Disparities in Delaware Caregiver Beliefs about the COVID-19 Vaccine for their Children

U.S. Parental Vaccine Hesitancy and the COVID-19 Vaccine: A Scoping Review

Parental vaccine hesitancy has been a hotly debated issue long before the COVID-19 pandemic. Still, the emergence of a new vaccine during this public health crisis made even pro-vaccine individuals reconsider vaccines for their children. This scoping review was conducted to understand why parents expressed hesitancy towards the COVID-19 vaccine for children under 12 years old. The search included primary sources of evidence published in English from 2020-2022. A final 41 articles met the criteria. Overall, more vaccine-hesitant characteristics were non-white, female, lower education level, lower income, on public insurance, conservative political affiliation, younger age, and rural residence. Concerns affecting confidence in the vaccine were the risk of possible side effects and lack of trust in the development of the emergency approval of the vaccine. School nurses can acknowledge parental fears and provide parents with evidence-based information when communicating with them about vaccinations.

Community Partnership to Co-Develop an Intervention to Promote Equitable Uptake of the COVID-19 Vaccine Among Pediatric Populations

Objective

To describe the process of engaging community, caregiver, and youth partners in codeveloping an intervention to promote equitable uptake of the COVID-19 vaccine in non-Hispanic Black (Black) and Hispanic youth who experience higher rates of COVID-19 transmission, morbidity, and mortality but were less likely to receive the COVID-19 vaccine.

Methods

A team of 11 Black and Hispanic community partners was assembled to codevelop intervention strategies with our interdisciplinary research team. We used a mixed-methods crowdsourcing approach with Black and Hispanic youth (n=15) and caregivers of Black and Hispanic youth (n=20) who had not yet been vaccinated against COVID-19, recruited from primary care clinics, to elicit perspectives on the acceptability of these intervention strategies.

Results

We codeveloped five strategies: (1) community-tailored handouts and posters, (2) videos featuring local youth, (3) family-centered language to offer vaccines in the primary care clinic, (4) communication-skills training for primary care providers, and (5) use of community health workers to counsel families about the vaccine. The majority (56-96.9%) of youth and caregivers rated each of these strategies as acceptable, especially because they addressed common concerns and facilitated shared decision-making.

Conclusions

Engaging community and family partners led to the co-development of culturally- and locally-tailored strategies to promote dialogue and shared decision-making about the COVID-19 vaccine. This process can be used to codevelop interventions to address other forms of public health disparities.

Policy Implications

Intervention strategies that promote dialogues with trusted healthcare providers and support shared decision-making are acceptable strategies to promote COVID-19 vaccine uptake among youth from historically underserved communities. Stakeholder-engaged methods may also help in the development of interventions to address other forms of health disparities.

An Informed Approach to Vaccine Hesitancy and Uptake in Children

The tremendous success of vaccination programs worldwide over the past two centuries has produced a paradoxical effect whereby a lack of exposure to the devastating consequences of vaccine-preventable diseases has created an environment in which fear of the side effects of vaccines can overshadow concerns about the impact of the diseases they are meant to prevent. As vaccine hesitancy grew over the past twenty years, states passed legislation, such as non-medical exemptions from vaccination, that have cultivated pockets of poor vaccine uptake allowing for the return of vaccine-preventable diseases such as measles and pertussis. The COVID-19 pandemic has further intensified mistrust of vaccines, impacting both the reasons for vaccine hesitancy and the attributes of vaccine hesitant parents. Because unimmunized children are at increased risk for vaccine-preventable diseases and associated cancers, as well as reduced access to adequate healthcare, they are a particularly vulnerable population warranting special protections and support. A comprehensive approach to combat vaccine hesitancy and promote uptake should include a focus on evidence-based initiatives at the legislative, practice, and provider levels. These strategies can substantively inform health policy, from upstream legislation strengthening school mandates and eliminating non-medical exemptions to downstream policies that impact provider conversations about immunization.