The double-edged sword of inflammation in inherited retinal degenerations: Clinical and preclinical evidence for mechanistically and prognostically impactful but treatable complications

A novel founder variant in BEST1 gene causing autosomal recessive bestrophinopathy

BACKGROUND

Autosomal recessive bestrophinopathy (ARB) is a rare retinal dystrophy caused by homozygous or compound heterozygous null variants in the BEST1 gene. Clinically, ARB presents with variable features including central visual impairment, global photoreceptor dysfunction (as indicated by abnormal full-field ERG), and a significantly reduced electro-oculogram (EOG) light rise, a hallmark of bestrophinopathy. Fundus examination reveals widespread retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) disturbance, vitelliform deposits in the posterior pole (more clearly visualized with fundus autofluorescence), and macular fluid accumulation. Angle-closure glaucoma, secondary to anterior chamber dysgenesis, is a potential complication. This work aims at documenting the founder effect of a novel variant in the BEST1 gene causing autosomal recessive bestrophinopathy and determining its variable clinical features.

METHODS

Twelve members of nine unrelated, consanguineous Egyptian families with a history of impaired central vision underwent comprehensive ophthalmological examination, fundus color photography, fundus autofluorescence (FAF), spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) of the macula, and electrophysiological studies. Variant screening of coding exons of the BEST1 gene and some flanking regions was performed using the Sanger sequencing technique. The pathogenicity of the variants was tested using different in silico functional analysis tools.

RESULTS

The clinical examination and investigations confirmed the ARB phenotype. All twelve patients exhibited (c.365 G > C, p. Arg122Pro) a novel BEST1 gene variant in a homozygous form. On top of the classical retinal phenotype of ARB, some patients had other ocular associations: four patients were found to have angle-closure glaucoma, one patient had associated corneal dystrophy, one developed a macular hole, and one patient developed uveitis.

CONCLUSION

The identification of the same, novel homozygous BEST1 missense variant in twelve patients from nine unrelated, consanguineous families of Egyptian origin, suggests a founder effect. Angle-closure glaucoma was the most commonly associated ocular abnormality (30%). Our finding expands the molecular spectrum of ARB-associated variants, and identification of this founder variant can simplify genetic testing in the presence of limited resources and lead to better counseling.

Gene Therapy-Associated Uveitis (GTAU): Understanding and mitigating the adverse immune response in retinal gene therapy

Retinal gene therapy using adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors has been a groundbreaking step-change in the treatment of inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) and could also be used to treat more common retinal diseases such as age-related macular degeneration and diabetic retinopathy. The delivery and expression of therapeutic transgenes in the eye is limited by innate and adaptive immune responses against components of the vector product, which has been termed gene therapy-associated uveitis (GTAU). This is clinically important as intraocular inflammation could lead to irreversible loss of retinal cells, deterioration of visual function and reduced durability of treatment effect associated with a costly one-off treatment. For retinal gene therapy to achieve an improved efficacy and safety profile for treating additional IRDs and more common diseases, the risk of GTAU must be minimised. We have collated insights from pre-clinical research, clinical trials, and the real-world implementation of AAV-mediated retinal gene therapy to help understand the risk factors for GTAU. We draw attention to an emerging framework, which includes patient demographics, vector construct, vector dose, route of administration, and choice of immunosuppression regime. Importantly, we consider efforts to date and potential future strategies to mitigate the adverse immune response across each of these domains. We advocate for more targeted immunomodulatory approaches to the prevention and treatment of GTAU based on better understanding of the underlying immune response.

Inherited retinal disease-associated uveitis

Inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) are genetic disorders characterized by progressive photoreceptor function loss, often leading to significant visual impairment. Uveitis has been increasingly recognized in the clinical course of some IRDs. Despite advances in understanding the genetic causes and pathophysiology of IRDs, gaps remain in understanding the roles of inflammation and autoimmunity in IRD and IRD-associated uveitis. This review discusses IRD-associated uveitis, including anterior, intermediate, posterior, and panuveitis, as well as complications such as cystoid macular edema and retinal vasculitis. In patients with IRD-associated uveitis, mutations affecting protein function in cilia or photoreceptor outer segments suggest a universal autoimmune mechanism triggered by the immunogenicity of shedding photoreceptor discs. Notably, in patients where uveitis is the initial sign, CRB1 mutations are often implicated, likely due to the compromised blood-retina barrier function or alterations in the external limiting membrane. Other mechanisms leading to uveitis preceding IRD diagnosis include ALPK1 mutations, which activate the proinflammatory NF-κB pathway, CAPN5 mutations, which lead to dysfunction of the innate and adaptive immune systems, and VCAN1 mutations, which elicit immunogenicity due to irregularities in vitreous modeling. Understanding these mechanisms could enhance the development of innovative treatments that target personalized inflammation pathways in IRDs.

Macrophages coordinate immune response to laser-induced injury via extracellular traps

BACKGROUND

Retinal degeneration results from disruptions in retinal homeostasis due to injury, disease, or aging and triggers peripheral leukocyte infiltration. Effective immune responses rely on coordinated actions of resident microglia and recruited macrophages, critical for tissue remodeling and repair. However, these phagocytes also contribute to chronic inflammation in degenerated retinas, yet the precise coordination of immune response to retinal damage remains elusive. Recent investigations have demonstrated that phagocytic cells can produce extracellular traps (ETs), which are a source of self-antigens that alter the immune response, which can potentially lead to tissue injury.

METHODS

Innovations in experimental systems facilitate real-time exploration of immune cell interactions and dynamic responses. We integrated in vivo imaging with ultrastructural analysis, transcriptomics, pharmacological treatments, and knockout mice to elucidate the role of phagocytes and their modulation of the local inflammatory response through extracellular traps (ETs). Deciphering these mechanisms is essential for developing novel and enhanced immunotherapeutic approaches that can redirect a specific maladaptive immune response towards favorable wound healing in the retina.

RESULTS

Our findings underscore the pivotal role of innate immune cells, especially macrophages/monocytes, in regulating retinal repair and inflammation. The absence of neutrophil and macrophage infiltration aids parenchymal integrity restoration, while their depletion, particularly macrophages/monocytes, impedes vascular recovery. We demonstrate that macrophages/monocytes, when recruited in the retina, release chromatin and granular proteins, forming ETs. Furthermore, the pharmacological inhibition of ETosis support retinal and vascular repair, surpassing the effects of blocking innate immune cell recruitment. Simultaneously, the absence of ETosis reshapes the inflammatory response, causing neutrophils, helper, and cytotoxic T-cells to be restricted primarily in the superficial capillary plexus instead of reaching the damaged photoreceptor layer.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data offer novel insights into innate immunity's role in responding to retinal damage and potentially help developing innovative immunotherapeutic approaches that can shift the immune response from maladaptive to beneficial for retinal regeneration.

CRB1-Associated Retinal Dystrophy Patients Have Expanded Lewis Glycoantigen-Positive T Cells

Purpose

Eye inflammation may occur in patients with inherited retinal dystrophies (IRDs) and is seen frequently in IRDs associated with mutations in the CRB1 gene. The purpose of this study was to determine the types of inflammatory cells involved in IRDs, by deep profiling the composition of peripheral blood mononuclear cells of patients with a CRB1-associated IRD.

Methods

This study included 33 patients with an IRD with confirmed CRB1 mutations and 32 healthy controls. A 43-parameter flow cytometry analysis was performed on peripheral blood mononuclear cells isolated from venous blood. FlowSOM and manual Boolean combination gating were used to identify and quantify immune cell subsets.

Results

Comparing patients with controls revealed a significant increase in patients in the abundance of circulating CD4+ T cells and CD8+ T cells that express sialyl Lewis X antigen. Furthermore, we detected a decrease in plasmacytoid dendritic cells and an IgA+CD24+CD38+ transitional B-cell subset in patients with an IRD.

Conclusions

Patients with a CRB1-associated IRD show marked changes in blood leukocyte composition, affecting lymphocyte and dendritic cell populations. These results implicate inflammatory pathways in the disease manifestations of IRDs.