer greater sensitivity than time series analysis for predicting the prognosis of vertigo.

The dissociation between pathological caloric testing and a normal video head impulse test helps differentiate between Menière's disease, vestibular migraine, and other vestibular disorders: a confirmatory study in a large cohort of 2,101 patients

Vestibular migraine (VM) and Menière's disease (MD) are characterized by episodes of vertigo of similar duration. It is well known that differentiation between both diseases is not always possible based only on the patient history, physical examination, and audiological testing. In addition, the quantification of the vestibular function can also be helpful since, among patients with MD, there is often a dissociation between a normal/pseudo-normal video head impulse test (vHIT) and reduced caloric testing. The goal of this confirmatory study was to determine the sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values (PPV and NPV) of this dissociation to differentiate between MD and VM as well as between MD and other vestibular diseases. We performed a retrospective analysis of 2,101 patients. The examination group consisted of 1,100 patients; of these, 627 (57%) had MD according to the diagnostic criteria of the Bárány Society and 473 (43%) had VM. The comparison group consisted of 1,001 patients with other peripheral, central, or functional vestibular disorders. Statistical analysis revealed the following findings for the dissociation: MD vs. VM: specificity: 83.5%, sensitivity: 58.9%, PPV: 82.6%, and NPV: 60.5%, and MD vs. all other vestibular disorders (VM plus others): specificity: 83.5%, sensitivity: 58.9%, PPV: 60.3%, and NPV: 82.7%. The dissociation between a normal vHIT and a reduced caloric response is due to the high specificity and PPV suited for the differentiation between MD and VM. This part of the study confirms previous findings in a large cohort of patients. When it comes to differentiating between MD and all observed vestibular disorders, if there is no dissociation, the diagnosis of MD is unlikely.

Evolution of Vestibular Findings During and Between the Attacks of Meniere Disease: Update

Purpose of Review

The diagnosis of Meniere disease (MD) has based on characteristics of vertigo and findings of audiologic evaluation. This review focuses on the recent findings of the evolution of vestibular function and their underlying physiology during and between the attacks of MD and thus aims to help identify this common disorder with many faces according to the phase.

Recent Findings

During the attacks, the direction of spontaneous nystagmus changes over time, beating initially toward the affected ear (irritative nystagmus), then toward the healthy ear (paretic nystagmus), and finally back toward the affected ear again (recovery nystagmus). Apart from these direction changes, atypical forms of spontaneous nystagmus, such as downbeat, discordant horizontal-torsional, and aperiodic alternating nystagmus, can be observed. Head impulse tests (HITs) are mostly normal during the irritative/recovery phases, but positive in more than half of patients during the paretic phase. By contrast, caloric tests are usually abnormal irrespective of the phases, although paradoxical caloric hyper-responsiveness can be observed in 18% of patients during the irritative/recovery phases. Thus, dissociation in the findings of caloric tests-HITs can be observed during and between the attacks. Horizontal head shaking tends to augment spontaneous nystagmus during each phase, while skull vibration mostly induces nystagmus beating toward the healthy ear irrespective of the phases. During the attacks, ocular vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs) may be enhanced, whereas cervical VEMPs are usually decreased during stimulation of the involved ear.

Summary

Recognizing these evolutions of vestibular findings during and between the attacks of MD would provide insights into its pathophysiology and aid in treatments and diagnosis.

Dissociation between video head impulse test and caloric test: a marker of menière's disease? - A systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To analyze, by means of a systematic review and meta-analysis, the proportion of patients with Meniere's disease who have altered caloric test and vHIT, as well as to determine the prevalence of altered caloric test and normal vHIT dissociation in the diagnosis of Meniere's disease.

METHODS

The literature search had no restriction regarding the period of publication on the following indexed data platforms: PubMed, PubMed PMC, BVS-Bireme, Web of Science, Embase and Cochrane Library. Articles that evaluated patients with Meniere's disease who underwent caloric test and vHIT were included. Two researchers independently conducted the analysis of the articles, promoting the selection and capture of data, following the recommendations of the PRISMA method, and complying with the criteria for articles inclusion and exclusion defined in the research protocol. In case of disagreement during the selection process, a third researcher was included for analysis.

RESULTS

From a total of 427 initial studies, the researchers selected 12 articles, published between 2014 and 2021, with a total of 708 patients evaluated, with a mean age of 52.72 years old. The prevalence of patients with Meniere's disease with altered caloric reflex test was 64% (95% CI 57%‒71%), while the prevalence of altered vHIT was only 28% (95% CI 16%-40%). The prevalence of the altered caloric test + normal vHIT dissociation was 47% (95% CI 37%-57%).

CONCLUSION

The video head impulse test and the caloric test are valuable tools for vestibular assessment. The dissociation of findings between these two tests in patients with Meniere's disease was more prevalent in this meta-analysis and may be a result of the tonotopy of specialized hair cells in the ampullary crest. The prevalence of altered caloric test was 64% and anormal vHIT was 28%. The dissociation caloric asymmetry and normal vHIT was observed in 47% of the patients.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 1

Comparison between caloric and video-head impulse tests in Ménière's disease and vestibular neuritis

OBJECTIVE

To compare the diagnostic accuracies of air caloric testing with electronystagmography and the vHIT (video-head impulse test).

DESIGN

Prospective, controlled study.

STUDY SAMPLE

MD (Ménière's disease), 26; vestibular neuritis, 27; control, 56.

RESULTS

In MD, CP (canal paresis) was pathological in 88.5%, the GA (gain asymmetry) on vHIT was pathological in 65.3%, and the gain was abnormal in only one patient. The GA and CP, were significantly higher in the MD group than in the control group, indicating hypofunction of the horizontal canals in MD, whereas a hyperfunction may also occur. No correlation was observed between the results of the two tests for evaluating MD, suggesting that pathological outcomes of one test do not guarantee abnormalities on the other test. For vestibular neuritis, significantly higher CP (96.3%), GA (81.5%), and gain (51.9%) values were detected. A correlation was identified between the two tests for vestibular neuritis, indicating a similar diagnostic efficiency. The higher percentage of pathological GA versus pathological gain values indicates that the asymmetry may be more informative.

CONCLUSIONS

The vHIT showed a higher specificity, whereas the caloric test a higher sensitivity. No correlation between the two methods was observed; therefore, the tests appear to provide complementary information.

Exploratory saccades data analysis of video head impulse test in Different Meniere's Disease Stages

BACKGROUND

Unapparent saccades in video head impulse test (vHIT) are usually present in MD patients but tend to be ignored by the clinician. The result of vHIT is constantly questioned in MD patients due to a lack of uniform metrics. A more effective indicator is needed for indicating MD's pathological progress.

OBJECTIVES

To get a comprehensive understanding of the nature and usability of saccades in different MD stages.

METHODS

118 patients diagnosed with unilateral MD were recruited in this study. Patient history, audiological examination, caloric test, vHIT were performed. We proposed 'raw saccades' to represent all showed wave peaks behind the head peak and named saccades by their appearance sequence: 1st saccade, 2nd saccade and 3rd saccade. An exploratory saccade analysis was executed to investigate the effectiveness of saccade attributes in identifying MD stages.

RESULTS

MD patients have greater detectable 1st saccade than PR score as well as 2nd saccade. The time and velocity of the 1st saccade show high interaural variability (p = 0.028, p = 0.000 respectively). No statistical difference concerning the vHIT gain, PR score and 2nd saccade among stages could be recognized on both affected and contralateral sides. Multiple comparisons show the affected 1st saccade velocity and affected 1st saccade absolute velocity have stage-difference. At late stages (3&4), the affected 1st saccade is manifested as a speed increase, and this measure shows a relatively high correlation with MD stages compared to other vestibular indicators.

CONCLUSION

The 1st saccade velocity on the affected side could indicate the MD disease process and severity.

Interpreting pendred syndrome as a foetal hydrops: Clinical and animal model evidence

BACKGROUND

Menière disease (MD) and SLC26A4 related deafness (Pendred syndrome (PS) or DFNB4) are two different inner ear disorders which present with fluctuating and progressive hearing loss, which could be a direct consequence of endolymphatic hydrops.

OBJECTIVE

To present similarities between both pathologies and explore how the concept of hydrops may be applied to PS/DFNB4.

METHODS

Review of the literature on MD, PS/DFNB4 and mouse model of PS/DFNB4.

RESULTS

MD and PS/DFNB4 share a number of similarities such as fluctuating and progressive hearing loss, acute episodes with vertigo and tinnitus, MRI and histological evidence of endolymphatic hydrops (although with different underlying mechanisms). MD is usually diagnosed during the fourth decade of life whereas PS/DFNB4 is congenital. The PS/DFNB4 mouse models have shown that biallelic slc26a4 mutations lead to Na+ and water retention in the endolymph during the perinatal period, which in turn induces degeneration of the stria vascularis and hearing loss. Crossing clinical/imagery characteristics and animal models, evidence seems to support the hypothesis of PS being a foetal hydrops.

CONCLUSIONS

When understanding PS/DFNB4 as a developmental hydrops, treatments used in MD could be repositioned to PS.

Vestibulo-ocular reflex tests may reflect unilateral Ménière disease progression: A cross-sectional study

Vestibular disorders can manifest several patterns of horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) impairment, which can be detected by caloric test and video head impulse test (vHIT). Several studies have examined the patterns of caloric-vHIT response in Ménière disease (MD). The purpose of this study was to investigate the diversity of caloric-vHIT response and its related factors in unilateral MD patients. We also explore the possibility of assessing the progression of unilateral MD by using the horizontal VOR tests.Ninety-eight patients with unilateral MD were enrolled and underwent a battery of audio-vestibular evaluations, including the pure tone audiogram, caloric test, and horizontal vHIT. Some patients received the electrocochleography and glycerol test. The combined results of caloric test and horizontal vHIT were categorized qualitatively into 4 patterns: Pattern I: normal caloric and vHIT responses; Pattern II: abnormal caloric and normal vHIT responses; Pattern III: normal caloric and abnormal vHIT response; and Pattern IV: abnormal caloric and vHIT responses. The abnormal caloric results were semi-quantitatively subdivided into sub-patterns as mild, moderate, and severe abnormality. The associations between these patterns/sub-patterns and related factors were analyzed.Pattern I was found in 35 cases (35.7%), Pattern II in 57 (58.2%), and Pattern IV in 6 (6.1%). No patient had Pattern III. No significant differences were found between the patterns/sub-pattern distribution and age, electrocochleography, and glycerol test results. Disease duration was not associated with the pattern distribution, while remained a relation with sub-pattern distribution. The pattern/sub-pattern distribution varied significantly across MD stages. The proportion of pattern II or pattern IV increased with the stage of unilateral MD.MD can manifest several patterns of horizontal VOR impairment, of which the impaired caloric response with normal vHIT is the most common pattern. With the progression of unilateral MD, the caloric-vHIT pattern tends to shift, which may reflect the deterioration of endolymphatic hydrops and vestibular hair cells impairments.

Assessment of the effects of menopause on semicircular canal using the video head impulse test

This cross-sectional study included early menopausal and late menopausal women aged between 40 and 60 years to evaluate the effects of menopause on semicircular canal function. A video head impulse test (vHIT) was performed for all subjects. Vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) mean gains of each semicircular canal and gain asymmetry were compared between groups. Of the 87 subjects, 37(42.5%) were reproductive age 28(32.5%) were early menopausal and 22(25.3%) were late menopausal patients. VOR gain of semicircular canals or gain asymmetry values did not differ between groups. In postmenopausal women, presence of vasomotor symptoms was associated with higher gain asymmetry of the left anterior-right posterior (LARP) plane (p = .01), and presence of balance problems was associated with lower right anterior (RA) VOR gain (p = .01). In conclusion semicircular canal function in postmenopausal women was similar to that in women of reproductive age.IMPACT STATEMENTWhat is already known on this subject? During menopause, women face potential risks such as dizziness, balance problems, falls and fractures. Postmenopausal patients were tested with dynamic posturography to measure balance before and after oestrogen treatment, and it was shown that balance problems significantly improved with oestrogen treatment. Healthy vestibular system is one of the components for sustaining normal balance.What do the results of this study add? In postmenopausal women the function of the semicircular canals is normal and the balance deficit in postmenopausal women may not be caused by the vestibular system. In this study changes within normal limits were observed in vestibular system of postmenopausal women.What are the implications of these findings for clinical practice and/or further research? Reported balance deficits might have been due to central origin. Further research to differentiate origin of balance deficits are needed. Specific research on symptomatic postmenopausal patients would reveal more information.

Usefulness of Video Head Impulse Test Results in the Identification of Meniere's Disease

Meniere's disease (MD) is an inner ear disorder inducing tinnitus, aural fullness, sensorineural hearing loss, and vertigo episodes. In the past few years, efforts have been made to develop objective measures able to distinguish MD from other pathologies. Indeed, some authors investigated electrophysiological measures, such as electrocochleography and vestibular evoked myogenic potentials or imaging techniques. More recently, the video head impulse test (vHIT) was developed to assess the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR). In the last few years, authors aimed at identifying how vHIT may help to identify MD. The objective of this manuscript is to review the different vHIT results in MD patients. We will discuss the usefulness of these findings in the identification of MD, how these results may be explained by pathophysiological mechanisms associated with MD, and finally provide directions for future studies.

Evaluation of the vestibular system with video head impulse test in pregnant women with hyperemesis gravidarum

AIM

We aimed to evaluate the semicircular canal functions of the vestibular system in pregnant women with hyperemesis gravidarum.

METHODS

This is a prospective case-control study. Among pregnant women in their first trimester (<14. gestational weeks) who presented to our outpatient clinic, 36 patients diagnosed with hyperemesis gravidarum defined as persistent nausea and vomiting requiring intravenous hydration or loss of at least 5% of prepregnancy weight and 34 healthy pregnant without nausea and vomiting were included. Otorhinolaryngologic examination and video head impulse test (vHIT) was performed to all patients. Vestibular-ocular reflex (VOR) gain and gain asymmetry were assessed between groups.

RESULTS

The VOR gains in each semicircular canal did not differ between hyperemesis and control groups. Using a VOR gain cut-off value of 0.8, the groups were compared in terms of the frequency of low values. In the hyperemesis group, abnormally low gain values of left anterior canal were more frequently observed than in the control group (32 [88.9%], 22 [64.7%], respectively, P = 0.01). In left anterior-right posterior (LARP) plane VOR gain asymmetry was higher in hyperemesis group (13.5 [1.0-71.0], 6.0 [0.0-35.0], P = 0.001). No significant gain asymmetry was detected between the groups in the other planes.

CONCLUSION

Semicircular canal functions were not abnormal globally in women with hyperemesis gravidarum. However, higher LARP plane asymmetry and low LA gain in women with hyperemesis suggests need for further research to clarify functional role of vestibular system on hyperemesis gravidarum.

A New Proposal for Severity Evaluation of Menière's Disease by Using the Evidence From a Comprehensive Battery of Auditory and Vestibular Tests

To date, no widely accepted criteria exist to quantify the severity of Menière's disease (MD) by using vestibular tests. This study aimed to compare association of hearing loss and vertigo severity with association of accurate assessments of vestibular function and the vertigo severity. The severity of vertigo was documented by a comprehensive medical history with number of vertigo attacks in the past 6 months and a Dizziness Handicap Inventory (DHI) questionnaire. The involvement of vestibular organs was verified by audio-vestibular tests in 80 definite MD patients. Correlations between DHI scores, number of vertigo attacks in the past 6 months, audio-vestibular function, and the number of involved vestibular end organs were evaluated. We show that there are no significant differences in either severity of vertigo or laboratory results across the degree of hearing loss. Furthermore, the number of involved vestibular end organs was significantly correlated with vestibulo-ocular reflex gain in anterior and posterior canal video head impulse test (vHIT), interaural asymmetry ratio in vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials (VEMPs), and number of vertigo attacks in the past 6 months and DHI score. The vestibulo-ocular reflex gain in the rotatory chair test (RCT) was significantly correlated with the DHI Physical scores and number of involved vestibular end organs at 0.08 Hz. These results indicate that hearing loss is a poor indicator of vertigo severity in MD whereas the number of involved vestibular end organs may serve as an objective measure for MD progress. A battery of vestibular tests targeting different sensor organs is a complementary method for evaluating inner ear deficits and may aid in "grading" the severity of MD.

Are Meniere's disease patients with otolith organ impairment more likely to have balance dysfunction?

Background: Patients with Meniere's disease (MD) may present with peripheral vestibular end organ dysfunction and balance dysfunction. Objective: This study aimed to compare the results of vestibular evoked myogenic potential (VEMP) tests with those of the sensory organization test (SOT) in patients with MD to determine whether they are correlated. Material and methods: In total, 132 patients with unilateral MD were evaluated using an audiometric test, the SOT, a caloric test and VEMP tests. Results: Cervical VEMP and ocular VEMP tests were conducted in 132 patients with MD, and the response rates of the affected side were lower than those of the unaffected side. The composite score, C5^ES, and C6^ES of the SOT were significantly decreased in patients with no VEMP responses compared to those with VEMP responses. Conclusions and significance: MD patients with no VEMP responses are more likely to develop balance impairment than those with VEMP responses. MD patients with otolith organ impairment may therefore have balance disorders, and should exercise caution to prevent falls and subsequent injuries.