Recognition of BRAF by CDC37 and Re-Evaluation of the Activation Mechanism for the Class 2 BRAF-L597R Mutant

Oncogenic non-V600 mutations evade the regulatory machinery of RAF including the Cdc37/Hsp90 chaperone and the 14-3-3 scaffold

The Ser/Thr kinase RAF, particularly BRAF isoform is a dominant target of oncogenic mutations and many mutations have been identified in various cancers. However, how these mutations except V600E evade the regulatory machinery of RAF protein and hence trigger its oncogenicity remains unclear. Methods: In this study, we used mutagenesis, peptide affinity assay, immunoprecipitation, immunoblot, and complementary split luciferase assay as well as mouse xenograft tumour model to investigate how the function of RAF is cooperatively regulated by Cdc37/Hsp90 chaperones and 14-3-3 scaffolds and how this regulatory machinery is evaded by prevalent non-V600 mutations. Results: We found that Cdc37/Hsp90 chaperones engaged with mature BRAF proteins promoted together with 14-3-3 scaffolds a switch of BRAF proteins from active open dimers into inactive close monomers. Most non-V600 mutations were enriched on or around the Cdc37/Hsp90-binding segments of BRAF, which impair association of CDc37/Hsp90 chaperones with BRAF and hence trap BRAF in active open conformation favouring dimerization. These BRAF mutants with high dimer propensity sustained a prolonged ERK signaling, and were effectively targeted by RAF dimer breaker plx8394 in vitro and in vivo. In contrast, CRAF and ARAF existed as immature monomers highly packaged with Cdc37/Hsp90 chaperones, which will be released upon dimerization driven by RAS-GTP binding with their N-terminus as well as 14-3-3 scaffold association with their C-terminus. Mature CRAF and ARAF dimers also sustained a prolonged ERK signaling as non-V600 BRAF mutants by virtue of absence of the C-terminal Cdc37/Hsp90-binding segment. Conclusions: Cdc37/Hsp90 chaperones and 14-3-3 scaffolds cooperatively facilitate the switch of RAF proteins from open active dimers to close inactive monomers. Non-V600 mutations disrupt this regulatory machinery, and trap RAF in dimers, which could be targeted by RAF dimer breakers.

Structural dynamics of RAF1-HSP90-CDC37 and HSP90 complexes reveal asymmetric client interactions and key structural elements

RAF kinases are integral to the RAS-MAPK signaling pathway, and proper RAF1 folding relies on its interaction with the chaperone HSP90 and the cochaperone CDC37. Understanding the intricate molecular interactions governing RAF1 folding is crucial for comprehending this process. Here, we present a cryo-EM structure of the closed-state RAF1-HSP90-CDC37 complex, where the C-lobe of the RAF1 kinase domain binds to one side of the HSP90 dimer, and an unfolded N-lobe segment of the RAF1 kinase domain threads through the center of the HSP90 dimer. CDC37 binds to the kinase C-lobe, mimicking the N-lobe with its HxNI motif. We also describe structures of HSP90 dimers without RAF1 and CDC37, displaying only N-terminal and middle domains, which we term the semi-open state. Employing 1 μs atomistic simulations, energetic decomposition, and comparative structural analysis, we elucidate the dynamics and interactions within these complexes. Our quantitative analysis reveals that CDC37 bridges the HSP90-RAF1 interaction, RAF1 binds HSP90 asymmetrically, and that HSP90 structural elements engage RAF1's unfolded region. Additionally, N- and C-terminal interactions stabilize HSP90 dimers, and molecular interactions in HSP90 dimers rearrange between the closed and semi-open states. Our findings provide valuable insight into the contributions of HSP90 and CDC37 in mediating client folding.

BRAFΔβ3-αC in-frame deletion mutants differ in their dimerization propensity, HSP90 dependence, and druggability

In-frame BRAF exon 12 deletions are increasingly identified in various tumor types. The resultant BRAFΔβ3-αC oncoproteins usually lack five amino acids in the β3-αC helix linker and sometimes contain de novo insertions. The dimerization status of BRAFΔβ3-αC oncoproteins, their precise pathomechanism, and their direct druggability by RAF inhibitors (RAFi) has been under debate. Here, we functionally characterize BRAFΔLNVTAP>F and two novel mutants, BRAFdelinsFS and BRAFΔLNVT>F, and compare them with other BRAFΔβ3-αC oncoproteins. We show that BRAFΔβ3-αC oncoproteins not only form stable homodimers and large multiprotein complexes but also require dimerization. Nevertheless, details matter as aromatic amino acids at the deletion junction of some BRAFΔβ3-αC oncoproteins, e.g., BRAFΔLNVTAP>F, increase their stability and dimerization propensity while conferring resistance to monomer-favoring RAFi such as dabrafenib or HSP 90/CDC37 inhibition. In contrast, dimer-favoring inhibitors such as naporafenib inhibit all BRAFΔβ3-αC mutants in cell lines and patient-derived organoids, suggesting that tumors driven by such oncoproteins are vulnerable to these compounds.