Exhaled Breath Analysis in Diagnosis of Malignant Pleural Mesothelioma: Systematic Review

Physiology and Biomarkers for Surveillance of Occupational Lung Disease

Respiratory surveillance is the process whereby a group of exposed workers are regularly tested (or screened) for those lung diseases which occur as a result of a specific work exposure. Surveillance is performed by assessing various measures of biological or pathological processes (or biomarkers) for change over time. These traditionally include questionnaires, lung physiological assessments (especially spirometry), and imaging. Early detection of pathological processes or disease can enable removal of a worker from a potentially harmful exposure at an early stage. In this article, we summarize the physiological biomarkers currently used for respiratory surveillance, while commenting on differences in interpretative strategies between different professional groups. We also briefly review the many new techniques which are currently being assessed for respiratory surveillance in prospective research studies and which are likely to significantly broaden and enhance this field in the near future.

Prognostic risk assessment model for alternative splicing events and splicing factors in malignant pleural mesothelioma

BACKGROUND

Malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is a rare and highly malignant thoracic tumor. Although alternative splicing (AS) is associated with tumor prognosis, the prognostic significance of AS in MPM is unknown.

METHODS

Transcriptomic data, clinical information, and splicing percentage values for MPM were obtained from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) and TCGA SpliceSeq databases. Least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO) regression and multivariate Cox analyses were performed to establish a model affecting the prognosis of MPM. Survival and ROC analyses were used to test the effects of the prognostic model. LASSO/multivariate Cox analysis was used to construct the MPM prognostic splicing factor (SF) model. The SF-AS interaction network was analyzed using Spearman correlation and visualized using Cytoscape. The association between the MPM prognostic SF model and drug sensitivity to chemotherapeutic agents such as cisplatin was analyzed using pRRophetic.R.

RESULTS

The LASSO/multivariate Cox analysis identified 41 AS events and 2 SFs that were mostly associated with survival. Nine prognostic prediction models (i.e., seven types of AS model, total AS model, and SF model) were developed. An MPM prognostic SF-AS regulatory network was subsequently constructed with decreased drug sensitivity in the SF model high-risk group (p = 0.025).

CONCLUSION

This study provides the first comprehensive analysis of the prognostic value of AS events and SFs in MPM. The SF-AS regulatory network established in this study and our drug sensitivity analysis using the SF model may provide novel targets for pharmacological studies of MPM.

Common Strategies and Factors Affecting Off-Line Breath Sampling and Volatile Organic Compounds Analysis Using Thermal Desorption-Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (TD-GC-MS)

An analysis of exhaled breath enables specialists to noninvasively monitor biochemical processes and to determine any pathological state in the human body. Breath analysis holds the greatest potential to remold and personalize diagnostics; however, it requires a multidisciplinary approach and collaboration of many specialists. Despite the fact that breath is considered to be a less complex matrix than blood, it is not commonly used as a diagnostic and prognostic tool for early detection of disordered conditions due to its problematic sampling, analysis, and storage. This review is intended to determine, standardize, and marshal experimental strategies for successful, reliable, and especially, reproducible breath analysis.

Metabolomic profiling of exhaled breath condensate for the diagnosis of pulmonary aspergillosis

Objective

This study aims to ascertain the unique metabolic profile of exhaled breath condensate (EBC) samples in pulmonary aspergillosis (PA) patients, and explore their usefulness for the diagnosis of PA.

Methods

A total of 133 patients were included in the study, including 66 PA patients (invasive pulmonary aspergillosis, n=3; chronic pulmonary aspergillosis, n=60; allergic bronchopulmonary aspergillosis, n=3) and controls (n=67). Ultra high-performance liquid chromatography coupled with high-resolution mass spectrometry(UHPLC-HRMS) was used to analyze EBC samples. Metabolic profiling of EBC samples that were collected from 22 CPA patients at various times during treatment (before treatment, <1 month, 1–2 months, 2–3 months, 3–6 months, and ≥6 months after treatment initiation) were performed using UHPLC-HRMS. Potential biomarkers were evaluated using cluster analysis, Venn diagram and receiver operating characteristic analysis (ROC).

Results

A total of 47 metabolites of potential interest were detected in the EBC samples. Further investigation showed that Asperpyrone C, Kotanin, Terphenyllin, Terrelumamide B, and Cyclotryprostatin D could be used as a diagnostic biomarker for PA. The classification between metabolic profiling of EBC samples from PA patients and controls was good with a sensitivity of 100%, specificity 89.6% for patients with PA, respectively. Venn diagram analysis of these biomarker candidates displayed three main types of compounds, which could be used for the further discrimination of aspergilloma and chronic cavitary PA. In addition, antifungal treatment had a limited influence on the value of the EBC results.

Conclusions

This metabolomic approach using UHPLC-HRMS could be used as a noninvasive method for the diagnosis of PA.

External Validation of a Breath-Based Prediction Model for Malignant Pleural Mesothelioma

Simple Summary

Malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is an incurable asbestos-related thoracic cancer for which early-stage diagnosis remains a major challenge. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are metabolites present in exhaled breath, have proven to be promising non-invasive biomarkers for MPM. However, without the necessary validation in an independent group of individuals, clinical implementation is hampered. Therefore, we performed external validation of a VOC-based prediction model for MPM, which initially revealed a poor performance and thus poor generalisability of the model. However, subsequent updating of the model improved its performance in the validation cohort, resulting in a more generalisable model with a screening potential, which could significantly impact MPM management.

Abstract

During the past decade, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in exhaled breath have emerged as promising biomarkers for malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM). However, as these biomarkers lack external validation, no breath test for MPM has been implemented in clinical practice. To address this issue, we performed the first external validation of a VOC-based prediction model for MPM. The external validation cohort was prospectively recruited, consisting of 47 MPM patients and 76 asbestos-exposed (AEx) controls. The predictive performance of the previously developed model was assessed by determining the degree of agreement between the predicted and actual outcome of the participants (patient/control). Additionally, to optimise the performance, the model was updated by refitting it to the validation cohort. External validation revealed a poor performance of the original model as the accuracy was estimated at only 41%, indicating poor generalisability. However, subsequent updating of the model improved the differentiation between MPM patients and AEx controls significantly (73% accuracy, 92% sensitivity, and 92% negative predictive value), substantiating the validity of the original predictors. This updated model will be more generalisable to the target population and exhibits key characteristics of a potential screening test for MPM, which could significantly impact MPM management.

Headspace Volatile Organic Compound Profiling of Pleural Mesothelioma and Lung Cancer Cell Lines as Translational Bridge for Breath Research

Introduction

Malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is a lethal cancer for which early-stage diagnosis remains a major challenge. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in breath proved to be potential biomarkers for MPM diagnosis, but translational studies are needed to elucidate which VOCs originate from the tumor itself and thus are specifically related to MPM cell metabolism.

Methods

An in vitro model was set-up to characterize the headspace VOC profiles of six MPM and two lung cancer cell lines using thermal desorption-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. A comparative analysis was carried out to identify VOCs that could discriminate between MPM and lung cancer, as well as between the histological subtypes within MPM (epithelioid, sarcomatoid and biphasic).

Results

VOC profiles were identified capable of distinguishing MPM (subtypes) and lung cancer cells with high accuracy. Alkanes, aldehydes, ketones and alcohols represented many of the discriminating VOCs. Discrepancies with clinical findings were observed, supporting the need for studies examining breath and tumor cells of the same patients and studying metabolization and kinetics of in vitro discovered VOCs in a clinical setting.

Conclusion

While the relationship between in vitro and in vivo VOCs is yet to be established, both could complement each other in generating a clinically useful breath model for MPM.

Breathing new life into clinical testing and diagnostics: perspectives on volatile biomarkers from breath

Human breath offers several benefits for diagnostic applications, including simple, noninvasive collection. Breath is a rich source of clinically-relevant biological information; this includes a volatile fraction, where greater than 1,000 volatile organic compounds (VOCs) have been described so far, and breath aerosols that carry nucleic acids, proteins, signaling molecules, and pathogens. Many of these factors, especially VOCs, are delivered to the lung by the systemic circulation, and diffusion of candidate biomarkers from blood into breath allows systematic profiling of organismal health. Biomarkers on breath offer the capability to advance early detection and precision medicine in areas of global clinical need. Breath tests are noninvasive and can be performed at home or in a primary care setting, which makes them well-suited for the kind of public screening program that could dramatically improve the early detection of conditions such as lung cancer. Since measurements of VOCs on breath largely report on metabolic changes, this too aids in the early detection of a broader range of illnesses and can be used to detect metabolic shifts that could be targeted through precision medicine. Furthermore, the ability to perform frequent sampling has envisioned applications in monitoring treatment responses. Breath has been investigated in respiratory, liver, gut, and neurological diseases and in contexts as diverse as infectious diseases and cancer. Preclinical research studies using breath have been ongoing for some time, yet only a few breath-based diagnostics tests are currently available and in widespread clinical use. Most recently, tests assessing the gut microbiome using hydrogen and methane on breath, in addition to tests using urea to detect Helicobacter pylori infections have been released, yet there are many more applications of breath tests still to be realized. Here, we discuss the strengths of breath as a clinical sampling matrix and the technical challenges to be addressed in developing it for clinical use. Historically, a lack of standardized methodologies has delayed the discovery and validation of biomarker candidates, resulting in a proliferation of early-stage pilot studies. We will explore how advancements in breath collection and analysis are in the process of driving renewed progress in the field, particularly in the context of gastrointestinal and chronic liver disease. Finally, we will provide a forward-looking outlook for developing the next generation of clinically relevant breath tests and how they may emerge into clinical practice.

Odors and cancer: Current status and future directions

Cancer is the second leading cause of death in the world. Because tumors detected at early stages are easier to treat, the search for biomarkers-especially non-invasive ones-that allow early detection of malignancies remains a central goal to reduce cancer mortality. Cancer, like other pathologies, often alters body odors, and much has been done by scientists over the last few decades to assess the value of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) as signatures of cancers. We present here a quantitative review of 208 studies carried out between 1984 and 2020 that explore VOCs as potential biomarkers of cancers. We analyzed the main findings of these studies, listing and classifying VOCs related to different cancer types while considering both sampling methods and analysis techniques. Considering this synthesis, we discuss several of the challenges and the most promising prospects of this research direction in the war against cancer.

A systematic review of the diagnostic accuracy of volatile organic compounds in airway diseases and their relation to markers of type-2 inflammation

BACKGROUND

Asthma and COPD continue to cause considerable diagnostic and treatment stratification challenges. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) have been proposed as feasible diagnostic and monitoring biomarkers in airway diseases.

AIMS

To 1) conduct a systematic review evaluating the diagnostic accuracy of VOCs in diagnosing airway diseases; 2) understand the relationship between reported VOCs and biomarkers of type-2 inflammation; 3) assess the standardisation of reporting according to STARD and TRIPOD criteria; 4) review current methods of breath sampling and analysis.

METHODS

A PRISMA-oriented systematic search was conducted (January 1997 to December 2020). Search terms included: "asthma", "volatile organic compound(s)", "VOC" and "COPD". Two independent reviewers examined the extracted titles against review objectives.

RESULTS

44 full-text papers were included; 40/44 studies were cross-sectional and four studies were interventional in design; 17/44 studies used sensor-array technologies (e.g. eNose). Cross-study comparison was not possible across identified studies due to the heterogeneity in design. The commonest airway diseases differentiating VOCs belonged to carbonyl-containing classes (i.e. aldehydes, esters and ketones) and hydrocarbons (i.e. alkanes and alkenes). Although individual markers that are associated with clinical biomarkers of type-2 inflammation were recognised (i.e. ethane and 3,7-dimethylnonane for asthma and α-methylstyrene and decane for COPD), these were not consistently identified across studies. Only 3/44 reported following STARD or TRIPOD criteria for diagnostic accuracy and multivariate reporting, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Breath VOCs show promise as diagnostic biomarkers of airway diseases and for type-2 inflammation profiling. However, future studies should focus on transparent reporting of diagnostic accuracy and multivariate models and continue to focus on chemical identification of volatile metabolites.

Exhaled breath biomarker sensing

This goal of this minireview is to introduce the reader to the area of research concerned with exhaled breath analysis for the purpose of detecting abnormal levels of physiologically-relevant chemical markers reflective of respiratory diseases. Two main two groups of sensing methods are reviewed: mass spectrometry and (bio)sensors. The discussion focuses on biosensor applications for EB and EBC analyses, which are presented in detail. The review finishes with conclusions and future perspectives, including recommendations for future near-term and long-term development of EBC biomarker sensing.

Volatile organic compounds in a headspace sampling system and asthmatics sputum samples

Background:The headspace of a biological sample contains exogenous VOCs present within the sampling environment which represent the background signal.Study aims:This study aimed to characterise the background signal generated from a headspace sampling system in a clinical site, to evaluate intra- and inter-day variation of background VOC and to understand the impact of a sample itself upon commonly reported background VOC using sputum headspace samples from severe asthmatics.Methods:The headspace, in absence of a biological sample, was collected hourly from 11am to 3pm within a day (time of clinical samples acquisition), and from Monday to Friday in a week, and analysed by thermal desorption-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (TD-GC-MS). Chemometric analysis identified 1120 features, 37 of which were present in at least the 80% of all the samples. The analyses of intra- and inter-day background variations were performed on thirteen of the most abundant features, ubiquitously present in headspace samples. The concentration ratios relative to background were reported for the selected abundant VOC in 36 asthmatic sputum samples, acquired from 36 stable severe asthma patients recruited at Glenfield Hospital, Leicester, UK.Results:The results identified no significant intra- or inter-day variations in compounds levels and no systematic bias of z-scores, with the exclusion of benzothiazole, whose abundance increased linearly between 11am and 3pm with a maximal intra-day fold change of 2.13. Many of the identified background features are reported in literature as components of headspace of biological samples and are considered potential biomarkers for several diseases. The selected background features were identified in headspace of all severe asthma sputum samples, albeit with varying levels of enrichment relative to background.Conclusion:Our observations support the need to consider the background signal derived from the headspace sampling system when developing and validating headspace biomarker signatures using clinical samples.

Mesothelioma Biomarkers: A Review Highlighting Contributions from the Early Detection Research Network

Malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) is an asbestos-related neoplasm, which can be treated successfully only if correctly diagnosed and treated in early stages. The asbestos-exposed population serves as a high-risk group that could benefit from sensitive and specific blood- or tissue-based biomarkers. This review details the recent work with biomarker development in MPM and the contributions of the NCI Early Detection Research Network Biomarker Developmental Laboratory of NYU Langone Medical Center. The literature of the last 20 years was reviewed to comment on the most promising of the blood- and tissue-based biomarkers. Proteomic, genomic, and epigenomic platforms as well as novel studies such as "breath testing" are covered. Soluble mesothelin-related proteins (SMRP) have been characterized extensively and constitute an FDA-approved biomarker in plasma with diagnostic, monitoring, and prognostic value in MPM. Osteopontin is found to be a valuable prognostic biomarker for MPM, while its utility in diagnosis is slightly lower. Other biomarkers, such as calretinin, fibulin 3, and High-Mobility Group Box 1 (HMGB1), remain under study and need international validation trials with large cohorts of cases and controls to demonstrate any utility. The EDRN has played a key role in the development and testing of MPM biomarkers by enlisting collaborations all over the world. A comprehensive understanding of previously investigated biomarkers and their utility in screening and early diagnosis of MPM will provide guidance for further future research.See all articles in this CEBP Focus section, "NCI Early Detection Research Network: Making Cancer Detection Possible."