Evaluation of 793/B-like and Mass-like vaccine strain kinetics in experimental and field conditions by real-time RT-PCR quantification

Simultaneous detection and partial molecular characterization of five RNA viruses associated with enteric disease in chickens: chicken astrovirus, avian nephritis virus, infectious bronchitis virus, avian rotavirus a and avian orthoreovirus, via multiplex RT-qPCR

In the poultry industry, intestinal diseases can lead to significant economic losses due to diarrhea, weight loss and mortality, often linked to viral infections. Chicken astrovirus (CAstV), avian nephritis virus (ANV), infection bronchitis virus (IBV), avian rotavirus A (AvRVA) and avian orthoreovirus (ARV) are key pathogens on this disease including feed malabsorption and runting-stunting syndrome (RSS). This study proposes a multiplex RT-qPCR assay for the simultaneous detection of these five viruses in chickens with enteritis in Ecuador. Primers and hydrolysis probes were designed for the five viruses, along with a synthetic gBlock as a positive control. The method was evaluated for sensitivity, repeatability, and specificity, and 200 jejunal samples were tested. Genome regions of each virus were sequenced, and a phylogenetic analysis confirmed their presence in the samples. The optimized RT-qPCR assay showed efficiency between 98.8-105.9%, with a detection limit of 1 copy/μL. It specifically amplified the five target viruses without cross-reactivity. Among 200 chickens tested, 97% were positive for at least one virus, with ANV (89%) and CAstV (53%) being the most prevalent. Coinfections were common, especially between CAstV and ANV, with three samples positive for all viruses. Sequencing and phylogenetic analysis confirmed the circulation of multiple strains in chickens with enteric disease in Ecuador. This study describes a multiplex RT-qPCR assay for detecting key enteric viruses in Ecuadorian poultry highlighting the high prevalence of astroviruses, emphasizing the impact of coinfections, its possible role in the disease and the importance of improving disease control strategies.

Molecular analysis of 4/91-like variants of avian infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) obtained after the introduction of a 4/91 live-attenuated vaccine in Costa Rica during 2017

Avian infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) belongs to family Coronaviridae, genus Gammacoronavirus and is one of the most predominant causes of respiratory disease in poultry. Its high mutation rate constantly leads to the emergence of novel variants that complicate disease control. In 2016, a GA13-like IBV outbreak occurred in Costa Rica, prompting the introduction of the 4/91 live-attenuated vaccine. The objective of this research was to perform a molecular characterization of IBV variants circulating in the country six years after the introduction of the 4/91 vaccine. A total of 177 samples from symptomatic birds were analyzed, with 43 testing positive for IBV. Seven complete S1 sequences were obtained and clustered within the GI-13 lineage by phylogenetic analysis. Sequence analysis showed high genetic similarity to the 4/91 vaccine strain, with nucleotide and amino acid sequence identities over 99.13% and 97.96%, respectively, despite these samples being taken from unvaccinated birds. Post-translational modification analysis of the S1 protein revealed conserved N-glycosylation and palmitoylation sites, while two serine phosphorylation changes were predicted between the obtained sequences and the vaccine strain. Selective pressure analysis identified 10 sites under positive selection, mainly located within the receptor-binding domain and hypervariable regions of the S1 subunit. The presence of 4/91-like variants in unvaccinated birds needs attention, and its relation to observed pathology requires further research. Continuous surveillance is essential to monitor for potential vaccine escape mutants and mitigate their impact.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13337-025-00910-4.

Research note: Indirect evidence of avian Metapneumovirus circulation in broilers in Italy

The clinical relevance of avian metapneumovirus (aMPV) is growing in the poultry sector, especially in broiler farming, where no vaccination is administered in Italy. Given the naïve status of the birds, a serological survey was conducted in a densely populated area of Northern Italy, to evaluate aMPV circulation. Seven farms were selected and sampled in summer/fall, then sampling was repeated in the following season (winter/spring) to assess a possible seasonal effect. In each farm, fifteen birds were blood sampled towards the end of the cycle and sera were analyzed with an ELISA test. Clinical signs were reported in 5 out of 7 farms, although all farms were positive at both sampling points, except for one, which was negative at the first sampling. The seroprevalence within farm ranged from 26.6% to 100%, and antibody titres appear to increase with age. No seasonality effect was evidenced, whereas a farm effect was more distinct. aMPV circulation appears wide in Northern Italian farms, with different clinical outcomes that could be modulated by intrinsic characteristics of the farms. In absence of vaccination, serological monitoring can be a useful tool for viral entrance monitoring, although sampling timing should be evaluated in order to spot seroconversion after late infections.

Longitudinal Survey on aMPV Circulation in French Broiler Flocks following Different Vaccination Strategies

In recent years, the impact of respiratory disease resulting from Avian Metapneumovirus (aMPV) infection has been generally rising in the broiler industry in Europe. In this context, in order to investigate aMPV contribution to the clinical picture and the potential benefits of diversified vaccination strategies compared to nonvaccination policies, a longitudinal monitoring was performed, also evaluating Infectious Bronchitis Virus (IBV) presence. Broiler flocks located in Western France, where aMPV has already proven to be a health and productivity issue, were screened by RT-PCR on rhino-pharyngeal swabs, and the viruses were genetically characterized by sequence analysis. For a more comprehensive picture of aMPV molecular epidemiology and evolution in France, aMPV subtype B strains detected from 1985 to 1998 were sequenced and included in the analysis. The survey confirmed the detection of aMPV subtype B in commercial broiler flocks in France, together with a certain heterogeneity demonstrated by the circulation of more recent and historical French field strains. No IBV field strains were detected. The implementation and evaluation of different management choices and vaccine strategies suggests once again that immunization does not prevent infection but contributes greatly to the containment of the clinical manifestations.

Evaluation of UVC Excimer Lamp (222 nm) Efficacy for Coronavirus Inactivation in an Animal Model

The current pandemic caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome-related coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2) has encouraged the evaluation of novel instruments for disinfection and lowering infectious pressure. Ultraviolet subtype C (UVC) excimer lamps with 222 nm wavelength have been tested on airborne pathogens on surfaces and the exposure to this wavelength has been considered safer than conventional UVC. To test the efficacy of UVC excimer lamps on coronaviruses, an animal model mimicking the infection dynamics was implemented. An attenuated vaccine based on infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) was nebulized and irradiated by 222 nm UVC rays before the exposure of a group of day-old chicks to evaluate the virus inactivation. A control group of chicks was exposed to the nebulized vaccine produced in the same conditions but not irradiated by the lamps. The animals of both groups were sampled daily and individually by choanal cleft swabs and tested usign a strain specific real time RT-PCR to evaluate the vaccine replication. Only the birds in the control group were positive, showing an active replication of the vaccine, revealing the efficacy of the lamps in inactivating the vaccine below the infectious dose in the other group.

Metagenomic sequencing determines complete infectious bronchitis virus (avian Gammacoronavirus) vaccine strain genomes and associated viromes in chicken clinical samples

Infectious bronchitis virus (IBV, genus Gammacoronavirus) causes an economically important and highly contagious disease in chicken. Random primed RNA sequencing was applied to two IBV positive clinical samples and one in ovo-passaged virus. The virome of a cloacal swab pool was dominated by IBV (82% of viral reads) allowing de novo assembly of a GI-13 lineage complete genome with 99.95% nucleotide identity to vaccine strain 793B. In addition, substantial read counts (16% of viral reads) allowed the assembly of a near-complete chicken astrovirus genome, while lower read counts identified the presence of chicken calicivirus and avian leucosis virus. Viral reads in a respiratory/intestinal tissue pool were distributed between IBV (22.53%), Sicinivirus (Picornaviridae, 24%), and avian leucosis virus (37.04%). A complete IBV genome with 99.95% nucleotide identity to vaccine strain H120 (lineage GI-1), as well as a near-complete avian leucosis virus genome and a partial Sicinivirus genome were assembled from the tissue sample data. Lower read counts identified chicken calicivirus, Avibirnavirus (infectious bursal disease virus, assembling to 98.85% of segment A and 69.66% of segment B closely related to D3976/1 from Germany, 2017) and avian orthoreovirus, while three avian orthoavulavirus 1 reads confirmed prior real-time RT-PCR result. IBV sequence variation analysis identified both fixed and minor frequency variations in the tissue sample compared to its in ovo-passaged virus. Metagenomic methods allow the determination of complete coronavirus genomes from clinical chicken samples while providing additional insights in RNA virus sequence diversity and coinfecting viruses potentially contributing to pathogenicity.

Effect of assay choice, viral concentration and operator interpretation on infectious bronchitis virus detection and characterization

Despite the efforts to achieve a consistent classification scheme based on the complete S1 gene, the genetic characterization of infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) is often performed on partial S1 regions due to economic and time constraints in the diagnostic routine. Sanger sequencing remains the most common and cost-effective option even if the analysis of samples where multiple field and vaccine strain populations coexist can lead to partial or misleading results. The present study aimed to evaluate the different diagnostic outcomes of three commonly used RT-PCR methods targeting two regions of the S1 gene. A possible bias in IBV detection and characterization was investigated in relation to the adopted method, the strain concentration as well as their ratio in mixed samples. Thirty samples were prepared by artificially mixing two vaccine strains, combined at different ratios and selected among four different IBV lineages, i.e. GI-1 (Mass), GI-13 (793/B), GI-19 (QX), GI-23 (Israeli Variant 2). Sequence analysis was conducted both manually and with bioinformatic methods. The result agreement among methods, replicates and analysis approaches was statistically evaluated. Consistent results emerged among the three assays, with a few discrepancies likely caused by primer affinity and target amount. This study confirms the complexity of IBV strain identification and highlights the importance of evaluating and updating the available diagnostic assays for a reliable detection of all circulating IBV strains.

Infectious Bronchitis Hatchery Vaccination: Comparison between Traditional Spray Administration and a Newly Developed Gel Delivery System in Field Conditions

The control of infectious bronchitis (IB) is essential in intensive broiler production and is pursued through strict biosecurity and mass vaccination. Despite effective and routinely adopted, hatchery spray vaccination has been hypothesized to affect chicks’ body temperature and wellbeing. Recently, gel administration has been proposed as an alternative and proved feasible in experimental settings. In this study, IBV spray and gel vaccination methods were compared in field conditions. One hundred birds from the same hatch were enrolled in the study and vaccinated, half by spray and half by gel, with 793B and Mass vaccines. After vaccination, rectal temperature was measured and vaccine intake assessed. The two groups were housed for 35 days in separate pens and swabs and blood samples were collected at multiple time points for genotype-specific molecular analyses and serology, respectively. The temperature was significantly lower in spray-vaccinated chicks 10 min and an hour after administration. A similar trend in 793B titres was observed in both groups, while the Mass vaccine was detected later but persisted longer in gel-vaccinated chicks. No differences were observed in mean antibody titres. Compared to spray, gel administration appears equally effective and less impactful on body temperature, thus supporting its application for IBV vaccination.

Research Note: Effects of Escherichia coli co-infection on the protective efficacy assessment of two common infectious bronchitis vaccines

Avian infectious bronchitis (IB), a highly contagious disease hazardous to the poultry industry, is caused by an etiological agent called the infectious bronchitis virus (IBV). Some IBV strains (IBVs) alone usually do not cause high mortality in field conditions if not with secondary pathogens including Escherichia coli (E. coli). Herein, we established an IBV and E. coli co-infection model to evaluate the protective efficacy of two IBV vaccine strains against a new emerging genotype GVI-1 with mild virulence in experimental conditions. Chickens were inoculated with IBV field isolate ZQX (genotype GVI-1) and challenged 4 dlater with the E. coli strain MS160427 (serotype O8). Subsequently, these chickens were euthanized at seven days postchallenge (d.p.c.) with E. coli. An autopsy revealed that lesions in the IBV plus E. coli co-infection group were more severe than those in the IBV-infected group. This pathological model was used to assess the protective effect of two commonly used vaccine strains (H120 and 4/91) against the IBV ZQX strain, and a significantly better protective efficacy was observed for 4/91 compared with H120. Thus, IBV and E. coli co-infection could be employed in assessing the protective efficacy of IBV vaccines.

A closed-tube, single-step, real time, reverse transcription-loop-mediated isothermal amplification assay for infectious bronchitis virus detection in chickens

•

A closed tube, single-step-real-time-RT-LAMP assay was developed for detection and semi-quantification of IBV in closed tube.

•

The least limit of detection of our assay is 1 EID₅₀/ ml.

•

Clinical evaluation of samples from diseased chickens using our assay shows a very good concordance with RT-qPCR assay.

Infectious bronchitis (IB) is a viral infection of the chicken respiratory tract that causes substantial economic burden on the industry. Simple, specific and rapid diagnosis of this disease is critical for the initiation of appropriate control measures. Conventional molecular diagnostic methods require a relatively sophisticated equipment and skilled staff. Here we describe a rapid, simple, semi-quantative, closed-tube, single-step, real-time- reverse transcription-loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP) assay for IB and compare our assay with quantative, reverse transcription- polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR). The limit of detection (LOD) of our RT-LAMP assay is 1 EID₅₀/ ml. Clinical evaluation of samples from diseased chickens with our RT-LAMP showed a very good concordance with RT-qPCR. Our assay enables simple, specific, rapid molecular detection and semi-quantification of the infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) in veterinary diagnostic laboratories. Furthermore, our RT-LAMP detection is carried out in a sealed tube, eliminating the risk of false-positive results in subsequent tests because of any contamination of the work area as in the case of lateral flow strip or gel electrophoresis-based amplicon detection.

Infectious Bronchitis Virus Evolution, Diagnosis and Control

RNA viruses are characterized by high mutation and recombination rates, which allow a rapid adaptation to new environments. Most of the emerging diseases and host jumps are therefore sustained by these viruses. Rapid evolution may also hinder the understanding of molecular epidemiology, affect the sensitivity of diagnostic assays, limit the vaccine efficacy and favor episodes of immune escape, thus significantly complicating the control of even well-known pathogens. The history of infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) fits well with the above-mentioned scenario. Despite being known since the 1930s, it still represents one of the main causes of disease and economic losses for the poultry industry. A plethora of strategies have been developed and applied over time, with variable success, to limit its impact. However, they have rarely been evaluated objectively and on an adequate scale. Therefore, the actual advantages and disadvantages of IBV detection and control strategies, as well as their implementation, still largely depend on individual sensibility. The present manuscript aims to review the main features of IBV biology and evolution, focusing on their relevance and potential applications in terms of diagnosis and control.

Molecular epidemiology of infectious bronchitis virus and avian metapneumovirus in Greece

Respiratory diseases like infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) and avian metapneumovirus (aMPV) have been held accountable for major losses for poultry production. Nevertheless, scarce information was present dealing with the prevalence and molecular epidemiology of these infections in Greece and the efficacy of currently applied control strategies. To fill this gap, a specific epidemiological study was designed. A total of 106 broiler and layer farms, including 10 backyard and 96 commercial flocks, were sampled between March 2016 and May 2017, and the obtained tracheal swabs were tested for IBV and aMPV using RT-PCR based techniques followed by sequencing. For each farm, data regarding production type, flock features, clinical signs, and vaccination program were also recorded. Different associations between vaccination protocol, production type, animal category, birds density, age, presence of clinical signs, and IBV and/or aMPV infection were tested. Both IBV and aMPV field strain prevalence were proven high, approximately 20 and 30%, respectively, being the GI-19 lineage (14 out of 19; 73.6%) and B subtype (30 out of 30; 100%), the most commonly detected IBV and aMPV genetic types. Infection with IBV field strains was significantly associated with clinical sign presence (odds ratio = 8.55 [95CI = 2.17–42.90]). Remarkably, only the vaccination protocol involving a double vaccination at 1 D of age was proven protective against IBV-induced symptomatology, with the odds of developing disease being 4.14 [95CI = 1.34–14.51] times lower.

No association was demonstrated between aMPV infection and clinical outbreaks or between aMPV and IBV detection, suggesting the marginal role of the former pathogen in poultry farming.

Globally, the present study provides the first detailed investigation of the epidemiological scenario of 2 viruses traditionally considered of pivotal relevance in poultry farming and demonstrates that remarkable benefits could be obtained with just minor adjustments in vaccination protocols.

Vaccine or field strains: the jigsaw pattern of infectious bronchitis virus molecular epidemiology in Poland

Infectious bronchitis (IB), caused by infectious bronchitis virus (IBV), account for severe economic losses in the poultry industry. The continuous emergence of a multitude of IBV variants poses many challenges for its diagnosis and control, and live attenuated vaccines, despite their routine use, still plays a significant role in driving IBV evolution, further complicating the epidemiological scenario. Unfortunately, the impact of different vaccination strategies on IB control, epidemiology, and diagnosis has rarely been investigated. This work presents the results of a large-scale diagnostic survey performed in Poland to study IBV molecular epidemiology and how vaccination may affect the viral circulation in the field. To this purpose, 589 samples were collected between May 2017 and January 2019, tested by reverse transcription-PCR for IBV and sequenced. Vaccine and field strains were discriminated based on genetic and anamnestic information. The most commonly detected lineages were 793B (79%) and variant 2 (17.4%), with sporadic detections of QX, Mass, and D274-like strains. Most of the detected strains had a vaccine origin: 46.3% matched one of the applied vaccines, while 36.5% were genetically related to vaccines not implemented in the respective protocol. Besides their practical value for the proper planning of vaccination protocols in Poland, these results suggest that only a fraction (17.2%) of the circulating strains are field ones, imposing a careful assessment of the actual IBV field menaces. Moreover, phenomena like vaccine spreading and persistence seem to occur commonly, stressing the need to further study the epidemiological consequences of the extensive use of live vaccines.

Infectious bronchitis virus gel vaccination: evaluation of Mass-like (B-48) and 793/B-like (1/96) vaccine kinetics after combined administration at 1 day of age

Infectious bronchitis (IB) control has a strong impact on poultry farming, because of the necessary epidemiological knowledge for planning the best strategy, the optimal strain association, the priming and boosting interventions. Broiler farming is even more problematic given the short and intense productive cycle, which requires an early onset of protection against most of the infectious threats, possibly with limited respiratory post-vaccination reactions that would have a direct impact on the bird health and productivity. For this purpose, gel vaccination has been proposed as a new approach for infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) control and vaccine intake, kinetics and compatibility of combined strains administered by gel have been analyzed in this study. After gel vaccination with single and combined 1/96 and B-48 strains on 4 groups of commercial broilers, a 21-d-long experimental trial has been conducted to monitor the vaccine safety by clinical assessment and vaccine kinetics by strain-specific real-time RT-PCR on choanal cleft swabs. The vaccine strains administered by gel were safe and negligible respiratory signs were detected, even when combined. Vaccine titers were compared among groups and within the same group among a 10-bird pooled sample and 10 swabs from individually sampled birds. 1/96 strain early reached high titers in all animals, while B-48 presence was less constant even though it was detected in almost all birds before the trial end. The individual and pooled sample comparison revealed a partial overestimation of vaccine titers in the pooled samples and the loss of the prevalence data, although the trend portrayed by the pooled swabs closely followed the individual ones.