Comparison of Resting-State Functional MRI Methods for Characterizing Brain Dynamics

Metastability in the wild: A scoping review of empirical neuroimaging studies in humans

Metastability is proposed as the mechanism supporting our adaptive responses to the environment. While extensive research has characterized brain metastability during rest and task performance, prior studies have mainly focused on understanding underlying mechanisms, with limited exploration of its application in mental processes and behaviors. This scoping review offers an overview of the existing empirical literature in this area. Through a systematic search that included 36 articles, our results reveal a predominance of resting-state fMRI studies, variability in how metastability is defined, and a lack of consideration for common confounds in neuroimaging data. The review concludes with suggestions for future research directions to address crucial unresolved issues in the field.

On null models for temporal small-worldness in brain dynamics

Brain dynamics can be modeled as a temporal brain network starting from the activity of different brain regions in functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) signals. When validating hypotheses about temporal networks, it is important to use an appropriate statistical null model that shares some features with the treated empirical data. The purpose of this work is to contribute to the theory of temporal null models for brain networks by introducing the random temporal hyperbolic (RTH) graph model, an extension of the random hyperbolic (RH) graph, known in the study of complex networks for its ability to reproduce crucial properties of real-world networks. We focus on temporal small-worldness which, in the static case, has been extensively studied in real-world complex networks and has been linked to the ability of brain networks to efficiently exchange information. We compare the RTH graph model with standard null models for temporal networks and show it is the null model that best reproduces the small-worldness of resting brain activity. This ability to reproduce fundamental features of real brain networks, while adding only a single parameter compared with classical models, suggests that the RTH graph model is a promising tool for validating hypotheses about temporal brain networks.

Early altered directionality of resting brain network state transitions in the TgF344-AD rat model of Alzheimer's disease

Introduction

Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disease resulting in memory loss and cognitive decline. Synaptic dysfunction is an early hallmark of the disease whose effects on whole-brain functional architecture can be identified using resting-state functional MRI (rsfMRI). Insights into mechanisms of early, whole-brain network alterations can help our understanding of the functional impact of AD's pathophysiology.

Methods

Here, we obtained rsfMRI data in the TgF344-AD rat model at the pre- and early-plaque stages. This model recapitulates the major pathological and behavioral hallmarks of AD. We used co-activation pattern (CAP) analysis to investigate if and how the dynamic organization of intrinsic brain functional networks states, undetectable by earlier methods, is altered at these early stages.

Results

We identified and characterized six intrinsic brain states as CAPs, their spatial and temporal features, and the transitions between the different states. At the pre-plaque stage, the TgF344-AD rats showed reduced co-activation of hub regions in the CAPs corresponding to the default mode-like and lateral cortical network. Default mode-like network activity segregated into two distinct brain states, with one state characterized by high co-activation of the basal forebrain. This basal forebrain co-activation was reduced in TgF344-AD animals mainly at the pre-plaque stage. Brain state transition probabilities were altered at the pre-plaque stage between states involving the default mode-like network, lateral cortical network, and basal forebrain regions. Additionally, while the directionality preference in the network-state transitions observed in the wild-type animals at the pre-plaque stage had diminished at the early-plaque stage, TgF344-AD animals continued to show directionality preference at both stages.

Discussion

Our study enhances the understanding of intrinsic brain state dynamics and how they are impacted at the early stages of AD, providing a nuanced characterization of the early, functional impact of the disease's neurodegenerative process.

On the variability of dynamic functional connectivity assessment methods

BACKGROUND

Dynamic functional connectivity (dFC) has become an important measure for understanding brain function and as a potential biomarker. However, various methodologies have been developed for assessing dFC, and it is unclear how the choice of method affects the results. In this work, we aimed to study the results variability of commonly used dFC methods.

METHODS

We implemented 7 dFC assessment methods in Python and used them to analyze the functional magnetic resonance imaging data of 395 subjects from the Human Connectome Project. We measured the similarity of dFC results yielded by different methods using several metrics to quantify overall, temporal, spatial, and intersubject similarity.

RESULTS

Our results showed a range of weak to strong similarity between the results of different methods, indicating considerable overall variability. Somewhat surprisingly, the observed variability in dFC estimates was found to be comparable to the expected functional connectivity variation over time, emphasizing the impact of methodological choices on the final results. Our findings revealed 3 distinct groups of methods with significant intergroup variability, each exhibiting distinct assumptions and advantages.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, our findings shed light on the impact of dFC assessment analytical flexibility and highlight the need for multianalysis approaches and careful method selection to capture the full range of dFC variation. They also emphasize the importance of distinguishing neural-driven dFC variations from physiological confounds and developing validation frameworks under a known ground truth. To facilitate such investigations, we provide an open-source Python toolbox, PydFC, which facilitates multianalysis dFC assessment, with the goal of enhancing the reliability and interpretability of dFC studies.

Spatial and Spectral Components of the BOLD Global Signal in Rat Resting-State Functional MRI

PURPOSE

In resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI), the global signal average captures widespread fluctuations related to unwanted sources of variance such as motion and respiration, as well as widespread neural activity; however, relative contributions of neural and non-neural sources to the global signal remain poorly understood. This study sought to tackle this problem through the comparison of the BOLD global signal to an adjacent non-brain tissue signal, where neural activity was absent, from the same rs-fMRI scan obtained from anesthetized rats. In this dataset, motion was minimal and ventilation was phase-locked to image acquisition to minimize respiratory fluctuations. Data were acquired using three different anesthetics: isoflurane, dexmedetomidine, and a combination of dexmedetomidine and light isoflurane.

METHODS

A power spectral density estimate, a voxel-wise spatial correlation via Pearson's correlation, and a co-activation pattern analysis were performed using the global signal and the non-brain tissue signal. Functional connectivity was calculated using Pearson's linear correlation on default mode network (DMN) regions.

RESULTS

We report differences in the spectral composition of the two signals and show spatial selectivity within DMN structures that show an increased correlation to the global signal and decreased intra-network connectivity after global signal regression. All of the observed differences between the global signal and the non-brain tissue signal were maintained across anesthetics.

CONCLUSION

These results show that the global signal is distinct from the noise contained in the tissue signal, as support for a neural contribution. This study provides a unique perspective to the contents of the global signal and their origins.