Next Generation Sequencing for Detecting Somatic FAS Mutations in Patients With Autoimmune Lymphoproliferative Syndrome

Enrichment of Immune Dysregulation Disorders in Adult Patients with Human Inborn Errors of Immunity

Human inborn errors of immunity (IEI) comprise a group of diseases resulting from molecular variants that compromise innate and adaptive immunity. Clinical features of IEI patients are dominated by susceptibility to a spectrum of infectious diseases, as well as autoimmune, autoinflammatory, allergic, and malignant phenotypes that usually appear in childhood, which is when the diagnosis is typically made. However, some IEI patients are identified in adulthood due to symptomatic delay of the disease or other reasons that prevent the request for a molecular study. The application of next-generation sequencing (NGS) as a diagnostic technique has given rise to an ever-increasing identification of IEI-monogenic causes, thus improving the diagnostic yield and facilitating the possibility of personalized treatment. This work was a retrospective study of 173 adults with IEI suspicion that were sequenced between 2005 and 2023. Sanger, targeted gene-panel, and whole exome sequencing were used for molecular diagnosis. Disease-causing variants were identified in 44 of 173 (25.43%) patients. The clinical phenotype of these 44 patients was mostly related to infection susceptibility (63.64%). An enrichment of immune dysregulation diseases was found when cohorts with molecular diagnosis were compared to those without. Immune dysregulation disorders, group 4 from the International Union of Immunological Societies Expert Committee (IUIS), were the most prevalent among these adult patients. Immune dysregulation as a new item in the Jeffrey Model Foundation warning signs for adults significantly increases the sensitivity for the identification of patients with an IEI-producing molecular defect.

Autoimmune lymphoproliferative immunodeficiencies (ALPIDs): A proposed approach to redefining ALPS and other lymphoproliferative immune disorders

Chronic nonmalignant lymphoproliferation and autoimmune cytopenia are relevant manifestations of immunohematologic diseases of childhood. Their diagnostic classification is challenging but important for therapy. Autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) is a genetically defined inborn error of immunity combining these manifestations, but it can explain only a small proportion of cases. Diagnostic categories such as ALPS-like disease, common variable immunodeficiency, or Evans syndrome have therefore been used. Advances in genetics and increasing availablity of targeted therapies call for more therapy-oriented disease classification. Moreover, recent discoveries in the (re)analysis of genetic conditions affecting FAS signaling ask for a more precise definition of ALPS. In this review, we propose the term autoimmune lymphoproliferative immunodeficiencies for a disease phenotype that is enriched for patients with genetic diseases for which targeted therapies are available. For patients without a current molecular diagnosis, this term defines a subgroup of immune dysregulatory disorders for further studies. Within the concept of autoimmune lymphoproliferative immunodeficiencies, we propose a revision of the ALPS classification, restricting use of this term to conditions with clear evidence of perturbation of FAS signaling and resulting specific biologic and clinical consequences. This proposed approach to redefining ALPS and other lymphoproliferative conditions provides a framework for disease classification and diagnosis that is relevant for the many specialists confronted with these diseases.

Abnormal biomarkers predict complex FAS or FADD defects missed by exome sequencing

BACKGROUND

Elevated TCRαβ+CD4-CD8- double-negative T cells (DNT) and serum biomarkers help identify FAS mutant patients with autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS). However, in some patients with clinical features and biomarkers consistent with ALPS, germline or somatic FAS mutations cannot be identified on standard exon sequencing (ALPS-undetermined: ALPS-U).

OBJECTIVE

We sought to explore whether complex genetic alterations in the FAS gene escaping standard sequencing or mutations in other FAS pathway-related genes could explain these cases.

METHODS

Genetic analysis included whole FAS gene sequencing, copy number variation analysis, and sequencing of FAS cDNA and other FAS pathway-related genes. It was guided by FAS expression analysis on CD57+DNT, which can predict somatic loss of heterozygosity (sLOH).

RESULTS

Nine of 16 patients with ALPS-U lacked FAS expression on CD57+DNT predicting heterozygous "loss-of-expression" FAS mutations plus acquired somatic second hits in the FAS gene, enriched in DNT. Indeed, 7 of 9 analyzed patients carried deep intronic mutations or large deletions in the FAS gene combined with sLOH detectable in DNT; 1 patient showed a FAS exon duplication. Three patients had reduced FAS expression, and 2 of them harbored mutations in the FAS promoter, which reduced FAS expression in reporter assays. Three of the 4 ALPS-U patients with normal FAS expression carried heterozygous FADD mutations with sLOH.

CONCLUSION

A combination of serum biomarkers and DNT phenotyping is an accurate means to identify patients with ALPS who are missed by routine exome sequencing.

Combined germline and somatic human FADD mutations cause autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome

BACKGROUND

The autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) is a noninfectious and nonmalignant lymphoproliferative disease frequently associated with autoimmune cytopenia resulting from defective FAS signaling. We previously described germline monoallelic FAS (TNFRSF6) haploinsufficient mutations associated with somatic events, such as loss of heterozygosity on the second allele of FAS, as a cause of ALPS-FAS. These somatic events were identified by sequencing FAS in DNA from double-negative (DN) T cells, the pathognomonic T-cell subset in ALPS, in which the somatic events accumulated.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to identify whether a somatic event affecting the FAS-associated death domain (FADD) gene could be related to the disease onset in 4 unrelated patients with ALPS carrying a germline monoallelic mutation of the FADD protein inherited from a healthy parent.

METHODS

We sequenced FADD and performed array-based comparative genomic hybridization using DNA from sorted CD4+ or DN T cells.

RESULTS

We found homozygous FADD mutations in the DN T cells from all 4 patients, which resulted from uniparental disomy. FADD deficiency caused by germline heterozygous FADD mutations associated with a somatic loss of heterozygosity was a phenocopy of ALPS-FAS without the more complex symptoms reported in patients with germline biallelic FADD mutations.

CONCLUSIONS

The association of germline and somatic events affecting the FADD gene is a new genetic cause of ALPS.

Understanding the Spectrum of Immune Dysregulation Manifestations in Autoimmune Lymphoproliferative Syndrome and Autoimmune Lymphoproliferative Syndrome-like Disorders

As a disorder of immune dysregulation, autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) stems from pathogenic variants in the first apoptosis signal-mediated apoptosis (Fas) and Fas-ligand pathway that result in elevations of CD3+ TCRαβ+ CD4- CD8- T cells along with chronic lymphoproliferation, a heightened risk for malignancy, and importantly for the rheumatologist, increased risk of autoimmunity. While immune cytopenias are the most encountered autoimmune phenomena, there is increasing appreciation for ocular, musculoskeletal, pulmonary and renal inflammatory manifestations similar to more common rheumatology diseases. Additionally, ALPS-like conditions that share similar clinical features and opportunities for targeted therapy are increasingly recognized via genetic testing, highlighting the need for rheumatologists to be facile in the recognition and diagnosis of this spectrum of disorders. This review will focus on clinical and laboratory features of both ALPS and ALPS-like disorders with the intent to provide a framework for rheumatologists to understand the pathophysiologic drivers and discriminate between diagnoses.

Somatic mosaicism in inborn errors of immunity: Current knowledge, challenges, and future perspectives

Inborn errors of immunity (IEI) are a diverse group of monogenic disorders of the immune system due to germline variants in genes important for the immune response. Over the past decade there has been increasing recognition that acquired somatic variants present in a subset of cells can also lead to immune disorders or 'phenocopies' of IEI. Discovery of somatic mosaicism causing IEI has largely arisen from investigation of seemingly sporadic cases of IEI with predominant symptoms of autoinflammation and/or autoimmunity in which germline disease-causing variants are not detected. Disease-causing somatic mosaicism has been identified in genes that also cause germline IEI, such as FAS, and in genes without significant corresponding germline disease, such as UBA1 and TLR8. There are challenges in detecting low-level somatic variants, and it is likely that the extent of the somatic mosaicism causing IEI is largely uncharted. Here we review the field of somatic mosaicism leading to IEI and discuss challenges and methods for somatic variant detection, including diagnostic approaches for molecular diagnoses of patients.

Somatic genetic variation in healthy tissue and non-cancer diseases

Somatic genetic variants have been studied for several years mostly concerning cancer, where they contribute to its origin and development. It is also clear that the somatic variants load is greater in aged individuals in comparison to younger ones, pointing to a cause/consequence of the senescence process. More recently, researchers have focused on the role of this type of variation in healthy tissue and its dynamics in cell lineages and different organs. In addition, somatic variants have been described to contribute to monogenic diseases, and the number of evidences of their role in complex disorders is also increasing. Thanks to recent advances in next-generation sequencing technologies, this type of genetic variation can be now more easily studied than in the past, although we still face some important limitations. Novel strategies for sampling, sequencing and filtering are being investigated to detect these variants, although validating them with an orthogonal approach will most likely still be needed. In this review, we aim to update our knowledge of somatic variation detection and its relation to healthy tissue and non-cancer diseases.

Detection and evolutionary dynamics of somatic FAS variants in autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome: Diagnostic implications

Autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) is a rare primary immune disorder characterized by impaired apoptotic homeostasis. The clinical characteristics include lymphoproliferation, autoimmunity (mainly cytopenia), and an increased risk of lymphoma. A distinctive biological feature is accumulation (>2.5%) of an abnormal cell subset composed of TCRαβ+ CD4-CD8- T cells (DNTs). The most common genetic causes of ALPS are monoallelic pathogenic variants in the FAS gene followed by somatic FAS variants, mainly restricted to DNTs. Identification of somatic FAS variants has been typically addressed by Sanger sequencing in isolated DNTs. However, this approach can be costly and technically challenging, and may not be successful in patients with normal DNT counts receiving immunosuppressive treatment. In this study, we identified a novel somatic mutation in FAS (c.718_719insGTCG) by Sanger sequencing on purified CD3+ cells. We then followed the evolutionary dynamics of the variant along time with an NGS-based approach involving deep amplicon sequencing (DAS) at high coverage (20,000-30,000x). Over five years of clinical follow-up, we obtained six blood samples for molecular study from the pre-treatment (DNTs>7%) and treatment (DNTs<2%) periods. DAS enabled detection of the somatic variant in all samples, even the one obtained after five years of immunosuppressive treatment (DNTs: 0.89%). The variant allele frequency (VAF) range was 4%-5% in pre-treatment samples and <1.5% in treatment samples, and there was a strong positive correlation between DNT counts and VAF (Pearson’s R: 0.98, p=0.0003). We then explored whether the same approach could be used in a discovery setting. In the last follow-up sample (DNT: 0.89%) we performed somatic variant calling on the FAS exon 9 DAS data from whole blood and purified CD3+ cells using VarScan 2. The c.718_719insGTCG variant was identified in both samples and showed the highest VAF (0.67% blood, 1.58% CD3+ cells) among >400 variants called. In summary, our study illustrates the evolutionary dynamics of a somatic FAS mutation before and during immunosuppressive treatment. The results show that pathogenic somatic FAS variants can be identified with the use of DAS in whole blood of ALPS patients regardless of their DNT counts.

Gain-of-function defects in toll-like receptor 8 shed light on the interface between immune system and bone marrow failure disorders

In this article, we will share lessons that patients with gain-of-function defects in Toll-like receptor 8 (TLR8-GOF) can teach us about the interface between bone marrow failure (BMF) disorders and inborn errors of immunity (IEI), subsequently referred to as “Interface Disorders”. TLR8-GOF is a relatively young entity (from a discovery standpoint) that—through both similar and dissimilar disease characteristics—can increase our understanding of interface disorders, for example, as it pertains to pathophysiology, the genetic mechanism of disease, and related diagnostics and therapeutics. From a genetics point of view, TLR8-GOF joins a growing list of (interface) disorders that can cause disease both with germline and somatic (mosaic) genetic variants. This not only has repercussions for the diagnostic workup of these disorders, inasmuch that routine genetic testing may miss somatic variants, but has therapeutic implications as well, for example, with the approach to curative treatment, such as hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Following an introduction and schematic rendering of the interface, we will review the salient features of TLR8-GOF, with the understanding that the phenotype of this new disorder is likely not written in stone yet. In keeping with the principle of “Form Follows Function”, we will discuss specific immunological biomarkers that can be measured in clinical laboratories and highlight key disease features that pertain to TLR8-GOF, and can be found in several interface disorders. As can be seen from a schematic representation, the interface provides not only opportunities for learning and collaboration with respect to shared diagnostics but also the potential for drug repurposing and precision therapeutics. Ideally, collaboration also focuses on education and teaching, such that cross-fertilization and collaboration across these disciplines can create a framework for complementary research.

Postzygotic mutations and where to find them - Recent advances and future implications in the field of non-neoplastic somatic mosaicism

The technological progress of massively parallel sequencing (MPS) has triggered a remarkable development in the research on postzygotic mutations. Although the overwhelming majority of studies in the field focus on oncogenesis, non-neoplastic diseases are attracting more and more attention. The aim of this review was to summarize some of the most recent findings in the field of somatic mosaicism in diseases other than neoplastic events. We discuss the abundance and role of postzygotic mutations, with a special emphasis on disorders which occur only in a mosaic form (obligatory mosaic diseases; OMDs). Based on the list of OMDs compiled from the published literature and three databases (OMIM, Orphanet and MosaicBase), we demonstrate the prevalence of cancer-related genes across OMDs and suggest other sources to further explore OMDs and OMD-related genes. Additionally, we comment on some practical aspects related to mosaic diseases, such as approaches to tissue sampling, the MPS coverage required to detect variants at a very low frequency, as well as on bioinformatic and molecular tools dedicated to detect somatic mutations in MPS data.

DCAF12 and HSPA1A May Serve as Potential Diagnostic Biomarkers for Myasthenia Gravis

Background

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is an autoimmune disease that severely affects the life quality of patients. This study explores the differences in immune cell types between MG and healthy control and the role of immune-related genes in the diagnosis of MG.

Methods

The GSE85452 dataset was downloaded from the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) database and analyzed using the limma package to determine differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between patients with MG and the control group. Differentially expressed immune cells were analyzed using single-sample gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA), while immune cell-associated modules were identified by weighted gene coexpression network analysis (WGCNA). Then, the expression of the identified hub genes was confirmed by RT-PCR in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) of MG patients. The R package pROC was used to plot the receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curves.

Results

The modules related to CD56^bright natural killer cells were identified by GSEA and WGCNA. The proportion of CD56^bright natural killer cells in the peripheral blood of MG patients is low. The results of RT-PCR showed that the levels of DDB1- and CUL4-associated factor 12 (DCAF12) and heat shock protein family A member 1A (HSPA1A) were significantly decreased in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of MG patients compared with healthy controls. The ROC curve results of DCAF12 and HSPA1A mRNA in MG diagnosis were 0.780 and 0.830, respectively.

Conclusions

CD56^bright NK cell is lower in MG patients and may affect MG occurrence. DCAF12 and HSPA1A are lowly expressed in PBMCs of MG patients and may serve as the diagnostic biomarkers of MG.

Presentation and diagnosis of autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS)

INTRODUCTION

Autoimmune lymphoproliferative syndrome (ALPS) is a rare disorder of immune dysregulation characterized by derangements in first apoptosis signal-mediated apoptosis and elevations in CD3⁺TCRαβ⁺CD4^-CD8^- 'double negative' T cells. As our understanding of this pleomorphic disorder expands, the importance of molecular diagnosis is ever more apparent due to the growing number of disorders that may present with overlapping initial symptoms, but for which there is an ever-increasing list of therapeutic options.

AREAS COVERED

This review will cover the current understanding of the molecular biology and pathophysiology of ALPS as well as describe some of the overlapping syndromes in order to better demonstrate the importance of establishing the correct diagnosis.

EXPERT OPINION

Going forward, international, multicenter collaboration to fully characterize ALPS and the ALPS-like disorders, including with particular focus on defining the defects for those patients with undefined ALPS, is important to both continue to improve our understanding of this disorder and to drive patient care forward to provide the best outcomes. Additionally, it is probably time to re-convene an international expert panel to re-define diagnostic criteria taking into consideration the most recent available data in order to optimize patient care.