The Legacy of the TTASAAN Report-Premature Conclusions and Forgotten Promises: A Review of Policy and Practice Part I

Clinical and Neuropathological Evaluations of the New Brunswick Neurological Syndrome of Unknown Cause

Importance

In 2019, an alleged "mystery" neurological illness emerged in New Brunswick, Canada. Despite extensive media attention, no case description has been published to date.

Objective

To report on 25 patients with a diagnosis of New Brunswick neurological syndrome of unknown cause (NSUC) who subsequently received a second, independent clinical reassessment or neuropathological examination between 2020 and 2025.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This cross-sectional study of cases derived from a cohort of patients (n = 222) who had received an NSUC diagnosis. Four movement disorder neurologists and 2 behavioral neurologists carried out clinical evaluations at 2 hospitals in New Brunswick and Ontario, Canada. Neuropathological diagnoses were obtained in Ontario by a neuropathologist and a second reviewer, both blinded to the case histories. Eligible patients were offered a second opinion; 4 families of deceased patients provided consent for reporting autopsies and waivers of consent were obtained for 7.

Exposure

NSUC as described in the case definition circulated by Public Health New Brunswick in 2021.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Findings from the independent clinical evaluations and diagnoses obtained through neuropathological examination.

Results

Among 105 eligible patients, 14 patients (aged 20-55 years; 8 female, 6 male) received clinical evaluations, and 11 patients (aged 56-82 years; 5 female, 6 male) had neuropathological diagnoses. Well-known conditions were identified in all 25 cases, including common neurodegenerative diseases, functional neurological disorder, traumatic brain injury, and metastatic cancer. Based on the 11 autopsy cases, a new disease was extremely unlikely, with a probability less than .001. When applying the 95% confidence interval for the true probability of no new disease, the data revealed a high probability between 87% and 100%.

Conclusions and Relevance

There was no evidence supporting a diagnosis of NSUC in this cohort. The data inclusive of independent examinations and neuropathology strongly supported the presence of several neurodegenerative and non-neurodegenerative conditions. Unfounded concerns that a potentially fatal mystery disease, possibly induced by an environmental toxin, is causing the patients' neurological symptoms has been amplified in traditional and social media. Second, independent clinical evaluations are needed for any patient given a diagnosis of NSUC.

Outcome Measures for Disease-Modifying Trials in Parkinson's Disease: Consensus Paper by the EJS ACT-PD Multi-Arm Multi-Stage Trial Initiative

BACKGROUND

Multi-arm, multi-stage (MAMS) platform trials can accelerate the identification of disease-modifying treatments for Parkinson's disease (PD) but there is no current consensus on the optimal outcome measures (OM) for this approach.

OBJECTIVE

To provide an up-to-date inventory of OM for disease-modifying PD trials, and a framework for future selection of OM for such trials.

METHODS

As part of the Edmond J Safra Accelerating Clinical Trials in Parkinson Disease (EJS ACT-PD) initiative, an expert group with Patient and Public Involvement and Engagement (PPIE) representatives' input reviewed and evaluated available evidence on OM for potential use in trials to delay progression of PD. Each OM was ranked based on aspects such as validity, sensitivity to change, participant burden and practicality for a multi-site trial. Review of evidence and expert opinion led to the present inventory.

RESULTS

An extensive inventory of OM was created, divided into: general, motor and non-motor scales, diaries and fluctuation questionnaires, cognitive, disability and health-related quality of life, capability, quantitative motor, wearable and digital, combined, resource use, imaging and wet biomarkers, and milestone-based. A framework for evaluation of OM is presented to update the inventory in the future. PPIE input highlighted the need for OM which reflect their experience of disease progression and are applicable to diverse populations and disease stages.

CONCLUSION

We present a range of OM, classified according to a transparent framework, to aid selection of OM for disease-modifying PD trials, whilst allowing for inclusion or re-classification of relevant OM as new evidence emerges.

The Legacy of the TTASAAN Report - Premature Conclusions and Forgotten Promises About SPECT Neuroimaging: A Review of Policy and Practice Part II

Brain perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) scans were initially developed in 1970s. A key radiopharmaceutical, hexamethylpropyleneamine oxime (HMPAO), was not stabilized until 1993 and most early SPECT scans were performed on single-head gamma cameras. These early scans were of inferior quality. In 1996, the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology (TTASAAN) issued a report regarding the use of SPECT in the evaluation of neurological disorders. This two-part series explores the policies and procedures related to perfusion SPECT functional neuroimaging. In Part I, the comparison between the quality of the SPECT scans and the depth of the data for key neurological and psychiatric indications at the time of the TTASAAN report vs. the intervening 25 years were presented. In Part II, the technical aspects of perfusion SPECT neuroimaging and image processing will be explored. The role of color scales will be reviewed and the process of interpreting a SPECT scan will be presented. Interpretation of a functional brain scans requires not only anatomical knowledge, but also technical understanding on correctly performing a scan, regardless of the scanning modality. Awareness of technical limitations allows the clinician to properly interpret a functional brain scan. With this foundation, four scenarios in which perfusion SPECT neuroimaging, together with other imaging modalities and testing, lead to a narrowing of the differential diagnoses and better treatment. Lastly, recommendations for the revision of current policies and practices are made.

Increased Asymmetric Perfusion of the Cerebral Cortices and Thalamus Indicates Individuals at Risk for Bipolar Disorder: A Family Cohort Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography Neuroimaging Study

Bipolar disorder is a significant mental illness affecting over 4 million people in North America and approximately 46 million worldwide. While the onset of bipolar disorder is typically in late adolescence and early adulthood, the correct diagnosis can be delayed for several years. This delay can result in inappropriate pharmaceutical interventions, loss of career or productivity, suicide, family hardship, and unnecessary expense. Moreover, prolonged untreated or inappropriately treated bipolar disorder may cause damage to the brain. Early diagnosis is a critical need to circumvent the damage, suffering, and expense caused by the current delay. Brain perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) neuroimaging reveals visual correlates of brain function. Herein, a family cohort all with bipolar disorder is described and their symptoms correlated with findings on the individual SPECT brain scans. The family consisted of two parents and three children (one female). The scans were interpreted by a panel of experts. Then a post hoc region-of-interest (ROI) analysis was conducted on SPECT data normalized to the cerebellum maximum with comparison to similarly normalized data from a normative sample. These findings support two distinct patterns of SPECT perfusion scan changes that can be found in individuals with bipolar disorder. In addition, these findings indicate that SPECT scan findings may be predictive of individual risk for progressing to symptomatic bipolar disorder. While preliminary, the findings in this cohort support the need for larger, diverse cohort studies of bipolar and control subjects to assess the predictive value of these particular SPECT perfusion findings in bipolar disorder.